>I made my first attempts at turning bowls over the past week. I start by fixing a blank to a face plate and turning the outside and bottom. Turning the outside is no problem. It's when I turn the inside that disaster strikes. The one thing I can identify is that I am probably taking too heavy of a cut, leading to a catch, and I need to be a little more patient.
But the factor that I am not sure of is the method that I am using to hold the bowl when I reverse the blank to start working on the inside of the bowl. I was taught to cut a recess with a dovetail edge on the bottom of the bowl, and then mount the blank on a chuck with expanding jaws. I'm not sure if this is ideal, as when I started looking on the web for ways to mount the bottom side of the bowl, all I found were methods describing turning a tenon on the bottom of the bowl, and mounting the blank on a chuck in compression mode.
The one advantage I see with using the tenon method is that if the bowl dismounts, it still may be salvageable. It also may be a stronger way of holding the bowl, but I'm not sure about that.
When my bowls have gone orbital, the wall of the bottom recess blows out, and I haven't figured out a way to be able to remount the blank. I can't do it from the bottom because of the blowout, and I can't remount the top since I already have hollowed out the inside, so there's no place for a faceplate.
>Can the bottom be trued up using a jamb chuck and the tailstock? If so, you may be able to attach using a glue block. I normally use the tenon and compression method. Haven't tried the recess, yet. Good luck.
>I tried the expansion mode twice and then switched to compression. I'm might be completely off base but I think one needs to be experienced and in control to keep from getting the catches that orbit the bowls when using the expansion.
I highly recommend Bill Grumbine's video "Turned Bowls Made Easy". In the meantime using a jam chuck and adding a glue block is probably the way to go.
>I've used both methods and, by far, compression holds much more securely. With expansion, even a tiny catch can bugger up the alignment and set you up for a big catch. I would also suggest that you invest in a large set of Cole jaws for your chuck. If you had them now you could easily reverse the bowl and recut the bottom. Also once you finish the inside of a bowl it is really nice to be able to reverse the bowl and finish turn the bottom.
I use a recess often. If you are orienting your bowl side grain, be sure to leave enough meat outside the recess to support the pressure. Don't expand the jaws too agressively and take light cuts untill you get the hang of bowl turning. Also be sure the jaws have good crisp true edges, if they are rounded and nicked from use they won't hold as well. A final tip, make sure that your recess is flat where the jaws contact the wood. The face of the jaws is almost as important as the sides in holding.
>.....will take you far in turning Wilbur. The tenon for chuck compression mounting is the secure method vs. breaking the foot edge with expansion, so you are on the right path. And slowing down to make a more controlled cut on the inside as well as elsewhere is a good practice, especially during the learning phases of turning, which BTW never stops!
>I have never liked the expansion mode myself and really don't use it anymore. Turn a tenon just a bit larger than the diameter of your jaws when fully closed. Make sure you have a nice square edge for the jaws of the chuck to seat up against on the blank itself. Turn the tenon only about 3/8-1/2 inch or so in length so the tenon doesn't bottom out and wobble before the blank seats up against the chuck. Hope this helps
>I am not primarily a bowl turner, so take this with a grain (or two) of salt.
When I have turned bowls with a recess in the base, I typically lost a few bowls. When I turned them with a tenon and the chuck in compression, I didn't lose any. The compression method is probably "stronger" and you do have a greater amount of wood to "grip" as opposed to the expansion method where a lot of force is concentrated on a smaller amount of material. Just my $0.02.
>I also use the expansion mode most of the time. Don't over-expand the jaws and make sure both the sides and the bottom of the dovetail are flat and smooth.
I've used both modes and lost bowls in both modes. Practice, patience and more practice.
>Wilbur, I too orbited a few, using the recess for the chuck jaws. I have a small Nova Chuck that uses the Tommy bars (a midi?) and I thought it might be that he chuck was a little flimsy. Also, if you do not leave a substantial rim around the recess and you get a catch, the rim rips off as you have described. I know many people here use the recess for the chuck, but I found it unreliable and for me, dangerous. I seldom use it.
I often start with the blank mounted between centers and what will be the bottom of the bowl toward the tailstock. I tune up the blank and if I need to, shift the position of the centers until I have the shape I want. I use a tenon on the bottom and flip the blank to mount it in the chuck in the compression mode. My jaws are about 3/8" deep and I try to make the chuck foot about a 1/4" and I have a flat surface or shoulder on the bottom of the bowl to bear again the faces of the chuck jaws. (This is the surface the chuck jaws would rest on the table if you put your chuck down, jaws down.) Then I turn out the inside of the bowl. I usually run the lathe for a minute or two and take several light passes and then stop and tighten the chuck one more time. You probably want to use the largest jaws you can and they get a better grip if the tenon allows the jaws to nearly close to their smallest dimension.
Once you have turned the inside and have the outside like you want it, you can reverse chuck the bowl to finish the bottom. There are at least ten different ways to reverse chuck. John Lucas has a link to a post of his that shows many different ways. A couple of simple ones are to turn a scrap the will fit inside your bowl and use it as a "jamb chuck" You can put a piece of carpet pad on it or tape to provide a little friction and to protect the inside of the bowl. Another way is to use a disk mounted on the chuck or a faceplate and just press the bowl against that. This is why I suggested putting the blank on the lathe with the base of the bowl toward the tailstock. If you left the tail center mark on the bottom, its there for you to use to recenter the bowl when you fix the bottom. Use gentle pressure from the TS and light cuts. You can sand and completely finish everything except the very small piece under the tail center. You can nip that off by hand with a knife or chisel and hand sand that little spot. (I use a small sanding disk in my drill press for this.)
A couple of tips. Figure out where you want the bottom of the bowl to be in relation to the chuck jaws. I have used a square to mark the position of the face of the jaws on the ways of my lathe with a black marker. I can then use the square to mark the rim of the bowl down onto the ways. (I actually have a piece of blue tape on the side of the ways for this.) Then its simple to measure from the rim to the base, and lets say that's four inches and you want the bottom of the bowl to be 1/2" thick, you cut out the inside of the bowl to 3 1/2" and you know there is enough wood left to make the base.
Sometimes the bottom of my bowl is inside the chuck foot or tenon. That's OK too, you just turn that part after to reverse the bowl.
Sometimes my blank is thin and I don't want to waste wood on a chuck foot or tenon. Use a glue block. Glue it on with yellow glue and wait an hour or more (overnight makes me feel better) and chuck the glue block and then turn it off later when you "fix" the bottom of the bowl.
A turner I know uses his drill press to "set" the depth of the bowl. He sets his DP to drill to what ever he wants to leave in the bottom and then drills a hole in the center of the blank. The stop On the DP Stops the bit at, say, a half inch up from the table. Then, when he has cleared the inside down to that depth, he knows to stop.
There are as many ways to do this as there are people doing it and there is something to be learned from all of us.
>This is an amazing place, When I started typing there were no responses. Congratulations to everyone for being so responsive.
Wilbur, On that chuck foot or tenon. I cut Ming with my skew, sue as a scraper. I that the long side of the blade at ninety degrees to the shaft of the lathe to create that flat shoulder for the jaws and at the same time to make the dovetail for the inner surface of the jaws. The "trick" here is for the angles to match nicely. Think of the jaws as "teeth". You don't want the teeth to "bite" the tenon off. The angles should match so that the jaws clamp the tenon without the sharp edges of the teeth actually hitting the tenon and prying it off the piece. (Imagine closing an adjustable wrench onto a bolt as apposed to a set of wire cutters.) So, if anything the fat part of the tenon should contact the jaws first preventing the teeth from digging in. Hope I have made this clear.
>Wilbur, You did not mention the type of wood. Some woods (i.e. spalted, wood that is easy to split, etc.) give more problems. I always use a tenon with spalted woods.
Next is the shape of the dovetail. It should fit the profile of the jaws as much as possible. The dovetail is being pulled apart when the jaws are expanded if top of the dovetail is too small. The jaws has a tenadacy to try and cut the dovetail off the bottom is too small.
You are to be commended that you have already seld-diagnosed that the problem are catches. What type of tool are you using? How close to the cut is your tool rest? Grain direction and direction of the cuts are important. Size of the bowl/platter is also important. Often times I will bring the tail stock up and leave a post in the center of large platters and remove it after I have completed the outer edges.
I start between centers. shape the outside and turn a tennon on the blank. If the wood is a little soft run a layer of thin CA around the basae of the tenno and when it is set re clean the tennon. Be sure the tennon does not touch the bottom of the chuck or you will have allignment problems. Cut the tennon only a little larger than the closed jaws of the chuck. Be sure the outside angle of the tennon matches the inside angle of the jaws. Now finish the outside, turn it around and finish the inside.
If you need to remove the work piece before it is done mark the jaws and the piece so you can rechuck at the same location.
This method will allow you to relay crank down on the tennon.
>If using a recess and if the design allows room, I sometimes leave extra thickness around the base to keep it stronger until I finish hollowing the inside, then go back and thin at the base to finish the outside shape. Some chuck jaws give you more room to work than others.
If the bowl is large enough to provide the room to work, you can also bring up the tailstock to add extra support through a temporary "tower" in the center of the bowl until the bulk of the heavy hollowing is complete.
>I suggest using a recess for dry wood only. Make sure the depth of the dovetail is approx. 5/16" until you get more experience in taking light cuts. The shape of the dovetail needs to match the shape of the jaws of your chuck. The best grip is when the jaws are almost closed and not fully expanded.
When turning green wood, frequently check to make sure the grip is tight on the tenon. The use of a tenon being the preferred method for green wood. And definitely make sure there is a flat surface for the jaws to butt up against when gripping the tenon.
>Thanks for all the suggestions! I have some things I already think will be useful -- primarily making the walls of the recess thicker and making the recess deeper.
Most of all, I have a way to save the bowl blanks that have been bounced around my shop, which is nice. I found the John Lucas article on reverse turning, which should help me salvage the bottom of my bowl satellites.
>If you must cut a dovetail vs. a tenon, try to make the dovetail size as close to the jaw size of the chuck. If you have a 50mm jaw in a 50mm dovetail, there is a full contact patch. If you have the dovetail expand to 100mm, the contact patch is just the high spots on the jaws.
>The recess method of holding bowls is a secure one, perhaps even more secure than the tenon method. But, as you have discovered, it has drawbacks.
First, the recess is not as attractive when the bowl is finished. Normally, the recess is left intact when the bowl is completed. The goal is to have a completed bowl with little or no evidence of how it was chucked in the lathe. With the recess method, it doesn't take a rocket scientist.
Plus, if the recess blows out, it is more difficult to satisfactorily salvage the bowl when there is substantial damage.
With the tenon method, I think the end result is much more attractive. You turn a shallow tenon. Then you turn a base for the bowl. Then, after the bowl is hollowed and sanded, the bowl is reversed and the tenon is turned away almost entirely. This leaves only a small nib that is removed with a chisel by hand off the lathe. Done correctly, this leaves a much more attractive bowl than the recess method. Good luck.
>Wilbur, two problems with a recess...even if your recess is perfect, if your bowl gets a bit thin, the pressure from the chuck splits your bowl blank, and the piece flies off the chuck in pieces. Second, you will have a tendency to turn bowls with a foot that's too large in appearance...the chuck now becomes a design limitation. In compression mode, reverse turn the base, completely removing the tenon...not easy to do with a recess.
>Thanks to all the suggestions to my post about my bowl orbiting experiences. I thought I'd post a picture of what I was able to salvage.
I started with one of the bowls I orbited after a catch, using a dovetail recess on the bottom to work on the inside. I think the main problems were [1] getting a catch, and [2] not enough thickness on the outside of the dovetail recess. The wall of the recess blew out when the bowl launched.
What I did was to make a jam (jamb?) chuck big enough to hold the opening of the bowl, then mounted the bowl with support from the tailstock and a live center. I hadn't completely hollowed the bowl, so there was enough wood at the bottom for me to turn away the walls of the recess, reshape the bottom, and leave a dovetail tenon. I then finished the outside of the bowl, reversed the bowl and mounted it in my 4 jaw chuck in compression mode. I finished the inside, adjusted the jam chuck to fit the new opening of the bowl (I had to do some work on the rim, so the old jam chuck was now too big), and reversed the bowl again. I then used an incredible amount of blue painter's tape to hold the bowl on the jam chuck, and turned away the tenon to make the foot. A little more finishing, and this is what I wound up with:
I think this is honey locust. I used the Liberon Woodturner's polish and wax stick to finish it. The walls are a little uneven, and there's some endgrain tearout, but it's better than being a hunk of round firewood. Besides, I'm cutting myself a little slack since this is only the second bowl I've made. Well, it would have been the third if I didn't orbit another bowl blank before I tried making this one.
Anyway, thanks for all the help. I have one more blank that I want to try to save, but this one might be trickier since I don't have as much wood on the bottom of this one, so I don't know if I will be able to make a tenon. Maybe I'll try making a better dovetail recess.
>Wilbur, glad you are thinking thru the process of holding the bowl to perform the needed/desired operation. After a bit more experience and the input of others it will become second nature to you.
On the question of jam or jamb?? I see a lot of people using these words interchangeably but I don't think they are. A jamb is the vertical side of a door or window or even the top member as well. We jam a bowl, or other item onto a shaped piece of wood called a jam chuck so we can perform secondary operations. Now for the next question - why is it called a chuck when the wood has to be held on by some other means, usually the tail stock?