Re: Are you a learner?
Barry Elder
>Woodturning can be another long journey that begins with the first step. Learning will last until I die. Many people are not interested in taking the first step!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Are you a learner?
Barry Elder
>Woodturning can be another long journey that begins with the first step. Learning will last until I die. Many people are not interested in taking the first step!
Re: Are you a learner?
Keith Tompkins
>Hey Steve, What you are noticing is simple human nature. What you describe can be applied to any hobby or profession. For example, all doctors have been through medical school....do you think they all posess the same skill level? I don't think so. In fact, I believe there is a percentage that excel at what they do, perhaps 10%. Another 10% are completely incompetent, while the rest fall somewhere in the middle. Same with engineers, auto mechanics, and as you probably know, salepeople. Another factor is natural ability. For example, I cannot dance. At All. I don't care if Fred Astaire himself gave me private lessons.....ain't gonna happen. Unfortunately, there are turners who fall into the various categories. Some will have natural ability, and will become proficient in an amazingly short time. Others will gradually improve over time, while some will be content to make chips fly. Some will strive to learn proper technique, and will be willing to invest in the time required to do so. Most will not. Many will be enthusiastic at first, then quietly move on to something else. Everyone has potential...how many people live up to theirs?
Re: Are you a learner?
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Steve, I have demonstrated and taught people all over the eastern part of the US, and at all levels or interest in turning. I even had one guy spend a day with me who had no intention of buying a lathe. He just wanted to have fun. And that is the bottom line for the vast majority of the people doing this stuff. They want to have fun. And, their level of fun, and the way they have it is defined by each individual. Some want to putter, some want to spend money on nice machines and polish them, some want to outfit their shop on the proverbial shoestring, and others want to develop their skills as far as they can. But each one decides for him or herself what they want to get out of this. Once someone else intrudes unasked to try and change the way another person does something, it is not going to be fun anymore.
My philosophy is to let people do and be what they want, and if they want to change, improve, or whatever, they will seek that out, whether from me or from someone else. But if I got frustrated at the stuff other people do, I would go insane. I have enough trouble keeping up with my frustration with myself.
Bill
I am no longer frustrated by it, Bill...
steve antonucci
>I agree with you that it's the way of the world. I'm just trying to figure out why? I've given up on trying to change the world, I just want to figure out what makes it tick...
If you figure that out, you can sell something :-)
Steven
Who has nothing to sell (yet)
Re: Are you a learner?
Halsey
>Bill I agree with you.A fine answer. Halsey
Re: My golf swing is like-
Carole Valentine
>Raymond, when I played golf, we used to have an evening "one club" match almost every Sunday night in the summer. You carried only one club and your putter. Many times my scores were better with a 5 iron and putter than they would have been with a full bag of clubs - even on the par fives! I didn't have the distance of a driver, but I had accuracy with a 5 iron that kept me out of the trouble I often got into with a driver. Of course the fact that I had had a couple of glasses of wine might have helped. :) There is a lesson in there that can be applied to turning turning, but if you looked at my tool rack, you would never know it!
Re: Are you a learner?
eaglesc
>The best teachers taught me how to learn.
I have learned more from my "mistakes; than anything else.
The"right" or "better" way is the way that works and is not necessarily shown to you for a fee nor does it need to come from someone else.
Re: Are you a learner?
charlie belden
>This one's got me going in several different directions.
Golf analogy - off the tee - hit that thing with EVERYTHING you've got - and probably slice the ball, or hook it - into the trees, sand trap or water "obstacle". I've heard that problems described as "putting too much ego on the ball".
And I watched a guy every day for a week practice his raquet ball power serve and kill shots - hours at a time - alone on a court. He had the power and the techniques - but absolutely no finesse. At the end of the week he'd play with the pro - and older fellow, in a silk jump suit - and loafers. The pro cleaned this quys clock EVERY time - without breaking a sweat or taking more than a step or two to return Killer's last shot. Killer was playing his technique - the pro was playing, or playing with, his opponent - playing the personality and style, not the ball.
There seems to be a "best tool for the task" vs "any tool that'll get the job done" thing.
Some feel that the ONLY tool that MUST be used to turn a bowl is a bowl gouge - often a specific kind of bowl gouge with a specific grind for each specific size of bowl - used EXACTLY the "right way" - for EVERY cut.
Others find they're most comfortable doing the outside of a bowl with - maybe a skew and a scraper - and the inside that way as well - maybe spending more time with the "80 grit gouge" than would be necessary if a bowl gouge had been use - even adequately.
If neither has to earn a living turning - and time is available to do things the "comfortable way" rather than the "best way" - does it matter in the end if the results are comperable?
There is the temptation when one has found something really great - to become evangelical. "I have found THE way - and I want everyone to experience what I've experienced - because I'VE found it so wonderful." I get really evangelical about the Festool DOMINO ( a hand held power tool that permits ANYONE, with almost no training, to do "loose tenon" mortise and tenon joints quickly, easily AND accurately.), and understand the frustration of not being able to adequately get other woodworkers to see and appreciate the DOMINO as I do.
Woodturning is the Wild West of woodworking - no laws, barely ANY order, and folks coming up with what today is seen as Off The Wall - and perhaps a year from now "Old Hat". And the beauty of turning is that there's space for everyone who wants to do it, in whatever way that works for them.
So worry less and enjoy more. And when somebody sees something of yours and asks "Can you show me or tell me - HOW you did THAT?" - tell them and show them - if you've got the time - and inclination. But be aware that to teach - well - you not only have to have a good understanding of the subject - but also a good understanding of your student in order to adapt what they want you to teach them to HOW they're most able to Get It - if that's the goal.
And have fun - whichever way you go.
charlie belden
Re: Are you a learner?
Tom Sweeney - Coatesville, PA
>Hey Steve,
Interesting thread. First a caveat - the last time I picked up a woodturning tool was at Bill's I think 2 years ago & I remember you were there also. Here's the thing as I see it: This is a Hobby for the majority of turners. I would guess that most peoples lives are similar to mine. Stressful, fast paced, work problems, kid problems, money problems, etc... ( don't worry life is good, but sometimes I have to step back from day to day stuff to realize it). I am having a new 40'X30' garage built so that I can have a place to fix up my classic cars & also to move everything I have stored out of what used to be my WW'ing shop. After that I will set up shop again & start turning on a lathe I bought 2 years ago & have yet to assemble. When I do I want to get back to a decent, safe technique, and put out nice looking turnings, but I'm not terribly concerned with sweating every detail & striving to be the best. Why, because this is a hobby - something I enjoy doing precisely because I don't have to stress over every little detail or make sure all my T's are Crossed & I's dotted.
I will work on improving to the point where it is more enjoyable, but I feel no need at this point to be a world class turner.
I like the golf analogy! When I first started playing I was a Realtor during a very stressful sales market. I would go out on the course & try to do as good as I could, but wasn't improving much. I didn't have the time or the $$ to take a bunch of lessons. I would be out on the course cursing, throwing clubs, etc... when it hit me one day. If I wanted to be agravated I could go back to the office & make money instead of spend money. From that day on I worried much less about technique, swing & score & to this day enjoy every round of golf I get to play. & you know what - I've had a couple of sub 90 rounds & a hole in one to boot!
Don't sweat the small stuff & it's all small stuff!
Why does it matter?
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>It is my hobby.
I am enjoying myself.
That is all that really matters.
Don't you want to be good at the things you do?
steve antonucci
>I have a few hobbies too. I want to be good at the things I chose to do. Whether they are hobbies or otherwise, I want to be good at things.
I don't do things to be bad at them. Things that I am bad at, i don't do very long. Can't sing, can't dance. Move on...
steven
Re: Are you a learner?
Carole Valentine
>"But if I got frustrated at the stuff other people do, I would go insane. I have enough trouble keeping up with my frustration with myself."
I could not have said it better, Bill!
Reminds me of...
Raymond Overman in SC
>What do you call a medical student who graduates at the bottom of the class?
Doctor
What do you call a guy who owns a lathe and throws chips around?
Woodturner
Depends
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>on your personality type, Steve. As a salesman, you are naturally competitive, even if it's with yourself. Close a big sale, overcome obstacles , better your TDV over last year/quarter/month. That translates to your other activities.
But many people are quite the opposite. They will actively reject the notion of self improvement because they don't want the "PRESSURE TO PERFORM" whether external or internal. They will take a task or activity only to a certain level, usually within their self-perceived comfort zone, but no further
Those people are, I suspect, very hard for you to understand because their core is so very different from yours. If they take up an activity which you do as well, They may marvel at work better than theirs, but they won't try to emulate or match it. They learn how to do many things and may be quite intelligent, but they will consistently avoid being pushed to higher levels of performance because they don't want the pressure. It's not a learning thing, however, its a performance pressure issue.
Re: Don't you want to be good at the things you do
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>Good idea, Steve. Move on. As a sales guy you should know not everyone
is the same nor wants to be.
People whop are happy the way they are are difficult sales targets. I understand that. Getting 'a million 'no's' should have taught you that you don't make a sale (or a point) to everyone.
No rebuttal (or comment) necessary. Truly, please, move on.
Keen observation.
steve antonucci
>
Re: Change management theory
Mark Williamson
>One must understand that not everyone has the capability to "see a better form". not everyone is an "artist" by nature and may never be an "artist" in other's eyes. The important thing you are failing to see is that instead of giving up because their "round nose, scraped bowl" doesn't look like your "bowl-gouged" bowl. They are still at it, with yet another piece of crappy wood at their crappy little lathe and round nosed scraper makeing, to them, may be the most beatiful bowl (crappy dog dish) they have ever turned! Even the dog likes it. :) No, they were not born with the knack as others have, but they continue to try! THAT is the important thing! Some people may never get to the point of turning the magnificent pieces that you turn but they are still trying and they are still haveing a wonderful time! (unless of course people begin to go from helpful and encouraging to just plain ruthless and impatient!) I have seen some pictures posted here that I personally wasn't crazy about but just because it looks somewhat like a dog bowl doesn't mean that it isn't a nice piece. Just keep in mind that there are only so many "turning god" slots. Maybe one day we can all be like you. Use your knowledge and talent to encourage instead of teach. Stop thinking of it as "some people just won't learn" (because eventually they will) instead, realise that everyone learns their own way and perhaps your way of teaching is not right for them?! On that note, I would gladly accept any knowledge you have to offer, but know this, I may not learn a thing. :)
Mark
Re: You make a great point...
Mark Williamson
>AH!!! But you strive to be good at everything!? why not golf? Did you just give up? I'll tell you something about golf, all the lessons in the world will not make you Tiger Woods! You have to have the passion and the talent already within to ever be even ok at it! Just like with turning! I personally suck at golf! However, that does not stop me from going out there and making a complete ass of myself and enjoying the game twice a month! LOL I golf with a guy that shoots pro-scores most of the time and for a long time always tried to give me lessons the whole time. I finally had to tell him to stop so that I could just enjoy the game! We now both have a great time! I told him that I would never be competition for him so if that is what he was looking for then he needed to find someone else to golf with. I just didn't have the passion he has but that doesn't mean that I should not play the game because it may frustrate the golf pros! LOL I have to know Steve, what is it you sell? Cars or Timeshare? he he
Mark
Missing the point...
steve antonucci
>I don't care if you are any good at golf. I only care if you want to get better. I would never do anything over and over without WANTING to be getting better at it. It's the lack of desire, not skill, that I find frustrating.
I stopped playing golf because I had no desire to get better at it. I have tried a great many things, and the one's that I enjoy usually ignite some level of desire to improve. Not to be competitive, but to do the best that I can (ok, at some level to be competitive too... :-)
BTW-I sell software and consulting solutions to high tech manufacturers to help manage their supply chains. I get a lot of apathy there too...and I guess the frustration carries over to my "shop life".
Steven
Willingness to learn is the first step...
steve antonucci
>I will contend that anyone-ANYONE!- can learn to turn. I have stood behind my 6 year old daughter at the lathe, and we can cut wood.
Perfect form? I don't have it yet. Occasionally, I get "really good form", but I didn't start there. I also didn't start making "good cuts", but I sought out how to do it.
You'd be welcome in my shop like anyone who asks me for my time. I feel that turners are some of the most willing to share their knowledge and experience. You may not use anything that you learn, but I guarantee you that something would stick ;-) Heck, I might even learn something back on you...
Steven
Re: Willingness to learn is the first step...
Mark Williamson
>LOL Me, I'm a frickin' sponge! I garauntee I would learn something! I have to agree, turner's are some of the most knowledge sharing people I have ever been around! (And salesmen, they ALWAYS want to give you their oppinions! he he) I doubt you are in Virginia so I don't know that I will get the pleasure of spending the day picking your brain! You have inspired me! I have been in the shop today working on a turning useing nothing but a round nose scraper! LOL I have not posted any pictures of any of my work here before but I will post this one as soon as I am done with it! Only stipulation is that you are not allowed to say anything nice about it! LOL (So far, it looks nothing like a dog bowl!)
Mark
Re: Missing the point...
Mark Williamson
>Any good salesman is good because he/she is competitive! LOL (There is very good money in Timeshare sales! LOL) Some people just aren't competitive even with themselves therefore the don't look at it as they must get better to enjoy it. They just enjoy it. You don't care if I am any good at golf but you care if someone sucks at turning? You sure I'm the one missing the point? LOL
You're alright in my book! LOL
Mark
P.S. If you are ever in Virginia, I would like to treat you to a game of golf! he he Maybe we can talk about people's crappy form in turning?! :)
Care? Not really...
steve antonucci
>It's more of a "why is it this way?" at this point than a "how can I fix it?" Anyone that wants to "be fixed" can find it.
I'm just curious what motivates people to be "unmotivated". If I can figure it out (and then fix it ;-), I can retire. (and I won't waste that knowledge on turning, since there are no commissions!)
As far as playing golf with you, if I ever get down to VA (DC once in a while, is it close?) I'll send you a warning. We'll stop at the driving range and buy a bucket of balls, since I'll need them to get through a whole round...
Steven
The best thing someone every told me was...
steve antonucci
>my work wasn't good enough. That person was Tina LeCoff of the Woodtuurning Center in Philadelphia. Until that moment, I had never looked at it with a critical eye, and everyone had "nice jobbed" me to death.
I looked at her opinion, and I agree. Now my work is better, but it's still not good enough.
That's how I roll :-)
Steve
you said it charles
robert davis
>