Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Sandpaper info needed

Posts

Sandpaper info needed

#1

Sandpaper info needed

Joe Pack

>My sanding needs for pens, keychains, etc. have been met by using a decent 3M paper I bought on a 50% sale at Rockler a couple of years ago, but that has been lightweight stuff, and I can sand by looping the sandpaper under the object while keeping my fingers off the object...no friction burns on my tender little fingers.

Now I'm looking to move on to plates, bowls, etc. that require holding the paper more firmly with my hands, and also sanding more contours. The thin paper I have been using probably won't cut it. I don't know much about sandpaper; I can read the biggest words on the Klingspor page, but they don't mean much to me because I don't have a frame of reference. They could be selling exactly what I need, or they could be selling me a Cadillac to drive in a demolition derby and I wouldn't know the difference. I'm hoping folks here can educate me on what sandpapers I need for bowl work...grit ranges, backing material, etc. Also, do you have a favorite brand? Can you tell me why you prefer one brand over another?

Thanks. I'll look forward to reading and learning.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#2

Re: Sandpaper info needed

john lucas

>Joe I am a fan of the Norton 3x papers. I buy them at Woodcraft. They are more expensive but last much longer than the cheaper stuff. I sand more and more by hand instead of power sanding. I guess it's because my tool usage has improved a lot. I simply tear off a piece and fold it in half. I slow the wood down a little if it's a large piece of wood to prevent overheating my fingers. Hot sandpaper doesn't cut as well either.

I also use the Klingspor gold in 2" widths for smaller work. It's too easy to just tear off a little chunk and use it.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#3

Ric Taylor

Re: Sandpaper info needed

Ric Taylor

>Joe,

As John said, hot sandpaper doesn't cut as well, but also the heat can lead to checks in the wood and other problems. If the sandpaper is too hot to hold, then you are sanding too aggressively, and you should either ease up on the pressure or slow down the lathe, or both.

Ric

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#4

Re: Sandpaper info needed

Cyril Griesbach

>Joe, I also like the Klingspor rolled gold sand paper in the 2" rolls but I also power sand and for that the best I've tried are the discs from Vince Welch. Vince sells a starter kit that allowes the customer to give his products a try without a lot of expense.

Neither of these papers load up like others I've tried.

And...lessons learned the hard way.

1. slow speeds

2. Clean the surface between grits

3. Don't skip any grits

4. Sand paper is a consumable, throw it away when it quits.

5. Cheap sand paper costs more than good sand paper.

I, and others, could go on but you get the idea.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#5

Steven Antonucci

Like Carborundum and Norton 3X

steve antonucci

>I used 3x because it was available locally. I bought some Carborundum (it's kind of red...) at Totally Turning and I love it. It lasts so long, and never feels like it's spent (even though it is)...

You can probably Google sources, since I can't remember the name of the folks I bought it from.

Steven

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#6

Re: Klingspore

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Check out the Kingspore site. I have used their J-Flex for year's. It folds and reopens without any fold line, it cuts great. I buy the 3" by 25 yard in all the grits and tear off just enough to overlay on a sanding block.

Remember to use sandpaper like someone else was paying for it.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#7

Re: Sandpaper info needed

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Good advice so far. I used to sand too agressively and got heat checks. Now, I've cooled it a bit. I like Norton 3X and buy it at Home Depot, from 80 to 400 grit, in contractors packs. I also use wet/dry sandpaper from 400 to 1200 grit. Cloth backed sandpaper is OK for the rough stuff but generally too agressive for me.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#8

Re: Sandpaper info needed

John K Jordan

>I like the Klingspor Gold and have a dispenser for 2" and 1" rolls over the lathe. For bowls and plates I use slow-speed rotating power disks for each grit BUT I also turn off the lathe and hand sand each grit afterwards, going with the grain or figure.

If I sand only with the piece turning, I sometimes get concentric scratches which I think is sloppy.

JKJ

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#9

Vinces web site

Mark Paulley

>Here is Vinces web site.

wwww.vinceswoodnwonders.com

Great product, question the individual (joke!!!)

He will return phone calls in the evening.

Mark

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#10

Re: Sandpaper info needed

Ed Karch

>Anything below 220 I use clothback flexible from klingspoor bulk bins at symposia. 220 320 I use Norton paper then shift to Norton pads Maroon then grey then shift to abralon pads 500 on up to 4k if I need to go that high. I usually quit about 500-1k any thing above is polishing. This is just a routine I developed over time that fits my needs. You will end up doing what fits your taste in finishes. A lot of what you use may depend on what type finish you apply after sanding.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#11

Re: Sandpaper info (long)

Bill Neddow

>Joe, I have been studying and working with most of the sandpapers on the market over the past two years, trying to find the best way to do the tedious job of sanding quickly, effectively and inexpensively. I will give you a quick summary of some of the information I have found -- but I can talk for over an hour on this and hardly scratch the surface (pun intended).

First I will address grits. There are dozens out there, but for woodturners, there is a nice little rule of thumb that will keep you from jumping too far up the grit scale and spending needless time trying to get out deep scratches with paper that is too fine.

The rule is as follows: When moving from one grit to another, DO NOT jump more than half the number of the previous grit. Sounds complicated, but it is not. Start with 80 grit. Add half that number (80 + 40) and you get 120 -- which is the next grit to use. Add 120 and 60 and you get 180 grit -- your next step. So the steps, for simplicity sake, are 80 grit, 120,, 180, 220, 320, 400, and 600.

Sanding by hand is fine, but you might want to try power sanding with velcro-based pads. There are many of these on the market, but the best is made by Tim Skilton. I have had some of his pads for years now and I finish about 250 large bowls a year. Some of the others have lasted 10 minutes or less. Most good woodturning outlets sell the Skilton pads.

Several people have mentioned sanding with the lathe at low speed. This is good -- but more important in heat buildup is the pressure you put on the sandpaper. If the paper is heating up, apply less pressure. If that does not work, then slow the lathe down. Also, keep the sanding pad as flat as you can. If you can cut an unused 2 inch disk out of your old 3 inch pieces of sandpaper, you are holding the pad at too much of an angle. I know there are papers out there with wavy disks to keep you from getting cuts in the wood from the edges of the sandpaper -- but you don't need these if you are holding the pad relatively flat.

There are literally thousands of sandpapers out there. I have not tried them all, but have tried hundreds that the manufacturers claim are for sanding wood -- as well as quite a number originally designed for steel (they obviously last longer).

If you are looking for inexpensive but decent paper, buy some Industrial Abrasives Rhyno Grip (http//commerce.riverweb.com. 8002/hnlsandpaper.html) Good stuff that comes in one yard by 39 inch sheets. Just simply rip some off if you are hand sanding, or cut it with an old hole saw if you want disks. Take the drill bit out of the middle of the hole saw, grind off the teeth (and sharpen the edge), mount it in a drill press, and cut out what you want with the paper laying on the drill press grit side up.

Most of the papers sold to us are made of aluminum oxide. And they work well.

But there are two others out there that are not aluminum oxide, and are even better.

The most easily available is Astra Dot. It is sold by WoodChuckers Supply (1-800- 551-0192) It is made in Japan and WoodChuckers is the only North American supplier. It appears to be silicone carbide which has been electrostatically placed on the backing. That is the stuff your grinding wheels are made of -- so it stands up well on wood. And because it is electrostatically placed, it does not clog like your sanding wheel. Cindy Drozda is a fan of this papers, as is Clay Foster. The paper comes in 6"x39" rolls (the most economical) or pre-cut in 2 or 3 inch disks.

The other incredible paper is Norton A975 (Dry Ice). This is a pure ceramic grit. Steve mentioned a Carborundum red paper he got at a symposium. It is similar, but a mix of aluminum oxide and ceramic (Norton and Carborundum are the same company). Like the Astra Dot, it lasts forever. Although these papers are relatively expensive, I find them more economical in the end for production turning.

The A975 us harder to find as it is new on the market. Any cabinet maker friend can get it from a wholesaler, but I have not yet seen it on the retail market. It comes in 6 inch disks. From that I can make two 3-inch disks for 32 cents and two 2-inch disks for 16 cents. (Or 6 two-inch disks for 15 cents apiece).

3M also makes a pure ceramic sandpaper, but it has a sticky back, not a velcro one, and is only available in the coarser grits.

Slightly further down the scale is the Norton 3X, which many people have discovered. It is similar, but has less ceramic grit. It also does not come with a velcro backing -- but if you are hand sanding, you do not need this anyway.

To get full value out of these papers, keep them away from CA glue, as it will ruin them as quickly as inexpensive paper.

Now, that is probably more than you ever wanted to know about sandpaper, but I am just starting to get warmed up. Better stop now.

Just remember, there is no such a thing as bad sandpaper. The companies go to incredible length to make products best suited to a wide variety of applications. If the paper is not working, then it probably is designed for a different application.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#12

Excellent Writeup!

Charlie Anderson

>

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#13

Wow!

Joe Pack

>And I thought it was just sandpaper! Really, thanks for all the information. I appreciate it.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#14

Mike Stafford

Great information, Bill!

Mike Stafford

>I thought I knew something about sandpaper but after reading your write up I realize that there is a lot more to know.

Thank you for this excellent article.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#15

Veddy intresting- Thanks Bill

john lucas

>

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#16

Re: Like Carborundum and Norton 3X

Dinyar Chavda

>Like Steve, I bought Carborundum a while ago--in fact, I made a purchase for my club-members to get a good deal (either on the price or on shipping)---not something I'd like to do again, as counting individual sheets of paper is a right toyal pita! I got it from http://www.britecon.com/, and their service was excellent.

I also use Norton 3x, and get it from Home Depot in the contractor packs of 20s.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#17

reference?

John K Jordan

>>...When moving from one grit to another, DO NOT jump more than half the number of the previous grit.

>...80 grit, 120, 180, 220, 320, 400, and 600.

Interesting, Bill. I assume someone did a study to compare sanding sequences. Do you have a reference on this rule (of thumb)?

I generally include 100 and 150 in the sequence but perhaps that is being too conservative.

JKJ

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: reference?

Mike Stafford

>John, I keep an arsenal of papers that start at 80 and proceed through 100, 120, 150, 180, 220, 240, 280, 320, 360, 400, 500 and 600. All of these are scraps, albeit large scraps, that I fish out of the bulk bins at Klingspor. Seldom do I find on most woods the need to go much above 600 as very few can see scratches that small.

On the really dense hardwood exotics like cocobolo, ebony, blackwood and some of the other rosewoods I will go to 1200 or 2000 but usually they are done with wax as a lubricant.

If you can keep that pesty raking bright light out of your shop it is harder to see even larger scratches....

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#19

Re: reference?

Bill Neddow

>John, I got that information off this web site several years ago and I cannot remember who posted it. I tried it and found that it works wonderfully well -- and saves me some money by eliminating a couple of grits.

Woops, I found it. It was posted by Woodturner on 15 August 2006 at 1:25 p.m. It was posted s a question as he had heard this protocol and was wondering what other people do. The protocol posted by Jerri on his ASAP website (abrasives ASAP.com) -- the same paper Vince sells -- is the same. It is also the protocol suggested by Steve Worcester on his website at www.turningwood.com

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#20

Re: Sandpaper info needed

Jim Miles - Charlotte NC

>Joe

Our AAW club - NC Woodturners meets at Klingspor in Hickory NC. They have some big bulk bins of scrap sandpaper. Cost $2 - $3 a pound.

I buy up 5 - 10 pounds at a time and use old blade on the bandsaw to cut it into smaller pieces. This way it is cheap enough you can use it til dulls & not feel bad about trashing it.

Aren't you in the Asheville NC area?

If so, come on down the mountain to club meeting in Hickory, 2nd Sat at Klingspor.

Hint: Klingspor's bulk sandpaper changes each month, so if you find anything you use regularly stock up, it won't be there next month.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#21

Re: reference? *LINK*

John K Jordan

>>...I got that information off this web site several years ago

Bill, thanks for the references.

I see no reference to testing or experiment, just statements like "I once heard a formula" and "my usual routine would be". I can't find information on the http://abrasivesasap.com/ site. The protocols described by Woodturner and Worcester are slightly different: Woodterner uses 220 where Worcester uses 240.

At closer look, the data at www.turningwood.com seems inconsistent with other references I have on the particle size of various grits. Assuming the grits in his list are FEPA rather than CAMI, Worcester lists the grit size for 80 (P80?) as 150 microns where other reference charts list it as 201. The link below has a typical grit reference chart.

It would be interesting to create a graphic showing the relative grit sizes in the sequence, but with a quick look it seems to me that jumping from 201 to 125 microns (P80 to P120) is a pretty big step.

Looking at this another way, consider the difference in grit size as a percentage of the coarser grit. Following the P80-120-180-240-320-400 protocol, the percent differences are

38%

34%

29%

21%

24%.

Those first jumps are large compared to the jumps at the end of the list. Compare that with a protocol which fills in with the two extra coarse grits for P80-100-120-150-180-240-320-400, where the percent differences are

19%

23%

20%

18%

29%

21%

24%.

Notice how in this list the difference in grit size as a percentage of the coarser grit is more uniform. (Including P220 grit in the sequence results it a tighter 19%-23%-20%-18%-17%-14%-21%-24%.) I think a case can be made for not skipping the coarser grits.

At one time I ran a small metallography lab supporting nuclear research reactor element manufacture, working primarily with uranium alloys sandwiched between layers of aluminum. From my experience with sectioning and polishing metals for microscopic analysis, the actual grit sequence used is more than a trade off between the time spent sanding/polishing to remove visible scratches. But for the perfect finish, you not only have to remove the visible scratches from the previous grit, you must remove a layer below the bottom of the deepest scratch, the layer of subsurface deformation. The particle of grit not only digs a furrow but deforms the material underneath the very bottom of the furrow, weakening the metal and allowing grains to more easily break away later in the polishing process. Unfortunately, the most severe subsurface deformation is always with the coarse grits - failure to remove that sublayer may not show up until the very end of the polishing sequence as tiny scratch lines or rows of pits that cannot practically be removed with the finer grits - the only recourse is to go back to the coarser grits and start over.

Fortunately wood seems far more forgiving than aluminum since the grain and elasticity works to reduce subsurface deformation AND the variations due to grain and figure tend to mask small defects. However, I've seen similar issues with deformation in end grain in the form of a fine line or band where under the microscope fibers appear to have been torn loose by a coarse grit particle, or worse, by my poor cutting tool technique! No amount of fine sanding will remove the problem - the only recourse is to go back to the coarse grits. At least when sanding end grain then, it may be important not to take large jumps in the coarser grit sizes.

JKJ


http://www.sizes.com/tools/sandpaper.htm

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#22

Re: reference?

Bill Neddow

>John, I was not looking for a scientifically proven protocol when I tried this. It was presented as a "rule of thumb" and I have found, over the years, that these often embody the practical experience of many years (or, in some cases, many generations).

Quite simply, I tried it and it works for me. I have made one change, which you picked up. I do not use 220 sandpaper, but rather 240. According to the "rule", you would add 90 to the 180 grit to get the next grit sandpaper. That comes out at 270. I do not know of any sandpaper available at that number -- but, following the rule, 240 is the closest. This brings me more in line with what Steve Worcester recommends.

Using this rule, I get a good finish. Jimmy Clewes, for one, has commented on this when looking at my bowls.

And, as a production turner, it saves me money as I am eliminating some grits I do not seem to need.

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#23

Many Thanks Bill... works for me... :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#24

Re: reference?

John K Jordan

>Bill,

While I'm also a firm believer in the "whatever works" method, I do like to try to understand the "why" behind the ideas, perhaps a trait related to working for years in R&D.

I find this subject quite interesting. I've heard plenty of recommendations over the decades and I've always wondered if there were technical reasons behind the years (or generations) of experience.

The number method you mention seems as good as any since from what I can calculate the (FEPA) grade numbers are roughly related to the size of the grits: the grade * grit size in mm is approximately a constant, around 15 for most of the common sizes. The number method would make less sense with the CAMI grading - I can't figure out WHAT relationship the grades have to the grit sizes there.

BTW, when people discuss sandpaper grits, it would be helpful to state if they are referring to the European FEPA or US CAMI standard since the numbers aren't even close for the fine abrasives. For example, while FEPA P80 is very close to US 80 grit, a P600 abrasive is somewhere between the US 360 and 400 grit. When someone says "I sanded the pen to 1200", what does that mean? Even the manufacturers aren't much help - I can't tell from the Klingspor literature whether they use FEPA or CAMI grading, although all the paper I've purchased from them is marked with a "P" prefix.

JKJ

Re: Sandpaper info needed

#25

Re: reference?

Bill Neddow

>John, I also like to know why things work, and prefer the scientific approach. But when that fails, I will revert to whatever rules, established by convention, will work.

And, although I cannot say that science has failed in this case, it certainly has produced confusing results.

Is this simply a matter of different standards -- celsius versus imperial measurement systems? If so, this is a real case for having one standard, not two. I have lived through the conversion here in Canada and it did not kill me. But I have learned the hard way that 18 degrees celsius means a warm spring day -- while 18 degrees F means I am freezing my butt off! I can even tell you how many centimeters there are in an inch (more or less)!

After all, a grain of grit in the US should be the same size as its twin in Europe.

"And I agree with you that the sandpaper companies are not going out of their way to make things clear for us. Often, they will not even tell you what kind of grit they are using. For example, I was told by many people, including two Norton/Carborundum dealers, that their "red" paper is a mix of ceramic and aluminum oxide. Yesterday, I was cruising around the Norton/Carborundum site, and the company has posted information that the mix is zirconia and aluminum oxide. I guess it does not matter to most people. The red paper is one of the best out there. (zirconia is the stuff they make fake diamonds out of -- it will scratch glass). But I like to know what I am working with --- and I like to be correct when I am passing information on to others!