John Lucas - Hunter swan neck report?
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>Were you not test driving a swan neck with the Hunter cutter? How about a report? Will they become available? Or is this another metal working DYI project?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
John Lucas - Hunter swan neck report?
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>Were you not test driving a swan neck with the Hunter cutter? How about a report? Will they become available? Or is this another metal working DYI project?
Re: John Lucas - Hunter swan neck report?
john lucas
>Carol If you mean a John Jordan curved tool with a Hunter tip I'm going to work on that today. I already have a curved bar with the tip straight in but I wanted the same bar with the tip mounted at 45 degrees or so for reaching under shoulder on hollow vessels with really flat tops.
I believe the Swan Neck is a sorby tool and I have one of those but I'm not sure how a Hunter could be adapted to that. I'll look at that today also. I had laid today aside to work on an article about Hunter tools. Of course as things usually go something will come up and it will take me 3 days instead of 1. It should be fun however. I'm glad you reminded me of the swan neck tool. It is possible I could mount a #1 tool in a larger bar and drill and tap it to fit the swan neck tool.
I know Mike is working on several possibilities. He's been gathering information on possible tools from several people so we'll have to wait and see what comes out.
Re: John Lucas - Hunter swan neck report?
Mike Stafford
>Carol, I have been working with Mike Hunter on developing a swan neck tool for several months now. We have tested a number of different prototypes. At long last we have one we feel is ready for "beta" testing. This Hunter swan neck has the cutter mounted at a 45 degree side and 5 degree front tilt. It cuts like crazy and leaves a surface nearly polished if your tool control is good. None of the Hunter swan necks I have tested are for bulk removal of wood although if you are patient you can use them for that purpose. Rather I find them to be an excellent choice for final shaping and smoothing. I do the bulk removal of wood with a gouge.
On some of my boxes with undercut rims I used to have a terrible time with tearout from using a scraper on the underside of the upper curve of the box on the inside. I have been using the Hunter swan neck and have just about eliminated this problem. Where I used to start sanding at 80 or 100 to eliminate the tearout I can now start at 220 or higher sometimes dependent on how well I control the tool.
There is a learning curve associated with these tools. You have to become accustomed to the feel of the cut. This is a matter of rotating the tool so that the angle of presentation places the cutter in a cutting orientation not a scraping mode. If you are scraping with the Hunter tool you are not using it properly as it is cutter. I have been practicing on scrap hardwoods and simple forms before I moved on to more expensive woods in more difficult forms. I also have found out that turning at higher speeds yields a smoother cut particularly in dense hardwoods. The cut with this tool in dense exotics like rosewood, cocobolo, bocote, etc. is almost a polished surface. If I am able to control the tool properly I can peel off shavings that are onion skin thin. The more I use it and practice the better I like it. Almost every box I have turned in the last 4 months has been hollowed/finished in whole or in part with a Hunter Tool. I use the straight tool now in place of my asymmetric scraper on boxes with curved internal forms and the swan neck for any boxes with undercuts.
Re: Thanks Mike and John
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>I tried the straight Hunter at Indy Fest with John. I ordered one as soon as I got home. It didn't take long to pile up onion skin shavings on top of my hands. I love the thing!
Now when can I get a swan neck version??? I found I like to do a little under cut for bowls and working up to hollow forms. And then there is my primary goal - boxes!
Truth be told, they're the reason I got a lathe. They fascinate me to no end. I am busy collecting wood for them - thanks, guys! I am going to glue up common wood to practice forms and such. Then I will give a more special wood a go.
Re: Thanks Mike and John
john lucas
>Carol What kind of undercut are you talking about on bowls? Do you mean where the rim starts to come over toward the inside? I've been able to do an awful lot of different shapes with the #4 cutter in the straight bar.
Also when I think of a swan neck I thing of a bar with a long curve. That's what I would use on a larger hollow form but on boxes and small hollow forms and ornaments just a slightly offset cutter is all that I need. Where you thinking of the larger ones or just a small bar?
The first one I built has been the best so far for this purpose but producing that shape would probably require stamping out a few thousand to make them affordable. They could probably be made in small quanitity on an EDM machine but that would be slow and probably expensive.
Pictures of some swan neck Hunter tools...
Mike Stafford
>Here are some pictures of the Hunter tools I have been working with....
Unfortunately I don't have a picture of the latest version where the cutter is mounted at a 45 degree angle to the shaft and tilted downward 5 degrees as well. That is a cutting machine.
Re: Pictures of some swan neck Hunter tools...
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>John: Not necessary long and strong, just something that can get under a small rim.
Mike: That's it! Which one is your favorite? And when (and where) can a person get one?
I have a design in mind...
Re: Pictures of some swan neck Hunter tools...
Mike Stafford
>Carol, none of these are currently available. Mike Hunter is making up a batch of the newest version for testing by some other turners. I don't know how long after that it will be before they will be available for sale.
If Mike Hunter sees this he may be able to shed some light on availability.
Re: John Lucas - Hunter swan neck report?
Keith I E. Tenn
>I just got my #4 Hunter yesterday and the paperwork that came with it showed a #1 cutter mounted on a 1/4" half round that should fit the Sorby swan neck. I thought about ordering one but they don't have it on their web site yet. Love the #4 already!
Re: Pictures of some swan neck Hunter tools...
Paul Zerjay
>Hey Mike, how does a guy become one of those tester turners?
"Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
Mike Stafford
>Paul, my understanding is that Mike Hunter has a list of subscribers that have signed up to receive e-mails from his web site. He is going to contact them about whether they wish to test one of these tools. It is also my understanding that he will expect the tool to be returned after testing so he can evaluate the cutter wear and learn if the angle at which it is mounted is correct.
Re: "Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
Paul Zerjay
>I'll bet that a mighty long list!!
Re: "Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
Mike Hunter
>I want to extend my appreciation to both Mike Stafford and John Lucas. Both have provided input into these "S" tools or swan neck tool.
Yesterday an email was sent out via the web site as before introducing these tools to the market, I would like to get feedback from various skill level turners. I have received many replies and will sent out some tools in the near future. Currently there are only few tools available.
For now, the more important task is that I have knee replacement surgery scheduled tomorrow morning and will put this project on hold for a couple of weeks.
Does anyone have any name suggestions to call this new tool?
OT: What;s with the....
Steven Kubien
>...knee injuries to turners? (see Mike Rubes post up above). I've ruined mine doing jodo. What''s your story Mike?
Steve Kubien
Rollerblading belongs to a younger generation
Mike Hunter
>
Re: "Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
Roger in MO
>Moke, best wishes for a quick recovery. I've had my replacement for over 12 years and it is great. Had a hip replaced last March and it is also great. Roger
Re: "Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
Carol - now in NC Nebraska
>Mike, your surgery makes it to my personal prayer list. And I truly hope a couple of weeks is all you need. But don't be surprised if total functionality takes a wee bit longer. :)
I have no name suggestions, and I don't do enough turning (yet) to merit being a beta tester. Any estimate when it will be available for us rookie types?
Well, maybe one name suggestion - the Hunter S. You know, "S" for swan or sexy, depending on the curve. :)
Re: "Beta testing" Hunter Tools...
john lucas
>Mike Best of luck on the surgery. I tried rollerblading. I'm glad I borrowed the skates because nothing I've ever done hurt my knees more, even ice skating. I will stick to bicycling while my knees only hurt a little.
I've been working on some new tools today both will hold the Hunter #1 square tool. I modified a version of a curved John Jordan tool and mounted the cutter bar at about 45 degrees (I'll have to measure I did it by eye). This should allow me to reach the inside of some vessels I've tried that have an almost flat top.
The other tool was just a redo of the 3/4" bar that holds the Jamieson style rotating disc straight out. I didn't do a very good job making the first one. My skills and my tooling have improved since then.
Hunter "Bent Knee Cutters"....
Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.
>Sorry, the idea sort of came to me......
Nancy and I both got a nice dose of road rash on our rumps from rollerblading with the kids a long time ago. I then resorted to having one of my youing engineer rollerblading colleagues teach my kids and me how to rollerblade. End result for me was higher speed crashes.
That's for sure, but
Carole Valentine
>Save the wheels - they are good for making bowl and spindle steadies. Good luck with your surgery, Mike.
Re: DYI: Do Yourself In. :))
Allen Neighbors
>