Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

cherry toxicity (?)

Posts

cherry toxicity (?)

#1

cherry toxicity (?)

richard jones

>After reading an old article in FWW about cherry as a bad choice for kitchen utensils and toys, I got to wondering just how much of the article was truth or myth concerning toxicity. Other articles say quite the opposite. I make quite a few large spin tops, rattles, kitchen utensils, etc., from cherry and certainly don't want any adverse reactions from the end users.

Your thoughts?

rich in va

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#2

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Richard,

I've never seen cherry listed as being toxic.

The publication "Hardwoods of North America" from the Forest Products Lab says "no information available" on the toxicity of cherry.

Gary

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#3

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Carole Valentine

>My Mom was extremely allergic to the bark of wild cherry - hives, throat swelling - but the wood without bark didn't bother her. May have been some foreign substance on the bark, but my parents had to stop using cherry as firewood when I was a teenager because she couldn't handle the logs. She had many turned cherry pieces of mine that did not produce any reaction, but they had no bark on them.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#4

Myth *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Link is to the wood toxicity resources on the AAW site. Reprinted there are three detailed lists of potentially toxic woods and their affects, plus links to governmental publications. Domestic cherry is not listed anywhere. Think you should check that FWW article's sources.


Toxicity

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Richard, All trees have an immune system to protect themselves against parasites and disease. For example, "herbal" tea made from an infusion of cherry leaves will reportedly kill you. I don't imagine the bark is much better for you. Perhaps caterpillars seeking a quick snack have learned to look elsewhere than a cherry tree. Have you ever noticed that cherry wood does not spalt? It may have anti-fungal properties as well.

It makes an excellent barbeque wood however...or does it?

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#6

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

john lucas

>My friends who have horses won't take my cherry shavings. They say it's poisenous to horses. I don't know. I've used cherry in cutting boards for years and haven't killed anyone yet that I know of.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Keith Tompkins

>Interesting reading: www.vet.purdue.edu/depts/addl/toxic/plant46.htm

I googled "toxicity in black cherry".

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#8

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Johannes Michelsen

>I've never heard of any Cherry related toxicity but it's not clear if we are talking about Black Cherry, maybe it was some fruit tree that was considered toxic. Also if a finished utensil/bowl presumably with some finish on it could concievably leach out something of concern then what about the woodworker/turner who created it in the first place?

I've turned countless Cherry pieces hats, bowls, vase parts and have likely had at least 2 million miles of Cherry shavings go over my should all the while breating what ever vapor is being released by that cutting not to mention sanding and I ain't dead yet. So I gotta asume that Cherry is safe to use and abuse.

I sure hope so I just took delivery of 136 blocks about 24,000 lbs, Dave Lancaster is coming from Maine to get about half of it but I still have way more than i can use myself so if anyone is interested I do cut and ship lathe ready blocks.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#9

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I had started to post something earlier and decided not to because I wasn't sure if it was a rural version of an urban legend. The link you just posted confirms that what I had always heard is in fact true.

I have heard for years that cattle should be kept away from fallen cherry trees because the wilting or dead leaves could kill them.

On the other hand, cherry seems to one of the favorites for tent caterpillars. One of the reasons poison ivy is so widespread is that birds love the berries. Toxicity for one might not be toxicity for all.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#10

Re:Wild cherry trees are among the................

Jamie Donaldson

>...preferred hosts for Eastern Tent caterpillars, and were identified as a link in a disaster here in the horse country of KY about 5 yrs. ago. It was never completely explained, but apparently mares in foal ingested caterpillars during a freak early warm spell, and the hairs penetrated the GI tracts and resulted in spontaneous abortion of the fetus.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#11

Re: I've never heard of cherry shavings...

Jamie Donaldson

>....being toxic to horses, but it is a known fact in the horse industry that wilting red maple leaves can be toxic to horses if ingested.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#12

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Barry Irby

>The article you posted backed up and thoroughly explained what I always thought I knew. Growing up on a farm, I knew that farmers would put a fence around a fallen or dying cherry tree and keep the live stock away from it for a long time.

The story was that the leaves and twigs released cyanide when they wilted. It would not =hurt the animals as long as it was fresh and healthy, but something about it wilting made it dangerous. Exactly what the article said.

So, The wood and dust are not dangerous, at least anymore than any other wood.

This is sort of like potatoes. They are in the Night Shade family. The vines are toxic, but the potatoes are fine. Tomatoes are also in the Night Shade family. They were feared for years until the poor in Italy started eating them out of desperation. Soon the rest of the Population followed.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#13

Wild Cherry toxcitiy

Chicago Bob

>Without getting into a lot of chemistry, the wild cherry leaf and berry contain fairly high levels of cyanide compounds and thiocyanates that can be toxic to animals when ingested. I have never heard of similar CN compounds being in the bark or wood.

Bob Haines

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#14

cyanide

John K Jordan

>From my books, wilted black cherry leaves contain a cyanide toxic to many animals including horses, and especially goats and llamas. Unwilted (green) black cherry leaves are not a serious problem.

One thing my vet pointed out - many things are toxic to certain animals, I have a list for what I keep, goats and horses. But many things are tolerated in moderate quantities and toxic in large quantities. Red maple leaves are an exception - it is reported that a single mouthful can cause the death of a horse.

None of my references mention any toxicity to the wood, sawdust, or shavings. The only wood product warned against is black walnut sawdust/shavings as bedding for horses.

JKJ

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#15

Re: cyanide

Barry Irby

>John, I have known about he wilted cherry thing all my life, having grown up on a farm, but this is the first I have heard of the Red Maple thing. Are we discussing the ordinary red maple trees? Does it have to wilt? Aren't the woods full of them?

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#16

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

GaryG in MD

>One of our Club members who has turned a lot of black cherry reports having mild but definite allergic reactions to it now. ...Gary

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#17

Roger in MO

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Roger in MO

>Randy, the same report on wilting cherry leaves and cattle is prevalent here in Missouri. I won't cut a cherry tree in a pasture where cattle are grazing.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#18

Re: cyanide *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Barry,

From what I read (and echoed by my vet), common, ordinary red maple leaves can kill a horse in anywhere from a few hours to a few days. Google gave me plenty of references, the first one listed is below. (choose any search method and pick 'red maple') This reference indicates wilted or dry leaves are and can remain toxic for a month but recommends keeping horses away from green leaves as well.

However (and there is always a "however"), horses evidently don't seek out red maple leaves when there is something else available to eat, although the reference below indicates the leaves are palatable. The problem is evidently worse in the fall when grass may be sparse and falling maple leaves blow into a pasture. I know a guy who has a big red maple tree growing right in the pasture and the horses ignore it.

I read a sad story from one owner who found her horse dead in a pen when she came in from work - there wasn't anything else for the horse to browse on and it had eaten all the red maple leaves which had blown in from a nearby tree.

BTW, the reference in the link is one of the better I've seen, although it is centered on Indiana.

JKJ


to kill a horse (or other animal)

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#19

So...........................

richard jones

>If I'm reading the consensus correctly, it appears that I might not have to do that product recall quite yet.

Thanks for all the comebacks, that was quite an interesting thread.

Hope all have a great week.

rich in va

Matthew 8:26

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#20

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Stephen Mushinski

>Keith I have some cherry wood that has markings of spalt. I cannot get at it for a picture as the ice and snow makes opening the shed to much work at this time of year.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#21

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>Healthy cherry leaves contain prunasin, a cyanide precursor that in itself is non-toxic. When the leaves are damaged, the prunasin molecule is split and free cyanide (in the form of prussic acid or hydrocyanic acid) is liberated. Cyanide is extremely toxic (think gas chamber) and wild cherry trees contain the highest level of cyanide of any plant commonly encountered in nature.. Fortunately, the cyanide is usually present in this bound, non-toxic form. But the potential exists for serious toxicity, especially in animals which consume large quantities of the leaves or bark.

I am a retired pharmacologist/toxicologist, with a special interest in toxic plants and mushrooms.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Stephen...I would be interested to see it...I've seen cherry rot to dust without any black lines at all. I've been looking for quite some time for spalted cherry with no results.Perhaps there are varieties that will spalt...you may have found one. Anyone else see any cherry that has spalted?

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#23

Re: cyanide

Barry Irby

>Thanks, did not know this, but I don't think maples are all that common here except as yard trees. Sometimes I am stunned at what I don't know.

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#24

Re: cherry toxicity (?)------WebKitFormBoundaryto+

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>Richard,

As a followup to my cyanide/cherry response, and since I really did not address your specific question, there would be essentially no concern about cyanide toxicity from items made from cherry. The cyanide precursor is located primarily in the bark and leaves. And remember the dose factor -- to consume enough cherry wood to be concerned about cyanide toxicity, one would have to eat a lot of bowls, not merely be exposed to the surface of the wood. Not likely.

In fact, leeching of toxic chemicals from wood is not a health concern unless someone happened to be allergic to some component. Even then, properly sealed and finished wood should be safe. In medicine, the classic leeching concern is that of lead being dissolved out of unglazed ceramics by an acid liquid, usually orange juice. There have been reports of serious lead toxicity in individuals who used such pottery for their orange juice over a period of many months.

------WebKitFormBoundaryto+owIPNmQmvZtIp

Re: cherry toxicity (?)

#25

Re: cherry toxicity (?)------WebKitFormBoundaryto+

richard jones

>Emmett,

Yep, that makes sense. Doesn't sound like the little ones will fall ill from chewing on a rattle. Thanks again, a very interesting thread.

rich in va

Matthew 8:26