Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

Posts

Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

steve antonucci

>So, for a long time, I was in solitary. I turned for 10 years before I met another turner. This year I joined the AAW and two turning clubs. I am glad I did.

One of the clubs is brand new. We have 16 members, and we just had our third meeting. I watch other people during the meetings, and I have sort of volunteered to take an active "leadership" role of some sort. Honestly, I think my interest in the club meetings is very different than the typical attendee.

Looking for an answer to the following: Why do you belong to a club AND attend the meetings?

So far, here's what I've seen:

Beginners wanting to learn the basics

Interested in the demonstrator (big name turner)

Night out (easy to please)

Opportunity to network with other turners (trade wood, tools, techniques, whatever...)

So, with such a diverse group of skills and interests, how do you manage to attract new members and keep everyone happy and meetings interesting? I may end up being the guy who needs to figure this out...

Thanks

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Birds of a feather flock together......

Jesper, Denmark

>It is very much easier to socialize with people you know have a same or similar interest to yourself.

Turning, like so many other crafts are of their nature a solitary occupation. Like with so many things, being herd animals, we have a need to socialize and exchange ideas/views/experience/you name it with a group of people, who we know are pre-qualified.

It gives turners a very nice feeling that their peers understand their difficulties with the skew - or have mastered it and can give that know-how to others.

I do not really know why it is, but in woodworking clubs, there does not seem to develop the competition in other types of clubs - you know what I mean, the type of mine is bigger than yours type of thing. No it is much more like. " I can help you with this!"

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#3

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

GaryG in MD

>Steve,

I think you've already hit the nail on the head with your list. I believe it comes down mainly to education and camaraderie. Education includes local/member demonstrators as well as "name" demonstrators. Camaraderie includes an active Show & Tell program with photography, a Silent Auction for donated wood and stuff, and joint wood harvests, as well as the ability to chat offline and just hangin' out. To support both objectives, it's a good idea to have monthly meetings in an appropriate space (hopefully with a lathe), a book/tape/DVD library, and a solid web site and newsletter. Participation with AAW is highly recommended.

Phil Brown started Montgomery County Woodturners (of Maryland) a little over a year ago. We have all the above and a membership of 63 at last count, around half of whom come to any given meeting.

See http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org

and http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/MCW%20Newsletter%202008-05.pdf

We have hosted the likes of Bill Grumbine, Ed Kelle, Alan Leland, Brian Butters, Ron Brown, David Fry, and Dean Swaggert, and are looking forward to Stuart Batty, Judy Ditmer, and Jamie Donaldson this year.

The most important thing is to get everyone involved. The more who participate (rather than just attending), the better. Not everyone has the time, energy, or interest, but you'll be surprised by the talents that may be available.

...Gary

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#4

Free wood!

david

>We have at least two tree trimmers/arborists in our club. They and other members regularly bring a truckload of wood to the meetings to share.

--Great website: Secretary Tom Young, with no prior experience, developed a great website where members can post photos of their work in the Members Gallery.

--Demos: Through the networking efforts of Sharon Doughtie and Pat Kramer at symposiums and events--we have a great roster of demonstrators coming to out islands. If they are not passing through, we share the cost of transportation with the Big Island woodturning groups.

--Newbies who got bitten by the bug. Treasurer Andy Cole teaches a novice bowl-turning class at the local Woodcraft--a source of quite a few new members. Our current expanded meeting space is the result of the enthusiasm of a new member.

--Chapter challenges and Instant Gallery: The challenges usually pick up the topic covered the previous meeting. Last month it was a small or large platter. We ran out of table display space. This month it will be a small calabash--imagine what will happen this time. We have a participation prize for all Challenge or IG participants--a gift certificate, club logo merchandise, or donated wood for that evening.

--And did I mention free wood? We are fortunate to have great turning woods available--and some found nowhere else...

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#5

Steven Antonucci

I wish I was a member of you club too :-)

steve antonucci

>I've looked at your club via the internet, and I'd like to see us get there someday!

I think that we've got some plus one's going... the more (+1's) you have, the more people get motivated.

Having a good roster of demonstrators (+1).

Free wood (+1) Free wood in Hawaii (+2)

Having "good turners" (+1)

Diversity (+1)

I honestly think you need to be +5 or better to have people consistently return and participate.

Thanks for the input.

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Good input

steve antonucci

>We're small, and it would be great to be 60+ in a year. How did you recruit so many in that little time? Was it via cannibalizing other local groups (yours is closer?) or reaching new members?

I don't know if people don't know we're out there or just that I live in a "turner deprived" area. More is better for now. Active will come...

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#7

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

robo hippy

>I first started going to the local club (Beaver State Woodturners) to be a sponge--soak up as much information as possible. This continues still. I also wanted to get wood from the wood raffel. Now I want to get rid of wood, I have more than I can use, and still get more. I now belong to 3 clubs, and I do demonstrations, and mentor, which I love as much as the turning.

robo hippy

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#8

Re: Birds of a feather flock together......

ET

>Jesper, said:

"I do not really know why it is, but in woodworking clubs, there does not seem to develop the competition in other types of clubs - you know what I mean, the type of mine is bigger than yours type of thing. No it is much more like. " I can help you with this!"

On many occassions, I have witnessed woodturners slump into bragging about who has access to or knows the where abouts of the biggest stash of burls. I have seen this happen in informal groups at several conferences, both local and international. I guess these people recognize that they are standing among other turners who are equally skilled (or unskilled) and the conversation has no where to go but into the bigger unknown. I suppose the same thing happens among other hobbyists. Car collectors "know" where there is a mint '56 that was driven into the garage and left there, and only they know the owners aged sister.

I have also seen turners talk down their noses to beginners as if "where have you been", "everyone knows about that tool", "why aren't you buying from that catalog". Or people who give out only so much information, not wanting to reveal all their secrets.

One of the most successful clubs that I was introduced to was a 10 to 14 member (varied with the passing of time) club that met in the members shops and homes. Members know each other well and are respecful of what each brings to the group. Meetings are intimate, packed with discussion and exchange of information. They seem to drive each other with their enthusiasm and their productivity. Food figures prominently at these meetings. People breaking bread together forming a stonger bond.. I am making that up, but maybe it is true. Other clubs that I have been to that don't have food and drinks (non alcohlic) do not have the same kind of intimacy.

ET

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Food is a great idea!

steve antonucci

>I agree that food makes people more relaxed and open. When I sat with other turners at Totally Turning over dinner, we built an instant repoire.

I wonder if bringing some Dunkin Donuts to the meetings wouldn't be such a bad idea? We're small, so it's still manageable.

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#10

Steven Antonucci

Wood surplus here too...

steve antonucci

>If I ever run out of wood, it'll be a miracle.

I think mentoring programs make a lot of sense. Volunteerism seems to be something critical to a well organized club. I am not a spectator in anything I do...

Thanks

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#11

Beat me with a rock

Steven Kubien

>For me, the most important thing is being able to have more experienced turners and artists view my work (we have show-and-tell at each meeting) and say things like, "This is a nice piece but if you did X, and smoothed out Y it could be fantasitc!" Go ahead, beat over the head with rock until I get it straight! I get a lot of similar information listening to what is said about others work.

Demonstrators and demos are great, connecting with others who are covered in shaving and access to some neat wood are all bonuses which I enjoy very much. Learning and growing are more valuable to me right now.

Good topic

Steve Kubien

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#12

answers and more thoughts...

GaryG in MD

>Steve,

I wouldn't say "cannibalize", because you can never have too many meetings. "Add an additional venue"... yes. The DC area is loaded with turners from professional to wannabe (that's a positive term). We already had two clubs (Capital Area Woodturners and Chesapeake Woodturners), but both are an hour drive. That doesn't mean we don't still go, but... MCW is a success because 0) it's down to a 10-20 minute drive; 1) we have a critical mass; 2) great organization; 3) outstanding programs; 4) good meeting facility (thanks Nick); and 5) we keep reaching out. For every member we lose, we gain two. (Yes, computer people number from zero.) ;-) There's no question that it helps to be in an urban area where the line between craft and art is not considered to be important (see next month's MCW Newsletter).

Mentoring -- definitely! I forgot to mention that, but it's very important. How else does a beginner make rapid strides? We have some "beginners" who are turning out excellent work because they've had a couple of sessions with our more experienced turners. The reason I'm proud to be a woodturner is because we SHARE! And don't tell me we don't.

Demos -- when I joined CAW a few years ago, that was the most important thing for me -- and it still is. That's how I learn and grow (along with WC, of course -- thanks Ellis). Having a "name" turner come will often make the difference for me between "maybe" and "definitely". [Indeed, I'm having a severe quandry right now because Nick Cook is coming to CAW tomo, and the Beltway is effectively closed at that location in the morning. It's either a) getting into a huge backup/nightmare or 2) a very long detour and probably 1.5 - 2 hours each way. ...sigh... I haven't decided yet. This is the downside of the urban environment.]

Personal Contact -- Welcome your new members and make them feel at home. On my very first visit to CAW (bearing in mind that a typical meeting runs around 100 people), I was feeling a little timid and unsure of myself. Several of the "top" members searched me out and invited me to lunch (CAW meetings run all day Saturdays with a lunch break). They made me feel at home, and it's been so ever since. I can't say too much about this aspect.

Food -- MCW meetings are after dinner, so that's not appropriate, but CAW meetings have doughnuts and coffee. Very nice. Additionally, CAW occasionally provides free lunches on site -- sandwiches or pizza and drinks. Very nice, indeed. Otherwise Wendy's gets us. Food is good.

Steve, all things said and done, the two most important things are 1) get 'em in and 2) keep 'em coming back.

...Gary

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#13

Steven Antonucci

Real computer people number 00, 01, 10,11,100...

steve antonucci

>:-)

Appreciate you making the time to put the thought into the answer and follow-up. An all day meeting sounds like you'd have a full opportunity to do, demo, discuss, mentor, and more...

We have 3 hours, and realistically only 2. If we had the full day and pizza, I can only imagine what we could do. I bet that the pizza would get some pretty weird toppings- cherry curls and burl, anyone!

Get them in and keep them coming back... sage advice. I wonder how many people come in only once? I know I did at the first club meeting I went into years ago. It almost needs to be like a fraternity rush, where a big brother is assigned to the "pledge' to get them to fully commit to the group.

Thanks for the advice.

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#14

Re: Real computer people number 00, 01, 10,11,100.

GaryG in MD

>LOL re your new subject line!

MCW meetings are only 2 hours long (7-9pm) on a Thursday evening. It's a little on the short side, but that's our facility requirements. It gives us enough time for quick announcements, a decent Show & Tell, and a demo (bearing in mind that typical Symposium demos are just 1.5 hours). It works for us.

Good luck and keep us informed, Gary

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#15

Warning: Brag coming *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Because our's is the BEST! AAW's John Hill and some 400 others make Carolina Mountain Woodturners the biggest club in America. Our close proximity to both Arrowmont and Campbells brings the best demonstrators into the neighborhood. We have four video cameras and a moderator with monitors to select the best image for our three wide-screen televisions. It takes three people over three hours to handle our library. Our IG is forty feet long. Our meeting place has elevated, padded seats with a twenty foot square projection screen. Lots of the presenters say, "WOW, I have never demoed in such facilities!"

If you are around Asheville, NC on most third Saturdays, look us up. All meetings are FREE!

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains


CMW

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#16

Steven Antonucci

We're a little bit behind you...

steve antonucci

>Sounds like you might have a pretty good thing going. We had 16 the other night, and we ran out of seating. I sat on a workbench, which gave me a close-up view of what was going on. We had a PC with a projector.

We are also located by school, and Peters Valley lets us use their woodshop facilities to hold our meetings. This summer, they will be bringing in Michael Mocho, Beth Ireland, Mark Sfirri, Graeme Priddle and a few other well known turners. Some of them have agreed to come by the club and present "short programs". Can't beat that with a stick.

Thanks for the drive-by "mine's bigger n' yours" ;-) I think we've overlooked some of the video aspects so far, and I might just through my Handicam in the car for next meeting...

Steven

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#17

Re: Warning: Brag coming

John K Jordan

>I can vouch for that. The Carolina Mtn turner's facilities are wonderful and the times I've visited the meetings and demos were excellent.

JKJ

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#18

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>For me personally I enjoy sharing the evening with people I respect and who for the majority want to do the same.

I enjoy taking part in club activities and enjoy getting my leg pulled in a jocular fashion by those I consider friends.

It gives me some pride of place in the community.

Peter

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#19

Re: answers and more thoughts...

Carole Valentine

>"Personal Contact -- Welcome your new members and make them feel at home. On my very first visit to CAW (bearing in mind that a typical meeting runs around 100 people), I was feeling a little timid and unsure of myself. Several of the "top" members searched me out and invited me to lunch (CAW meetings run all day Saturdays with a lunch break). They made me feel at home, and it's been so ever since. I can't say too much about this aspect."

Wow. If that had been the case with the club I joined, I may have actually gone back. Not a single person welcomed me to the club, introduced me as a new member or otherwise made any attempt to make me feel welcome. Sourest bunch of people I have ever seen with the exception of one gal (I think we were the only two women there besides the club secretary) It was a wasted 3 hour round trip and and a $17 bridge toll. I made the trip because I had received an email from a board member (whom I did not know) encouraging me to come and join the club. That board member was not at the meeting. Had he been, perhaps things would have been different. I guess I will never know, especially with the price of gas approaching $4/gal!

Re: Open Discussion: What draws you to your club?

#20

Steven Antonucci

Mirrors my first meeting too...

steve antonucci

>Thanks for the reminder that a club needs to welcome new members. I had the same experience at the first meeting that I attended years ago. I just kind of sat and watched, and people let me.

I think your advice is very important to a new club to recruit new membership, you actually need to recruit! It isn't enough to e-mail someone and invite them to come by, you have to make them feel welcome and want to come by from the FIRST meeting. I looked around our new group, and I saw some familiar faces (even though I don't know everyone's name yet), and I suspect we lost a couple from the last one. One on, one off equals no growth.

Thanks, and I'll make a note to include to the President.

Steven