Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Who made it? #21?

Posts

Who made it? #21?

#1

Who made it? #21? 

Al Neighbors

>


img

Re: Who made it? #21?

#2

I Don't Even Have a WAG

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#3

Re: I Don't Even Have a WAG

Carole Valentine

>Me either. I am actually still trying to figure out exactly what it is...not sure if it is a box or what?

Re: Who made it? #21?

#4

Roger Dunn

not Richard Raffan

Roger Dunn

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#5

A Committee?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#6

Perfect Mark, I agree

john lucas

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#7

Mike Stafford

Anthony Harris.....SWAG!.

Mike Stafford

>http://acmewoodturning.com/

Of course it is probably not Anthony's work but if you are not familiar with Mr. Harris' wonderful threaded boxes it is still a nice site to visit.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Someone short on wood ;-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#9

Pssst, Barb . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What's a WAG and why and for what would I need one?

|;-}

Re: Who made it? #21?

#10

Re:It will be interesting to find out........

Jamie Donaldson

>....if Carole's "Wild Ass Guess" is the same definition as mine!

Re: Who made it? #21?

#11

Used To Have

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A good link for acronyms, but lost it.

Wild . . . Ass . . . Guess

Thanks, Jamie

|;-}

Re: Who made it? #21?

#12

Re: Pssst, Barb . .

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>LOL, now you know. I don't know what the S is in SWAG so don't feel bad.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#13

Scientific

Stuart Johnson

>

Re: Who made it? #21?

#14

Mike Stafford

SILLY!!!

Mike Stafford

>I always thought it was Silly Wild A$$ Guess...

Re: Who made it? #21?

#15

Re: Anthony Harris.....SWAG!.

charlie belden

>Mike wrote

> http://acmewoodturning.com/

> Of course it is probably not Anthony's work but if you are not familiar with Mr. Harris'

> wonderful threaded boxes it is still a nice site to visit.

Thank you, thank you, thank you!

( and maybe Curse You Curse You Curse You - now I've got to go find the Hows

and With What for threading boxes)

charlie beldenb

Re: Who made it? #21?

#16

Re: Anthony Harris.....Right!!

Al Neighbors

>You win the prize, Mike. It's Anthony's. Absolutely perfect threads. I don't know what kind of woods. Thanks for the link, too, Mike!

Re: Who made it? #21?

#17

Here it is, Mark.  *LINK*

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>


http://www.acronymfinder.com/

Re: Who made it? #21?

#18

Thanks! Now

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I won't be CWAD

Re: Who made it? #21?

#19

A Committee? What do you mean?

Al Neighbors

>Apparently John Lucas got the point, but I guess I haven't done much to improve my density, which seems to be inherent. :)

Can you explain it to me Mark?

Thanks,

Al

Re: Who made it? #21?

#20

Re: A Committee? What do you mean?

Ron in Drums PA

>Old saying

If a committee designed a horse it would look like a camel.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#21

Re: Close

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A camel is a horse designed by a committee of lawyers.

|;-}

Re: Who made it? #21?

#22

Re: The Committee

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Al.

With all due respect to whomever turned it, it shows disparate choice of woods and a pair of forms whose only clear relationship is the point where they meet. There is little attempt to reconcile the upper form with the lower cylinder which while subservient as a support, somehow manages to swallow a large chunk of the upper form. In short they don't fit awfully well, so the posited "committee," like so many, appears to have members turning items will little communication as to a unified goal i.e. the end product.

Re: Who made it? #21?

#23

What's Happening Here?....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The game of "Who Made It" has turned into a bunch of nasty, unasked for comments and critiques.

I think that the game should be over.

Wally

Re: Who made it? #21?

#24

Re: What's Happening Here?....

Steven Kubien

>Thank you Wally. Well said.

Steve Kubien

Re: Who made it? #21?

#25

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Maybe we need to be more selective of the examples we post. I've seen a number of Anthony Harris' pieces, but what is shown, while it used the "onion dome" and finial forms Anthony Harris does a lot, illustrates an incongruity of the wood mix and form juxtiposition that did not look like his work; a copy, maybe, but not an original. I was rather surprized when Al confirmed it as a Harris piece. Anthony Harris is a much much better artist than the picture presents, and the comments in this thread indicate reactions of others to the example's shortcomings.

So, rather than end our little game, maybe we should spend a bit more time in selecting photos. Putting up a second or third tier (even funky) example of a turner's work kind of skews the odds of identification.

Make no mistake, I'm not pointing a finger at Al here; just making a suggestion for future posts.