Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

Posts

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#26

Steven Antonucci

I've never broken one in shear

steve antonucci

>I have snapped the heads off of them in dry wood under a twisting load (not shear), but I've never had one break on the lathe. We've all twisted heads off of screw in the past, but the screws aren't being twisted on the lathe once they're in. It's the fact that they're brittle and subjected to a load that they weren't designed for that causes them to break.

If you have 8 of them holding wood on and the wood is relatively balanced, I can't imagine what you'd have to do to simultaneously shear all 8 heads off. Just for giggles, screw one into a board and try to shear the head off without "twisting it". A quick Google of the "shear strength of drywall screws" lead me to an article that said it was ~190 pounds. 8 of them will support almost 1500 of shear load. If you somehow manage to generate that, you let me know... :-)

It's not luck that they've never broken. It's physics.

Steven

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#27

Re: Almost any screw.

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Drywall screws would be my last choice for a faceplate screw.

Wally

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#28

Re: I like Spax screws *LINK*

Wilford Bickel

>Paul - look at the link. I would have to check on a box at the shop when I get home but I think they are made in Germany.


Spax Screws

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#29

Not so confused, but another question

wilbur

>Actually, I have been able to pull some good info from this thread. Thanks, everyone!

The question that I thought of as I was reading the replies is, is there any reason to believe that a #8 zinc plated steel screw from the specialty dealers (McFeely's, etc.) would be more resistant to torquing the head off than the ones from the borg?

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#30

I wish

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I wish they would not try to make the screws work with both drives. I love the square drive screws and I think the combination slots are a step backwards. I'd rather have to find the right driver than to have a slot that doesn't hold as well. I'd like to see all screws go to square drive, unless they are hardware screws and it is a matter of appearance.

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#31

Dick Hines

Re: Almost any screw.

Dick Hines

>Wod turning is the only thing I wouldn't use a drywall screw for. But if you give me dry wall screws, duct tape, ty-raps and WD 40 I can fix anything around the house.

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#32

Menards carries them.

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#33

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

jim Miles - Charlotte NC

>Wilber I do 95% of my turnings on faceplate with glue block & don't have tailstock

Also to support my Woodturning habits I build boat docks on the Lake and have installed probably over 100,000 screws of all kinds.

Some experience & prejudiced opinions:

1. All slotted head screws have one location in my shop - the trash

2. Wood screws- tapered -same

3. I find most useful and easiet to use are sheet metal screws.

Photo attached - several varities avail at Lowe's

4. Phillips heads strip out too quickly

5. Square head much better, I get about 20 - 30 uses before they strip

6. Hex heads don't strip out

7 Deck screws are OK, but the metal very brittle. ( In dock construction if we have one that bends or won't go in the quickest way to deal with it is to kick it and they usually break off)

8. Stainless steel - the metal is too soft -breaks easily

9. If you break a scew in the wood, chisel out around the top of it, until you can hold with visegrips & turn out.

10. I use a faceplate with an inner & outer circle of 6 - 8 screws. see photo. The outer circle screws are longer to hold weight of rough blank.

The inner circle are shorter, when finishing I take out the long ones so I can turn off the waste block ( 2' stock ) the short screws allow you to cut through the waste block and work on the bottom of the piece without hitting screws.

11 Most sheet metal screws should not require pilot holes


img

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

#34

Re: Which screws to attach a blank to a faceplate?

Darrell Feltmate

>Wilbur,

Use #14 (i.e. 1/4" diameter) self tapping sheet metal screws. For the wood size you are using a couple are all you need although I use 4 because my faceplates have 4 holes in them. Make sure the length of screw allows for 1/2" penetration. Square drive is best. These things are incredibly strong and have deep, tough holding threads. O, for end grain, drive them at a steep angle.