Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sandpaper info needed

Posts

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#26

Re: reference?

John K Jordan

>>...Is this simply a matter of different standards...?

I haven't discovered the real story yet, but I think they take fundamentally different approaches making equivalences difficult. FEPA evidently bases grading on ranges of grain sizes while CAMI specifies average particle sizes. Each, I'm sure, will defend it's own method as the best. Republican vs democrat, PC vs Mac.

It is interesting that the grits are even measured differently. For example, FEPA abrasives classified as Macrogrits (P220 and coarser) are sorted by running particles through sieves, while Microgrits (P240 and finer) use sedimentation methods. Consider the FEPA spec for macrogrit F180: no more than 3% by mass of the grit can have a particle size larger than 90 microns, and at least 94% must be larger than 53 microns. This seems to indicate the remaining 3% of the particles can be any size! For microgrit F220: no more than 3% can be larger than 75 microns and at least 50% must be in the range of 50-56 microns and at least 94% must be larger than 45 microns. (from http://www.sizes.com under Tools - a very interesting and useful reference resource, BTW)

What I have not yet found is how they came up with the grade numbers (220, 400, etc). The FEPA method seems to roughly correspond to the grit sizes in microns while the CAMI method must be based on the phase of the moon or something. In the graph below I plotted a "normalized" number vs the stated grade number - the numbers across the X-axis are the sandpaper grits from 80 to 600. The vertical axis is the grade number multiplied by the grit size in microns. FEPA is blue, CAMI is magenta. Notice how the CAMI numbers take a dive then level out for the finer grits while the FEPA line is much closer to a constant through the range - I expected to see approximately a straight line if the grade and grit sizes were linearly related. (that would make it too easy!) I suspect the actual grit numbers either have some historical significance or are based on some calculation and measurement that has meaning to the engineers - the heck with the users!

I sent an inquiry to Klingspor asking a simple question about their grit numbers. If they respond, I'll try to get some more detail or at least some good technical references from them.

JKJ


img

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#27

Re: reference?

Bill Neddow

>Thanks, John. Please keep us posted.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#28

Cheap Carborundum *LINK*

Jack Savona

>The folks in the link below have Carborundum velcro disks w/o holes at a price that allows you to use it like someone else was paying for it. (100 6" disks for $8-9.)

I cut out my own 2" & 3" disks or fold and use as regular sandpaper. Unfortunately, they have limited grit sizes, mostly in the upper range .

No connection, just a serendipitous discovery.

Jack


Carborundum 6" Disks