how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
RogerC
>I found a 1/2" bowl gouge at a garage sale for $1 (gloat!) and now have to make a handle for it.
How deep should the hole in the handle be?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
RogerC
>I found a 1/2" bowl gouge at a garage sale for $1 (gloat!) and now have to make a handle for it.
How deep should the hole in the handle be?
Depends on how long the overall tool is...
steve antonucci
>I'd suggest that you make it at least 3", unless the gouge is terribly short from use.
Steven
I agree.
john lucas
>
Re: how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
Gordon Seto
>The standard tang length in Thompson tools is only 2" for smaller gouges, and 2�" for large gouges, 5/8" and up.
On a metal handle, the grubbing screws are under 2" from the end of the handle. On the large Oneway handle, it is only 1�".
What gives the strength is the ferrule.
Gordon
Re: how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
john lucas
>Gordon I'm not sure the ferrule gives it strenght. It keeps the wood from splitting. I've brocken one tool handle over the years and it broke where the ferrule meets the back of the handle. I've also seen another gouge brocken in the same place. this makes me think the weak point is the joint between the ferrule and the wood. consequently I try to make my tools go at least an inch beyond that point and usually a little more.
I'll be interested to hear what others think because 2 is a pretty small sampling and I'm certainly not engineer material.
Without doing the calculations...
steve antonucci
>mainly because I can't any more...
The tip of the gouge where the wood is being cut is on one side of a fulcrum, and when cutting well, subjected to a downward force from the rotation of the wood. The fulcrum is where the tool contacts the toolrest.
The force will be greater during a catch and is magnified by the amount of gouge hanging over the tool rest. The resulting upward thrust of the handle during a catch is Newton's law in application. A force equal and opposite is transmitted about the fulcrum through the length of the gouge. This is why we make our tool handles long.
One of the absolute truths that I recall from my materials class in college is that corners are stress concentrators. Where the shoulder of the tenon meets the ferule is usual a squared off corner. I would imagine that this combination of facts would cause more handles to fail if there was a catch with only a small amount of the tang buried in the wooden part of the handle.
I think it's a good idea to go at least the 2" past the ferrule, since you can't really get a good cut when you've got that much steel hanging out over the tool rest anyway.
Steven
It's about 9"or 10" (I don't have it with me now)
RogerC
>
Re: how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
Gordon Seto
>John,
May be a larger ferrule is needed.
I assume with the number of tools that Doug sells. if the 2" and 2�" tang is not adequate, he would have heard the feed back and revised. He doesn't have automatic machining; it would be easy for him to change in his new batch.
I have some of his earlier productions. I noticed there are some improvements on his current tools.
Gordon
Re: how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
Fog Tanner
>I bought some Henry Taylor tools when I first started, these came with handles. Later I started buying them unhandled and making my own. Being in your situation, I measured how much steel they were putting into the handle, I found it ran between 1 1/2"- 1 3/4" for 1/2 gouges. I made mine with 2"-2 1/2" deep holes. I never had a problem with either factory handles or mine.
When I started using the Thompson gouges, I went with a 2 1/8"- 2 1/4" deep hole and only have 2" of steel in the handle. These days I have started making the handles striaght instead of the classic coke bottle shape and using two 1/4"x20 brass inserts so I can use set screws to hold the gouge in. I use my 5/8" Thompson in a 17" steel handle that came with my McNaughton coring tool and the set screws work for that. It is comfortable, so I started making the same thing in wood. I also changed the size of the ferrel to accomidate the diameter needed for the brass insert. This increased the strength of that area. The handle will spin in your hand before the tool turns in the handle.
The only handle I have seen break was a scraper, and it broke where the steel ended. So the wood is still going to be the weakest point and to eliminate that, you would have to have a gouge with a shank that was the lenth of the handle or wooden sleeve. Much like the "gouge" Del Stubbs made from a length of water pipe, with tape wrapped around it for the handle.
Talking with Stu Batty, he made the observation that you needed five times the length of the handle beind the rest as you had tool over the rest if you wanted control --- three times if you didn't..
Re: how deep should hole in bowl gouge handle be?
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>Wood is only so strong so the metal ferrule is added to give the joint strength, without the ferrule the wood handle will break with very little force. When a tool handle is made the hole is bored into end grain... this is weak as it gets.
IMO - use a larger ferrule and design the handle shape with a larger diameter behind the ferrule to give the wood strength. If you feel comfortable with a 3 inch depth then do it but 2 inches is enough on a smaller diameter tool.
OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
RogerC
>OK, thanks guys, now I have an idea on the depth.
Now, to glue it in.
Would it be better to drill the hole undersized and burn the gouge into the handle, or should I drill a 1/2" hole and glue(epoxy,CA)the gouge into the handle.
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
Allen Neighbors
>Roger, I've always glued my tools in wooden handles with epoxy... the two part 1 hour 2 ton stuff they sell at WalMart. I've never had a handle break. I put my tool shaft at least two inches into the handle, and make the thickest part of the handle just behind the ferrule, where it needs the most strength.
I also agree with the one who said a handle should be five times the length of the toolshaft extension over the toolrest. To me, that means when I stick my 3/4" toolshaft over the toolrest 12 inches to get to the bottom of a long vase, I should have at least 60 inches of handle to hang onto. I'm about a foot short on that, but it's close enough... it's got BBs inside, and I can ride the end of it. :)
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
Fog Tanner
>Before I started using the 1/4"-20 set screws and brass inserts, I would drill the hole slightly undersize a few thousands and drive the shaft in. For the gouges that were undersize of the hole I would use 30min or 60 min Epoxy from Bob Smith. Rough the shaft with 80 grits first for the expoy. I have never had either method come loose. If the ferrel gets loose over time, then I use CA.
I have used expoy with a filler materia added to fill the hole when I made scraper handels. Keeps the hole from wallowing out over time when the scraper wants to pivot on the edge of the tang. For those I also use a stepped hole to help reduce the problem.
For some of the smaller gouges, you can use a tapping handle as the collet mechanism in a quick change handel. This works quite well for 3/8" gouges or round skews.
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>This is to much work just buy a metal handle! LoL
Epoxy or thick CA is more than enough.
Fog, think about designing a Texas size tool for the raffle... 1 inch diameter, 12-14 inches long, U or V... maybe a big shallow bowl gouge.
Fog
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>Read the post above.
I use a force-fit
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I drill the hole just slightly under-sized and force the tang into the handle. That's the way most tools that come with wood handles are done. I've never had a tool come loose and when I change the handle, I have to cut the handle off and use a chisel to split the wood to extract the tool.
Two ways to force fit:
1) If you have a woodworking bench with a GOOD tail vise, use the vise and bench dogs to force the tool tang into the handle.
2) Hammer the handle onto the tool. A concrete floor work best for this. Put a block of wood on the floor. The tool goes point down against the block. Tap the end of the handle with a heavy hammer (but not a sledge hammer) to get the tang aligned and started in the hole, then pound on the end of the handle until the tool is completely seated. I usually leave a nub on the end of the handle when I turn it and saw it off afterward to leave an un-marred handle end.
OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
Martin Harris
>I'm new to turning (6 months) but I have made several tools and glues them in with CA. On the first one I didn't use enough and while hollowing it broke free and turned inside the handle. No damage to the vessel or me (other than suprise). So all the others have more thick CA and no problems.
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
john lucas
>Martin I don't think CA is the best choice. It becomes brittle with age. A thin layer of epoxy is better. As I mentioned above I often grind 2 small flats on the end that goes into the handle. This helps the epoxy keep the tool from slipping.
I use the slightly smallhole and heat method. I drill the hole a little short so the ground off tang will burn into that area. After I grind the end of the tang I heat it up just below red hot. I'll let it cool down until it's not longer red. Then I drive it in the handle. The slightly squared off tang seats itself in the bottom of the hole and keeps the tool from twisting.
I usually clamp the tool in my vise with wooden jaws and wood on the workbench so I won't damage the tip. If I'm concerned about overheating the tool itself I put a pair of vise grips just below where the tang will be seated. these act as heat sinks. I'll drive the handle on with a dead blow mallet.
In this case I don't use any epoxy. If you only wanted to use epoxy you could grind some short grooves into the tang with the corner of the stone. the epoxy will grip these and keep the tool from slipping.
Brittle Glue...
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>John, is there actual proof that CA becomes brittle with age? I have read that manufacturers claim that it doesn't. I have 2 or 3 shop made tools that are at least 20 years old that were assembled using CA..No problems yet.
Wally
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
Fog Tanner
>CA glue is not the glue you want to use in an application where it will be subjected to a shearing action. This would be when you first put the tool to the wood and tool wants to turn. The glue joint produced by CA is hard and to a degree brittle as soon as its made. Accelerators make the joint weaker and more prone to failure. I have quite a few projects that are around 30 years old now and the CA glue joints are still intact. While they were in some high stress situations, there are no CA joints where a shearing action took place. Those glue joints were either aphalic resin or epoxy. The joints that did have CA in a shearing force location failed 30+ years ago.
CA is a great glue, but it does have its applications and limitations.
Re: Fog
Fog Tanner
>Doug,
Now you are talking about a real Texas sized gouge. That would be great for working on some of the large peices of Mesquite and Pecan. I have used all three, the "V", "U", and shallow flutes. I think any one of them would be a winner, but since a lot people use the "V" flute with a swept back grind (Ellsworth, O'Neal, Irish) that may be one that people would be more comfortable with.
But down here, just the size says Texas all over it and would be a hit...
Fog
Re: Brittle Glue...
john lucas
>Wally I may be using the wrong term. I find that woodmovement causes it to loose it grip. I sort of thought it became brittle but it might simply be that it doesn't have any flex. I'm basing this on my own experience. When I want long term holding capability I use epoxy.
I can't say have tools that hold after 20 years because I don't think I own any of my tools from 20 years ago. Well not home made ones anyway. You have me about double in age and triple in experience so I bow to the master. :)
Re: Fog
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
>I'll try a one of a kind 1 inch V shape bowl gouge about 12 -13 inches long. IF they could pick it up to use it just might work. LOL or it might be a good paper weight.
The record is a 1 inch X 18 inch long parting tool for a stone turner. I could only imagine the handle he put on it.
Re: OK, now is it better to burn or glue it in?
RogerC
>Thanks for all the help guys.
Thanks for all the help guys.
RogerC
>