Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Chainsaws

Posts

Chainsaws

#1

Chainsaws

Justin Fields

>Hi.

I am contemplating buying a chainsaw, and I'm looking for some recommendations. I haven't used one before, though I'm pretty comfortable with other power tools.

My usage is probably going to be pretty light. I'm not anticipating taking down many large trees or using it commercially in any way. I'm thinking that the principal usage will be getting "found" wood from big chunks or small logs into more manageable sized pieces that I can take into the shop and bandsaw into turning blanks.

For example, a neighbor a few houses down had two huge silver maple trees taken down. I got permission to take whatever I wanted. I ended up only taking a little bit, because the pieces were so huge I couldn't manage the bigger ones. I can only drag or hand-saw so much. If I'd had a chainsaw at the time, I would have been able to grab more wood, or just hack off some of the better spalted pieces.

Anyway, I'm thinking of a gas-powered one, so that I'm not limited to the range of an extension cord. Also, if a friend with a big property lets me take some trees down (or I just end up helping someone), I'll have freedom of location. I was browsing at Home Depot to get some ballpark prices and stuff. The bottom end of the gas models was about $120. The top end was over $500. I don't want to spend more than I need to, but don't want to buy junk that won't do the (small) job or will fall apart on me.

Thoughts? Suggestions? (Other than carefully reading all the safety info, which I will do).

Thanks!

Justin

Re: Chainsaws

#2

Re: Stihl. No question about brand.

Allen Neighbors

>Size and need are the next consideration. I have an MS 310, and wouldn't trade it for anything.

Re: Chainsaws

#3

Or a husky, depends on where you are.

henthorn

>

Re: Chainsaws

#4

Re: Or a husky, depends on where you are.

Justin Fields

>For what it is worth, I'm just outside Washington, DC. Hardly real logging country. ;-)

Re: Chainsaws

#5

Re: Chainsaws

Barry Turner

>The usage you describe may be infrequent, but I wouldn't call it "light". Cross-cutting a 12" log for a bowl blank puts a fairly heavy demand on a chainsaw. So does ripping that log lengthwise into two bowl blanks also requires a fair bit of muscle from a chainsaw. These are commonly repeated operations for a woodturner's chainsaw.

Buy as much chainsaw as you can afford. Seldom does anyone complain about having too much saw, but they gripe long and loud about not having a saw large enough for the task at hand.

I have a Stihl 361 and am very happy with it. I use it only a few times a year, but there simply is no comparison between it and the big-box store saws like Poulan, Homelite, McCulloch and the like.

I consider Stihl to be one of the best brands, if not the best. Husqvarna has it's fans as well. You can spend a little more and buy a good adequately-sized saw that will serve you well for many years, or you can buy a small, cheap one (or several) and cuss it for as long as you own it. Your choice. Just my opinion. You know your needs and budget better than anyone. What ever your choice, get some instruction and learn to use the saw safely. A chainsaw would rather cut flesh than wood.

Re: Chainsaws

#6

Steven Antonucci

Practical advice.

steve antonucci

>How big of a lathe do you own? What amount of weight can you mount by yourself? How often do you plan to turn big wood?

I have a 16" swing on my Nova, and that's a pretty big block of wood. May not sound like it, but it is. My headstock swivels, so I can turn even bigger, but truth is that it just takes so much effort to turn away 50-60# of wood that I rarely do it.

So how does this answer your question?

I own a Stihl O17 with a 14" bar. I can cut wood about 28" in diameter (one pass from either side). Do I work on logs bigger than 28"? I sure do, and only then do I wish I had a bigger saw. Someday, I'll buy one, but I'll still use the O17 for most of what I need for woodturning because it doesn't weigh 13#.

Steven

Re: Chainsaws

#7

Re: Chainsaws

Lan Brady

>Justin,

I have the same question. Last weekend, I burned up my 3rd chainsaw by trying to cut bowl blanks. No more box store chainsaw for me. I have searched the web sites and read everyting I can find.

I will be buying either:

Husqvarna 460 or

Stihl MS 310

In my area, Prices are about the same, I am now investigating the Service centers.

Good Luck to both of us, Lan

Re: Chainsaws

#8

Re: Chainsaws

John Scheideman

>I bought a Stihl MS 310 about a year ago after doing quite a bit of research. It has served me well for sawing turning blanks. That is mostly what I use it for. I haven't regretted the purchase. Good luck with your search.

John

Re: Chainsaws

#9

Re: Chainsaws

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Justin,

If you are going to get a saw, get a good one and it will run better and last a lifetime. I bought several cheap saws before I learned that lesson. The last one I bought at Home Depot and sold it in disgust at a yard sale for $25.

I use two Stihl saws, a smaller 250 with an 18" bar for almost everything, and a larger newer saw with a 24" bar for Really Big Wood. I'd recommend a smaller saw due to it's lighter weight and ease of handling. The 250 is no slouch. I cut up to about 30" or so diameter logs with the smaller saw; bigger, I take along the larger saw.

Good related tools:

- two or three plastic wedges

- extra bar and chain

- cant hook

Good safety equipment:

- combo hard hat/face shield/ear protection

- kevlar chaps (the most common injuries are to the legs)

Cutting up trees on the ground is relatively safe. Felling trees is one of the most dangerous things you can do in life. Since you have not used a chain saw, either get someone else to cut down the trees, work with an experienced person for a couple of years, or take out some extra life insurance. I've cut down many trees over the years, but MOST of the time I will hire someone - it's usually pretty cheap if they just put them on the ground and I do all the rest.

I recommend one small book in particular, "The Good Woodcutter's Guide" by Dave Johnson. This is full of excellent advice on chainsaw care and feeding, operation, and safety, especially safety.

This book describes some new ways to die that I never imagined. If you can't imagine it, it is waiting to get you. As an example, in the section on rotational kickback Dave writes "...the saw tends to rotate in the hands of the cutter, throwing it back at him. Fast. ... The whole thing is over in less than a second. If the victim does recover his senses, his first instinct is to push the saw away. This often causes him to squeeze the handle, thus depressing the throttle and revving the saw. Some unfortunate souls actually have gutted themsleves as the saw is pulled down through their chest and stomach."

I think I'd rather go with the old age method.

JKJ

Re: Chainsaws

#10

Justin...

GaryG in MD

>Introduce yourself to me at the next MCW meeting -- I'm the one with the candid camera. ...Gary

Re: Chainsaws

#11

Get quality the FIRST time...

Peter Teubel

>Leverage the experience of others and choose wisely.

FYI: I went thru 3 POO-lans (I cannot over-emphasize the POO part) in one year before I wised up and got my first Stihl (after using a friend's MS290 for a few days). No comparison. It was truly an eye-opener. I have 4 Stihls now and they are always a pleasure to use.

Re: Chainsaws

#12

Re: Chainsaws

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Justin,

Some good advise so far. I have a Husky 346 XP for my main saw. I run a 20" bar on it. I also have a Stihl 180 C electric that I use in the shop. They are both great saws with different applications.

I would suggest that you go to some of the pro saw forums and read for a bit before you buy. That is what I did and found it easier to make a good choice for my needs with some education from the people who use saws every day and all day.

It is important to know that there are pro saws and consumer models out there. It is usually reflected in the pricing. :) I only wanted to cry once when I bought my saw. I have not regretted it so far.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Chainsaws

#13

Re: Stihl 250. . .

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>

Re: Chainsaws

#14

ebd

Re: Chainsaws

ebd

>Stihl if available in your area, otherwise Husky. The Stihl's have a bigger chip ejection chute so it keeps clear when you are ripping better than the Husky. Both are great saws.

Re: Chainsaws

#15

Clarifications

Justin Fields

>To clarify some follow-up questions people have asked and give further info:

I don't know how big my turned pieces will be. At the club where I turn, I have access to an old Delta, 2 new Jets and a nice big Oneway lathe. Between them, including turning outboard, I could probably turn something as big as I wanted. Also, since I work at a club, I'm sure I could also snag somebody to help me mount something huge if I needed to. So far, I've only done small stuff. Primarily, that has been because of the cost of the wood. I haven't developed good sources for free or inexpensive wood yet (wink, wink, nudge, nudge ;-)) so I've been learning on little 4x4x2 and 6x6x2 blocks that I bought online. So I don't know what the upper limit of the size I'll be turning will be. I'd rather that be limited by my eventual preference than by cutting limitation.

Stihl and Husky are both available in my area.

The trees I've taken down in the past for non-woodworking use have been up to about 14" in diameter. I did those with an axe or bow saw. Both of those options are more workout than I really want to get. Felling trees will be an incredibly rare event for me. Generally, I'm content to let the professionals or more experienced folks actually take the trees down to the ground. I'd just do on-ground cutting.

People have already commented enough for me to rule out the Home Depot available models. I do not want to go down the road of buying and discarding cheap tools that aren't really up to the job. The folks at Home Depot were pretty bewildered when I was trying to explain the process of and shape of a bowl blank. They couldn't conceptualize farther than cutting the tree down and taking it to logs with simple crosscuts. You all have also corrected my misperception that my infrequent use would be fairly "light usage".

The extra life insurance I've taken out does specifically cover my skydiving, but I'd rather not test the general policy with chainsaw mutilation either. ;-o

On the hypothetical that I were to buy a Stihl, where in the product line is most appropriate for my anticipated usage? I understand that to a large extent, larger and more power equal more capability, but I also don't want to pay for and tote around some overkill behemoth. The 230 lists for $290. The 250 is $320. The 270 and 290 list at about $350. After that, the prices climb into regions I can't possibly justify for my homeowner/hobbyist use. I could probably scrape up for one of these, and there isn't a huge range between them, so what are your thoughts? What bar length is reasonable?

Thanks again for the info, folks!

Justin

Re: Chainsaws

#16

Re: Chainsaws

Bob Macgregor

>I have a Stihl 026 with 16" bar that has worked great for me. This is my second of this model; the first is probably still running well for whoever stole it.

I gather that Stihl renumbered their line of saws, so I don't know what the equivalent is now.

Only once or twice have I wanted a longer bar. More often, I have thought a shorter bar would be better. When decoring a block, I need to watch for clogging of the chute; that lengthwise ripping really produces a lot of long ribbons that can tangle up into a pretty impressive wad in short order.

Look at the specs and consider the weight, the max rated bar length, and fuel capacity. If you ever go on a day-long cutting expedition, you will notice the weight and frequency of refueling stops.

With luck, you will be able to get a package deal with combo hardhat/earmuff/faceshield AND chaps; don't start sawing without these. I also wear high-top steel-toes boots whenever I use the saw.

Good luck.

Re: Chainsaws

#17

Re: Chainsaws

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Justin

I have a couple of Sthil 310 saws one short bar and one long bar. Steve mentioned a small saw but I think it has a narrow chain that tends to bind in green wood. The 310 uses a # 27 chain that has a wider cut with less binding.

One thing you need with a larger saw is a good grip to pull the rope. If your hands are not strong go with a smaller size. Buy as large as you are comfortable handling. Start it before buying to be sure you can handle it. Buy Sthil or Husky and be happy you spent a few extra dollars. Buy an extra bar and a couple of chains.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Chainsaws

#18

Re: Chainsaws

Steven Kubien

>I recently picked up my first gas chainsaw (Stihl MS390). I hummed and hawed for quite a while. I've spoken to a lot of people with MS290's and they are really happy with them. Dependable with a lot of power. However, a couple of folks did mention that if they had to do things over again they would look for a larger saw. The 390 is rated for up to a 25" or 28" bar (can't remember) which I took to mean plenty of power for the 18" or 20" I would end up with. I like this saw a lot. I LOVE the decompression feature as it makes starting a lot easier. Would I want to use it for 8 or 10 hours in the bush? Because of it's weight, probably not, but I sure would like knowing that it could handle anything I came up against.

HTH

Steve Kubien

Re: Chainsaws

#19

Dick Hines

Re: Chainsaws

Dick Hines

>Thanks John, you just screwed up a good lunch.

Re: Chainsaws

#20

Re: Chainsaws

Bill Crommett

>Let me add one more: You have to knock a few trees over backwards in order to know how to handle a saw.

Re: Chainsaws

#21

Justin, another thing you need to ....

Allen Neighbors

>consider, is Chainsaw Chaps. I used a chainsaw for 30 years without an accident, then, after a stupid mistake, sawed my knee. I bought the chaps and sawed them instead, the next stupid time. They cost about 60 bucks, and worth every penny.

Re: Chainsaws

#22

Re: Clarifications

John Leonard

>Santa brought me a Stihl 280 easy start (decompression valve) with a 20 inch bar for Christmas. I love it. It easy on my bad elbo to start and there is no comparison to the poulan I had been using. I wll get a 16 inch bar soon so i can save the 20 for bigger stuff. John L.

Re: Chainsaws

#23

Re: Clarifications

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Justin,

You have gotten a lot of good advice. I use my chainsaw a bunch. I cut lots of turning blanks of all different sizes, as well as using it to cut firewood. We heat exclusively with wood, so I cut a bunch of that, also.

I bought the MS290 about 3 years ago. I think I have the 18" bar. I liked it so well, I bought one for my son. I don't think you really need any more saw than this, and if money is a problem, I wouldn't hesitate to step down a model.

Gary

Re: Chainsaws

#24

Re:Electric Chainsaws

Larry Gottlieb

>I would appreciate any recommendations for an electric chainsaw. I wish to cut small logs in my shop (basement), and trim shrubs in the yard. No major tree felling or extensive cutting.

I burned out 2 cheap electric saws several years ago.

Larry

Re: Chainsaws

#25

Re:Electric Chainsaws

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Quality only by name. I have seen a Husky electric but know nothing about it. I consider all electrics as short term if they get much use. Buy the electric for in shop and a small Sthil, 017, for outdoor use.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.