Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Something to watch out for

Posts

Something to watch out for

#1

Ellis Walentine

Something to watch out for

Ellis Walentine

>In my 49 years of woodturning, I have never had an experience like the one I had last Sunday. I was hollowing a little cherry pot/vase using a small goose-neck Jordan hollowing tool. I had to swing the tool into the somewhat long neck of the vase because of the curvature of the goose-neck shank, but when I finished my cut, I inadvertently pulled the tool straight out instead of swinging it. This had the effect of jamming the tool in the neck of the vase.

Well, I had never seen a lathe tool go from 0 to 1500 rpm in zero seconds flat, but that's what happened. By the time I could let it go, the rubber-coated handle had already sizzled the crook of my hand. Today I have some dandy blisters to show for it, along with a new respect for this particular danger. It could have been worse.

After reflecting on my experience for a while, I had an even creepier thought: What if I had been using a tool with a forearm clip? A catch like that would have spun my whole arm off in a split second!

I don't mean to sound alarmist; I just wanted to let you know about something that could ruin your whole day.

Ellis

Re: Something to watch out for

#2

Re: Something to watch out for

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Zounds, I've wondered about that. Hollowing always scares me.

Maybe hollowing tool evolution will someday create a breakaway joint on such tools.

There was a recent thread questioning whether a lathe could have "too much" power. Makes me wonder.

What kind of lathe? I don't want to try an experiment, but I wonder if some lathes would be more forgiving to such a "catch". The VS controller on my Jet 1642, for example, will cut the power and freewheel to a stop if I get a big catch. This has happened a couple of times in the last 6 years.

JKJ

Re: Something to watch out for

#3

Re: Something to watch out for

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Ellis,

Thank goodness your injuries weren't more serious. I too have had momentary lapses when you just loose your concentration and these type of accidents are waiting to happen. For most of my hollowing I use a captive tool. I just recently bought the Trent Bosch set to try some hollowing by feel and your warning will make me pay more attention to what I am doing.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: Something to watch out for

#4

That's why I don't use an armbrace

Carole Valentine

>I have had a couple of catches that wrenched my shoulder before I could even let go of the tool. I can't imagine what would have happened if my my arm had been captive in a clip! I really do think those things are dangerous, but each to his/her own.

Re: Something to watch out for

#5

Re: Something to watch out for

Mark Williamson

>I too have had a moment similar to this. Mine was based more on sheer stupidity though! LOL I had just sharpened up a dental pick to hollow out a longer miniature that I was turning and not thinking about the fact that it was a double ended pick. It caught as well and before I could even register that I was feeling pain, I was bleeding from about 30 pinholes across my palm. Needles to say, I have started cutting the doubled picks in half and mounting a handle on the two halves.

Mark

Re: Something to watch out for

#6

Steven Antonucci

Good lesson

steve antonucci

>The danger mostly lies in "loss of control" of the business end of the tool. My experience is that it is usually a momentary lack of concentration that does you in. I have a window in the garage door by the lathe and passing cars, deer, squirrels and a host of other things have cause me temporary stress and discomfort!

Hollowing needs to be an almost zen-like state. In the begining, the chances of a catch ruining your day are from the mass and momentum of the wood being enough to break things on you. Towards the end, that same momentary slip ruins hours worth of work, and likely without injury...

I'll never wear an armbrace, and for now, will stay handheld.

Steven

Re: Something to watch out for

#7

Re: Something to watch out for

Carole Valentine

>My DVR is supposed to stop in the event of a big catch too, but I don't think it can do it quick enough.

Re: Something to watch out for

#8

it doesn't...don't ask how I know

Ralph

>

Re: Something to watch out for

#9

You ARE the weakest link.....

Barry Irby

>Not meant to be an insult, but you are the weakest link, or at least the only one that feels the pain.

As the lathe becomes more powerful and the attachment of the wood to it stronger, the risk is transferred to you. Same thing with the tool handles. If you use a really slick wood handle it may turn harmlessly in your hand, but that nice textured or rubber grip transfers the energy to your skin much more efficiently.

Then you do an even better job of attaching yourself to the tool, you become an even larger target. I have never actually used an arm brace, but it sure looks like it has a chance to wrench your arm severely. All these things work both ways. If you can hold the tools and apply more force to the work, the work can apply more force to you.

I went to Arrowmont for a class with David Ellsworth. I couldn't wait to get started, so the first night, I was "playing" with David's tools. (Can you believe those idiots at Arrowmont left ME unattended???) I had never seen the tools before and had no idea what I was doing. Managed to get the "angle" tool caught. Held on for dear life. Broke the tip off. (In hind sight I should be thankful.) Next morning I had to sheepishly confess. I had slept poorly, envisioning being thrown out or worse, having the entire class cancelled because David would have nothing to work with. David was very gracious and started the class with a lesson on replacing the tips.

Glad you were not hurt any worse. Heal quickly. Thanks for the warning. Maybe we can all be a little safer.

Re: Something to watch out for

#10

I have one too.....

Barry Irby

>It stops if you get a catch, which is good, but it may not be good enough to prevent injury. Whatever energy is stored in the motor and the block you are turning remains. I assume the rotor in the motor is a significant amount of weight and it is part of the lathe shaft. So, whatever the force is, you get all of it until it stops. At least it stops, which is better, but it may not be enough to completely protect you.

Incidentally, if you get a minor catch, it restarts immediately. If you get three in a row quickly it shuts down. (DAMHIKT) So if you get a catch, be ready for the restart.

Re: Something to watch out for

#11

Re: Something to watch out for

john lucas

>Ellis I had that happen once and I was using an armbrace. I was hollowing an offcenter piece through the offcenter neck. I had it basicallly done and was trying to thin out one area. I did something I shouldn't have and blew the vessel up. I thought I had brocken my wrist for a while. The feeling finally started coming back and I realized nothing was too serious.

That's why I'm a fan of captured bar hollowing. It's kind of like learning to use a push stick with the table saw. At first it's kind of tough and unnatural to use but now my push sticks are like extensions to my hand. I figure with enough work on a captured bar system and maybe getting a newer more versatile system like the Kobra it will become second nature like my push sticks.

Re: Something to watch out for

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Something to watch out for

Dick Hines

>Things like tis is why I use my captured hollowing rig most of time. And when I don't I don't use am arm brace.

I can get into enough trouble anyway. I don't need any help.

Glad you came ouit of this OK.

Re: Something to watch out for

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Something to watch out for

Dick Hines

>Mark, you may want to start turning some small handles on the picks. It's safer and gives you a better grip.

Re: Something to watch out for

#14

Re: Barry- the unattended idot was .......

Jamie Donaldson

>.....YOU!! I thought there was a rule that at least 2 students had to be in the room before any tools were turned on- that is policy at Campbell Folk School, and I enforce it for good reason!

Re: Something to watch out for

#15

Re: Ellis et al- I know from years of .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....hollowing experience that most OOopps! OOhh s#%*&$#@t happens when inserting or removing tools thru a small opening, so I long ago developed the practice of moving tools in and out with the lathe stopped. A remote ON/OFF switch properly placed is both a convenience and safety feature worth a LOT when "stuff happens!"

Re: Something to watch out for

#16

Re: Something to watch out for

Mark Williamson

>Oh yes! I just wish I didn't have to explain to my wife how the series of bleeding dots across my hand came from in order to learn that! LOL She loves it when I give her resons to tell me that what I did was really stupid! he he

Re: Something to watch out for

#17

thans for the heads up, Ellis...

GaryG in MD

>...and everyone else for their comments.

I've been using an arm brace, and I'm now questioning it. ...Gary

Re: Something to watch out for

#18

Re: Something to watch out for

Russ Fairfield

>I'm surprized it took you so long before this happened. And, yes, that is a problem with an arm-brace hollowing tool.

Re: Something to watch out for

#19

My solution..

Mike Nelson

>I slightly loosened the motor tension on the belt (PM3520). I can still hog out a hf but a big catch on a thick piece will make the belt squeal instead of me! I think it has taught me to be smoother with hollowing. Mike

Re: Something to watch out for

#20

another vote for lyle jameison

robert davis

>

Re: Something to watch out for

#21

Re: Something to watch out for

Bruce Lane

>Mr. Lucas, what is this Kobra of which you briefly mention?

Re: Something to watch out for

#22

Re: Something to watch out for

Bruce Lane

>Sorry, found it in another thread.

Re: Something to watch out for

#23

Re: Something to watch out for

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've been using a Dennis Stewart armbrace tool since 1987. Over the years I've had a few jolts but nothing serious. When turning vessels with small openings I stop the lathe before removing the tool. When I'm teaching a hollow form class I try to impress on the students than you never touch the rim with the tool while cutting. A sure way to bust the rim and possibly hurt yourself if a catch occurs.

Wally

Re: Something to watch out for

#24

Re: Something to watch out for

Craig Daymon

>I'm in NO position to give advice, but that's one of the reasons I bought a remote switch for my 3520. If you don't have one, it's worth the investment. If you're turning on a Oneway, their remote switch is really nice.

Get well soon.

-Craig

Re: Something to watch out for

#25

Re: Something to watch out for

Clay Foster

>Like Wally, I've been using the Dennis Stewart arm brace for about 20 years. I've never injured myself with it. Does anyone know some one who actually has hurt themselves with it?

On the other hand, I know lots of woodturners who have seriously injured themselves on a bandsaw. Maybe we're worrying about the wrong thing here.