Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Bowl gouge suggestions

Posts

Bowl gouge suggestions

#1

Bowl gouge suggestions

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hello,

I'm looking to buy a bowl gouge and was wondering what the group thought about different brand names, size, powder mettalurgy (spelling) and anything else I need to know before plunking down $$$$.

I don't want to break the bank....and as a novice / knowledgable turner I don't think I need to just yet. I'm looking for a tool that will last a while until my skills become more advanced and honed. (no pun intended)

And....if I can ask a stupid question..... I should be able to use this gouge for the outside and inside of bowls....right?

Sincerely,

Ray

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#2

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

dtewell at central illinois

>My first 'good' bowl gouge was the Ellsworth bowl gouge with the sharpening jig. Since then I've purchased some Crown and Pinnacle gouges, but seem to go back to the Ellsworth. I'd start with a 1/2" and you can get started for under $100. I'm sure more advanced turners will offer better insight, but this has worked well for me.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#3

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Ray,

You can find a lot of your questions answered here:

Even the bowl gouges are expensive, but do you aware that you probably would spend more on sanding disks per bowl than bowl gouges.

BTW, Thompson is the best in value and performance in my opinion.

Gordon


FAQ turning tools

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Dick Hines

>Doug Thompson has all you will ever need. I am sure some will post his site. I can't remember it. Sorry

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#5

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Ed Wujciak

>I recommend Thompson Lathe Tools. He can be found among the WC advertisers. And he's a nice guy too.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#6

Dick Hines

thompsonlathetools.com

Dick Hines

>

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#7

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'll second the motion for the Thompson bowl gouge. I suggest the 5/8 gouge. V flute or U flute shape is a matter of preference. No one has mentioned it yet but the Thompson comes unhandled. You do have make or buy a handle yourself.

If you're looking for quality along with price I can recommend the Artisan brand sold by Craft Supplies for around $50. There, the 1/2 in. size is the same as the 5/8 in. size in a Thompson. Artisan is made in the UK where they sized them differently.

Re. your question about using the bowl gouge on both the inside and outside of a bowl....the bowl gouge is just as the name suggests. it's designed for turning a bowl. All of it.

Wally

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#8

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions *LINK*

Rick Allen

>For $22 you can get a 5/8" Benjamens Best bowl gouge that is a fantastic value. And yes a bowl gouge works both inside and out.

Do yourself a favor and get two ($44). Sharpen them both the same. Use one until the tool isn't cutting the way you expect. Try the other, known sharp tool to discover if the cutting difficulty is technique or sharpness of the tool. The time it takes to sharpen a tool is just long enough to forget exactly how you were using the tool. Often times a slight change in angle or rotation of the gouge will produce significantly different results.

When you know what a less than sharp tool feel like you can grind the second to for a different profile that you might use for specific purpose (perhaps an extra long wing for shear scraping).


Penn State 5/8" bowl gouge

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#9

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

bowlman

>As others have said, get a Thompson 5/8" bowl gouge ... around $60. Then go to Craft Supplies, USA or Packard or any other seller that has lathe tools and accessories. Buy a handle designed by Mike Hosaluk (now sold by One Way and others)... another $30. Then you need the Ellsworth grinding jig and either a home made sliding jig arm or the Oneway Wolverine grinding attachment for your grainder. Another $ 125. Also make sure you have a decent whell dresser and set up jig. I recommend the Horizontal Solution from Don Geiger and also his wheel dresser. Cost maybe another $200. Sounds steep, eh? But, you can invest in these items now and eliminate most of the variable except your own skill set. So, if its not cutting, maybe it needs sharpening. A jig setup allows for repeateable dependable results. The wheel dresser adn set up jig keet the wheels true and balanced.

Or, you can spend maybe 5 years and a lot of frustration learning to grind freehand, going through several more bowl gouges in the process.

I started with a 6" Craftsman grinder, no jigs and tried it freehand. After a lot of learning, a lot of ruined wood, a lot of utterances of unreaptable words like darn and gosh dang, I finally tool the plunge. Now both sharpening and turning are a pleasure, not a hair raising, blood chilling method of raising blood pressure and shortening my life span.

Like the old commercial ... pay me now or pay me later ... and later always costs more than now.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#10

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Greg Haugen

>Ray,

One thing that hasn't been mentioned, I don't think. When someone is talking about Thompson's 5/8" gouge, it's the same size as the English (Hamlet/Packard, Crown (ellsworth), Henry Taylor, etc.) 1/2". English tool makers size bowl gouges by the flute width, and spindle gouges by the diameter of the tool, go figure. American toolmakers size everything by the size of the steel used.

For the price, bang for your buck, you can't beat the English high speed (M2) 1/2" bowl gouges which run about $60 handled. Packard tools (packardwoodworks.com) are made by Hamlet, which is what Craft Supplies sells, (woodturnerscatalog). Craft Supplies also sells Henry Taylor, which owns Hamlet. They also carry an "artisan" line of tools which are Henry Taylor tools that aren't polished, so what. Confused yet? Bottom line, with the exception of Sorby-which are still the same but higher priced, any of these tools are very close if not identical because the majority of them are made by the same place. For me, Packard is half of the time in shipping than CS so I order alot more from them. Depending where you are, east or west, it may be the other for you. For a good all around bowl gouge you cannot beat these.

For a step higher, then you get to the Thompson's and M4 steel gouges from Oneway. There's a few other American made gouges also. As you get to the more complex steels I'd recommend a better wheel, Norton's 3X. The steel is harder and sometimes with a soft AO white wheel may take longer to sharpen.

I do not like the Hamlet 2030 or 2060 steels. If you're looking for a better steel go with Thompson's or Oneway's.

I have the Packard M2 gouges and like them alot.

Greg

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#11

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Greg Burnard

>Ray, In addition to all the great suggestions already offered I might add that if there is a woodturning club in your area it would be time well spent to attend a meeting and pick a few brains. As far as tool quality I can now say after turning for quite a while that I have a couple five gallon buckets full of the cheap stuff. Id rather buy my last tool first. Greg

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#12

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

robo hippy

>Ray,

I also recomend the Thompson gouges. They do hold an edge better than any other gouge I have used. Size depends on what you like, I prefer bigger heavier tools because they just feel better in my hands, and I can do as fine of cuts with them as I can with the lighter tools. Also, you can reach out farther off the tool rest without getting chatter. You do need a jig to sharpen them, and the Ellsworth jig works fine. It is only about a half a degree more pointy than the way they come. You do need a grinder, and setting up for the Ellsworth jig is fairly simple. You do have to make some sort of pivot point for the sharpening jig to sit in. They do work well on both the inside and outside of the bowl. For narrower, deeper bowls, you can have difficulty making the transition from the side of the bowl to the bottom, but for flatter and more normal bowls, they work very well, kind of an all purpose tool. I frequently use them on spindles. There are U and V shaped gouges. With Dougs tools, the U is fairly round, almost C shaped, and the V is more U shaped. I prefer it.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#13

Think Thompson

Fog Tanner

>I have a large number of Henry Taylor M2 tools. But my choice these days is the Thompson. The edge lasts longer, which means less shaprening and wearing the tool away. The price of a Thompson is better than the same thing in M2, so I see no reason to buy the M2 anymore. There is also the personal satisfaction in supporting the economic recovery efforts of Occupied Clevland. I buy tools unhandled when possible, so I never consider that part of the cost. I like having the tools fit my hands and enjoy the practice in making them, so I look at a handled tool as paying for something I don't want.

For deep fluted or bowl gouges there are two different measuring systems, the American and English. The American is basicly the bar size, which for tools steel is several thousands over. The English measure from the edge of the flute to the opposite outside edge of the bar. So the measurement will include the width of one side of the flute. Craft Supplies uses the English standard in their adds, while Thompson and Glaser use the American. This means a 1/2" English is roughly a 1/2" American.

What size you get will depend on what you want to do. I have five or six 1/2" , three 3/8" and two 5/8" bowl gouges. For the larger and deeper bowl (over 12"-14") I use the 5/8". For the smaller I use the 1/2" and 3/8". A lot will depend on your grind and turing style. For the outside, I use a 9/16" and 1/2" shallow gouge for most if not all the bowl, saving the more expensive steel for the inside only. Something I learned from Raffan.

The reason for so many 1/2" gouges is different bevel angles and grinds. Each has a use and different style of using the tool. The same with the 3/8", even though I may use one on a 22" bowl. The two 5/8" are ground the same, as I only use them on larger bowls and don't worry too much about two different bevel angles. If I need a different angle close to the rim I use the 1/2" and the 5/8" for deeper in the bowl.

Doesn't matter if you a beginner or not. Get the better tools and save yourself the grief of the cheap tools in the long run. If you are worred about learning to sharpen, you can always buy a piece of 1/2" or 5/8" mild steel, gind a flat on it the width of the flute and grind it up learning to put the bevel and profile on it. A lot cheaper than buying cheap tools. The other advantage of buying the better steel, like the Thompson, is the edge stays longer and you spend more time at the lathe improving your skill level with the tool and you time as a "beginner" is reduced. When compared to some of the professionals, we are all beginners. They never got good using cheap tools, to be the best you have to use the best.

my $0.16 worth (after the adjusted cost of gas these days)..

Fog

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Keith Tompkins

>Amen, Brother!

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#15

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

Barry Turner

>I have a Crown PM/Ellsworth Grind and a CET/Glaser, both in 5/8" size. I like both tools. I also have a Sorby 1/2" bowl gouge. In spite of some bad press from others, I love my CET/Glaser bowl gouge. Using the Wolverine setup and a 120 white wheel, I can get that gouge sharper than any tool I own and it probably stays sharp longer than any tool I own. I like the new-style aluminum handle with lead shot inside to dampen vibrations. Except in Winter, of course, when it is cold to the touch until the shop warms up.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#16

No question about it...

Allen Neighbors

>you can use a gouge on both, outside and inside of a bowl.

One more thing: If you go with Sorby, Henry Taylor, Crown, Jerry Glaser, or any of the other well known, expensive tools, you might be satisfied, but you'll always wonder if a different brand would be a better gouge.

I'd bet my boots that if you went for a Doug Thompson Gouge, you'd never wonder. You'd know you have the best.

Just my humble opinion! :)

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#17

Re: Now the probing question of.......

Jamie Donaldson

>...which has to come first, the Thompson steel tool or the handle??(;-)))

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#18

Re: Now the probing question of.......

Fog Tanner

>Which shows the difference between Hisownself and us mere mortals. I was in a class with Raffan last summer. He was using one of the Kelton collet handles to save on weight when traveling. He was showing how to make a partiular cut on a piece, which is now in my display case along with a memory. He only wanted to make one particular cut and rather than waste time switching the tool out in the handle, he picked up the detail gouge with no handle and preceeded to make the cut. He did this a couple of times when he got in a hurry. Of course we had some fun with this over the week.

As for me, I used my Henry Taylor skew to make a handle for my Doug Thompson skew, which I then used to make a handle for my Thompson gouge(s)....

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#19

Re: Think Thompson

Bill Neddow

>I can only agree. I turn a lot -- finishing 250 bowls a year and roughing about 500 (to build an inventory). I have tried almost every bowl gouge on the market and now use the Thompson tools exclusively. They are the best and very inexpensive. Better to learn with a good tool than to get frustrated and quit because of bad tools. I first tried wood turning over 40 years ago, buying a cheap lathe that was no good. I could not even turn a file handle on it, and I gave up wood turning for almost 30 years. Finally, I bought a decent second-hand lathe and turned a file handle on the first try. Never stopped turning. My big table saw now serves as a table for turning tools. Just think of the fun I could have had for almost 30 years if I had bought that decent lathe at the beginning.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#20

Re: Think Thompson

Fog Tanner

>Bill,

Thanks for erasing several years of regret. For the past several years I have been regretting that I did not get into woodturning forty years ago. I had been married a couple of years and we had just moved from an apartment and were renting a house and had the space. I looked at the adds for wood lathes for years back then, but couldn't afford them. About the only thing I could have afforded was the one you got rid of. From what you wrote, that would have probably ruined me on turning forever. Would never have turned a bowl and never had a use for a Thompson gouge.

Now I will just consider myself fortunate for having walked into the Cutting Edge looking to buy either a Delta Unisaw or a wood lathe and coming out with the lathe and getting into turning when I did. And equally as fortunate for seeing a response in a thread one day by some guy named Thompson who had made a few gouges out of A11 steel and was going to sell a few of them. I got the first one in Texas and more important a friend in Clevland, Ohio. Funny how things work out for a reason. Just like your relating experience of 40 years makes me glad now instead of sad....

Thanks again,

Fog

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#21

This is so true.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>We all have stories like that... I to had a cheap lathe for 25 years and a four piece set of Craftsman tools. Turning was not fun but something you had to do. I use to make a Maloof style rocker and the front legs are a simple offset turning, it would scare me to death to turn the legs, once the joint was cut there was no room for error on a simple turning.

I bought a PM and it sat for months, it wasn't fun with the craftsman tools. A set of three Henry Taylor bowl gouges were bought and that lasted about 1 hour... it wasn't fun. I then bought a Glaser, right from the package Jerry's tools were sharp... I still remember the first 5 seconds that tool hit the wood, this was fun. I never looked back, in the sprit of a true tool hord I bought 11 Glasers (4 still in the package LoL) That one tool changed my world.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#22

Bill Blasic

Re: This is so true.

Bill Blasic

>One thing is for sure and that is that it is tough to beat a Thompson tool. Price vs Value unbeatable and if your not happy with it Doug will buy it back. My goto tools.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#23

Re: This is so true.

George Van

>And to add to that Bill, They are great tools with well thought out flute profiles at a great price. The design of his round flutes are perfect for a conventional grind, with or without a micro bevel, they produce fine finishing cuts that save a lot of sanding time.

I do not think Doug is spending any money buying tools back ;-))

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#24

ebd

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

ebd

>I just looked at the Thompson site and they do look good. One thing I would strongly advise. I would go with a U flute. The V flute in larger sizes seems to me to be a little harder to control. At 3/8" the V's are pretty easy but at 5/8" you have to really pay attention.

Re: Bowl gouge suggestions

#25

The tool comes first!

wilbur

>When I was getting myself started up with woodturning, I had this very problem. I had my choice of using the 50+ year old tools that came with the lathe when I bought it, or the unhandled Thompson tools that had just arrived in the mail. I wound up using the Thompson 1 1/4" skew chisel unhandled (!) to make a handle for itself. Then I used the now handled skew chisel to make handles for my other Thompson tools.