Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Posts

Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#1

Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

charlie belden

>Coming up with "fair curves" and "fair curves" that flow together is a tricky thing - to do well. Any discontiunous continuity along the outline of the shape will be picked up by the "eye" and identified as "something's not quite right here".

We turn forms horizontally that will, when finished, be viewed standing or sitting upright.

I'm playing with some more plumwood, trying to striked a balance between going for the heartwood grain and going for a nice pinch neckish pot ( to use a clay turner's term for the form ). I have three "fair curves" to blend one into the next - the neck to upper body of the pot, upper pot body to both pot neck and lower pot body.

I thought I'd got the curves and their blending pretty close to right. Couldn't stand the whole thing up to really look at it vertically because the bottom on the drive end wasn't cut square.

Only AFTER parting the piece of from Between Centers was I able to see a problem with the neck curve to upper body curve. The upper part of the piece seems too thick/fat.

Attached is the piece take on the lathe Between Centers - one image of the piece horizontal, as seen while turning, and one standing upright as it will be seen when finished.

A little playing around with one picture of the piece on the lathe PhotoShop, a copy turned to see the piece upright and the problem area neck to body transition was obvious, whereas it wasn't that noticable - to me - while on the lathe. I can of course fit it once in a chuck and before I begin hollowing but it would be nice to see problems while still Between Centers.

(BTW - this is "green" wood so the yellowish areas will fade into the background when dry)

Do others have the same difficulties "seeing things that just ain't right" while the piece is mounted horizontally which seem to become more obvious when the piece is upright?

If so, and you've found a way around the horizontal/vertical perception thing, how do you do it?


img

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#2

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Bill Howatt

>Yes! In fact I mentioned it when I showed an outside-in petal vase at our last club meeting. Looked good on the lathe but after I parted it off and stood it up I could see things that weren't as obvious on the lathe. This tended to be inadequate curvature and too much thickness. I agree with your assessment when looking at the pictures of your vessel.

Was at a Lyle Jamieson presentation last weekend and he literally left the lathe and walked 8-12' away from the piece mounted on the lathe to check the curves and shape. Maybe this is a solution. Unfortunately my lathe room wouldn't permit that approach - at least not as far.

Bill

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Dick Hines

>If you are useing a chuck to turn you hollow forms you can take the chuck off the head stock and sit up so you can see what your piece will look like when finished.

Hollow forms are like finials. When on the lathe a finial will look great. Whe it if parted onn it will look some what like a tree trunk.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#4

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

john lucas

>Charlie one of my friends mounted a video camera above the lathe and then turned it sideways so the image on the TV was vertical. I think that might be a good idea but I've never tried it. I pull the chuck off the lathe and set it up and look at it if I'm in doubt.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#5

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Dinyar Chavda

>When I'm not sure about a piece, I'll take a picture of it, and then print it (in b&w). A picture allows me to look at the piece in any orientation; doing it in b&w gets rid of the distraction of the grain so I can focus on just the form; and I find that it is often obvious what's wrong when I look at a piece in 2 dimensions instead of 3. Also, I can play with alternatives either on-screen with many of the photo-editing programs, or with a pencil on paper.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#6

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Carole Valentine

>I don't do any shaping on a vessel between centers except to bring it to round and cut a tenon for the chuck. I begin shaping only after it is chucked and I may remove it several times (chuck and all) to stand it upright and look at it before I finish it.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#7

Steven Antonucci

I think your issue here is slightly different

steve antonucci

>I actually didn't think it was as bad as you said until I covered up the spigot on the tailstock end. Only then did I see what you meant. Since the wood was still there to be seen, my eye included it in the overall piece, even though it was clearly going to be removed.

I agree with others who suggest using a chuck to remove/evaluate on/off the lathe. In addition, it will allow you to remove the wood at the top to get a true view of the form you are developing. You could always rechuck this one and thin it out on the bottom to elongate the existing neck if you weren't satisfied.

We burn our mistakes, but we get to look at out compromises every day.

Steven

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#8

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

david

>Interesting problem--even in your photos, the piece in the horizontal orientation appears more bottom heavy than when in the vertical orientation. Could be due to the lighting. I have the same issues, even though lately I have been concentrating on the same form, but no two pieces end up the same.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#9

Re: BW pic "trimmed" in PhotoShop

charlie belden

>The video camera connectge to a flat screen monitor - camera turned 90 degrees to show the piece oriented upright is an interesting idea. When I'm turning the fine shaping cuts I'm watching the profile at the back of the piece not on the tool rest side anyway - so maybe not even looking at the actual piece but at the video image might work.

And the idea of using a black and white rather than a color image of the piece so the color and grain isn't as much of a distraction is a great idea. I've done that when studying tansu chest - but to see the grain pattern and how it was used without the distraction of the color of the finish.

Was easy enough to remove the tenons/spigot in PhotoShop - they were a distraction - just like they are on the actual piece on the lathe.

Great ideas offered. The BW idea - and the removal of stuff that won't be on the finished piece was as well. Revised pic attached.

Thanks.

More?

charlie belden


img

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Keith Tompkins

>Charlie, a couple of things that may help. First, the "emphasis Point", usually the point of the largest diameter, is important; its placement dictates the overall appearance of a form. Moving the emphasis up or down changes the line up to the rim, and down to the foot.

Many turning instructors insist on making the final cut in one continuous pass....I disagree in most cases. I think it's better to examine the form, then have the ability to see breaks in the line and then take the smallest of cuts to correct them..only where needed. Sometimes holding a contrasting piece of paper behind the turning will show variations or flats.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#11

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Bill Crommett

>I never take a piece off the lathe with the chuck in place. I just go with the flow and end up with a lot of ugly pieces. But the recipients of my gifts are usually not artistically trained, and they think the stuff is great.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#12

Re: I think your issue here is slightly different

charlie belden

>Re:

"I agree with others who suggest using a chuck to remove/evaluate on/off the lathe. In addition, it will allow you to remove the wood athe top to get a true view of the form you are developing. You could always rechuck this one and thin it out on the bottom to elongate the existing neck if you weren't satisfied. "

I find my shape/form while between centers because it's hard to modify the lower area of the form when the piece is in the chuck - it's tricky working in the tight space - with the chuck jaws so close.

Even removing the piece from the lathe, but keeping it in the chuck, in order to see it upright - there's that actual and visual mass of the chuck that, for me, makes the lower part of the form beefier than it actually is.

So far a digital image, converted to black and white and with it's contrast tweeked to emphasize the profile sure helps. Being able to "take out" all but what will be the finished piece with an image processing app like photo shop sure helps to.

Any other suggestions?

charlie belden

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#13

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I will stand at the headstock to look at the piece from a near "vertical" perspective. The mass of the chuck or un-turned end doesn't usually bother me, but covering it with my favorite shop rag (on the lathe), or a piece of paper or wood (off the lathe) lets me see how it will look when completed.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#14

Steven Antonucci

I saw your B/W photo

steve antonucci

>and I'd add the fact that color can also add weight to a piece too. Darker colors sometimes anchor a piece, while lighter colors appear to be less heavy. When you have both in one piece, you need to visually balance them or something turned to 1/16" with perfect form might still look visually out of balance.

One of the suggestion for getting better access to the foot is to leave it somewhat heavy until the end, but then cut it down to a very small tenon before you take the piece off. By having that mass removed and being smaller than the chuck iteslf, I think it's a lot easier for your brain to visually remove it from the image.

Steven

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#15

ebd

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

ebd

>By facing parallel to the ways, bending over, and turning my head I can look from the side as if the piece were vertical. It's very quick and requires no additional equipment.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#16

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The difference between a good piece and a very good piece is often just a matter of tweaking the profile just a little to achieve that near perfect curve. (The perfect curve is very elusive)

If I'm turning a tall piece I rough it out between centers. Then either using a glue block or a chuck I do a lot of tweaking to get the final form. I find that it helps a lot to "see" the profile if I hold a piece of contrasting paper behind the piece. White paper for dark wood, a sheet of 600 sandpaper for a light colored wood.

Removing the piece and standing it at near eye level to view it from several feet away can really help when trying to get a difficult piece just right.

Wally

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#17

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

charlie belden

>Thanks to all for the interesting suggestions and to those who copped to having the same difficulties with - looks nice on the lathe - not quite as nice once parted of and standing on a table or shelf.

My JET mini bench is against the wall on the drive end so I can't stand behind the drive end (finite floor space, approaching infinity for what's stuffed in that finite space). And if I lean over the piece and crank my head - I end up making more visits to the chiropractor.

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

#18

Re: Turn Horizontally - View Vertically

Ed in Leaside

>Maybe a mirror would do the trick. I used to have a 10x24 plastic mirror.