Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Posts

Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#1

Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Peter Hyde

>What is the difference between "multi axes" "multi centre" and "off centre"

Is there a difference? Are there any rules that should be used when describing a piece that uses any of the above?

Enquiring mind wants to know.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#2

No sure

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>But I think the first one has to do with chopping stuff. |;-}}}}}

Actually, from what I've seen, merely different terms describing the same thing. Of course the term "multi" implies more than 2, but that would be splitting hairs (with an ax?)

m

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#3

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

john lucas

>Peter I would assume they all mean the same thing but you could take it to mean Multi axis which would be rotating around an axis point such as the Escoulen chuck. Multi center would be moving the centers and probably offcenter would be the same thing but could also be multi axis.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#4

Mike Stafford

Huh????

Mike Stafford

>

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#5

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I believe multi-axis involves working between centers by moving the center point on both ends of a piece equally. This is eccentric turning. Multi-center also involves moving the center point, but not equally. This enables the turner to use separate axes for different elements on a piece, such as a multi-neck weedpot. Off-center is actually sliding a piece sideways off the center point so the element being turned is not in the middle. In the off-center bowls I turn, I will have a rim that is thinner on one side and thicker on the other. I will try to post a photo of a new off-center bowl tonight.

Hope this helps a little.

keithz

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#6

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

david

>FWIW, here is my take on the subject: When you get beyond the dimensions of a sphere, a 3-D manifistation of a circle, you no longer have a radius, therefore you are beyond any "center" terminology, such as off-center, multi-center, etc. An axis is formed by connecting point A to point B. You can have an axis on a sphere, but the implication is that the distance from point A to point B is more than twice the radius, or more than the length of the diameter. Using this logic, a piece of rectangular dimensions is a piece with an axis, which can be defined as a line around which the edges (distance from the axis) are symmetrical. Any time you are not turning on the true axis (spindle turning), you are creating another axis, which leads to multi-axis and other terms with axis in them.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#7

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

charlie belden

>Peter Hyde asked:

What is the difference between "multi axes" "multi centre" and "off centre" ?

My understanding is that multi-axis turnings

are done between centers - plural - as in a center at each end of the piece being turned.

Think of a square blank with centers on the same corner on opposite ends - or on opposite corners of opposite ends- or adjacent corners on opposite ends - each producing different "shadow" and "solid" areas along the blank.

A turned crank shaft is an example of multi-center turning to full round cross section though intersecting arcs are also available (think turned three sided box - with three intersecting arcs making up the sides)

Off center turning involves the blank being supported at only one end - in a chuck or on aface plate and typically a broad flat surface on the chuck/face plate side. The blank is moved so that its center is moved off its true center.

A square plate with two or more hemispheres turned into the surface. Graeme Priddle's "Canoes" pieces - a spear point shaped deck,

longer than it is wide - with one or more round "hollows" turned into the deck as an example.

Multi-center turning utilizes a special type of chuck which allows the center of the blank to be moved off the lathe's centerline - AND tilted off the lathes axis as well. Escoulen's little ball chuck with a hole in the ball for a tenon on the blank allows the centerline of the blank to be tilted away from the lathe's axis. His deluxe chuck (or whatever it's called) uses the same ball with a hole in it idea - but adds the ability to move the ball off the lathe's centerline as well.

Almost any Escoulen piece was probably done multi-center.

That's how I understand the differences - but I'm open to other ideas ; )

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#8

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

charlie belden

>chungd007 wrote

> FWIW, here is my take on the subject: When

> you get beyond the dimensions of a sphere,

> a 3-D manifistation of a circle, you no longer

> have a radius, therefore you are beyond any

> "center" terminology, such as off-center,

> multi-center, etc.

So if I swing a 30 degree arc, all points equidistant from a single point - the arc's center is not a true "center"? And the distance from that point to any point are the arc - which are all the same length - is not the radius of the arc?

While round cross sections are common in spindle turning - as well as bowl, plate and hollow form turning - other cross sections can be turned as well and have intersecting arcs creating two, three, four or more intersecting curved "sides".

charlie belden

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#9

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Fog Tanner

>I do quite a bit of multi-axis and offcenter turning. None of this involves between centers and all done with chucks. I have some peices which have the axis other than 90 degress from the base. This requires changing the angle of the piece in relation to the axis of the lathe. This would give you two axis, depending on how much you turn where. I have some which have more than two, where I turn some portion and then reposition the piece and turn on another axis.

I have some where I keep the same 0 axis and rotate the piece such that the original center is now off center by some amount. When turned you now have an off center or offset cut in relation to the original center. I do this when making intersecting bowls. I have also turned a three sided bowl this way.

I have some fun pieces where both the axis and center are changed. This produces a whole different effect. The first of these I turned was a square bowl, which added to the fun. The sides are higer on one side and the "center" is closer to one corner. I have some others where I changed the axis and offset several times. This is fun just to see what happens, it is not always what you think it is. One I thought would look like a spiral came out looking like an eye. Another was a bowl which has two distinct outer profiles and the inside has two intersecting "bowls" on different axis. The rim also has two differnt axis to.

I have several different chucks which allow me to do muti axis and offcenter work. Along with that I have had to make several fixtures for them to allow some of what I do. The Escoulen chuck is a good one to start with, but you need a sturdy lathe if you do bigger pieces. The larger one will allow you to do offcenter and eccentric or multi axis work. It is defiantely not for everyone and not the safest of endevours, but neither is mountain climbing. These days, I do more multi axis and offcenter pieces than I do "normal" bowls. I can't climb mountains anymore so this is the next best thing - well almost.

Multi-center pieces done between centers are another expereince. I have done a few and know how, but prefer chucks. You can offset the location of the drive or tailstock or both. This may either be by equal amounts or different amounts. You will get different variations doing each. You don't need any special chucks and can come up with some interesting pieces. I don't think I will ever forget the tribal looking piece that Clay Foster did in a demo a few years ago. It was a little pot bellied piece, he turned some groves across part of it giving it the tribal look. One end is larger than the other and the effect looked like some tribal art work or a small pygmie with markings across his stomach.

I saw Stacy Hager turn a spiral box between centers, the outside was spiraled the inside was turned on a 0 degree axis. This was done by laying out the two ends 180 degrees off from each other. On one end the "Y" points up and the other it points down. The ends were divided into three 120 degree segments which allows you to place the center along one of the three lines and the opposing end on a diagnal on the corresponding line. Its an interrupted cut on the three centers which will produce a spiral. Vary the offset from each end and you get a tapered spiral.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#10

Confusing???

david

>I guess I meant you no longer have a center point with a constant radius, for example an ellipse, which would have an axis. Difficult to define exactly, I guess.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#11

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Russ Fairfield

>Is there a difference? Apparently not. I sat in on a demonstration at the AAW Symposium and the demonstrator used all three terms, "multi-axes", "multi-centre", and "off-centre", in addition to "eccentric" in a single sentence.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#12

Charlie: multi-axis equations *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Charlie,

Is that your web page in the link below? Could Eqn(3), R=.7873S, be incorrect?

In looking at how the equations were derived, some things on page 2 confuse me:

"HF = S" :

---from the drawing, seems like HF = S - FCJ

---however, HF doesn't seem to be used anywhere

"IF = S - FCJ" :

---from the drawing, it seems instead that IF = R - FCJ

---then written as IF = R-(FC+CJ), R = IF+FC+CJ

---and since IF = r, then R = r+FC+CJ = 1.5r+CJ which is Eqn1

in "SOLVE FOR 'r', the 4th line is .634*r=.2103*S :

---typo, .2103 should be .2113

after equation 4: "Now sub. "r" into eq (1)" :

---typo: should the equals sign between the two terms be a plus sign?

---where does .3317 come from? (Eqn3: r = .3333*S)

---where does .2897 come from? (Eq1 has .2887 instead, from CJ=.2887*S)

---should R be closer to .7887*S (.788676*S)?

Also, AJ is determined, but I don't see where it is used.

JKJ


http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/MultiCe

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#13

Well I'm glad we cleared that up:-)

Peter Hyde

>My understanding was the same as Charlie Belden's but he put it in a lot easier format than I could. I'm going to do a print out of it and keep it handy so I know what the correct terminology is, assuming Charlie was right.

I think it will lead to some lively discussion on club night :-)

Thanks to all.

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#14

Re: Charlie: multi-axis equations

charlie belden

>John:

It's been 7 months since I put the page you

reference and I was jumping back and forth

between a spreadsheet where the actual

calculations were being done and the graphics

package used for the diagrams with the

accompanying text.

I'll try to round up the originals and go through

it again to fix the typo you found and to check

my work. But right now I'm working on an

"article" comparing three methods of cutting

mortises for loose tenon mortise and tenon

joinery illustrating each method's procedure

and layout and set up requirements along with

times per operation in order to utlimately

compare time to complete a real world sample

project. The three methods are

- the LEIGHT FMT jig

- the MultiRouter

- the Festool DOMINO

While a 20 minute demo of each would convey

the significant differences in methods, trying

to illustrate the differences has turned into

a "challenge" (read time consuming PITA).

Anyway - I WILL go through that page and the

related spreadsheet - make the correction(s)

and post the URL of the corrected page here

with a subject line "Multi-Axis Equation - Revised"

Thanks for slogging through the details. The

Peer Review is appreciated - and hopefully

will improve info for some curious turner,

charlie belden

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#15

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Al Neighbors

>This makes sense to me, Keith. Always knew you were a knowledgable person. :)

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#16

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

Dave Noon

>Hi Peter,

My twopenn'orth:

An axis is typically a line between two points, normally between two centres. Erego, when one has multiple centres and turns using them one creates multiple axes. Conversely when one uses multiple axes one has used multiple centres with which to create them.

So in my view,to paraphrase an old song, ...you can't have one without the other!

Dave

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

#17

Re: Your collective esteemed knowledge sought

charlile belden

>FOG Tanner (sounds like Smoke Grinder):

How about posting some pics of your muti-center / multi-axis bowls and pots? And maybe some Here's How I Did It?

Round cross sections are fine, but "interrupted cuts"/arcs open up a lot more possibilities.

charlie belden