Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Who made it? #21?

Posts

Re: Who made it? #21?

#26

Okay. I understand. Now let...

Al Neighbors

>me say something about this little box. Anthony was preparing for a demo of sphere turning. I asked him if he was going to hollow one and make a threaded box out of it. He said he wasn't intending to demo threading. He saw that I was disappointed, and glanced at his watch... he said, "we've got a few minutes, let's do some". He grabbed a couple of pieces of wood, and turned this little box.

And I ended up with it, unsanded, and unsigned. I finished it.

And, though maybe contrary to what you think of it, I like it... it reminds me of the Russian domes in Moscow. :)

Thanks for the explanation... I'd never heard that about the committee. :)

Re: Who made it? #21?

#27

Re: Or

Al Neighbors

>Read my response of explanation to your post, above, Mark.

I'm sorry I chose less than an "exceptional" collector's item to post. I can assure you that I won't make that mistake again.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#28

Re: Or

Barry Elder

>Or perhaps the poor pictures, the lack of collectors' interest, not giving a bio to educate us as to the history of the turners has provoked some unwanted responses.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#29

Al

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I read your explanation. There was nothing at all wrong with your choice. The game doesn't have rules as far as I know... other than basic consideration for other people's feelings. I think some of the responses were in poor taste and very unfortunate.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#30

What's Happening Here?.... Nothing unusual

Ron in Drums PA

>What's wrong with voicing an opinion?

I didn't see any post that I would consider in bad taste.

Or would you prefer "OMG - That is Lovely!" to every picture that is posted?

Ok, before you answer that, I know why, I'm just trying to illustrate a point.

But to tell you the truth, there has been a few times I wish I could say, "Friend, that is the ugliest thing I ever saw. Why don't you drop in the fireplace... like now. You have my word, I wouldn't tell anybody you turned it."

(BTW - I have a box full ready for the fireplace too, and I keep the lid on tight.)

Re: Who made it? #21?

#31

Re: What's Happening Here?.... Nothing unusual

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ron, when a critique is asked for, I feel that it's best to say what you really think. That's what a critique is. I agree, too many attaboys seem to be the rule. However, if no critique or comments are asked for when a piece is posted, then negative comments are out of order in my opinion. That is the rule on WoW, and I think that it should be here too.

That would be especially true when a piece is posted in a game such as Who Made It. In that case the person who turned the piece might not have even wanted it posted or commented on..

That's my opinion.

Wally

Re: Who made it? #21?

#32

Well Said Wally

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I agree,

If the picture of the turning is not posted by the maker, to me it's not to be critiqued.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Who made it? #21?

#33

Re: Critiques

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since my comment was the only "critique" in this thread, I'll point out that I commented in detail only because Al asked me to explain what I meant about a committee. Having been, I assumed in good faith, asked for an explanation, I think it's disingenuous to then be criticized for responding honestly.

Of course anyone is free to disagree with my opinion that was, after all, requested (although not by Anthony). But this wasn't a "pile on Anthony" (or on Al for that matter) situation in need of some forum protocol. Moreover, the WOW rule works because, almost without exception, that site is turners posting their own work. The rule works to encourage people to share their work with others without fear of unwelcome comment. Principle doesn't apply if someone is going to post a picture of somebody else's work, for implied comment through its recognizability or lack thereof, because the poster's feelings (or ego) are not at stake or in need of such a protective rule.

Al posted a piece in the little game. His post didn't intimate that he had a personal link or a story that made the piece somewhat special to him. If he had let on something of that connection, I most certainly would not have posted my original response, let alone the follow up comment.

We can all get very thin-skinned here, but I rather doubt that's the direction to take on WoodCentral boards.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#34

Well Said Wally I Agree 100%

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#35

Point to one post in this thread...

Ron in Drums PA

>Point to one post in this thread that is in bad taste or a critique.

If you want to ban all opinions, that is a different story.

Now, if you want to talk about critiques, isn't a critique a critical comment and not "don't ruffle any feathers" type of comment? Negative comments are sometimes part of a critique. The reason I am not a part of WOW is because some prefer a dishonest critique than one fits the truth.

But this is a game, no rules where ever laid out. Maybe you should write a list and submit them to a committee for their review.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#36

Actually Critique Is Not A Good Word

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>for what happened. The actual term might be catty. Just because you say it didn't happen does not mean it didn't. We are not stupid. Go back and decide if these are nice comments:

"A Committee"

"Perfect Mark, I Agree"

"Someone Short on Wood"

Re: Who made it? #21?

#37

I suggest you look up the word "Jocularity"

Ron in Drums PA

>Please don't put words in my mouth Barbara, I never said or inferred that anyone was stupid.

I will say that some have a lack of a sense of humor.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#38

Re: Critiques

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Mark, if someone posted one of my pieces in a game without my knowledge or consent, and the question was "Who Made This?", and one of the replies was "A Commitee" I would consider that a negative comment. I, or anyone else might take offence at such a comment.

I just don't feel that such comments belong in a game such as this one. We shouldn't have to have rules for such a simple and fun game, just a little respect for each others feelings.

Wally

Re: Who made it? #21?

#39

Ok, Guess I Better Fess Up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My use of the term "committee" arises from the study of art history and particularly a situation where the "name" master would block in the primary design/form/etc. and then hand the piece off to several apprentices to complete. Careful examination of the piece, whether in brush stroke or tool mark, could reveal which parts of the piece were actually done by which apprentice. I had a professor back when who was tracing work done by known artists back to when they were apprentices and the trying to determine what parts of their former master's work they had done earlier. We called such items "committee" pieces or "school" work.

The piece Al posted to start this thread has an apparent break in the form and color, making it look, to my eye, as if two parts of separate pieces had been put together. As I mentioned, the top seemed as if it was Anthony's work, but I discounted that impression because of what appeared to be a mismatch. I couldn't confidently say "Harris" so I a cracked a little joke. Not something that should invoke all of this charging to the defense of a person not here, who, I suspect, might even agree with the "comment."

Negative? Ahhh, perhaps. But not insulting unless one consciously chooses to take it that way. I've had pieces I've done subjected to far worse. Anyone who has had to put up a Master Thesis show (the final exam for years of effort) of their work for a panel of art historians and highly respected artists primed to pick your very best efforts apart and fire questions at you about those shortcomings for an hour or so, knows what "negative" is really about. You can take it as crushing, or you can make it a learning experience. Artists with fragile egos and thin self esteem don't get very far, especially if they can't take someone either disliking for finding fault with their work.

Yes, you're right, nobody here (least of all me) has been appointed Grand PooBah Critic At Large. But posting work invites comments. There's no WOWie Rule on this forum, but somehow, mean spirited negative comments just don't seem to crop up here. Maybe it's the water . . . .|;-}

And when it comes to photos of Dickermans being posted by others, I'm reasonably sure that the artist would never let loose of a piece, even a practice product, which would be open to the comment of its parts being mismatched in both color and form.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#40

Re: Ok, Guess I Better Fess Up

Ron in Drums PA

>Having an art degree, I can say that Mark is absolutely correct. (Mark, I thought you where a lawyer.)

I've been subjected to these panels and you come out knowing your worth, or lack of worth. I have seen people come out crying and take up dish washing as a profession and others take on a whole new direction in their art.

Maybe we should chance the name of this forum to WOWieCentral. :D

Re: Who made it? #21?

#41

Re: Ok, Guess I Better Fess Up

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Okay Mark, I guess that your definition of the term "made by a committee" differs from mine. I've always heard it used in a derogatory way.

My thoughts are that the game that's being played, "Who Made It", is just that, and im my opinion doesn't call for comments on the quality of the piece. That's in fairness to the person who made the piece but didn't post it, and certainly didn't ask for comments, good or bad.

I suspect that if Anthony was going to post one of his pieces for comment it wouldn't be this one.

I hope that the game continues for a while. It adds a little fun to WC. A bit of a change from the "What chuck should I buy" post'

Wally

Re: Who made it? #21?

#42

Panel Reviews

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Had 2: One for my studio minor in undergrad (in addition to the major comps exam). Since I was the first and (that year, only) art major to graduate, they took it easy on me. The second panel was for my masters in sculpture at IU. Had Roy Seiber (African Art historian) appear to ask me, in all honesty, about the "Messerschmidt Faces" on my figures. The pieces dealt with strenuous subjects from sport and dance, so I replied that using Mona Lisa smiles or Pieta facial expressions might be interpreted as a bad case of gas. We got along fairly well after that, |;-} but I still walked out feeling like someone who has taken a knife to a gunfight.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#43

Steven Antonucci

Are we only allowed "Nice comments"?

steve antonucci

>Let me know, and you can review my stuff before I post it. I wouldn't want to be viewed as anything but "nice."

Oh, wait. I'll take honest over nice.

I agree with Mark, Ron, et. al. about being able to openly express an opinion. You don't need to agree with it. You don't need to "read" my intent into it. I didn't make my comments to be meanspirited- they were meant to voice what everyone who looked at the box was thinking, but didn't have the guts to say.

Thankfully, there are some 'not nice' people who provide an honest opinion when someone posts something instead of all of the people who post attaboys or even worse... nothing at all when they see something "bad".

Steven

Re: Who made it? #21?

#44

Re: What we are allowed to do.........

Russ Fairfirld

>Unmless someone has changed the rules around here, what we are allowed to do is "abide by the generally-accepted, largely-unspoken rules of respect, courtesy and common sense that guide all communities, real or virtual. When in doubt, treat others as you would have them treat you."

Re: Who made it? #21?

#45

Steven Antonucci

And I prefer honest over nice so there you go.

steve antonucci

>All of the nice people have to realize that "nice" doesn't mean that they're right. I value the opinions of those who offer "negative" opinions occasionally much more than the "only nice" one's.

Either nice or negative, at least I know that they probably mean it...

Steven

Re: Who made it? #21?

#46

And that is what I thought was happening...

Ron in Drums PA

>And that is what I thought was happening until the same people get themselves bent out of shape over some ill perceived faux pas.