Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

How long does it take to dry chunks?

Posts

How long does it take to dry chunks?

#1

How long does it take to dry chunks?

Joe Pack

>I have a good number of log sections that I have picked up over the last couple of years from our town's tree trimming, planning to cut them up for bowl blanks "some day." I sealed the ends well, so end checking does not seem to be a major problem. These are primarily maple, with some walnut and cherry tossed in. Diameters range from 8" to 20" and most are about 16" long.

I know that bowls from fresh, wet wood need to be roughed out and allowed to dry for several months before finish turning, but I'm not sure how long to let bowls from 1 or 2 year old cuttings to dry before finishing. In general, how long would you guess it would take? The 2 year old cuttings have been stored in a back yard shed under cover. The cuttings from last summer have been on end, circling the trunk of a big sugar maple in my back yard.

An ignorant follow-up...how do you know when wood is dry enough to turn directly to finished size without the probablity of the bowl cracking?

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#2

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I have always understood that timber dries at the rate of approximately (Dependent on storage, climatic conditions etc.etc.) one inch per year.

As for part finished bowls it varies considerably, usually the only recourse is to weigh the bowls before storage and then reweigh three to six months later and repeat as often as necessary. When the weight stabilises it usually means that that is the mein for that piece of timber and it is likely not to change too drastically (If kept in the same conditions)

No doubt others have different ideas on this subject, just bringing it up at a club meeting is sure to have as many ideas as members!

Peter.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Jesper, Denmark

>Splitting them lengthwise through the pith is a safe way to stop splitting in places you don't want. Even when sealed on the ends, the wood will eventually dry enough to split. The shirinkage simply has to open up a crack somewhere.

They will dry faster and safer when split thi way, but you still have to seal the ends.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#4

Steven Antonucci

1" per year is a flat stock notion

steve antonucci

>The truth is that in log form, you will not get down to EMC (Equilibrium Moisture Content) in your lifetime and you will split.

As other have mentioned, it's a good idea to get the pith out. It also is a good idea to get the sapwood off, since it attacts bugs. Basically, prep your wood as much as you can, and seal at least the end grain with something like Anchorseal.

I always leave it longer than wider, to avoid any end checking causing issues. I simply cut it away. As previously mentioned, rough outs can speed up the stabilization process. I usually can return a bowl to the lathe after 3-6 months and it will keep pretty round.

Steven

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#5

Re: 1" per year is a flat stock notion

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Actually that is an invalid gauge with flat stock. With anything over 1" (i.e. 2"=2 years) it is so totally invalid that I can't imagine why it is still being used.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#6

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Joe, there is no one accurate answer. As has been mentioned the logs should at least be split and if possible the pith removed. Each type of wood will react differently in every part of the country. I have found that eventually even large cut out blanks will split somewhere even when completely treated with Anchorseal (twice on the ends and once on the other cut surfaces).

If split, the small log sections will eventually dry (or rot depending upon the environmental conditions) however the wood will probably not be usable because splits.

If you are not able to rough out the pieces, you will eventually loose them.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#7

Steven Antonucci

I agree...

steve antonucci

>Actually, I meant it for people cutting boards. I don't think of "flat stock" as anything over 2", since I'd just cut a circle out of it and turn something if it was that thick ;-)

The local mill guys all say the same thing. If you start getting into cants or flitches, the numbers go way up. I don't have that much patience to get my wood ready to use, and with prices in BF, a 4" thick x 6" wide board is going to be 2 BF per lineal foot, so not only will it take forever, but it will cost an arm and a leg!

Steven

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#8

It Is Still Wrong

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>The old saying of an 1"/ year for flat stock is wrong no matter how many of the local sawyers are still saying it. I certainly would qualify as an old sawyer but unlike many other old sawyers I keep up on current information.

The saying would be right up there with "You will get a cold if you go out in the winter with wet hair" or "If you reach above your head when you are pregnant, the baby will have the cord wrapped around its neck".

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#9

Denis Putland

Re: It Is Still Wrong, I agree

Denis Putland

>I agree wholeheartedly ::)))

Different woods = different rules + different environment = ????????

use your cheek to feel for moister or weigh or use a moister tester, or ????

Denis

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#10

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Barry Turner

>A better idea is to rough turn your blanks. You remove the wood from the inside of the bowl and this allows it to dry from both sides instead outside only. Rough-turned blanks will usually dry enough to be reasonably stable in 3 to 6 months, instead of years. Not only does rough-turning allow for faster, more even drying, relieves internal stresses in the wood, but it also gives you something to do in the meantime.......:-)

In terms of relative fun and excitement, waiting for bowl blanks to dry is right up there with "watching paint dry".

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#11

Steven Antonucci

It's a rule of thumb, not a law...

steve antonucci

>If someone asked me for a best guess, that would be my starting point. After a year, a cheek test will probably not say much (the outside will feel dry, but you won't know about the inside if the wood is thicker).

If it is critical, I'd use a moisture meter. Otherwise, I'd put it in a stack and forget about it for a while. Can't hurry wood air drying, and there isn't such a thing as "too long"...

Steven

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#12

Wood Can Be Left Too Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Unless the conditions are correct, wood can be left to air dry too long, especially in dry climates. Since you are still insisting that the inch/ year has any validity, even as a "rule of thumb" I assume you are speaking of flat wood.

This discussion is a very good example of why all of us need to critically look at information we receive from others. Just because one of us gives information does not mean that information is correct. That is why I am making an issue of this erroneous assumption that for flat lumber the inch/year has any validity.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#13

One Source *LINK*

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Dr. Gene Wengert has been in the sawing/drying profession for years. Here is just one quote and the source.

"12/29 #4: Can this wood be dry? ...

GeneWengert-WoodDoc

In an enclosed strucure, it would be expected that you would achieve around 9% to 10% MC. In an open shed, 12% MC is common.

The 1" per year is incorrect and I have no idea where it came from. If yu see it in a book, perhaps the book is no good. For example, 8/4 takes 2.5 times longer than 4/4. Further, 60 to 90 warm days will achieve very dry wood in most cases for 4/4. "


Source

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#14

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Barry Irby

>Good advice here.

My experiences. Letting chunks or log sections sit around and dry results in mostly failures. They often split. Or they rot. End sealing and other attempts to retard drying may slow them down a bit, but it does not completely stop the drying and therefore does not stop the splitting. Think about what is going on. Green wood is wet and swollen. As it does, it shrinks. The problem is that the part that dries first shrinks first. The end grains dries readily and splits easily. If you Seal it, then it dries through the bark, and the sapwood or outer surface splits. The core or center stays wet and swollen the longest while the rest is trying to shrink. Somethings got to give. If you plastic bag the wood and arrest eh drying, it may not split, but it rots. DAMHIKT

So the purpose of AnchorSeal and other retardants is not really to cause the wood to dry perfectly, its to slow it down to give you a chance to cut it into blanks or smaller pieces that will have a better chance of drying uniformly with out splitting. Smaller pieces are more successful than huge chunks.

I have turned a few hundred wet bowl blanks. My success rate was better than 80%. I don't keep records and compile statistics, but I bet I got a bowl of some description out of about 90% of the rough outs. I bet 90% of the logs and big chucks failed.

If I were going to cut pieces to be put away or ignored for a long time, I would split the log down the pith and then leave it full length or if I cut it in shorter sections I would make them time and a half to two time the bowl diameter. That it, if I were looking for a twelve inch bowl, I would make the blank 18 to 24 inches. Then later, I would cut the split ends off and turn the bowl out of the sweet part. If I had the long length, I would cut half a diameter off the end and then take out the blank.

Think about that for a minute. What is really happening is you are preserving the wet part of the blank by sealing the ends and/or cutting off the dry part so that you can turn the wet part that has not cracked yet.

So, to maximize the wood, you should turn it into roughed out bowls as quickly as you can. Raffin discusses that he has people cut trees and bring them and he has people chainsawing blanks while he is roughing like a maniac. He has bowl blanks in the drying room on the same day the tree was cut.

He also discusses cutting a slice off the end of the log and giving it a whack to see if it will split. If it splits, he takes another slice. You really don't want to waste your time turning a blank that has cracks in it you have not seen.

All of this varies with species of wood, local climate, what ever conditions you set up for drying. Just how high is up?

There must be a hundred pages of discussions about how to dry bowl blanks here. DNA, soap, paper bags, shavings, and about ten more. Some are fairly well based in science and some are pretty much folk lore.

Make some rough outs and let them dry a while and turn some bowls. Weigh the blanks if you want or use the kiss method, or just wait a few months and have at it. Some people turn the green to finish and let them warp. Its great. A very natural form you can't get any other way. Do both. Make some rough outs and while they are drying turn some green. Turn something. Have fun, or you really will end up with firewood.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#15

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

Barry Elder

>I agree with Barbara about the 1" per year blarney. Here in Florida with all the tropicals and native hardwoods, high humidity and temperatures much warmer through most of the year, I find that it depends on the tree and sometimes on the particular piece of wood. I salvaged some trees from a local botanical garden which were on the ground for five months before I discovered them and some had already checked severely and others had no checks at all. The black mangrove (dead, for all you tree huggers) on the island that I salvaged will probably take 50 years to dry.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#16

Barbara is right

Ron in Drums PA

>Even with flat wood you can not effectively dry wood that is over 2" thick, air dried or kiln dried.

As a rule of thumb, air drying 1" per year is "basically" only good for 1" thick wood that has been properly stickered and stored in an accommodating environment.

Please note, rules will differ in Pennsylvania compared to Arizona. Lets not even talk about Florida, they are still confused about voting let alone drying wood.

The rules also differ with different species of wood. Dense exotics such as the rosewoods from South America are allot more difficult to dry than the "light and soft" domestic Rock Maple. 2" thick Black walnut is easy to dry compared to 2" thick ebony which would never really dry.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#17

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: It Is Still Wrong

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>It is beginning to look as if I have stepped into a wasps nest on this subject!

I can only apply what I have been told since it is SO rare for me to use green timber due to lack of storage space.

Peter.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#18

Well said, my experience also

john lucas

>I don't have time to rough turn bowls and vessels. I get free wood but it usually comes when I'm busy at work so I put it up in the yard. Sealed or not, split or not it goes bad fairly quickly from bugs or splitting. Keeping it out of the sun and off the ground helps tremendously and sealing the ends seems to slow it down. Getting the bark off will help keep the bugs out but again only slows them down and usually it's too much work to remove the bark.

I leave the logs as long as possible and then cut off then ends when I want to use them. This works well if I can get to them reasonably quick. The problem with leaving them long is I never take the time to split them at the heart because ripping a 5 foot log takes forever. If the grain is really straight then I can split it but quite often I get the wood because it was in someones yard and it's knarly and crooked grain and won't split.

I just tell my self that it was free wood. The only cost is hauling it to the dump every so often to get rid of the truely bad stuff.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#19

Re: It Is Still Wrong

Stuart Johnson

>How were they able to build all of the colonial furniture shown on Antiques Roadshow? If they hadn't used some sort of "rule of thumb" how did they determine just when their stock was going to be ready? It seems like after x years of experience they would come up with something like a year for each inch. Whatever they did they didn't have the fancy moisture meters available now.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#20

Yea but students want an answer

john lucas

>I've read a lot of literature and found one article saying the wood in log form may actually stabilize and not dry out at all for years. Way longer than the year per inch theory. I cut 3" and 4" square blanks and they usually dry enough to use in a year or more (I don't really keep accurate track).

However when your teaching classes the students just don't accept the fact that you can't tell them when a bowl will dry. I think this is why the year per inch thing keeps going. If you rough turn a bowl to 1" thickness it has been my experience that it will dry in about 6 months or less here in Tennessee. I don't cut flat stock other than my 2", 3" and 4" square pieces and they seem to dry at a faster rate than the year per inch but again I don't have a moisture meter so I'm only going by how they turn.

Bowl blanks, say 10" by 4" seem to crack no matter what I do so I simply don't waste my time trying to cut them out unless I can put them in a plastic bag and turn them within a few weeks.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#21

Colonial Craftsmen

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>For the really fine quality furniture the general procedure was to air dry for 7 years. The craftsmen back then did not have to worry about modern heating and cooling. For the most part the houses inside humidity was not that much different from the outside.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#22

Re: Yea but students want an answer

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>IMHO students need to follow guidelines established by more experienced turners and then their own experience. If a student expects a teacher to provide all the right answers about everything then their expectations are unreasonable. A teacher should not feel responsible to provide all the answers.

The inch/year fallacy was applied to flat boards, not bowls. For the most part logs (saw length) will not dry completely unless reduced to smaller parts. Most will rot if left long enough. I have sawn many logs (usually walnut) that had been down as long as 10 years. The usual MC for the inside of those logs was +60 which is as high as the moisture meter registers.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#23

Plus

Ron in Drums PA

>Drying wood isn't an exact science. A trained eye and experience is what's needed.

There is no magic answer if a student wants an exact answer.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#24

Re: Colonial Craftsmen

Stuart Johnson

>For the really fine quality furniture the general procedure was to air dry for 7 years.

So they had a procedure (rule of thumb) to allow 7 years. My point is no matter what it is called, the length of time will vary because, wood species, thickness or even when cut will be varied but there has to be a general starting point.

Re: How long does it take to dry chunks?

#25

Re: Colonial Craftsmen

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Actually there was more involved than just the drying. The multiple seasons allowed the wood not only to dry but also to do a bit of shrinking and swelling which made the wood a little more predictable when used. That plus a knowledge of how to allow for wood movement made for successful craftsmen.