Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Posts

Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#1

Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Mark Williamson

>I was wondering if I use the Watco danish oil on a piece, can i also put Boiled linseed oil on it? Would this even make a difference? Would it just be overkill. I dont know much about any of the oil finishes? Found a can of boiled linseed oil from previous owner and was wondering what differences there are between it and other stuff?

Thanks

Mark

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#2

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Ron McKinley

>I think that's overkill since Watco contains BLO as one of the ingredients......Ron

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#3

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>I would add that the Danish oil likely contains enough varnish to seal the finish such that the BLO would penetrate little or not at all.

You could give it a wax rub down and polish if you wished.

And next time, if you wanted to use the BLO first, you could.

Seems a good reason to make some practice pieces.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#4

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Al Neighbors

>Old Linseed really isn't anygood, either. There's a big difference in Linseed's also. Some Linseed oil is a non-polymerizing oil... some is polymerizing. I used to know the difference, but have long since forgotten it.

Danish oil alone is one of the finest finishes for bringing out the beauty of wood.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#5

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

jim miles- Charlotte

>Boiled Linseed has nothing to do with boiling. It means it has chemicals added that help it dry out faster. Non- boiled take weeks or months to dry. Linseed oil will darken with age. I use it a lot on my turnings, but not as a final finish. I put it on mid way through the sanding process and sand it, This produces a slurry that fills small holes, cracks, & imperfections. It also "pops" the grain - or makes the grain and character more pronounced. I usually finish with Lacquer or varnish over it, by the time you finish sanding there is not a lot of LO left. I think Danish oil is mostly Linseed or Tung oil

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#6

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Fog Tanner

>I use BLO under shellac quite a bit. It can give the wood a warmer look. On some pieces I will wipre them down with BLO and then friction dry on the lathe, then wax and polish. Raffan had taken to using BLO instead of mineral oil for some of his production pieces. If you do a search on Danish oil recepies, you will find that they contain BLO as one of the componants.

Another alternative is Mahoney's walnut oil. It is not like the walnut oil you get at the grocery store. Mike buys raw walnut oil and his wife cooks it, which changes the composition. It won't get rancid like the grocery store oil will and the bottles don't seem to go bad. I have started using this as an oil finish where I will be putting on several coats and hand rubbing them. I also use it on the lathe too, friction drying it. It works great when sanding too, if you are going to be using it as a final finish. It also doesn't have the oder that BLO or Danish oil has. For some reason BLO will stay in my sinus for hours after using it. I hand rub bowls at the kitchen table and no one notices.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#7

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Mark Williamson

>Wow, good info to know! I just started using the watco danish oil and I like it for the most part. Perhaps I am not using it in the right match with something before/after? I am looking for a higher gloss to the peice after I apply watco. I am looking for something as easy to apply as watco. I don't have the can right here so I don't know if this is just a really stupid question or not but is it possable that I just bought a "semi gloss" Watco and there is a high gloss Watco that I should look for instead? Or is it that I should just be buffing after I apply the Watco? I hope all this makes since to someone other than me? LOL

Mark

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#8

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

John K Jordan

>You can get a nice gloss with nothing but Watco oil. I use multiple coats, dry well between each (takes a few weeks), then buff with Beale. The cherry bowl in the picture was done with this method.

JKJ


img

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#9

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Mark Williamson

>OK! THAT'S what I am looking for! :) So, many coats of just the Watco and that should do it. Of course with a buffing. I do not have a buffing wheel, is it possable to get the same effect using a buffing cloth with rough lightly rubbed into it and then some white diamond rubbed into another spot on the cloth? Poor mans a$$ backwards buffing system?

Mark

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#10

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Mark Williamson

>sorry, "rough" is supposed to be "rouge". One of these days I'll learn to read before I post! he he

Mark

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#11

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Fog Tanner

>I have a Beall system and have gotten polished results on bare wood. The high gloss comes from the wax, which will dull over time. If you mixed up some danish oil and used ureathene instead of varnish you could possibly get a gloss finish without the buffing.

Have not tried buffing with the piece on the lathe and the "buffing cloth" stationary, but that should work. The Wright brothers built their first plane half bassackwards and see where we are today. One way to find out, give it a try and see if it flys. The Beall system was sold to be used over a hard oil finish, but I have used it over bare wood and also mineral oil with gloss results. I have made many test pieces, straight cylinders which I tried various finishes, waxes, and buffing. They are good to label and keep around for what works and doesn't work. Its always good to keep the failures for when CRS sets in, it will save you from doing it twice. Its like hitting yourself in the hand twice to see if it really hurts - when once is enough. You might try that with your idea - be sure to share your results.

But, if you look at fine antiques or fine handmade items they all have a satin finish and not a high gloss. There is a lot to be said for that kind of hand rubbed finish. It imparts a sense of craftsmanship and quality, and of a time when items were well made and carefully crafted. The high gloss today has become assoicated with quickly made ill crafted items that carry a shiney finish that reminds you of plastic. They are also a higher maintenance item with any scratch showing.

There is however that polished surface that we cannot dupliacte on the lathe and is only achived by time and the human touch. It reminds us of that pourch on our grandpaents house, the one that had years of foot traffic (some barefoot), that achived a well worn polished patenia through time. That is one reason I make so many tooth pick holders with only an oil and wax finish. They are made to be used and handeled and over time will look better than when they were new. That some day when the original owner is a memory, there will be some grandkid that will have a fond memory of their grandpaents when they pick up a toothpick from the holder polished by time and the human hand.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#12

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

John K Jordan

>I don't remember, but I probably used 6-8 applications of oil. I put the first few applications on in over the first day until the wood will take no more oil, not waiting for it to dry. I wait at least a day or so for each of the subsequent coats to dry completely. I like the oil finish since it penetrates into the wood.

The Beall system uses three cloth buffing wheels, the first with a tripoli compound, the second with what they call "white diamond", and the third a hard carnauba wax. The entire set is expensive but you could buy cheaper wheels and make the mounting mandrels yourself. Note that you do NOT want to use the same buffing wheel for each compound.

The Beall system comes two ways - one mandrel with a morse taper for the lathe and three wheels, or three wheels mounted on a long mandrel. I bought the first (since they came out with the triple system after I bought mine) but found it a real pain to change the wheels on the mandrel for each compound. I ended up buying a morse taper mandrel for each wheel which added quite a bit to the cost. The triple wheel system would be cheaper, however, the individual wheels do give you more working room for large pieces. Note that the Beall wheels may not fit on small lathes.

Regardless of the finish, I apply Renaissance wax with a cloth at the end to help protect from fingerprints.

You can get the same results with hand rubbing. I recently helped a gentleman finish a gun stock and it came out with a beautiful high gloss finish. In fact, the guy thought it was a little too glossy so he was going to go back the the steel wool stage and stop when he had less gloss.

The recipe was sanding to 400, three coats of Casey Birchwood Tru-oil finish, 4/0 steel wool, then repeat the finish/steel wool sequence about 10 times, then rub out by hand with triple F compound, 3 coats oil and rub out again with triple F compound, then rub with 5 F compound, wax, and buff by hand. We used pummice and rottenstone from Woodcraft instead of the specified compounds. I think he cheated a bit on the number of oil applications but the result was fantastic.

The Tru-oil is a fantastic finish. It drys much faster than Watco. As mentioned, it is hard to beat a hand-rubbed finish on wood.

I haven't tried it, but I'm imagining that buffing with a cloth while the piece is spinning on the lathe might give you problems similar to the concentric sanding scratches commonly seen in careless work. What might work better is the small "bowl buffs" or buffing wheels in an electric angle drill while the work is spinning on the lathe. I have some that are about 2" in diameter. I think these are made to buff the inside of a bowl, but I think they would work better on the outside than a stationary cloth. I see Craft Supplies has them but maybe they are cheaper somewhere else.

JKJ

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#13

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Mark Williamson

>Either way, it looks like I have some stuff to add to the "when I win the lottery shopping list"! LOL So much stuff to buy, so little money to buy it all with! he he

Thanks for all of the feedback! I have some experimenting to do!

Mark

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#14

Email sent, Mark.

Al Neighbors

>

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#15

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

John K Jordan

>>...So much stuff to buy, so little money to buy it all with! he he

There are problems with everything. I have an abundance of tools and wood and almost no time to turn. Opps, gotta go fertilize the cabbages and feed the goats, mow the front pasture, turn over the compost piles, mulch the raspberries, and attack that stump by the chicken house with the backhoe.

JKJ

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#17

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils... *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>In case you aren't confused enough, there is more on the topic at the link below.

My comments on the Watco Danish Oil may or may not be correct, depending on when it was made and who made it. This product has had so many different owners and has changed so many times over the past 20 years that it has been impossible to keep up with what it is and how well it works as a finish. Some of them were pretty bad. The latest version is made by RPM Products, and is the beest formulation in recent years.


http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/finish7.shtml

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#18

Soybean Oil ?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I didn't see anywhere on the MSDS where it listed that there is only 5%BLO or that it contains soy bean oil. Actually I didn�t even see BLO listed but I did see info that lists that it contains a minimum of 3% raw linseed oil and that there is an unspecified alkyd resin.

MSDS info is a tricky read between the lines sort of thing. If you read the info it lists some of the ingredients as less than a certain percentage. The formula does not have to contain any of that ingredient to comply with the MSDS, it just can not contain more than that stated amount. For proprietary formulas it is common practice to list several non ingredients in the MSDS. For the vital things, in the case of Watco, the linseed oil, alkyd resin and other resin those percentages are listed as not less than 3%. That means that there can be 50% or more and the MSDS would still be accurate as long as the health and reactivity info is still correct for the actually product. Remember the info for the solvents which added up to 75% does not mean that there is 75% solvent content, only that the formula contains less than 75% solvent. My guess is that there is probably close to 75% resins and oils and 25% thinners and solvents and that there is at least one non ingredient listed on the MSDS.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#19

Re:Great article

Ron McKinley

>Great article Russ. Thanks. Do you think you might be revising that article for 2008? .......Ron

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#20

Re: Soybean Oil ?

Ron in Drums PA

>Any ingredient 5% or more needs to be listed in section 2

I was giving them the benefit of the doubt

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#21

Re: Soybean Oil ?

Ron McKinley

>MSDS is probably mandated by the government and is about as reliable as the political promises made by politicians! .....Ron

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#22

Re: Soybean Oil ?

Russ Fairfield

>Soybean Oil isan't all that bad. In its natural state it is not a drying oil, and it will stay as a liquid. Drying agents (metallic oxides) are added to the oil to provide the oxygen required to make it polymerize into a solid so it can be used as a wood finish. The manufactures use it because it is cheaper than any other oil.

A soybean oil finish dries faster than Boiled Linseed Oil because of the oxidizing agents, and it doesn't turn as brown as fast as Linseed Oil. It doesn't get as hard as Linseed (my opinion), and is not as durable or resistant to alcohols and acids as the Linseed oils (again my opinion).

Tung Oil is the best oil we can use for a finish. It will not turn as dark as fast, and it is more resistant to water, alcohols, and acids, than any of the other oils. It is also the most expensive oil on the market. The last time I looked, a quart of tung oil cost about the same as a gallon of Linseed Oil, and a 5-gallon can of Soybean Oil. These differences in costs are reflected in the peices we pay for the commercial finishes.

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#23

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils... *LINK*

charlie belden

>While the information contained at the attached link was put together specifically for finishing Pointy Sticks it is applicable to other forms of wood working as well.

The BLO Finishing Schedule should be familiar to anyone who has applied a BLO finish.

charlie belden

Executive Director

The Pointy Stick Compendium Project

(TPSCP)


The "truth" about finishes ; )

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

#24

Re: Q: Danish/Linseed oils...

Don at Central Illinois

>Really loved the link. Started LOL at work and got everyone wondering what I was reading. Great stuff.