Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Posts

Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#1

Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

I have gotten numerous emails from members asking me why I resigned as the Turning Chat Moderator and why I haven't been on the board lately. I really enjoyed moderating the turning chats, but I always said that if anyone ever thought I was not doing a good job, I would resign. Ellis sent me an email and said that some folks had mentioned in emails to him that I was "over-promoting" myself in the chats and he asked me to tone this down in future chats.

I was really surprised at these comments, because I always took great pains to be as benign as possible in the chats. When I first started, I tried not to mention anything about my studio work, but then I kept getting folks asking me about what I did, how much I charged, etc... I started answering these questions and apparently, some were offended by me discussing anything at all about my studio work in the chats.

I'm not sure how I can answer a question without giving my personal experience though... Since I felt that Ellis was stuck in the middle between unhappy chat participants and myself, I decided the best course of action would be to resign, to prevent any potential negative impact on WC. So I sent Ellis my resignation and explained why I was resigning.

I'm still puzzled by the comments to Ellis, as I can recall no such "over-promotion" of myself, or my studio in the chats. Nor did I ever intentionally attempt such a thing... Ellis never gave me any specific examples, so I'm still clueless as to how my moderator comments could be construed as "self promotion."

Perception is reality these days, so if that's what some perceived, then I sincerely apologize to the members of WC. As for not posting on the board recently, My adopted mum passed away recently and it has been difficult to maintain my work schedule and my participation on the various Internet boards that I frequent.

In addition, I had been getting strange error messages on the posting screen that prevented me from posting. I sent an email to Ellis about this and he said there was some information on the Internet about this particular error code (Webformboundarykit with a bunch of numbers and letters is in the name box on the posting screen and the password is mangled?). I still get the error code at times and when I do, it will not allow me to post anything. I still have some work to do on that I guess.

As for not posting pictures of my work, my website has tons of photos of my work. Since I turn for a living, I simply do not have the time to post as many photos of my work, or protocols as some would like. While hobby turners can easily accomplish this, many of the professional turners I know rarely post photos of their work on boards like these. I tried to accomadate requests, but I could not possibly post everything that was requested.

With my production studio work, my website, my newsletter and all of the other supplemental things that support these activities, there simply is not enough time in the day to take all of the photos that everyone would like to see. I wish there was, but this is not the case. Maybe when I'm retired I will have that kind of time, but when you run a production studio, you have production orders that have to be filled, or the business goes elsewhere. This is not right or wrong, it's just business.

I would like to say that I'm not upset at anyone at WC and I sincerely appreciated my time as moderator in the Turning Chats. I simply felt that resigning as moderator was the best option to prevent any negative impact on Ellis and the greater WC community. I do intend to continue my participation on the board, so I'll see you there... Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#2

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

robo hippy

>Steve,

I think you are the best chat group minitor there has been on this site since I first found it. I am not able to join because it is just at the wrong time for me. I loved being able to read what went on. I never noticed anything that seemed out of place to me. I have been wondering where you have been, and how you even managed to find the time to moderate the group.

thanks

Reed Gray

aka robo hippy

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#3

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

john lucas

>I agree with Robbo Hippy. I think you were the best. It's hard for me to be here on Wednesdays but I really wanted to join the chat's when you were moderator. I am truely amazed that some were upset by the way you handled things.

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#4

JL

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

JL

>Speaking as someone who only attended the Turning Chats upon occasion - I never felt you were promoting yourself at anytime.

I do miss your moderating the Chats - you did a good job of "herding cats" :). I also miss someone selecting (and enforcing) a particular topic.

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#5

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Lan Brady

>Steve,

You did a good job.

Herding cats is the most accurate description of a moderator.

It was great having topics.

I hope you can return some day.

Lan

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#6

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Cyril Griesbach

>Steve,

While I did not participate in the chats I always enjoyed reading the log you posted. I, too, find it hard to believe the comments that were made and believe they're groundless but I'll look forward to your continued participation.

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#7

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Chris LaPine

>Steve,

I concur with the rest of the gang. I thoroughly enjoyed the moderation and more importantly the ability to gain some insight from your experiences. It certainly helped me in improving my skills and taking on new challenges.

Chris

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#8

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>Steve,

I agree with the rest. I thought you did a great job and made the chat the most educational chats that I know of. Very good topics also.

Gary

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#9

Thanks Steve

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Glad to hear you're OK and sorry about your loss. I didn't participate in the chats all that much, with a dialup connection it can be difficult. But I always checked out the logs afterwards, and found them to be very interesting and informative.

About that Webformboundarykit thing, it's connected with using Safari web browser. Do a google search for that phrase and you should find a solution--I don't use Safari so from me, a solution would be to use Firefox but I think the problem only arises in a certain version of the browser, and upgrading takes care of it. Or was it downgrading? One or the other... :)

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#10

Unfounded

Joe Pack

>Steve, the complaints were unfounded. Any mention of your professional work was either as an explanation of how your learning and skills have progressed or as part of a response to a question. It is unfortunate that the person or persons who had a concern did not share that concern directly with you first. I think they would have found you to be a reasonable person, willing to listen to their concerns and address them in a gentlemanly manner.

While I was not an active participant very often, I appreciated being able to "lurk and learn." I thank you for your willingness to take over a thankless job. I'm sorry you felt it necessary to resign, but, given the circumstances and the terrible hourly rate of pay a volunteer receives, I don't blame you. I do hope you continue to participate. Your insight and input are much appreciated.

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#11

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Ralph

>Sigh.....

The only reason I participated in the Chat's, was because someone of your caliber was moderating them.

The only reason I read the logs, was because someone of your caliber was moderating them.

Most of us are not even close to the level of someone like you, (or Reed, or Malcolm, or Bill, or the other top-level Pro's that post to the forums).

Passing up any time to get group instruction from someone of that level is not an opportunity to pass up.

Or why I subscribe to your newsletter.

Yes I think the situation is unfounded.

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#12

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Ron McKinley

>I've never been on the chat board. Out here on the Left Coast by the time I remember it it's already over!

Sorry to hear of your loss and sorry to hear you're no longer moderating the chats. I look forward every month to your newsletter and keep a file of them. Hope you will continue to post as you have time...Ron

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#13

What a terrible shame

Robert W - aka nailshooter

>Well, it had to happen. When someone with Steve's talent and motivation steps into the arena in full view of everyone with confidence self assurance, it will irk someone. Maybe more than one someone(s0>

What an incredible loss of this huge talent to this forum. He took time out of his day to moderate the chat when he could have been out making money. He willingly and freely shared his experiences and talents with others, some of whom could barely stay on topic.

And then to find out someone went and complained to Ellis about his skills and intent as a moderator? Did anyone contact Steve or talk to him about this or was it just a lot easier to go whine to Ellis? How small a person it has to be to complain behind Steve's back. I am wondering if the person(s) that complained participated in the actual chat, or just read the logs and complained about them after reading...

Being familiar with Steve and his work habits from other venues over the years, I am surprised that he actually took the time away from his own work to do it to begin with. But the internet brings out the best as well as the worst in people. Sadly, when it is the worst, nasty things can easily be said and done without any responsibility for those actions through anonyminity of internet.

For those who criticized Steve, shame on you. I am hoping that you will pick up the flag and take on the moderators job to show all of us how it is to be done properly. Please don't wait until there is another moderator and run to Ellis again when they say something you don't like.

Robert

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#14

Bill Blasic

Re: What a terrible shame

Bill Blasic

>Isn't it always like this? The few ruin it for the many!!!

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#15

The New America

Ken George

>Our country is now ruled by the minority. It's happening everywhere not only in government and politics but in our schools, churchs, businesses even here at WoodCentral. It is truly sad!

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#16

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello Reed,

Thanks so much for your comments... I think every chat that I moderated was logged, save the first one or two maybe. As for how I found the time to moderate the chats, I made the time. My schedule is so full that it's hard to find even a couple of minutes of free time, but I always managed to rearrange my schedule to moderate the chat - except for when I was in Hawaii last year. The time difference and our activities made moderating the chat impossible, however, Ron graciously agreed to step in and host for me until I could return. Thanks again for your kind words and If I can ever help you, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#17

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello John,

Thanks for your very kind words... I always appreciated your attendance at the chats when you were able to attend. I know how hard it is to juggle your schedule to do everything you want to do. You are a tremendous resource for all of us here at WC!

As a side note, you have been most helpful to me over the years with several photography questions (I'm still trying to learn Photoshop!) and I sincerely thank you for your counsel and assistance. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#18

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello JL,

Thanks for your comments. The reference to "herding cats" was a hoot! :-) Having grown up around cats all my life, this produced an instant visual image for me. I always enjoyed my duties as moderator of the Turning chats and I tried to do the best job I could. Thanks again and as always, if I can ever help you, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and best wishes!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#19

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello Cryil,

Thanks for your kind words. I'll still be around on the main board and I'll try to stop into the chats whenever I can. I'm spearheading the formation of a new AAW club in the North Houston/Woodlands, Texas area (Lone Star Woodturners Association), so my schedule will be jam up and jelly tight in the near future. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#20

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello Lan,

Thanks for your kind words... I loved the reference to "herding cats"... Having grown up around cats my entire life, your post produced an instant visual image for me. :-) I really enjoyed my time as moderator for the Turning Chats and I always tried to do the best job I could. Take care and best wishes to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#21

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello Chris,

Thanks for your comments... I hope that I was able to help or encourage you in some way. If I can ever help you in the future, please do not hesitate to contact me. Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#22

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

Steve Russell

>Hello Gary,

Thanks for your kind words... Coming up with interesting topics was difficult at times. I got lots of great ideas from some of the participants and I came up with a few on my own. Most of the chats were well attended and interest in the chats was steadily increasing, so we must have been on the right track. Thanks again and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#23

Re: Thanks Steve

Steve Russell

>Hello Ken,

Thanks for your kind words of support... My adopted mum passed away from complications with Alzheimer's disease. The last three years of her life she was bedridden, unable to speak and without any memory of her loved ones. She's in a better place now, so we are all trying to focus on that...

I do use Safari to browse the web, so I will have to keep looking into why I keep getting the error. It happens sporadically and at other times, every time I come on WC. I'm using the latest version of Safari, but maybe I need to downgrade? What's really weird is I do not have this problem on any internet site or forum, except here on WC. Maybe it's a combination of Safari and the program used here on WC? Thanks again and all the best to you and yours!

P.S. AAW's newest club (Lone Star Woodturners) will soon be official... I'm spearheading the effort to start a new chapter in the North Houston/Woodlands, Texas area. We are having a formation meeting later this month... :-)

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#24

Re: Unfounded

Steve Russell

>Hello Joe,

Thanks so much for your kind words of support... I always felt that I received more than I gave in the chats and I tried very hard to do a good job as moderator. When I agreed to moderate the chats, I had no prior experience moderating, but I had the desire to pitch in and try my best. Participation in the chats was steadily increasing, we were covering good, relevant topics, new members were attending and I thought we were building something that would be a valuable benefit for WC members... Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Why I Resigned As The Turning Chat Moderator

#25

Steven Antonucci

No good deed goes unpunished.

steve antonucci

>Our loss, Steven. No one can blame you.

Be well in whatever you choose to do.

Steven