Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Camphor burl box....

Posts

Camphor burl box....

#1

Mike Stafford

Camphor burl box....

Mike Stafford

>No, I didn't turn this with my new lathe. I am still acclimating myself to where all the handles are and have been roughing out blanks, turning some bowls and generally getting a feel for the new machine.

This form is a radical departure for me in some ways. I took elements from some of my shorter boxes; the bead and the lid shape and used them on a box where the join is much higher. The lid is an overfitting lid and has a nice slip fit. I left the interior of the box finely sanded but unfinished so when you open the box you get a whiff of camphor. The box is 3 1/2" in both height and diameter.

I would be interested in hearing what you have to say about the proportions and join height. All comments appreciated.


img

Re: Camphor burl box....

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Camphor burl box....an open view. 

Mike Stafford

>


img

Re: Camphor burl box....

#3

Re: Camphor burl box....

david

>Mike:

Your boxes are all terrific, but I don't think this 'stretching' or heightening of the shorter forms you do so well is as successful here. For this height, my preference would be a form with more vertical sides, or alternately a continuation of the inward slant of the lid in a gracefull concave curve and then cut back near the bottom. But who am I to say?

Re: Camphor burl box....

#4

Re: Camphor burl box....

jim reimers

>i think i would have closed the gap between top and bottom, but thats just me. it really has a warm look. graceful, simple and elegant. i like it! jimtex

Re: Camphor burl box....

#5

Re: Camphor burl box....

Woody in VT

>Very nice box. I like the simplicity of it. I will take a well executed simple form over a badly designed or executed complex form any day.

Re: Camphor burl box....

#6

Re: Camphor burl box....

Texian

>Guess I'm not qualified to comment, as the proportions and joint height look fine to me. Nothing wrong with square. Had to look at the bead at the cover joint a while to decide that I like that too. It would be awfully plain without the bead.

Re: Camphor burl box....

#7

Ellis Walentine

I love it, Mike

Ellis Walentine

>Things I like:

- The bulge of the top beautifully complements the swell of the box body;

- The bead makes a nice transition from the inward curve of the body to the outward slant of the lid;

- It is simple and unadorned enough to allow that wonderful (and rare?) burl to command attention;

- The olfactory dimension. I turned a couple camphorwood pieces and really appreciate the aroma;

- The sweet fit of the lid, which I can only imagine from the photo. :-)

One questionable feature: The shadow line between the lid and the bead, formed by the rolled under edge of the lid. I question whether that detail is in the best service of the design. It isn't offensive at all, but since you wanted to stir comments, there it is.

Great job as usual.

Ellis

Re: Camphor burl box....

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: I love it, Mike

Mike Stafford

>I appreciate all comments since they make me look at things in different ways.

Ellis, you are not the first to mention the shadow line. It is very pronounced and probably is as a result of me starting the curve too soon and not leaving enough of a flat.

Thanks to all who commented.

Re: Camphor burl box....

#9

Dick Hines

Re: I love it, Mike

Dick Hines

>Looks great to me. I put a copy of it in my "one day to do " file. If I every get hollow forms out of my system I will try to learn to turn boxs.

Re: Camphor burl box....

#10

Re: Camphor burl box....

Cyril Griesbach

>What's not to like with this one, Mike. I think the "stretch" is great and, to me at least, it still follows your signature form. I paid little attention to the shadow line till Ellis brought it up but I do not find it in the least offensive. I'd be proud to have this one.

Re: Camphor burl box....

#11

Steven Antonucci

Don't mind the shadow line, but...

steve antonucci

>I thought the top would be inset like a cork when I saw it because the shadow line cast that illusion to my eye. When I saw the open picture, I realized it was different than what I expected. Not bad, just different.

Steven