>What I find to be a major disappointment is that Ellis didn't tell this person to take a hike. Does the person complaining think they could do a better job? I felt it was great to have some direction. While I could not often join the chat, I always read the logs. I continue to be amazed at how the squeeky wheel gets greased rather than tossed on the burn pile and replaced. Here we had someone with experience, knowledge, and willing to tackle the thankless job and we thank him by running him off.
>I can empathize Steve. The commercial post police are at it again.
I was politely asked to stop posting pics of beautiful wood that I come across. Someone was afraid that I was trying for free advertising. Like you, I didn't want to put Ellis in the middle, so I agreed to cease and desist.
Of course, I never sold any wood because of the pics. My motivation was more along the lines of gloating. 8^]
Sorry you were forced out. I didn't attend the chats but I understand you did a very competent job of moderating.
Then again, the chats are a bit to chaotic for my taste, so I rarely attend. I think that the moderator position for that chat is a thankless post to man, since someone is almost guaranteed to complain-no matter who does the job or how they do it.
Frankly, I don't understand why anyone would accept a job that is set up for failure. I applaud those who have tried, but scratch my head at the same time. A better approach might be for the folks that actually attend to run it on a rotating basis- with each person having to contribute once a year to be able to participate.
Put a little skin in the game, but not too much...
>Even though I never found time to participate in the chats, I find it sad how a few people can have such a negative effect on an otherwise positive aspect of this site. And as others said, to not even address it directly with Steve is unfair at best. We get an enthusiastic, accomplished, and intelligent moderator and lose him because a couple of people don't like something he may have said. We have been through this before unfortunately. If those who are doing the complaining can do a better job then get off your whining butt and step up ! See how you like it when people complain about the job you are doing when you put a lot of time and energy into it. If you don't like what is happening in the chat room, no one is forcing you to be there. It's an unfortunate commentary on our society when the vocal minority holds sway over the quiet majority.
>Sorry, I missed the resignation message. More importantly, I missed any , public messages from offended members that complained about Steve's self promotion. That could have easily put the subject up for debate amongst the WC faithful so that their support could be out in the open.
I didn't see anyone in this thread say he was fired...
The bottom line in all of this to remember is that this board belongs to Ellis; he can run it any way he wants. Like my own business, no one but my creditors has a say so.
All of this is getting irrelevent anyway. It's done.
It makes you wonder though, how the next moderator will be treated.
>I feel responsible since I was the one who passed along what was intended to be constructive feedback to you. I never intended it to be marching orders, merely a heads-up, in the "if the shoe fits" spirit. I'm sorry if you understood it as a sign of dissatisfaction, from me or the majority of forum participants.
One thing everyone in the public eye, including chat moderators, has to be aware of is that not everyone is going to agree with or identify with them on everything. It is sufficient that we have the courage and confidence of our convictions and take an active interest in what others are saying or suggesting, but feel free to discard any advice that we know isn't useful or correct. If I had known that you would take this so personally, Steve, I wouldn't have mentioned the comments to you. I loved your ambition and enthusiasm and I felt you had brought an excellent dimension to the Turning chats. Clearly, the turnouts for your chats reflected others' agreement on that, too.
The door remains open if you would like to resume your moderator position. You have a strong following here and it sounds to me like they would like you to get past this episode and on to some more great chats. I would, too.
Thanks for your comments. Hopefully the next moderator will be able to find some way to please everyone... Take care and all the best to you and yours!
Thanks so much for your very kind words... Although it was tough at times with my hectic schedule, I always managed to rearrange my schedule (save my vacation in Hawaii), so I could moderate the chat. I was eager to do this and I always felt privileged to do so. I never heard from the people who emailed Ellis, although I frequently asked for comments - both good and bad. Hopefully the new moderator can continue to build the chat into a valuable resource for all of WC's members. Thanks again and best wishes to you and yours!
>I was one who enjoyed the format that Steve had developed immensely and found it extremely informative. As I said in a previous post I was unaware of any unpleasantries and never saw anything going on besides some lighthearted jabs. His selection and variety of topics offered something for everyone. I particularly enjoyed the Show and Tell part of the chat as it provided feedback and guidance on design and finishing. Wednesdays were a lot of fun for me.
If I had one suggestion for the next moderator and I hope it will be Steve Russell now that he has had a little vacation is that he will incorporate guest turner interviews. It would be great if we could entice some high profile turners to visit us once a month in chat and share what they might be willing to share. It would also be nice to have guest chats with WC Turners of the Month just so we could get to know each other better.
Sorry for your loss, Steve. We had a mother-in-law to pass over the holidays. No fun....
And it's usually a newbie to a group that has little knowledge of a group, it's history, or active members that seem to protest what he/she percieves as an abuse of a forum. When Steve Knight posts about a new plane he's come up with over in rec.woodworking, someone ALWAYS screams "SPAMMMMMMM!" Usually a Regular will provide some background on Steve and all the things he's done to help other woodworkers, and often provide a user's perspective of one of his planes they won - and use. And when Ed Bennett posts to the group that he's got a special on his TS-Aligner, and that may be once or twice a year - a newbie will cry FOUL! Then a regular will fill in some of the misconceptions the newbie may have had - and all is well.
When an adult percieves a problem with the behavior of another adult, it's normally preferable to discuss it with that adult, adult to adult. Only if that doesn't clear things up should (IMHO) a third party be called upon to mediate - and make a decision to resolve the issue.
I've got a woodworking website - personal, not commercial - and I can put together a page or two about a subject and provide a link to it. Being able to mix text and graphics together provides a bit more coherence than a forum usually provides. The intent is to provide hopefully useful info to other woodworkers. And when the subject comes up again - a link is all I need to contribute.
I haven't particiapted in any chats here, but I understand why Steve would, given his time constraints, and number of inquiries, provide a link to some info he already has out there on the web rather than retype and repost pics. Even though he might have a commercial site, if the linked info provides the info being asked for - I see no problem.
Sure hope whoever chose to take a percieved problem up with this site's owner doesn't wander over to rec.woodworking unless he/she/they come wearing a Nomex suit . . .
Thanks so much for your kind words of support. It's lots of people like you that really make WC a special place to hang out. If I can ever help you, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!
I seem to recall a few of your pictures... I love looking at beautiful wood... Too bad, we've lost another great resource. Take care and all the best to you and yours!
Thanks for your kind words... No one ever contacted me with a complaint in this matter, even though I requested comments on several occasions when I was a moderator. Too bad because we were really building up the chat and it was seeing very good attendance. Take care and all the best to you and yours!
Thanks for your kind words... I would like to personally thank you for all of your assistance, whilst I moderated the Turning Chat. You were a big help to me in many ways. If I can ever help you, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and all the best to you and yours!
Thanks for your kind words. I appreciate your explanation of what happened... On numerous occasions I asked members of WC to give me feedback, positive or negative about the chats and my moderation. I never heard anything about this until your email to me. Please know that I did not take the comments from you personally at all. I have no such ego to bruise...
My resignation was my humble attempt to "fall on my sword" as it were, because I felt that you were caught in the middle between a few unhappy chat participants and myself. To me this was unacceptable (we've never even met for goodness sakes) and it would have been unprofessional of me to ask you to take any heat for my actions as moderator. This is your baby and you have enough on your plate as it is, therefore I felt the only way I could protect WC from any possible negative impact (and to insulate you from this matter) was to resign.
You have built a great community here on WC and I have been proud to participate and contribute as a member. However, when you accept a position of leadership (such as my moderator position) that carries with it the responsibility to meet the needs of the group you are attempting to lead. Obviously, I failed to meet someones metric for performance as moderator in the chats. Whether I agree with this assessment or not is irrelevant, perception (whether right or wrong) is reality these days. My resignation was solely designed to protect you and the greater WC community...
Thanks for your kind words. My adopted mum was one of the finest people I have ever met. She is in a better place now and I keep trying to focus on that...
I really enjoyed moderating the chats and I hoped that we could build them into a much more valuable resource for WC members. I was working on lots of plans, including some of the ones you mentioned, as well as others, to bring more value and interest to the chats. In the short time I moderated the chats, I made many new friends here on WC. For me, that was one of the high points of my time in the moderators chair. If I can ever help you, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!
Thanks for your comments... It seems that no matter what you do, someone will take issue with it. In the end, we all loose as a result of such practices. Take care and all the best to you and yours!
>>Sure hope whoever chose to take a percieved problem up with this >site's owner doesn't wander over to rec.woodworking unless >he/she/they come wearing a Nomex suit
Good Lord, isn't that the truth. Petulant whining, know it alls, bad behavior... not well tolerated at all in an UNMODERATED atmoshpere. Everything has to be done online, in front of everyone else, so everyone knows who said what about one another. No running to daddy or passing an anonymous note to the teacher.
It is an odd place to be; you express your thoughts publicly, and you are forced to stand behind what you say.
Thanks for your comments... I always looked forward to seeing you at the chats... Thanks for your contributions! Take care and all the best to you and yours!