Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Posts

Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#1

Steven Antonucci

Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

steve antonucci

>I had a chunk of olive burl that I had set aside until I was appropriately inspired. Inspiration struck me yesterday morning, and I set out to make something that was well within my skills.

If you've ever worked with dry climate/desert woods, you know that they are typically very hard and almost always contain wild grain with close growth rings because they grow slowly. In addition, there are often voids and cracks. This piece of olive burl had all of them-and the inspiration to hollow through one of the natural voids seemed too good to pass up.

I had epoxied a waste block tenon on Saturday using some 1 min epoxy. I let it set for an hour or so, and began working on the shape. My original design had a bit of a corny pun intended- and olive turned to an onion/garlic bulb shape. During the rough shaping, I managed to break the epoxy bond with a not paying attention, too tired to be turning mother of all catches. I reglued and called it a day.

The next day, epoxy cured, I remounted and set about the business at hand. Since the void in the top was probably a solid 1.5" across, this would be an easy one to hollow. I would be able to see inside, measure with all of my existing tools, and the wood is built for what I had in mind. For those of you who have never tried thin walled vessels- here's a secret. There are some really hard woods in the world that can be cut ridiculously thin with very little risk of breaking if you are careful. Manzanita burl, desert ironwood, olive... all qualify.

So I spent a couple of hours in front of the lathe, spinning at 800 rpm or so, compressor hose right behind me to blow out the chips every 30 seconds or so. When I was convinced it had it to an honest 1/16" thick throughout, I nervously parted through my tenon. I caught it with my free hand, and grabbed a sharp chisel to pare/scrape off the excess wood/tenon.

I then went through the grits- 120, 180, 220, 320 for another hour until I was 100% sure that I had gotten all of the tool marks. With that cavernous entry hole at the opening, I decided that I needed to sand the mouth of the vessel too. I stopped at 220, figuring that most people wouldn't actually stick their hands to feel the inside.

Finally, I reached for one of my hanging lines for finishing. This is where the begining of the end starts. I have a "large" that I wanted to used, but it was too large, so I went down a size. A coat of Bush Oil went on and the grain and color popped, just like I had hoped. I suspended it next to a siberian elm form that was waiting for its second coat and went about my business. Fifteen minutes later, I went to wipe off the excess. I replaced it on the line, and decided that I wasn't happy with how it was hanging. As I reached up to get it and reposition, it slipped off. Life sometimes happens in slow motion. This wa one of those times. "NOOOOOOOOOO....."

As a means of satisfying my own curiousity about the overall thinness of a piece, you'll often notice that I post size AND weight. This piece was 5.5" tall by 4.5" wide, and weighed in at 2.4 ozs. It was now accelerating under the force of gravity towards my concrete garage floor six feet below. I'd like to think that if I hadn't been reaching for it to take it off at the precise moment it began to fall that I may have been able to catch it. But alas, time came abruptly out of slow motion with a crash on the floor.

As this picture will attest, I have glued it back together. It will never hold the place in my heart that it did before the Great Crash of 2007, but it will not go to its intended destination either (back to the person who sent the wood to me originally...)

Look at it in its shattered former glory of itself and throw me a pity party...

Steven


img

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#2

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

JohnKJordan in East TN

>What I do with such an experience is add it to my Box of Shame. The box is getting full.

JKJ

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#3

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Randy G

>Wow.. that would have been hard to watch. Glad you saved it.

In response to John's comment, They aren't "Box of Shame" they are reminders of learning experiences. :-) At least that's what I tell myself.

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#4

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Ah, the Skills Refinement Scrapbook, I like that better.

I added a finished piece the other day that the final beall buffing wheel rudely but dispassionately snatched from my inattention. Maybe I should just put the box directly under the lathe.

JKJ

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#5

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

eaglesc

>It looks too good to give up on it.

Is it possible to rechuck it?Remember I am not well versed on this subject.

Would it not be possible to "dremel" out the glue joints and add a contrasting mixture off ebony dust and CA? and then re-turn?

If you can't hide it, show it off?

If this is a dumb suggestion forgive me,

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#6

Steven Antonucci

already toying with ideas

steve antonucci

>I'm on the fence about piercing it (a first) or possibly "stitching" it with some copper wire along the crack. Both are none revesable procedures...

Even if I could rechuck it, there isn't enough wood left to recut. It's not going anywhere any time soon...

Thanks for the ideas.

Steve

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#7

Steven Antonucci

Also known as "the future firewood pile"

steve antonucci

>I have a lot of "experience" in that pile already...

Steve

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#8

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Bill McWhirter

>Sorry for the loss.

I doubt that there is one among us who has not learned and relearned and relearned again one very painful truth-

"THE ENEMY OF GOOD IS BETTER."

I would bet that striving for "better" has screwed up more really great pieces than everything else combined.

Just wish I had a better memory.

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#9

Steven Antonucci

The enemy of good is good enough ;-)

steve antonucci

>I wasn't even trying for better. It just fell before I could catch it...

Steve

Who has lost MANY, MANY things to "one more cut"

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#10

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Hey Steve

I would think a build up of thick CA would hide all. If what you have shown is as bad as it gets, No Problemo.

I would be honored to have something like that in my collection.

When I finish I use a board, of an appropriate, on a lazy susan base I spray the bottom and set the piece in small stickers and finish finishing. If you have several to do at a time you can just move the base you used to set it on to a curing location and re start.

Good turning and be safe

Bill

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#11

A design opportunity!

david

>

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#12

Re: already toying with ideas

Randy G

>I watched a demo from _____ ( I just cannot remember his name right now) this summer and he kept saying it's not 1 more cut, it's 2. And you stop before the 2nd one. He figures it's always that last cut that gets you... so figure you have 2 more cuts.

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#13

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Ed Karch

>Now you know why I have a wood floor over the concrete, a carpet over the wood floor and a soft layer of shavings over the carpet. My matress should be as soft. As long as it doesen't suicide on the ways it usually has a soft landing.

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

#14

Re: Ohhh! the agony! (A tale of woe...)

Don in Central Illinois

>That's why I don't sweep any oftner than I do. A nice soft landing.