Re: Sandpaper info (long)
Bill Neddow
>Joe, I have been studying and working with most of the sandpapers on the market over the past two years, trying to find the best way to do the tedious job of sanding quickly, effectively and inexpensively. I will give you a quick summary of some of the information I have found -- but I can talk for over an hour on this and hardly scratch the surface (pun intended).
First I will address grits. There are dozens out there, but for woodturners, there is a nice little rule of thumb that will keep you from jumping too far up the grit scale and spending needless time trying to get out deep scratches with paper that is too fine.
The rule is as follows: When moving from one grit to another, DO NOT jump more than half the number of the previous grit. Sounds complicated, but it is not. Start with 80 grit. Add half that number (80 + 40) and you get 120 -- which is the next grit to use. Add 120 and 60 and you get 180 grit -- your next step. So the steps, for simplicity sake, are 80 grit, 120,, 180, 220, 320, 400, and 600.
Sanding by hand is fine, but you might want to try power sanding with velcro-based pads. There are many of these on the market, but the best is made by Tim Skilton. I have had some of his pads for years now and I finish about 250 large bowls a year. Some of the others have lasted 10 minutes or less. Most good woodturning outlets sell the Skilton pads.
Several people have mentioned sanding with the lathe at low speed. This is good -- but more important in heat buildup is the pressure you put on the sandpaper. If the paper is heating up, apply less pressure. If that does not work, then slow the lathe down. Also, keep the sanding pad as flat as you can. If you can cut an unused 2 inch disk out of your old 3 inch pieces of sandpaper, you are holding the pad at too much of an angle. I know there are papers out there with wavy disks to keep you from getting cuts in the wood from the edges of the sandpaper -- but you don't need these if you are holding the pad relatively flat.
There are literally thousands of sandpapers out there. I have not tried them all, but have tried hundreds that the manufacturers claim are for sanding wood -- as well as quite a number originally designed for steel (they obviously last longer).
If you are looking for inexpensive but decent paper, buy some Industrial Abrasives Rhyno Grip (http//commerce.riverweb.com. 8002/hnlsandpaper.html) Good stuff that comes in one yard by 39 inch sheets. Just simply rip some off if you are hand sanding, or cut it with an old hole saw if you want disks. Take the drill bit out of the middle of the hole saw, grind off the teeth (and sharpen the edge), mount it in a drill press, and cut out what you want with the paper laying on the drill press grit side up.
Most of the papers sold to us are made of aluminum oxide. And they work well.
But there are two others out there that are not aluminum oxide, and are even better.
The most easily available is Astra Dot. It is sold by WoodChuckers Supply (1-800- 551-0192) It is made in Japan and WoodChuckers is the only North American supplier. It appears to be silicone carbide which has been electrostatically placed on the backing. That is the stuff your grinding wheels are made of -- so it stands up well on wood. And because it is electrostatically placed, it does not clog like your sanding wheel. Cindy Drozda is a fan of this papers, as is Clay Foster. The paper comes in 6"x39" rolls (the most economical) or pre-cut in 2 or 3 inch disks.
The other incredible paper is Norton A975 (Dry Ice). This is a pure ceramic grit. Steve mentioned a Carborundum red paper he got at a symposium. It is similar, but a mix of aluminum oxide and ceramic (Norton and Carborundum are the same company). Like the Astra Dot, it lasts forever. Although these papers are relatively expensive, I find them more economical in the end for production turning.
The A975 us harder to find as it is new on the market. Any cabinet maker friend can get it from a wholesaler, but I have not yet seen it on the retail market. It comes in 6 inch disks. From that I can make two 3-inch disks for 32 cents and two 2-inch disks for 16 cents. (Or 6 two-inch disks for 15 cents apiece).
3M also makes a pure ceramic sandpaper, but it has a sticky back, not a velcro one, and is only available in the coarser grits.
Slightly further down the scale is the Norton 3X, which many people have discovered. It is similar, but has less ceramic grit. It also does not come with a velcro backing -- but if you are hand sanding, you do not need this anyway.
To get full value out of these papers, keep them away from CA glue, as it will ruin them as quickly as inexpensive paper.
Now, that is probably more than you ever wanted to know about sandpaper, but I am just starting to get warmed up. Better stop now.
Just remember, there is no such a thing as bad sandpaper. The companies go to incredible length to make products best suited to a wide variety of applications. If the paper is not working, then it probably is designed for a different application.