Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Are you a learner?

Posts

Are you a learner?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Are you a learner?

steve antonucci

>I'm in a thought provoking mood this morning.

I've been kicking around a few questions after being around a bunch of turners for the past couple of months. I consider myself a learner, but I think that a lot of turners I've met are "just turning for fun."

For me, I may not want to do everything I see, but I have to know how it is done. If I do it, I want to be the best that I can be at it, and I push myself. I seek out critiques from all kinds of people, because I know that every opinion has a value, and learning from different types of people makes me better at what I want to do.

The other side of the coin is the "just for fun" group. These people tend to be doing things that frustrate me and I feel the need to correct. They tend to be very simple things like bevel contact, which makes such a huge difference you'd think they'd welcome the knowledge. But they typically don't care if there is a better way, or minor things would greatly change their ability. They are what I refer to as "snapshooters"- heads cut off in portraits, blurry pictures. All of the basic fundamentals can be improved in a few minutes, but they don't care.

Does anyone else see this or am I just rambling?

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#2

Re: Are you a learner?

Ron in Drums PA

>Yes, I'm a learner who loves to experiment.

You never know when seeing something new will give you an idea for something else.

Re: Are you a learner?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Are you a learner?

Jesper, Denmark

>Steve,

I am sure there is a valid point in this, but I fail to see it.

Conclusion: Apply your turning approach to communicating your idea.

I am kinda curious as to what it really is.

Re: Are you a learner?

#4

Re: Are you a learner?

Don Orr

>I think I get where you are coming from and I agree. While I'm not the divergent thinker and experimenter like you and Ron, I also want to know how and why tecniques work and then practice them until I can do them well.

I have taught and helped at many workshops and know that different people learn differently. I am lucky to have the ability to see something done and explained and usually be able to replicate the technique. Not everyone can do that and it makes it difficult to teach them sometimes. And as you say, many do not care to learn if what they are doing makes them happy. I can give many examples but won't elaborate here. One quick example is a friend who has a LARGE lathe and no design concepts. Turns clunky, garish pieces with scrapers. I bust on him that one of these days I'll teach him to cut instead of scrape now that he has a real lathe. We both laugh and he keeps doing what he's doing and enjoys himself.

So I guess it comes down to who's better off in this scenario? The guy turning however he wants and having a good time, or you and me getting frustrated over it. I've tried to get over the frustration and concentrate on my own learning. If someone has a question, I am happy to share what knowledge I have and let them do with it what they will. Then I go to my own shop and do what I want, how I want. Saves me a headache. I know you are trying to help people get better and so was I. Think head and brick wall here. If they REALLY want to get better they will seek you out as you set a great example of skill and design. I have come to the realization that it's not worth my stress to try and force the issue.

Let them come to you, grasshopper, and seek your wisdom.

Re: Are you a learner?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Push vs. pull

steve antonucci

>I think you hit the nail on the head. It's push vs. pull. Turners that want to learn will pull the information from a variety of sources and seek out answers to issues.

Those that don't cannot be pushed into it.

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#6

That's it in a nutshell !

Don Orr

>That's exactly what I was trying to get across in my rambling.

Good thought provoking thread. For both sides !

Re: Are you a learner?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Change management theory

steve antonucci

>A lot of people have difficulty asking for help, difficulty accepting "rejection" or criticism, and some resist change no matter what.

I sell for a living. I know that I cannot possibly do my job without other people's input. I get told "no" a million times a year. I have to change to get better at my job.

What baffles me is that not everyone wants to be "better". I watch guys who have been turning for a long time reach for a scraper to hollow a bowl because they never learned how to use a bowl gouge. I watch people produce nicely sanded UFO's and dog dishes because they have never looked at form.

My true question is "why"? What is it that makes someone "not care" enough to want to be better? If help is available (and often free!), if criticism is done to encourage growth (vs. that stinks...), why would someone not embrace this?

Now, I'll shut up and listen...

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#8

Re: Push vs. pull

E. Tabachek

>When the student is ready, the teacher will be provided.

Everyone has your interest to or commitment to woodturning (or anything else in life). Something that took me a long tome to understand. You amy want to learn all that you can about something, immerse yourself in thre details. Other people may be happy to know only a little bit.

Did I answer the question? ET

Re: Are you a learner?

#9

Re:" Not Everyone" correction, NM

E. Tabachek

>

Re: Are you a learner?

#10

Steven Antonucci

But wouldn't you want to do some things well?

steve antonucci

>I can see not being into every possible nook and cranny of the craft, but wouldn't you want to do the basics well?

It would drive me nuts if I didn't know how to use a gouge. I know this because it drove me nuts until I figured out how to use a gouge! I seek to be "proficient" with the tools I need to do a job. Expert only comes after proficient.

I contend that anyone can learn the minimum basic skills in a weekend. From there, they can chose a direction. If they want to be the next famous turner or just some guy who makes bowls, the first step is proficiency.

"I've been turning for 20 years" means nothing if you do not have proficiency with the minimum basics skills. I will again contend that you can learn what you need to be proficient in a few days, but to be good takes a lot more...

Where you get off the ride doesn't really concern me...

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#11

Re: But wouldn't you want to do some things well?

Don at Central Illinois

>I had not thought of the push vs pull but it is right. I think a lot of it has to do with the persons personality. Some people just want to 'get by',without a lot of thought, etc. When, and if, they are ready, they'll ask.

Re: Are you a learner?

#12

Re: Are you a learner?

Steven Kubien

>I think part of the problem (if that is the correct word) is that not everyone shares your/our passion about the "how's" of tool control, sharpening, design, finishing etc etc. They are happy doing what they are and producing what they do because they enjoy being out in the shop and playing. Certainly nothing wrong with that. Think about it, how many people out there own a handplane and a few chisels but will never approach the level of execution of Krenov or Nakashima? What's more, they often don't care to try. They are perfectly content to make a few bookshelves, coat racks etc because there is no stress involved for them. This may be in direct opposition to their day-jobs where vitamin S (stress) is given in high doses.

It is the same way in the dojo I belong to. There are a number of students who are quite happy to dance and swing sticks at people but never look into the deeper stuff like why a technique works in this situation but not another. What would I do if the sword was coming at me in this way? Me, I have enough of a handle on the basics now that I am starting to think more. Maybe too much! I wonder how steeply angled terrain effects my targets and more importantly, how can I hit that target now that I am higher/lower than my opponent. The same is true in turning. I've started looking more at forms and curves and why some work and some don't. I now know I am not destined to rely on an 80 grit gouge because I have learned a few things so I can start with an 85 grit gouge. :) I also wonder how many of us go through this evolution (for lack of a better word) and don't even realize it?

An interesting thread Steve. My humble advice is not to stress over it. I don't try to convert people to my way of thinking in life, politics, religion, jodo or turning. Lots of people don't want to be converted and I have often found that those are the people who are happiest and most at peace.

Take care,

Steve Kubien

Re: Are you a learner?

#13

Re: Are you a learner?

Bob Macgregor

>It isn't just woodturning, either.

Compare golfers, for example! Or guitarists.

I wonder if it is a characteristic of a person, ie, that they will approach any activity with the same lackadaisical (or learning) attitude or if, on the other hand, some activities are met with a "good enough" attitude while others get the full-intensity treatment...I suspect the latter for most folks.

I tend to get inspired by some undertakings and really dig in to how to do them well, sometimes verging on obsessively (don't ask my wife about the "verging" part of that statement!), while other things I may enjoy doing, but am content to do them any which way.

BOB

Re: Are you a learner?

#14

Steven Antonucci

The enemy of good is "good enough" :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Are you a learner?

#15

Steven Antonucci

I no longer stress: I qualify

steve antonucci

>I spend a lot of time every day talking to people I can help that don't want the help. Rather than tell them the 10 things I can do to make their lives better, I start with a simple question:

Do you want MY help?

I've adopted things to my turning philosophy. I can usually gauge a person in the first 2 minutes of conversation. The ones that don't seem interested usually aren't. The ones that are interested will usually ask you to show them once you make yourself available.

Sometimes, they want help, but not from me. That's fine, just the same...

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Peoples perception of Better are different

Jesper, Denmark

>

Re: Are you a learner?

#17

Better a diamond with a flaw than a pebble without

Raymond Overman in SC

>Below are a few quotes on perfection. I assume, probably falsely, that "good enough" falls just below perfection. At what point will you stop practicing and make something if you are striving for perfection?

Better a diamond with a flaw than a pebble without. ~Confucius, Analects

They say that nobody is perfect. Then they tell you practice makes perfect. I wish they'd make up their minds. ~Wilt Chamberlain

I want to stay as close to the edge as I can without going over. Out on the edge you see all kinds of things you can't see from the center. ~Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., Player Piano

Striving to better, oft we mar what's well. ~William Shakespeare, King Lear, 1605

Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it. ~Salvador Dali

All of us failed to match our dreams of perfection. ~William Faulkner

A good garden may have some weeds. ~Thomas Fuller, Gnomologia, 1732

Re: Are you a learner?

#18

My golf swing is like-

john lucas

>a dull scraper on a hard piece of wood. I get there eventually but have to work a lot longer and harder than the pro's. Golf is very much like turning in that you always think a better tool will make you a better golfer. In reality it's how you use the tool.

Re: Are you a learner?

#19

Re: My golf swing is like-

Raymond Overman in SC

>It's interesting that even the longest courses I've ever played, which isn't very many, you could probably par the whole course with a seven iron, a pitching wedge and a putter if you knew what you were doing. Yet, when it comes time to tee off, I reach for the driver and still end up double bogeying the hole.

So it goes.

Re: Are you a learner?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Not a question of perfection, but proficiency

steve antonucci

>One thing that I will never be accused of is being a perfectionist. I have a grounded sense of "good enough" within what I am trying to accomplish, understand what I need to do to get "better" at it, and make conscious decisions to stop when and where I do.

It's not about the relentless pursuit of perfection (someone copyright being invoked here..), it's about getting away from being dangerous, moving towards proficient, and then to competent.

I used to play basketball competitively. We'd often play pick-up games, and there were lots of guys who wanted to play. Nothing irked the group more than a guy on the court who wasn't running. Not because he was tired, but because he didn't care. He could be a pebble, but he couldn't be a "rock"...

Steven

Re: Are you a learner?

#21

Drivers now look like pie plates-

john lucas

>Why don't we just buy better glasses. :)

Re: Are you a learner?

#22

Or my favorite quote

Ron in Drums PA

>I am always doing that which I can not do, in order that I may learn how to do it. - Pablo Picasso

Re: Are you a learner?

#23

Steven Antonucci

You make a great point...

steve antonucci

>I can pick up anyone's tools and start turning with them (assuming they are sharp, often are not). Why is that? Oh, yeah, because I passed the minimum basic skills training...

Just like an automobile, we all know how to drive. Which lathe, what tool, what kind of wood- shouldn't matter!

Sharp tool+spinning wood+good technique= wood ribbons. Every time.

Steven

P.S. I started playing golf 20 years ago, but have only played 2 rounds in my life. I don't wonder why I am no good at it, but if I wanted to be good, I'd go take a lesson from someone who was good...

Re: Are you a learner?

#24

Re: Are you a learner?

RonZ

>I agree with you to a point and apply it to my self. In other words, I have yet to do some forms of woodturning until I feel that I have reached an expertise in tool usage. I am fortunate to turn and teach for a living so I can rack up practice time. many people cannot and only turn for a hobby. Some people don't have that luxury or have the means to do it. There is no reason for you to get frustrated, you do it right and let him/her keep doing what they are doing [just get out of the way]. If they notice that for some reason your work is cleaner, has less to sand or didn't fly off the lathe you might have gained a student. The only way to change the world is start with your self and then be an example.

Re: Are you a learner?

#25

Re: Are you a learner?

E. Tabachek

>Amen. Nicley phrased, Ron.

Other woodturners are not our employees; we are not paying them to run rather than walk. We are not operating a training and licencing program; this a hobby. If you want to teach other hobby woodturners you have to leave them alone to get as good as they want to (get good). ET