Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

New Shop Lighting

Posts

New Shop Lighting

#1

New Shop Lighting

Stuart Johnson

>I'm at the stage in my new shop to start giving some serious thought to the lighting. The shop lights will be on four circuits each switched so I don't need to turn them all on if not needed.

Right now I am considering going with spiral CFL with 100 or 150 watt comparable bulbs rather than tube lights. This is for general lighting that hope will be shadow free. I have only seen one shop with type of lighting and there was good all around light. Has anybody here used these lights instead of tubes? If so how do you like them. Does anyone have any input whether you have them or not? I figure if they don't work out it will be very easy to change them to tubes but I do have a concern about dust build up over time.

The shop is 30 x 40 with 12 foot walls but I think the finished wall will be closer to 10 foot. What spacing would be good for the lights either regular tube lights or CFL? The end result should be good general light as I will use task lighting where needed.

Thanks for any input.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#2

Re: New Shop Lighting

david

>Stuart: It is great to have a space with such a nice ceiling height. Most of us with converted garages do not have such a luxury. You did not mention a very important factor: does this space have a ceiling? If it has, you can suspend the lights and have both direct and indirect (reflected) light, which will help to eliminate shadows. I am not an electrical engineer(architect)--you can benefit, perhaps, from the light data charts that you can find in the lamp product catalogs. This information may help you with spacing of the fixtures. Lamp technology seems to be changing very rapidly, and LED seems to be all the rage now. My feeling is that CFLs would result in a lot of point sources of light, while the tubulars, like the T-5 and T-8s (investigate "super" T-8 technology too). Spread the light over a larger surface and will give you more light over a larger area. For what is available in places like Home Depot, I would go with T-8s. If dust is a big concern, consider a fixture with a sealed enclosure. I recenlty installed some track fixtures using aimable fluorescent flood lamps, and am very happy with them.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#3

Re: New Shop Lighting

Dick Parr

>That is what I am doing in my shop. As the 4 foot shop lights burn out I am replacing them with that type of light and bulb. I only have a 10" ceiling but they work great and NO ballast to burn out. Some of the fixtures I am installing have the pull chain because I am finding out I don't need as many light fixtures with these and only need some for spot use.

I do have a 500 watt halogen light over the lathe. But the others give off plenty of light. Make sure you get the bright white bulbs, the other type don't give off a glare, but they only have half the light.

Seems to be a drop in my electric bill for the shop also...

Re: New Shop Lighting

#4

Re: New Shop Lighting

Stuart Johnson

>Dick, What spacing are you using?

Re: New Shop Lighting

#5

Re: New Shop Lighting

BillyJ

>Don't count on the CFL bulbs for to much, I have replaced the standard bulbs in several fixture (keyless) with them and they start getting dim after about the first 200 hrs. of use. Also they never produced the amount of light that was hoped for. I had to go back to mixing 200 & 300 watt incandescent to get usable light. Initially I was concerned about putting fluorescent in because of the flickering in temps below 50 degrees in the non HO bases, however have found though experience seldom does the shop get that cold, so the search for fixtures is on. I'm going to use the quad T-20 both drop in and chain hung. The Shops box car siding ceiling is 11ft. and really don't care if the fixture side shows by using the drop in and converting it to chain hung (I think I can skirt it anyhow). Since the T-20 is being replaced by T-8 in commercial remodels I'm getting the fixtures for carry off its yours, have 6 only 20 more needed and have been told they are on the way. Most of the time the armor wiring thats going to be needed comes along also. Plus a case of bulbs.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#6

Re: New Shop Lighting

Texian

>Stuart,

My 25' x 30' shop has 18 two-tube fixtures (two 40 watt tubes each) on three circuits, more or less equally spaced around an 8 foot high ceiling. The fixtures are hung close to the ceiling on short chains. The ceiling and all walls are painted flat white. My reason for multiple circuits was to allow capacity for ceiling drops to various other equipment. Also have six 220v outlets in ceiling, as I wasn't exactly sure where the lathe was going to be.

One local gallery has special tubes in their lighting with 5200K color temperature (simulated daylight), but am told these were special order and rather pricy.

I think the tube fixtures will give more uniform light distribution than single bulbs, but that's just an opinion. I use the twisty compacts in photography, and they have a color temp. of 2700K, probably about the same as regular "daylight" tubes.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#7

Re: New Shop Lighting

Bart Castleberry

>Had the 100/150 watt CFL's up as temp lights on pigtails, put up the 8' T8's, T8's are far, far better. According to the labels they had the same outputs. The difference was apparent. T12's are being phased out, don't waste the time. The T8's next to T12's make the decsion clear too. T8's will cold start better. $40 for a 8' T8 fixture with 4 4' bulbs is cheap. On one side of the shop, I've got about 1k sqft, and about 20 8' fixtures, roughly every 2-3 feet. It's just about right. In a 14x20 spray booth, I've got 7 8' fixtures and about a dozen 100-150 watt incadescent flood lights. It's not blinding. You will neve regret having extra light. Frankly I'd figure out what you think you need and add 50%, add 100% if you skimp on things.

White semi gloss walls and ceiling will make a huge difference too.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#8

Re: New Shop Lighting

Stuart Johnson

>Thanks everyone. Some good information that give me a starting point.

Re: New Shop Lighting

#9

Re: New Shop Lighting

Ed in Leaside

>I'm not sure if it was flourescent or incandescent, but I recall you need 1.5 to 2 watts per sq ft.