Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

I don't get it... ...Ellis?

Posts

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#26

Re: Anybody else feel this way? --no

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>if there's no speed benefit to the

>thumbnail versus the full-size image,

>I'd prefer to see the full size image.

After trying it both ways, I prefer to see the thumbnails instead of the full-size pictures, regardless of speed. The reason - it makes scrolling and reading through the messages cleaner and quicker. I do not necessarily look at each picture, especially if it is the second or third time I've visited that thread to read new messages. Even when reading a new message added to the bottom, I may scroll up and down to review some of the other's comments. Having the pictures in thumbnails makes this easier. The extra clicks spent viewing a few photos are balanced by the savings in mousewheel rolls to scroll past thumbnails rather than big pictures.

In addition, using thumbnails solves the problem we saw when someone posted a picture wider than the screen width. In that case, the text of the message was spread in long lines across the picture width, requiring cumbersome left and right scroll bar manipulation to read each line of the message.

The way the thumbnails are implemented is clean and clear as well, with the blue borders that indicate a link as well as the text prompt to remove clue the newcomer.

JKJ

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#27

multiple pictures

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...give the poster the ability to post

>multiple pictures in a message.

I second this motion. Many times it is useful or necessary to put two or more photos in a message. Both existing options to do this have drawbacks.

Posting successive photos in separate messages breaks up the continuity of the thought and allows further fragmentation as people post replies to each of the messages. The second option of putting the photos on a server somewhere and emebedding html code to display them in a message can make that message look great but all is lost if those photos are not maintained on that server - I came across some archived messages that were basically useless because the photos are no longer available. (Some forums, BTW, require all photos be uploaded for that reason.)

Actually, there is a third option for multiple photos that I usually use, but not everyone has the capability to do it easily and it's certainly not quick: make one composite image in Photoshop that contains multiple small photos.

If we could upload even two photos per message, it would help, even if they could not easily be positioned horizontally. (Positioning them across the screen might also get you back into width problems with the Google ads at certain screen resolutions.)

JKJ

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#28

Thank you for asking, Ellis

GaryG in MD

>I appreciate your consideration. I bow to the group consensus, however, to clarify,

most of the responders do not appear to understand what is actually happening and completely missed my point, or responded off topic.

As you pointed out, and many still did not understand, we are not downloading smaller files when the thumbnail is in the process of being displayed. We are downloading the entire large picture file, as always. Only the display is smaller. I continue to not understand why people don't want to see the image that was downloaded. So be it. Yes, I'm still using a 56k modem; yes the photo takes a finite time to load;

yes I want to look at the photo BEFORE I read the text (unlike many of your responders) so I have to wait;

yes, the wait time is exactly the same as it always was;

yes, because the max file size is 80k, even at 56k, the wait is only a few seconds.

The viewing issues may be different in Guestbook format -- I wouldn't know because I prefer, and have always used, "mixed".

I do not like to have to click the thumbnail, for which I had to wait (for the entire image to download) to see it in full size, and then have to click again to make it go away. The majority seem to prefer it the new way. So be it.

Ellis: I agree that you're doing a great job, as always, and handling these needed changes in an extremely professional and fair manner. Keep up the good work. This is still the best-looking of all the woodturning forums I have seen. I hope your future changes do not alter this. Frankly, some of your comments regarding additional changes sound ominous.

...Gary

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#29

Re: Anybody else feel this way?

Carole Valentine

>I like it because it keeps the ads out of the way. The ads being on top of text and pictures was NOT a good thing and I would have had to use an Ad Blocker.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#30

I dislike the thumbnails

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Especially for multiple picture posts, the thumbnails lose their value in a big hurry since it becomes more difficult to read and look at pictures simultaneously. Just let us know what the maximum width of a picture can be to avoid the ads and voila'.

I hadn't noticed the OP's point, but if the only reason for too small pictures is to avoid some ad overlap and not to save download time, it is too weak a reason for the irritaton thumbnails bring.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#31

I do not understand or agree

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>This makes no sense to me: "It gives me a choice as to whether I want to look at the full sized picture or not." So, looking at a postage stamp sized picture which HINTS at a real picture (but saves you no time) is somehow better than simply viewing the real deal the first time? What advantage does it bring? If it saved download time for those with slow connections, I could see some value, but this is more like a surprise party where they all shout surprise without turning on the lights. Isn't it better to get the full impact at once?

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#32

Me too

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>And the problem showed up in Clem's message! Anyone else see this?


img

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#33

Re: I do not understand or agree

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The reason for the thumbnail is so the Google ads on the right could stay where they are and help pay for the site. They were covering up any images that were over a certain size, around 600 pixels width.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#34

Re: Anybody else feel this way?

Carole Valentine

>My screen is perfectly capable of a much higher resolution than 1024x768 but my eyes are not. :) I don't know what the average age of WCers is, but I am betting it's over 55.