Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Which Elm is it?

Posts

Which Elm is it?

#1

Which Elm is it?

Greg Haugen

>I recently was given a fair amount of either Siberian or Chinese elm wood that has been turned into cylinders for drying and storage. I was wondering if there are any sources online or suggestions on how to tell which species this is from? The cylinders are made of about 50/50 heartwood/sapwood.

Thanks for any help?

Greg H.

Re: Which Elm is it?

#2

use your nose to tell

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Siberian elm is much darker and more ring porous than Chinese elm. The problem with that description is that without any reference you still have no way of knowing what you have. The other way to tell them apart is by smell. Siberian elm smells like a barn yard while Chinese elm has a spicy almost peppery smell with no hint of a barn yard. Chinese elm turns beautifully even if it does lack the more interesting figure of siberian elm. I particularly like chinese elm for mallets and chisel handles.

Robin

Re: Which Elm is it?

#3

Re: use your nose to tell

John Veerkamp, Western Mo.

>BTW, most of what has been called Chinese elm in this country is really Siberian elm. When the great American elm urban forests began dieing off they were replaced in many midwest cities by Siberian elms. It is a fast growing, short lived tree that is very prone to ice and wind damage. It does sprout back from stumps readily, but lacks the character of the native trees.

chances are you have Siberian elm.

John

Re: Which Elm is it?

#4

Re: use your nose to tell

Greg Haugen

>Thanks for the responses and info.

Greg

Re: Which Elm is it?

#5

Re: use your nose to tell

Ron McKinley

>Hi Robin! Very interesting. I've got several Elms and one will have to come down soon so I'll try your smell test. Thanks.....Ron