Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Lessons from my first "class"

Posts

Lessons from my first "class"

#1

Steven Antonucci

Lessons from my first "class"

steve antonucci

>I volunteered to teach hollowing to a bunch of club members yesterday(some who read here). I made a syllabus for my club demo coming in July, and kind of used it on my guinea pigs yesterday. I think I have the right material, but what works in a demo and what works in the lab do not always match :-)

Here are my notes for the next time:

1.) Classic "engineer" mistake: Estimating time. I had figured we would spend an hour making tools, and three hours turning. This was based upon my assumption that we'd blow through turning some handles because I COULD BLOW THROUGH THEM in 10 minutes. I had four beginning turners in the shop, and we took a lot longer than 10 minutes each handle. I think it was good overall, because we covered a lot of ground, but it put us behind a bit.

Same issue when it came to hollowing. Just because I can hollow something in an hour, in hindsight, it seems crazy to think someone hollowing for the first time might be able to do it. I had planned on covering two or three different forms, with each one getting progressively smaller openings. We got one, and it took an extra hour and a half.

2.) Never factored in the social aspects. In estimating time, I was heads down focused on the 10 tasks we needed to accomplish. While we were there, I sharpened a lot of tools for folks, reground a couple of profiles (what the heck are the guys at Sorby trying to do to these beginners?!), and generally milled around in and out of conversations.

3.) Didn't have a plan for the "failures"-i.e things that didn't go the way that I expected. Most of our work was successful in general, but we lost the bark on the vessel edge in a couple of places, and I would have started over. In retrospect, I should probably turned most of the handles prior to arrival, I should have roughed out a couple of forms just in case we had a catch, etc. If I run the session again, I have some lessons learned.

4.) I think I had too many people (5). Most of the time, there was a line at the lathe for people to turn. We had a good time and did the best we could, but 2-3 would have probably been a better number and given those folks much more hands on attention. I work in a one car garage, er um- shop, and it was also a little bit crowded.

So, for anyone else out there looking to jump into the void, I high recommend it. Some careful planning and a handful of turners can make for a fun day. Everyone learned something yesterday, including this instructor!

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#2

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

Cyril Griesbach

>The best laid plans can often go up in smoke, Steve. The important thing is that you made those plans so that you could provide the most learning possible for your students. Equally important is that you learned something yourself and now you can continue forward with improvement. I'm sure your students learned much and that each of them left with an appreciation of what is possible and some ideas of how to get there. No doubt they also left with an appreciation of your skills and efforts. Well done!

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#3

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

Barry Irby

>Cyril is right.

My son was fresh back form Iraq and made the comment "No plan survives first contact with the enemy". He saw me thinking that over and said, Well the actually quote is "No plan survives first contact with reality".

Next time that first contact will be different. You can't out guess it. No two sessions will be the same. Just try to get most of your topic covered. Also, have something to fill with in case you get a group that just sits and stares.

So, I think you did well. You had a plan. It worked reasonably well. Now you have a had a reality check on that plan and you can improve it. Allow for the discussion. Allow for the beginners. Pad the time. Have some spares. Have a good time.

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#4

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

john lucas

>Steve other than the willingness to share and help others you have taken what I think is the most important step. Evaluating what did and didn't work and trying to make a plan for the next time.

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#5

Steve, you have made an ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>important next step. You analyzed what did and did not work and you haven't wasted time blaming class members. You have also thought of ways to streamline the process next time. I think you will assess the class members next time and have a more realistic approach to what they can accomplish. Because you seem willing to learn from your teaching experiences, you would seem to have real potential as a teacher.

I will be teaching an ornament and boxes class in August and from what I see of the class roster so far there will not be many newbies (if any). We will need 1/4" round skews and I may just take a bunch, take some handle blanks and steel, and let them decide whether to purchase one of mine or make one of their own. This way we can get to the ornaments sooner.

Thanks for your analysis and observations.

Ed

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#6

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

Jerry McCaffrey

>As one of the guinea pigs, I greatly enjoyed the class. Steve, your analysis of the failures (relative) was accurate and stemmed only from your prodigious agenda. Counterbalancing that was your knowledge and enthusiasm for turning. I’ve now taken two afternoon hollowing courses in the club, the one from you and also from Dennis Fuge. One thing that I took away from both courses is that both of you do beautiful work with primarily homemade tools rather than over priced commercial versions.

I’m sorry that I could not stay for the entire hollowing instruction; my wife had acquired tickets for a show that evening – not something to miss to “keep things turning harmoniously.” The tool fabrication section was very worthwhile. Yes, we all took more than the allotted ten minutes each, but I enjoyed skew practice with the techniques you illustrated. I will practice some of that later today. One thing that you didn’t take into account for almost any turner and especially beginners is stepping up to a strange lathe, with different tools and grind profiles, and under the close scrutiny of ones peers can take some adjustment and time just to get comfortable. Yes, probably on my old Jet, alone down my basement, with my tools and sharpening, I could bang out a handle in well under the time allotted – not so easy under novel circumstances. It is from these new circumstances that you learn, however, and I enjoyed the “Lacer training” you provided and found it helpful.

Thanks for an enjoyable afternoon

Jerry

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#7

Steven Antonucci

The pleasure was all mine...

steve antonucci

>Thanks for your kind words. Be very thankful that I cut the agenda down (yes, it had a lot more in it... before I thought I had it "done").

It's sometimes hard to do these things when you've never met the folks andthey don't know what's where in a strange environment. I remember fumbling around Bill Grumbine's shop at Five Barns a few times, and scratching my head with some of his grinds too...

Wait until you see the program in action in July. I'll have the tool made in 5 minutes (since I am using a PowerPoint!!!!), unless there are a million questions (which I now anticipate...) I hope to have a few minutes to actually turn, and I will plan a bit better so that the tools I make in the PowerPoint are the one's we cut with in the demo...

Thanks again for being my crash test dummy, and being so candid. I am glad we both "walked away from this one".

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#8

Steven Antonucci

Blame is futile...

steve antonucci

>It's rearward facing, and nothing can be done to change the past. I signed up for it, and would gladly do it again, but it was kind of stressful knowing that some things just weren't going according to the plan.

My wife commented that I needed to have food too. If I had thought of it, I might have even had someone pack their mini.

Wait 'til next time...

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#9

Steven Antonucci

Six Sigma for woodturning

steve antonucci

>Eliminate defects at the cause vs. fixing them as they arise.

I had 10 pounds of stuff and a five pound bag...

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#10

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for the vote of confidence

steve antonucci

>Rookie mistakes. Can't get experience without the bruises...

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#11

Teaching Can Be Very Satisfying...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I congratulate you Steve for volunteering to teach other turners. I find teaching to very rewarding. I've taught a lot of turners over a lot of years and have learned a great deal about teaching along the way. Still learning.

I've thought about writing a short piece about my teaching methods and a few teaching experiences that I've learned from.

Early on (20 years ago) I volunteered or was asked to assist a couple of very good teachers, Ray Key and Vic Wood. A great learning experience for me, and it inspired me to pass on some of the turning knowledge I'd picked up over the years.

One of these days.

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#12

Steven Antonucci

Appreciate the encouragement

steve antonucci

>It was something that I had wanted to see if I could do, but was always worried that I couldn't fill a day. We scheduled for 4 hours, took 5 1/2 and just barely finished one vessel. Two of the attendees wives called looking for them (slightly panicked), so I guess I have enough material...

Steven

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

#13

Roger in MO

Re: Lessons from my first "class"

Roger in MO

>Steve, yoour thread brought back memories for me. It was 1958 when I began teaching industrial arts in a small school in mid MO. Thanks.

You are on the right track to review and analize each session and look for improvement. And its always a good idea to have more in the store than you need. Keep at it. Roger