Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

tormek vs slow speed grinder

Posts

tormek vs slow speed grinder

#1

tormek vs slow speed grinder

woody vt

>Does anybody have any thoughts on the subject? I am trying to decide to go with a Tormek or a Slow speed grinder with a wolverine jig setup. Both will do the job and I know that the Tormek will also shapen about anything, but it is about twice the price of the the grinder setup. Is the Tormek really worth the extra money? I am having a hard time justifying spending that much, but I also don't want to get the grinder and wish I got the Tormek. Help me please!!!

Thanks for your thoughts.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#2

Steven Antonucci

They do different things

steve antonucci

>Both will sharpen some tools. Tormek is slower, but sharper. Others will disagree with this, but it was proven with a scanning electron microscope to be the case. I own a Tormek, and you couldn't pry it out of my cold dead hands...

That being said, it is not a grinder. If I had to grind a bolt head off with a Tormek, I'd shoot myself first. I don't own a grinder, and I flip my belt sander over in a vise when I need to grind. I use old belts and whatever grit and this works pretty well.

If you want to sharpen tools, the Tormek is unbeatable. If I sharpen and hone my skew, I can shave myself with it. If you try that with a tool off the grinder, you'll end up with a burn :-)

Steven

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#3

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Doug

>I have them both. I used the Tormek for some things. I used to use it all the time on my turning tools. I don't anymore, I used a slow speed tool grinder.

I am a old tool and die maker and have made many cuttting tools. I can't argue that the Tormek sharpens better but with the time it takes to sharpen a tool verses usng a slow speed tool grinder I just found that I can turn just as well and long using the slow speed grinder for sharpening.

My opinion is get the slow speed grinder first and then if you can afford it get the Tormek. Then you have the best of both worlds.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#4

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Chris in KC

>I, too, have both and I believe that one compliments the other. My wife gave me the Tormek some years ago when I began turning, but when I wanted to change a bevel angle the Tormek was too slow. I finally put out the $$$ for the slow speed with the Wolverine and it has made a real diference. I still use the Tormek for getting the tools sharp, but I use the grinder for getting them shaped.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#5

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Barry Turner

>I don't think this is an "Either or" question. Although I have never used one, mnost people agree that the Tormek will sharpen sharper, but at what cost? Well, the cost is apparent in the relative costs of the Tormek machine compared to that of a slo-speed grinder. But there is another cost, speed.

If it were me, I would buy a slo-speed grinder with the Wolverine set-up. Actually, that's what I have. I get tool edges that are quite adequate, right off the wheel, in a matter of seconds.

If I were heavily into woodcarving, with tools that are generally smaller, I would probably invest in a Tormek. The sharper edges would really pay off in woodcarving, but might not be so obvious for turning gouges and chisels. Trying to sharpen a bowl gouge on a Tormek would just take too long. This post will probably trigger a series of posts that will disagree with every single point I have made, and that's okay. That's why we have the First Amendment.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#6

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Barry Turner

>Don't forget the Jet knock-off to the Tormek. It might deserve a look, since it's quite a bit cheaper than the Tormek.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#7

Richard Allen

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Richard Allen

>Tormek expensive

Water and mess is a pain

Get the wolverine

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#8

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I bought an eBay Jet "knock -off" and set it up with the wolverine. Jet's wet/slow SHARPENER puts a fine edge on my gouges in about the same time that my bench grinder does, but I have so much better control that I never make a bad edge any more.

The bench grinder is very useful, but for me now, it's only brought out when I get a new tool and to change the factory grind. And, I kinda like the idea of being thrifty with my tools...not needlessly grinding away good steel.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#9

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Fog Tanner

>I have a Tormek and a slow speed 8" Delta tool room grinder. I use the dry grinder for reshaping and scrapers. For sharpening I use the Tormek. Once you get the hand of the Tormek, it doesn't take any longer to set the jigs as it does the Wolverine. When I am using my 5/8" or 1/2" bowl gouges a lot, all I have to do is put the gouge in the jig and spend a few seconds on the wheel. I don't change the horizontal rest distance from the wheel that way which saves time. The other saving is the edge from the Tormek lasts longer than the one off the dry grinder, so I don't have to go to the wheel as often as I did with the dry grinder.

What I do save over the dry grinder is steel. I don't grind tools away like I would on a dry grinder. With the price of steel going up, the trip to the grinder is going to increase. As far as any mess, you have a water tray versus the dust off the dry grinder. Its easier to empty the water tray than clean up all the metal dust.

I have all but one or two of the jigs and use the Tormek on everything from turning gouges to planer blades and wood chisels and don't regret spending the money. The turning tool steel I have saved has paid for all those jigs.

Fog

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#10

Diamond wheel

Bill Neddow

>No one has mentioned a diamond wheel. They are wonderful for getting a fine edge on tools and are available in many different grits. I use one all the time for touching up my tools, and it puts an incredible edge on the Doug Thompson gouges that lasts and lasts. It is also cheaper than a Tormek (a lot!) You can get one from Andre Martel (martel.public.netc.net/) If you do decide to get one, get the one with the metal center, not the plastic, as it is better balanced. Also, you MUST use it with a slow speed grinder. No connection with Andre. Just a happy consumer.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#11

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Barry Turner

>What about those of us who have shops that are unheated much of the week? Have there been instances of the Tormek water wheel freezing and cracking?

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#12

Cool...

Peter Teubel

>I wonder if he sells a diamond wheel for the Tormek. Now that is something I could use.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#13

Steven Antonucci

If my shop was unheated, I'd empty the water

steve antonucci

>My shop is heated, so I've never cracked a stone (on my second one).

I think it's about as common as a grinder wheel exploding...

Steven

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#14

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Cyril Griesbach

>Aahh...the Tormek VS slow speed grinder issue...once again. Every time this comes up the issue of how much time can be saved with one or the other. So...if I sharpened 100 times a day, and I don't and who does for that matter, I could possibly save what?...a couple of minutes? I can deal with all that lost time.

Me? I've got the slow speed and Wolverine. I spent my Tormek money elsewhere.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#15

or lower the tray when done

Darryl

>

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#16

diamond tormek wheel

Darryl

>There is a company that makes wheels for the Tormek. the tormek web site had a thread several weeks ago on that topic.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#17

apples, oranges

John K Jordan

>SUV, minivan. Folding chair, Aeron. Hammer, nail gun.

Both Tormek and grinder/wolverine will sharpen your lathe tools but in different ways, each with their own benefits and drawbacks. Much of the variety of response you hear depends on what that person has in their shop and is used to. This debate has been repeated nearly verbatim in various times and places.

I have both tools and what I reach for is:

Grinder/wolverine: Reshaping, removing a lot of metal quickly

Tormek: Beautiful, incredibly sharp tool edges on a variety of turning tools; extended tool life; no heat or sparks, very quick to sharpen once you know how.

- I have zero problems with the mess or inconvenience of dealing with the water. I keep a jug of water handy.

- I typically have a "sharpening session" and sharpen many of my tools at one time. This saves the setup time of pouring water into the little tank and letting it soak into the stone. This also compliments the way I like to work - for example, I keep more than one bowl gouge, hone between sharpenings with a small diamond paddle hone, and only stop to sharpen when several tools are dull.

- The Tormek does not take a long time to sharpen if you read the manual and learn how to do it properly. Once the edge is shaped, reseting it into the jig and sharpening takes only a minute or so to sharpen even the biggest bowl gouge I have. On the other hand, sharpening will take a LONG time if you don't learn how to align the jig properly.

- The Tormek is the wrong tool to use if you want to change the bevel angle or profile of a gouge or chisel or scraper.

- The sharpened edge is much smoother with the Tormek. This allows a much smoother cut, glass-like, especially with hard tropical woods. On many small turnings I start with 400 grit paper when sanding.

- Since the stone is so fine, sharpening with the Tormek removes so little material that your tools should last a lifetime or two.

- The very wide stone on the Tormek is a plus for many sharpening tasks.

- For the cost of a few extra jigs, the Tormek will also put a professional edge on a variety of non-turning tools.

- The cost of the Tormek is in fact far more than a grinder, but my observation is not many of poverty-stricken people of the world turn wood for a hobby.

JKJ

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#18

Re: Cool...

John K Jordan

>>I wonder if he sells a diamond wheel for the Tormek.

I've seen a diamond wheel advertised for the Tormek. From the experience with my Tormek, I don't think it would work well. Due to the manufacturing tolerances and materials used in the construction of the Tormek, it is necessary to dress the stone to make it perfectly concentric.

It would not be possible to dress a diamond wheel. I think a diamond wheel would need a more robust and higher-precision mount and bearings to run true.

JKJ

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#19

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>As stated this subject has been gone over a number of times with the same results. Either high or low speed grinder to shape your tools.

Tormek to keep them sharp, really sharp.

I primarily use 1/4, 3/8 and 1/2 inch double ended gouges for my work. When I go to the Tormek I sharpen all 6 ends in about 2 min..

I feel the savings in tool replacement cost over rides the cost of the Tormek. The new ones come with lifetime replacement of the grinding wheel and to me that would be an additional savings.

I have both in both of my shops.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#20

Re: Diamond wheel

robo hippy

>I looked into diamond wheels several years ago. I was told by Norton that they are for grinding carbide, and don't work as well on steel as they tend to clog up, and are hard to clean. Usually they are done like CBN (cubic boric nitride), which is made for grinding steel. You start with a aluminum or other material wheel that is turned perfectly round, then the abrasive is bonded to the wheel. This wheel doesn't need to be dressed, only cleaned. 1 by 8 inch CBN wheels cost me $300 each. The 80 grit wheel has lasted over 3 years. The bonded material was 3/16 inch thick. It might be down to 1/8 inch now, and I am a production turner, doing 700 or so bowls a year. It does wear, and I have to take it back to the manufacturer to get it dressed, but I am lucky that he is in town. You clean the wheel with an aluminum oxide stick. If you try a diamond dressing stick on it, it will eat the diamonds. 3M is getting into CBN wheels now. Don't know about their prices.

robo hippy

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#21

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Fog Tanner

>Barry,

That was a long running question in the Tormek users group. One of the members, who is a professional sharpener and uses the Tormek to make a living, ran a test since he lives in the phrozen north (New York state I believe). He took an old wheel which was down to around 8" and tried to break it. He set it in a pan with enough water to keep the wheel wet and let it set over night where the water froze. Didn't break, so he let it set several days, still didn't break. He did this several times and still has the same wheel. Several other people have tried and the freezing doesn't break the wheel like you would think. I don't know how the stone that Jet uses would work, since it is reportedly softer.

When I am through using mine, I lower the water tray. The wheel dries out in a few hours in the winter. But here winter is roughly three days, always starting on a Friday. Every so often we get a wake up call and will have teen and sub teen temps. When it is that cold, I don't turn so I don't worry about my Tormek. The cold air blowing over my bald head in my Airstream is no fun.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#22

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Doug

>I have to agree with this. The tormek is to slow for me. I use it to keep in practice it but my slow speed grinder with the wolverine setup is my main tool sharpner as for as my turning tools goes.

I do a little wood carving as well and I use only my tormek to sharpen my wood carving tools.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#23

there is one for sale

Darryl

>on the Tormek web page. (Yahoo groups). Phone 973-827-0230. Just noticed it don't know anything about it or owner.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#24

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

Russ Fairfield

>We have to ask ourselves some qestions, and how we answer them will determine which way we sharpen our tools.

For sharpening turning tools, the cost isn't a good comparison. There isn't that much difference by the time we have purchased a grinder, replaced the cheap wheels that came with it with a better grade, added balancers to the wheels, added a basic Wolverine system, and purchased a sharpening jig.

There is no arguement that the faster grinder removes metal faster.

Does the higher speed grinder do an adequate job for most turning? Probably.

Does it do a good enough job for making a light finish cut or a smooth cut in a wood that is prone to tear-out? Probably not.

Do you ever hone your tools with a slip-stone to get them to a sharper edge? If your answer is no, you will never like a Tormek. If you do like to hone your tools to a sharper edge, a Tormek is a Helluva lot faster than a slipstone.

And, don't forget the leather. If you have ever used a polishing rouge on a piece of leather to get the sharpest edge possible on a skew chisel or a spindle gouge, you will definitely appreciate a Tormek. If you would never do this, then you wouldn't.

Re: tormek vs slow speed grinder

#25

I bought a Tormek

wilbur

>I have a Tormek. The main reason I bought it was that I would rather deal with the water than with metal and grinder dust in my shop.

The Tormek is not as fast as a slow speed grinder at changing a bevel. But it's actually quicker than you might think. If you set the sharpening jig for your tool so that you are grinding with the wheel direction towards the tool, it proceeds much faster.

Besides, changing a bevel is for the most part a one time thing. If I was frequently changing the bevel on a tool, I'd buy two of the same tool and set up different bevels on each of them.

For me, the sacrifice in the speed of the bevel change is well worth the time saved in cleaning grinder wheel and metal dust.