Ok, Guess I Better Fess Up
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>My use of the term "committee" arises from the study of art history and particularly a situation where the "name" master would block in the primary design/form/etc. and then hand the piece off to several apprentices to complete. Careful examination of the piece, whether in brush stroke or tool mark, could reveal which parts of the piece were actually done by which apprentice. I had a professor back when who was tracing work done by known artists back to when they were apprentices and the trying to determine what parts of their former master's work they had done earlier. We called such items "committee" pieces or "school" work.
The piece Al posted to start this thread has an apparent break in the form and color, making it look, to my eye, as if two parts of separate pieces had been put together. As I mentioned, the top seemed as if it was Anthony's work, but I discounted that impression because of what appeared to be a mismatch. I couldn't confidently say "Harris" so I a cracked a little joke. Not something that should invoke all of this charging to the defense of a person not here, who, I suspect, might even agree with the "comment."
Negative? Ahhh, perhaps. But not insulting unless one consciously chooses to take it that way. I've had pieces I've done subjected to far worse. Anyone who has had to put up a Master Thesis show (the final exam for years of effort) of their work for a panel of art historians and highly respected artists primed to pick your very best efforts apart and fire questions at you about those shortcomings for an hour or so, knows what "negative" is really about. You can take it as crushing, or you can make it a learning experience. Artists with fragile egos and thin self esteem don't get very far, especially if they can't take someone either disliking for finding fault with their work.
Yes, you're right, nobody here (least of all me) has been appointed Grand PooBah Critic At Large. But posting work invites comments. There's no WOWie Rule on this forum, but somehow, mean spirited negative comments just don't seem to crop up here. Maybe it's the water . . . .|;-}
And when it comes to photos of Dickermans being posted by others, I'm reasonably sure that the artist would never let loose of a piece, even a practice product, which would be open to the comment of its parts being mismatched in both color and form.