Think Thompson
Fog Tanner
>I have a large number of Henry Taylor M2 tools. But my choice these days is the Thompson. The edge lasts longer, which means less shaprening and wearing the tool away. The price of a Thompson is better than the same thing in M2, so I see no reason to buy the M2 anymore. There is also the personal satisfaction in supporting the economic recovery efforts of Occupied Clevland. I buy tools unhandled when possible, so I never consider that part of the cost. I like having the tools fit my hands and enjoy the practice in making them, so I look at a handled tool as paying for something I don't want.
For deep fluted or bowl gouges there are two different measuring systems, the American and English. The American is basicly the bar size, which for tools steel is several thousands over. The English measure from the edge of the flute to the opposite outside edge of the bar. So the measurement will include the width of one side of the flute. Craft Supplies uses the English standard in their adds, while Thompson and Glaser use the American. This means a 1/2" English is roughly a 1/2" American.
What size you get will depend on what you want to do. I have five or six 1/2" , three 3/8" and two 5/8" bowl gouges. For the larger and deeper bowl (over 12"-14") I use the 5/8". For the smaller I use the 1/2" and 3/8". A lot will depend on your grind and turing style. For the outside, I use a 9/16" and 1/2" shallow gouge for most if not all the bowl, saving the more expensive steel for the inside only. Something I learned from Raffan.
The reason for so many 1/2" gouges is different bevel angles and grinds. Each has a use and different style of using the tool. The same with the 3/8", even though I may use one on a 22" bowl. The two 5/8" are ground the same, as I only use them on larger bowls and don't worry too much about two different bevel angles. If I need a different angle close to the rim I use the 1/2" and the 5/8" for deeper in the bowl.
Doesn't matter if you a beginner or not. Get the better tools and save yourself the grief of the cheap tools in the long run. If you are worred about learning to sharpen, you can always buy a piece of 1/2" or 5/8" mild steel, gind a flat on it the width of the flute and grind it up learning to put the bevel and profile on it. A lot cheaper than buying cheap tools. The other advantage of buying the better steel, like the Thompson, is the edge stays longer and you spend more time at the lathe improving your skill level with the tool and you time as a "beginner" is reduced. When compared to some of the professionals, we are all beginners. They never got good using cheap tools, to be the best you have to use the best.
my $0.16 worth (after the adjusted cost of gas these days)..
Fog