Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

P&N Gouges

Posts

P&N Gouges

#1

P&N Gouges

John Scheideman

>I am considering trying a P&N gouge. If anyone has used them I'd like to hear your opinions. Thanks.

Re: P&N Gouges

#2

ask Michael Hosaluk

Bob Elliott

>Canadian turner Michael Hosaluk uses P&N detail gouges. He recently stated at a demo (Central Florida Woodturners) that P&N detail gouges have a very shallow flute which also makes them very sturdy and less prone to flex / chatter.


img

Re: P&N Gouges

#3

Re: ask Michael Hosaluk *LINK*

Donna Banfield

>John, you should also consider Doug Thompson's gouges. I have both P&N and Doug's gouges, and prefer Doug's. They both come unhandled, and for the steel and price, Doug's are much better.

Besides being a tool maker, he's also a pretty good turner, and frequent contributor to this site.

Here's a link to his site


http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/

Re: P&N Gouges

#4

I agree with the Thompson tools

john lucas

>I was going to buy some P@N tools because I liked the shape of some of their gouges. The Thompson tools have some of the same shape and they hold an edge a lot longer than the P@N. One thing I was really interested in was the roughing gouge with a 3/4" tang. Doug now sells one of those also. I think you'll find the prices quite comparable.

Re: P&N Gouges

#5

Re: P&N Gouges

Mike Brazeau

>I have two of the 5/8" P&N bowl gouges and a 1/2" as well. One of the 5/8" is sharpened with the Irish Grind and the others I have left pretty much like the factory grind and use for finishing cuts. At the time of purchase our Canadian dollar was not worth as much as it is now and they were the best value out there and readily available from our local LV store. Don't like the black coating, but you get over it. I am pleased with the performance, but would probably pay the 1/3 increase to go with Doug's now that the Canadian dollar is stronger. I have the luxury of a LV store being where I do my shopping, so don't have to pay freight costs. I have tried the P&N roughing gouge and did not like the feel of it. Found it very heavy to use compared to my ASP 2030 I bought about five years ago from Jacques Coulombe and am extremely happy with. Based on my experience with other powder metallurgy tools (Oneway and ASP 2030 & 2060 and one Henry Taylor) there is no doubt they hold an edge longer. 2060 has a finer edge off the wheel as well.

Re: P&N Gouges

#6

Re: P&N Gouges

Steven Kubien

>Hi John,

A P&N bowl gouge (supa gouge?) was my first good tool. I really liked it and used it a lot...until I got my Thompson gouges. The Thompson's hold their edge better in my opinion and personally, i like being able to support a budding entreprenuer (sp).

My 2 cents,

Steve Kubien

Re: P&N Gouges

#7

Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

Craig Daymon

>Thompson has great tools, but they don't offer anything to compete with the P&N roughing gouge. Neither does anyone else that I am aware of.

Also, P&N carries one or two sizes you can't get from Thompson. I have a 5/16" (actually 8mm) shallow detail gouge that I like, as an example.

-Craig

Re: P&N Gouges

#8

Re: Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

john lucas

>I don't have one yet but I think the Thompson roughing gouge has a the same shank as the P@N roughing gouge.

Re: P&N Gouges

#9

Re: Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

Craig Daymon

>Based on their site, you may not have one because they don't offer one. There is no roughing gouge listed on the web site.

-Craig

Re: P&N Gouges

#10

Re: ask Michael Hosaluk

Bob Elliott

>During the recent demo in which he made one of his ladles, Michael used a 5/8" P&N detail gouge on the handle. Then re-chucked the ladle for hollowing the "bowl" of the ladle with a Thompson bowl gouge! Michael further stated that the Thompson detail gouges had deeper flutes compared to the P&N...his personal preference was for the shallow flute.

I own a 3/8" P&N detail gouge and 1" P&N roughing gouge. Both the P&N's came from the discount table at Woodcraft. Also have a 3/8" Thompson spindle gouge, 1/2" Thompson "V" bowl gouge and a 1/2" Thompson detail gouge. I too am a believer in Thompson tools!

Re: P&N Gouges

#11

Re: Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

john lucas

>Craig something must have come up. He had them when I talked to him and they were on his website. Now I don't see them. I'll have to ask again.

Re: P&N Gouges

#12

Re: Thompson gouges

John Scheideman

>I'm ahead of you! I already have one of Doug's gouges and I do like it. He's also great to deal with. I was just wondering about the P&N gouges since I had never tried them. Thanks for all the responses.

John

Re: P&N Gouges

#13

Re: ask Michael Hosaluk

Fog Tanner

>I have a 1/2" P&N detail gouge I got from Hoslauk several years ago. I also have a 1/2" Thompson detail gouge. I checked the flutes on the two and the Thompson that I have is shallower than the P&N. My 3/8" Thompson detail flute is shallower relative to its size than the P&N.

The P&N tools are great for M2, and were a good price when I got mine. If I were buying M2, I would buy some more. But, you just can't match the edge life of the Thompson tools. And nobody making or selling tools today is as nice to deal with as Doug. So as long as Doug is making and selling tools I won't be buying any M2..

Re: P&N Gouges

#14

Re: Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Craig, the 1-1/4 SRG was let out at the Ohio valley symposium (they were not going to be sold). Bill Neddow who posts on this site has one to turn the outside of bowls, this summer I will drive up to see him and find out how he does it... then make a gouge that can be used safely with the same type flute and grind.

Mark Sfirri got one too, his first comment after using it in a demo was "it doesn't get dull"

This next batch will have some made.

Re: P&N Gouges

#15

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Gordon Seto

>One thing I don't understand is on their larger tools, why the shank has to be reduced to under 1/2"?

A tool is only going to be as strong as the weakest link. Kelton handles can accommodate 3/4" and 5/8" shanks. A 5/8" shank has 1.5625 times more steel than a 1/2". A 3/4" has 2.25 times more steel.

I have their 22 mm Supa gouge with the Ultimate Kelton handle; that is a massive tool. But I don't really like it. When using I don't feel it as solid as a tool of this size should be. It is no match to the Sorby Mega bowl gouge of roughly the same size in stability.

The 1/2" shank probably would not snap like the forged gouge, but a stronger shank would reduce the any chance of chattering.

I buy a 22mm gouge; I want the strength of a 22mm gouge. Why reduced it to 12mm (1/2")? I don't think they can save any money with a smaller shank. The smaller shank didn't look like it was brazed on. I can't understand the logic behind this, may be someone knowledgeable about tool making can explain.

Gordon

Re: P&N Gouges

#16

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I don't understand the logic either, a tool chatters because the steel is flexing that's why we use larger diameter tools to overcome this force. The steel should remain the same diameter the entire lenght (within reason) a 1-1/4 SRG doesn't need a 1-1/4 shank. What we do a 3/4 inch shank is more than enough to overcome any force from the rotating blank.

Re: P&N Gouges

#17

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It is a little difficult to attach a 1 1/4" tool tang to a 1 1/4" tool handle (Oneway, Kelton #3, Hosaluk, etc.).

As far as stability and vibration resistance, a dedicated handle with intimate contact over the entire tang area is always superior. The interchangeable handles have the advantage of convenience, but at the sacrifice of rigidity. Two set screws can't even come close to providing the level of support and stability that an interference (force) fit or epoxy bedded handle provides.

Re: P&N Gouges

#18

Re: Their (spindle) roughing gouge can't be beat

Craig Daymon

>I'll try to remember to ask Mark about it at our next meeting. I know he was using a P&N SRG at the 2006 symposium (along with almost every other demonstrator I saw). If your SRG is anything like the rest of your tools, I'm sure it will be worth getting. Though it will be a while before I wear out my P&N.

-Craig

Re: P&N Gouges

#19

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Brian McInturff

>Well I'm just waiting for the SRG of Doug's to come out.I'm in need of a new one and have a couple detail gouges and a couple bowl gouges of his. I also just received another of Doug's gouges with A Hannes handle plus a couple more handles for the other gouges I have.

Re: P&N Gouges

#20

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Allen Neighbors

>I agree with you, Gordon. I believe it has to do with the people designing the tools not being wood turners.

I also agree with the previous poster (sorry, I can't remember which it was, and I can't see it while I'm writing this) who said that the two set screws can't compete with a solidly attached handle.

Doug's tools can't be beaten, thus far. In price or engineering.

Re: P&N Gouges

#21

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Gordon Seto

>I also agree with Brian Hahn about the grub screws. But that allows me a choice to have a removable handle which is a convenient.

If I epoxy the 1/2" shank into a fixed handle, I still have a weak link. Unless I bury couple inches of the full shank into the handle and make it a shorter gouge. IMO, that's poor engineering design.

Gordon

Re: P&N Gouges

#22

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Fog Tanner

>The 1/2" P&N detail gouge I have is really less than 1/2" at the shank - around .470 to .480. It is machined from solid bar and not brazed or welded on. This was a convience so you could interchange tools in the various types of metal handles. In a wooden handle it would seem the weakest link would be where the steel ends and the wood begins, regardless if its held in with set screws, epoxy or driven in.

One of our club members has a bowl scraper, one of the thicker ones around 3/8" thick. It had one of the handles assocaited with that type of scraper. He got a bad catch and the handle split at the end of the flat tang. After seeing that, I have gotten away from the traditional coke bottle style handles I was making for bowls. The handle for my 5/8" Thompson bowl gouge is the steel handle that came with my McNaughton system. If that bends or breaks, I need to find something else to do.....

Stu Batty made the observation that you need five times the length of the tool behind the toolrest as is in front if you want control - three times if you don't.....

Re: P&N Gouges

#23

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Gordon Seto

>Fog Tanner: "The 1/2" P&N detail gouge I have is really less than 1/2" at the shank - around .470 to .480..."

That is 12 mm. We are the only country left that has not gone metric.

Gordon

Re: P&N Gouges

#24

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

leppikallio

>Hey, don't speak such nasty things about my loved one! ;-))

Seriously, that 22mm Supa is so far my favorite gouge, with that Kelton Ultimate handle. That may be because I haven't been able to use any _really_ good tools but... Honestly I use it mostly for that big and nasty roughing and I feel it is extremely good gouge. No vibration problem at all however I always have had that thinner part of the tool behind the tool rest, not over or behind it. However I have had almost full length of that tool over the tool rest without any problems. Besides for some reason I think that there is (almost) always something weaker in that game than 12mm (slightly under 1/2") steel. That will absorb quite impressive forces.

For home shop machinists 12mm / 1/2" is much gentler size than 19mm or 3/4" when it is time to drill the hole to handle for the tool. Metal or wood. Just some thoughts.

Re: P&N Gouges

#25

Re: P&N Gouges-dumb engineering?

Fog Tanner

>Gordon,

Before I got into computers I was a chem major and used metric for a number of years. To me its just another numbering system, no better or worse than what we use. We have come from the cubit, to the foot, and then the meter. But for the future, the metric system will go the way of the cubit and foot. It is a multiple of 10 and not a true binary multiple and since the world is going to the computer, we will have to cater to what it wants. So, the world will go hexadecimal and we will wonder how we ever got along without it.

These days most of my time is spent in non-base 10 numbering systems. Either Base 2 or base 16. Still just numbering systems, but better suited for computers that use binary multiple and dealing with really large numbers.