Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Lathe Choice

Posts

Lathe Choice

#1

Lathe Choice

David

>Thinking about acquiring a new lathe, probably something in the $1500 - $2500 price range. Would like something with electronic variable speed and a good reputation. Have seen several that are available, powermatic 3520b (would have likely purchased the one for sale recently on this site but a family emergency prevented me from pursuing), Jet, Nova, Laguna, etc. Would just like some opinions on the model you have and pros/cons. I am a hobbiest that is interested in turning spindles for some flat projects and making bowls for fun.

Thanks,

David

Re: Lathe Choice

#2

Re: Lathe Choice

Ralph

>The Nova 1624-44 made "best value" in a recent FWW article.

With the optional bed extension (or more then one, it will take as many as you can fit). Would be an affordable option.

Re: Lathe Choice

#3

Re: Lathe Choice

Emmett Manley

>I purchased a OneWay 1224 two years ago and I absolutely love it. Quiet, vibration free, variable speed, index system, made from quality materials and even rather pretty.

Re: Lathe Choice

#4

Re: Lathe Choice

Gordon Seto

>The Jet 1642 recently on sale for around $1400 is a good candidate - electronic variable speed, cast iron legs, good service.

Gordon

Re: Lathe Choice

#5

Mustard Monster

Rick Davenport

>

Re: Lathe Choice

#6

JL

Re: Lathe Choice

JL

>Don't know where you are, but Bill has a 2 hp Jet 1642 available in West Central GA (see Classifieds).

I've got a 1.5 hp Jet 1642 and I like it a lot. If I had to do it over again, I'd probably get either the 2 hp Jet or a 3520.

Re: Lathe Choice

#7

Re: Lathe Choice

Bill McWhirter

>If you are going to do bowl, vessels, etc. or if you are left handed, I would suggest a lathe with a sliding headstock. It is much easier to work from the end rather than strain your back leaning over the ways.

Re: Lathe Choice

#8

Re: Lathe Choice

John K Jordan

>I use a Jet 1642 and it's wonderful.

Re: Lathe Choice

#9

Re: Lathe Choice

Fog Tanner

>My first lathe was the 16" Delta steel bed lathe. I liked it a lot, except for the sliding headstock. I was doing both spindles and bowls, which it would handle with no problem. The reason I wouldn't get another sliding headstock, was during coring the headstock would come unlatched and that is not a fun expereince.

I got into off center turning and found the limits of a 16" swing pretty quick. I started looking at larger lathes and contacted a number of the professionals I have met asking their opinions since they use them to make a living. I would up getting a Vic 300VL long bed. Its 1000lbs of lathe.

After getting the machine, I found out why you always see Raffan, Mahoney, and Key using them in their videos. Without changing anything else, my work was coming out better. The machine is a lot more solid than the smaller machines. So, their work will look better on camera and they don't have to fight a small lathe.

If I had it to do over again, I would have gotten a mini lathe to start with, saved my money and then gone from that to the Vic. If I get another lathe, it will either be the Vic 300 short bed, the larger Vic that they are working on, or build one myself. While the larger machines are outside your current price range, they really aren't in the long run. Even if its "just a hobby", life is too short fighting a small machine.

Re: Lathe Choice

#10

Lathe choice

Philip Duffy

>Whoa be unto those who choose other than Mustard for they will see catches and motor stalls and the lights go dim throughout the land!!!!!!!!!! Philip

Re: Lathe Choice

#11

Re: Lathe Choice

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary7+eSWGCzde+ut6

>One thing to keep in mind about the 3520 is that you are limited to 30" between centers. I have a 3520a and found out the hard way that the 35 refers to between the spindle ends and not between centers. Other than that, it has been an excellent lathe.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Lathe Choice

#12

Re: Lathe Choice

dtewell at central illinois

>You might want to check out the new table top version of the Vega lathe. I saw it at Indyfest and if I remember, it is in the $1,000 range. Great for bowls, spindles tend to be rather short, though.

Re: Lathe Choice

#13

Re: Lathe Choice

Rick Davenport

>You can get an extension for the 3520b that gives you another 18" or you can mount it low and allow another 12" of swing.

sliding headstock

lots of mass

reverse

plenty of power

proven dependability

I believe it's the most bang for the buck in the market.

And at least for me, it's the last lathe I will ever need.

R

Re: Lathe Choice

#14

Larger Vic that they are working on?

wilbur

>Details? More info?

Re: Lathe Choice

#15

happy owner of a Nova DVR XP NM

tm

>

Re: Lathe Choice

#16

Re: Lathe Choice

John Kyler

>Before I owned a Powermatic I would say something else..

But Now that I have one, there is no choice 3520B in that price range.

I work in a retail place (unnamed)and have sold a few to customers and all are very happy. Fit and finish is fantastic and the weight is great.

I replaced a Woodfast (was too small). I could have gone with Vicmac, Powermatic, or Oneway.

No choice anymore

John

Re: Lathe Choice

#17

Dick Hines

Re: Lathe Choice

Dick Hines

>I have a 3520A and i think it is your best bang for your buck.

Re: Lathe Choice

#18

Re: happy owner of a Nova DVR XP NM

Ralph

>I own a DVR-XP also, but, with a bed extension and stand, it's out of his price range.

In the price range, it's a great choice.

Re: Lathe Choice

#19

Re: Lathe Choice

Pete in Holland, MI

>Happy with my 2hp JET 1642. 2 years running now.

Re: Lathe Choice

#20

Re: Lathe Choice

RevDoug

>The laguna 1847 (I think this number is right) is one nice looking piece of equipment. If I remember right it is being sold right now for $1699 plus freight. You may want to take a look.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Lathe Choice

#21

Re: Larger Vic that they are working on?

Fog Tanner

>Mike Mahoney had Vic build him a V300 with a 5hp motor in it. Mike wanted some more power for what he does. I found out that Vic is working on a lathe that is larger than the VL300. No specifics as to bed length, but I was told it is to be a larger swing than the 23 1/2" 300. So it could come both in long and short bed versions. The VL300 is already fairly massive, so I would expect a thicker casting in the headstock for a larger swing. The bed on the 300 is already around 1" thick so it strong enough. I have seen a picture of a large Vic lathe that is not a production model. It had a rounded headstock unlike the VL300, similar to their VL175. That could have been the prototype of the new lathe. It caught me because of the design and the size. It looked like it would be easier to work around the headstock.

Vic had the oval turning device in testing for 5 years that I know of before it came out, so it could be a while before the new lathe comes out. Vic has come out with the new VM160, which is a massive dual action chuck aimed at large bowls and hollow forms. I have seen and operated one and it is a lot of steel, but just what you need for large bowls (saving my coins for one). It makes my Srongholds and large Vic VM120 look like toys. It appears that Vic is making some moves towards the large bowl and hollow form market.

Re: Lathe Choice

#22

Bill Blasic

Re: Larger Vic that they are working on?

Bill Blasic

>I have a DVR300 and a 3520b and I would not give up either.

Re: Lathe Choice

#23

Re: happy owner of a Nova DVR XP NM

Barry Irby

>I also have a Nova DVR, but mine is an older one. I am happy with it and if I were buying it again I would go to their repair center and buy a used/reconditioned one from Tim Geist. Great guy and a great lathe are a good price.

Re: Lathe Choice

#24

Re: Lathe Choice

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>David

As with any tool brand, some are more expensive by name than others.

Stay with a name brand and check pricing and features. I have been turning for over 12 years and have yet to turn a spindle. I have the big Oneway and a Vic 200. In comparison the Vic does not compare in price or quality but it is still a great lathe and I would buy it again.

Buy the heaviest, with the largest variable speed motor you can afford and you will never be sorry. DC motors are OK but AC is better but may be beyond your price range.

Remember by buying quality they can be sold at good price when you want to upgrade.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Lathe Choice

#25

Re: Lathe Choice

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi David,

I'm not sure how much help I'll be, but I'll throw in my two cents as well. I've been spinning on a Jet Mini for about 6 years and while I think I have outgrown it, it still serves me well until I can pull the trigger on a bigger one. For the longest time my dreams of big iron were all colored General green and were in the shape of a 26020 with the electronic variable speed. However, I've started doing hollowforms and really like being able to get "in line" with the piece at the end of my mini, thus when I finally do move to a bigger lathe, the current choice would be a Powermatic 3520. I've only seen them in person, never turned on one, but is an impressive hunk of iron.

While I still think about the General on occasion, I really think the sliding headstock on the PM would make a difference for me.

Good luck with your decision, let us know what you decide!

Mike

Maybe those "Green dreams" were Mustard Greens in Apex, NC!!!