Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

I don't get it... ...Ellis?

Posts

I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#1

I don't get it... ...Ellis?

garyg in md

>I just viewed a post with a photo for the first time. The so-called thumbnail did NOT come up quickly -- it took the same time photos always take to load. Then when I clicked on it to expand it to its full size, it appeared instantaneously -- the full file was already downloaded and available. So what's the point of this whole thing??? It makes no sense. If it is going to be more efficient, the thumbnail should be smaller and load instantaneously, and clicking on it should then download a bigger file. This way, you might as well just put the full-sized image on the screen to start with! This is very annoying, and I don't like it at all. It serves no purpose. ...Gary

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#2

Anybody else feel this way?

Ellis Walentine, Host

>We put the thumbnail feature in there because many people didn't like the way that large photos extended under the Google ads on the right side of the screen. All these changes we're implementing here are for the benefit of our visitors. The last thing we want to do is annoy anyone. So far, all the other comments I've heard have been positive. Maybe these people are seeing some benefit that you aren't.

The reason that it takes more time for the thumbnail to appear, by the way, is that the entire photo is downloading to your browser. That is also why the big photo appears instantaneously: it's already loaded. If the photo is large and/or you are on a slow connection, this will take a bit longer than a small photo would, but in no case longer than it would otherwise, without the thumbnail feature.

If the consensus is that the feature is not valuable, we can reconsider it.

Ellis

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#3

Steven Antonucci

I might if I was bandwidth restricted

steve antonucci

>but I'm not.

A good question to ask the audience is "how many of you are still on dial-up?" My guess is that it's relatively low percentages...

BTW- Without the bandwidth constraints, I like the feature. I get a good look from the smaller image, and I can look further if I want. Speed is not an issue on my DSL. I think the balance of content vs. performance is appropriate.

Steve

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#4

Barb Siddiqui

Not I.

Barb Siddiqui

>Perviously, so many people failed to size photos correctly for display, my load time was extreme on many of them put up full size. I'd rather be able to judge what I want to expand for viewing. And the thumbnails all have come up faster than I could before. I like, too, that they are all sized standardly, even if the photo is put up smaller than the thumbnail size. Don't dump on this feature!

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: Anybody else feel this way?

Ric Taylor

>Ellis,

I like the thumbnail format very much. Both the thumbnails and the full-size pics open up instantly for me.

None of the photos on my screen are anywhere close to the ads on the right side of the screen. My guess is the percentage of visitors using dial-up and having older low-resolution screens is probably dropping very quickly.

I think what you have done to the website is a great improvement in a lot of ways.

Ric

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#6

Please keep this feature!!!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It does more than just solve the Google ad problem.

Even more importantly, it also makes the larger photographs viewable without having to scroll it every which way to try and see the entire image.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#7

p.s. I have a cantankerous dial-up connection

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#8

I like the thumbnail option.

Stuart Johnson

>

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#9

Re: Anybody else feel this way?

russ Fairfield

>No.

I just looked at the pictures with both broadband and 56k dial-up, and the time between the "thumbnail" and the enlarged picture was almost instantaneous for both. There is so little difference that I could tell that one was faster or slower than the other. A slower modem might be slower

The loading time for the new site is about the same as the old one on both broadband and dial-up.

Anway, that's how I see it. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#10

Very good solution!

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The javascript popup has got to be the best solution there is. The image is loading in the background while you are reading the post and even with a dialup connection, it's ready to view within 30 seconds with any image that's posted on Woodcentral, since there is a file size limit of, I think, 60 kb here?

Nice going, Ellis and crew, you are doing a fabulous job of attending to and fixing all the things that have been complained about--the image under the google ad thing was the most annoying part in my opinion!

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#11

I like the thumbnails.

Steven Kubien

>I like that when I look at a full-sized picture there are no ads overlapping and get in the way. Please keep this feature.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#12

I didn't read all the other posts

Ron in Drums PA

>So this may have been said

Only the thumbnail is downloaded, the full size image is downloaded only when you click on the image. The reason is is so fast is because only the image is sent and not any webpage info.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#13

Not I

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#14

Ellis, FYI

Barry Irby

>I like the setup better now. The thumbnails are working well for me and I like how the board is posting the messages. I did not like the UBB if that is what was bringing the messages constantly to the top. Thanks for those Tweaks. It seems much faster now also.

FYI Occasionally I will be working my way down through the list of responders under a post, clicking on them in order and for no apparent reason the thread goes away and I have only the one sub message, even if I click on View Thread. I have to click on return to Index and start over. Just about once in ten or twenty. I'm using IE 6 I think in Windows XP on a cable modem. Don't know enough more to help you.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#15

Re: Thumbs UP for thumbnails!

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Sorry. Couldn't resist. :) But I do prefer the thumbnails.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#16

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

Craig Daymon

>I don't notice any speed improvement and I now have to click a second time to get the full image. If, as stated, the full image is downloaded and only a thumbnail is displayed, I cannot see the efficiency.

If, on the other hand, Wood Central is creating a thumbnail image of any uploaded image and displaying that until the larger image is requested, I can understand it being more efficient and placing the performance impact on those who wish to see the larger image. Otherwise, I can't see that you are gaining anything.

-Craig

P.S. I write software that deals with houndreds of thousands of thumbnail images a day (cancer cells) and an operator having to make an additional click on every thumbnail would be a disaster.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#17

Reconsider the implementation, not the idea

Craig Daymon

>Please see my other message on this subject for more info.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#18

Brian McKearney

Re: Anybody else feel this way?

Brian McKearney

>My opinion - if there's no speed benefit to the thumbnail versus the full-size image, I'd prefer to see the full size image. Otherwise it takes one more click to view images, which is one of the features that I've always liked about this forum versus others.

Any way to make the thumbnails versus full-size images optional as a preference?

Brian

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#19

One More Click?...Is That a Serious Complaint?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#20

I like the thumbnails...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>It gives me a choice as to whether I want to look at the full sized picture or not.

Something to consider if this format is finalized; give the poster the ability to post multiple pictures in a message. Using thumbnails it would be possible to fit 3 or 4 pictures in a row. that would address the only issue I have ever had with Wood Central.

keithz

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#21

And another thing...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>With the script Ellis is using, you just have to click on the full-sized image for it to go away. I use the same script on my site and I have had nothing but positive feedback on it. Most comments are, cool, or how'd you do that?

keithz

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#22

Re: I'm on Dial-up w/56k Modem...

Allen Neighbors

>The entire website loads as fast as it ever did. The thumbnails are up by the time I read the post, and the pic enlarges instantaneously when I click the thumbnail.

Every response to the thread is opened below the original post, and all I have to do is scroll down to read them. I think that's because I've chosen the guestbook option.

Whatever it is that has done it, this Site has gotten much better than it was... for me, anyway. I like the changes, Ellis. My .02.

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#23

I also get only one message, sometimes.

Clem Wixted

>"FYI Occasionally I will be working my way down through the list of responders under a post, clicking on them in order and for no apparent reason the thread goes away and I have only the one sub message, even if I click on View Thread. I have to click on return to Index and start over. Just about once in ten or twenty. I'm using IE 6 I think in Windows XP on a cable modem."

The same happens to me. Same computer stuff except I have IE-7.

Clem

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#24

I like the thumbnails

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>

Re: I don't get it... ...Ellis?

#25

Traveling: Modem Card on Laptop

Greg Deavers

>Hi Ellis

As a change agent now for over 18 years, I AM ALWAYS FOR SHAKING UP STATUS QUO!

FYI IF YOU NEED IT: In my case, I am online through a modem cell card extensively through the week. I was accessing the new setup last week, but IT SHUT DOWN access on my home computer this weekend (Fri, Sat & Sun), not sure why, but I could access other sites, just NOT WC.

I am now on my laptop/Modem 3G-Card and I am having to wait for the POSTS to open, and then WAIT to look at the picture, then WAIT to close the pic, and then WAIT some more to call up the next message. My Group Post (all posts open) is gone, and I am now not sure how to view all so I don't have to wait for each one.

MAKE CHANGE - MOVE FORWARD!!!! Hope this helps......

Greg