Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Bowl Gouge

Posts

Bowl Gouge

#1

Bowl Gouge

Julie

>Can't seem to get it right.

I have watched a couple of bowl turning videos and read a couple of books, tried and tired and keep catching the wood. YIKES !!!

then I run back to my trusty ole round nose scraper and finish the job even though it take forever.

and hint or suggestions to make it work better would be fantastic

thanks

Re: Bowl Gouge

#2

Re: Julie- you need to take a lesson from....

Jamie Donaldson

>...a skilled turner, maybe someone in your area. Have you tried to access a turning club in the vicinity?

Re: Bowl Gouge

#3

Re: Bowl Gouge

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Maybe you could describe the circumstance of the catch. Do you have trouble on the outside or the inside of the bowl? (I'm guessing the inside since that's where I used to have more trouble) While rough hollowing or while refining? At the rim, the foot, or everywhere? Are the "wings" of your gouge ground back or do they come to a sharp corner?

Re: Bowl Gouge

#4

Re: Bowl Gouge

Julie

>I used to go the the meeting at our woodcraft store but they didnt do any turning during the meetings. I was also only turning Pens then.

Didnt really find anyone who seemed interested in mentoring.

I am going to take a turning green wood bowls class at woodcraft in Feb.

Seem to catch when I pick it up. More so inside the bowl.

Watched Del Stubbs and Mike Mahoney and they start at the bottom of the bowl when it is first put on the lathe and go at it. The make it look sooo easy.

Im only running at 500 RPM.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#5

Re: Bowl Gouge

john lucas

>Julie Mike Mahoney starts in the middle of the bowl to waste away the wood. The way he cuts the middle is actually cutting down hill with the grain at that point. Once he cuts away some of the middle he goes back to cutting from the lip down toward the inside. This can be confusing for the beginner.

What is the shape or your bowls. I find my students have the most problems when their bowls have sides that converge sharply into the bottom. This takes a skilled turner to keep riding the bevel. Start with a bowl that has a long gentle curve from the lip to the bottom and is somewhat shallow.

I would also suggest finding someone to do some hands on. It is so much easier to learn when someone can watch what your doing.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#6

Re: John, you might explain...

Allen Neighbors

>to her the difference the nose bevel angle makes on the inside of a bowl. I can't, because I don't know enough about it.

I still don't have a gouge ground so that I can hollow out a bowl's inside, because I don't know how to grind the bevel... but I know the angle of it makes a difference, because I can't hollow deeper than about 2" with my gouges.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#7

Re: Bowl Gouge

Dinyar Chavda

>Julie:

I don't know how you have ground your bowl gouge, but if it is in the fluted swept-back position, the best video to learn from (in my opinion) is the old David Ellsworth Bowl Turning video. What it lacks in production value, it more than makes up in information. You may be able to rent it from Woodcraft.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#8

Bowl Gouge - See & Do

Jim Swank

>You need a hands-on lesson. It's all about entry and riding the bevel. You need to be able to see it done, then immediately try it yourself, and back and forth to re-inforce. To me, it's as much feel as look. If you learn the same way I do, you have a long hard road ahead of you without some patient hands-on time. You don't need a highly accomplished well known turner to teach you this, just someone who can use a bowl gouge to through a stream of shavings.

Go back to your Woodcraft meeting, and ask around.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#9

Re: Bowl Gouge

Raymond Overman in SC

>Julie,

Where are you? As other's said, hands on mentoring would be worth it's weight in goal for this problem since there are so many variables that would take forever to describe on this forum. I would suggest starting out with the AAW Resource book. If you're not a member, I'm sure someone here would be glad to help you find someone in your area that would be interested in helping.

If you're anywhere around Charlotte, NC I've got a dozen resources for you including me, for what good that would do you.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#10

Re: Bowl Gouge

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Julie

Where are you located? Most, if not all turning clubs have a list of mentors. They usually list specific skill sets they are willing to teach. You can find a list of AAW affiliated clubs on their web site.

Terry

Re: Bowl Gouge

#11

Re: Bowl Gouge - be sure it is sharp

Steve In NC

>Julie

In addition to the above advice, the biggest change for me was when I learned to properly sharpen my tools. The tool should slice easily through the wood. If you are pushing a dull tool you have less control. Also, try using green wood.

Hang in there. One day the wood will sing and the chips will fly.

Steve

Re: Bowl Gouge

#12

You don't have to have hands on instruction

Rick Allen

>Hi Julie

500 RPM is slow. Faster is likely going to make the process easier.

The bowl gouge must be sharp. A dull gouge and slow speed is much more likely to result in a catch. A bowl gouge is usually sharpened a couple of times for each bowl turned.

The techniques you see on videos are difficult to replicate if you have no frame of reference. The videos make a good reference to improve your skills but not so good at establishing skills.

There are a lot of woodturners who are self taught. You don't have to have someone show you how to use a bowl gouge. However, hands on training will put you 6 months to a year ahead.

I know several woodturners who use a scraper to turn bowls. They are as quick with a scraper as I am with a bowl gouge. If the scraper is taking you a long time you might want to:

Increase the lathe speed

Sharpen and put a bur on your scraper (a scraper needs to be sharpened a lot more often than a bowl gouge to effectively remove the same amount of wood).

Sharpening: The quickest way to learn the difference between a sharp tool and a "dull" tool is to have two identical sharp tools. Cut with one of the tools until you have some difficulty. Switch to the known sharp tool. If the difficulty goes away then the difficulty was likely caused by a dull tool. If the difficulty remains then the sharpness of the tool was not the issue. In a few weeks of turning you will have a solid feel for when your tools need to be sharpened.

There are many other possible reasons for your difficulty.

Most bowls turned in English speaking countries are turned from wood where the bottom of the bowl represents the bark of the tree. In many non-English speaking countries the bowl is turned from a cross section of the tree. The techniques and tools used are different.

The shape of the bowl contributes to ease or difficulty of turning.

Turning unsupported wood, especially green wood will result in catches and worse. Working the rim area to completion before removing the wood closer to the center of the bowl helps eliminate this issue.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#13

Re: John, you might explain...

john lucas

>Allen That is something that should go in WC articles. I'll work on it this weekend. The bowls shapes that I'm talking about have fairly straight sides that go rather bluntly into the bottom. This transition point is very hard for most people to turn with a bowl gouge. I try to teach beginning students to avoid this shape until they have more experience.

What you are talking about is turning a bowl with a lip that sticks up too far or curves in so that you can't rub the bevel all the way to the bottom with a gouge of a certain shape.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#14

Re: Bowl Gouge

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Julie

Once you get the outside round speed up the lathe. 500 is way to slow. I run the inside at 1000 - 1200 as a general rule. Fast Sharp and Easy touch will lessen the likleyhood of caches. Also do not over strech the tool over the rest as this will cause chater.

Get hands on help and you will be way ahead on your learning. Post where you live on this forum and ask for help. This is a great group and I am almost sure there is a person that will be willing to give you a little help. Take them a nice bottle of wine or something as thanks.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#15

Mike Stafford

Just a few minutes with someone...

Mike Stafford

>can make all the difference in the world as far as success with a bowl gouge. If you can just get someone to give you a 15 minute up close and personal lesson so you can see how to start the cuts and manipulate the tool throughout the various aspects of turning a bowl.

Start small. Turn some small bowls that are less intimidating. When I was first teaching myself to turn with a bowl gouge I turned coasters, lots of coasters. A whirling 4 or 5 inch piece of wood for a coaster is not nearly as intimidating as a large out of balance chunk of wood spinning on the lathe.

Be careful until you build your experience.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#16

Re: Just a few minutes with someone...

Barry Irby

>I agree with Mike and every one else that said get some mentoring.

Since you can present that tool to the wood in every conceiveable angle and some that many of us have not thought of, its hard to describe how to do it. I am somewhat dyslexic or dysgraphic or perhaps just dense and dysfunctional. I took my son to Arrowmount for a class with David Ellsworth. David described how to use the gouge and turned us loose. I completely misunderstood what he meant by "turn the flute up and point it in the direction you want it to go." I had a two handed death grip on the tool, was sweating, and my heart rate was probably around three hundred. It was terrifying, not only for me but for all those nearby. Mortal danger. David came by, tool the tool in one hand, held with his finger tips by the very end of the handle and drove it around my bowl as if it were a sports car. That alone was worth the price of admission.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#17

Re: Actually, I'm talking about...

Allen Neighbors

>the slight-curve transition point between the side and the bottom, and the bottom, itself. I've never been able to do that with a gouge. I can cut the bottom from the center out, and I can cut the side from the top down, but I can't do it all in one pass.

Someone told me that I need a different grind on a bowl gouge to do that. They said it needs to be a much "blunter" (less acute) angle.

I don't know enough about it to even explain it... :( I just know I can't do it without blowing a bowl.

Re: Bowl Gouge

#18

Re: Actually, I'm talking about... *LINK*

DWR

>Allen,

The inside of the bowl is easier to turn (especially on the final pass or two) in one smooth motion, if the grind is not the swept back fingernail type of grind and is not a "V" shape flute but rather the "U" shaped flute. The tip of the traditional bowl gouge is much less acute and the bevel is broader and moves through the transition more smoothly, and allows you to roll the tool easier as you go through the transition area.

I work 90%-95% of my bowls with the swept back grind and have, over time, developed the ability to do the final cuts with a fresh edge and not swapping out the tool for most bowls. However, to eliminate ridges and minimize sanding, changing to the old traditional style grind is the best move. I just picked up a 5/8" P&N bowl gouge for this purpose, as my old Super Flute is now too short for my work, so I converted it to a swept back grind.

The link shows a drawing of the bevel/flute style I am referring to. Tou will have to scroll down to the bottom of the page to see the picture.

Dave


Gouge Picture

Re: Bowl Gouge

#19

Re: Dave, I have a U flute...

Allen Neighbors

>1/2" and 5/8" bowl gouges. But they both have swept back wings.

It looks like the wings on those gouges (on the link you posted) would catch big time! You must cut with the lower part of the bevel?

Re: Bowl Gouge

#20

Bowl Gouge Inside....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Allen, when the bowl gouge first came out in this country in the early eighties, all came with the nose ground straight across like a roughing gouge. Everybody used them that way, making the cuts on the inside of a bowl somewhat difficult. Eventually most everyone ground them in a fingernail grind. The swept back grind came later.

For using a gouge on the inside, either fingernail grind or swept back, try grinding a second bevel, making the cutting bevel shorter and easier to ride as you sweep the tool through that transition to the center. Don't ride it too hard, which will create compression rings. Use the tool with the flute pointing at about 1 or 2 o'clock, and swing the handle to ride the shorter bevel all the way. Some turners who turn a lot of bowls have a gouge for the inside and another for the outside.

Wally

Re: Bowl Gouge

#21

Re: Bowl Gouge

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Julie, I along with everyone else recommend taking a class or getting hands on help.

I suggest that you take a look at the tool grinds library here on WC. Look at the pics of the various grinds to see if the grind on your gouge looks like any of them. Improper grinding can be the cause of catches. Notice that all of them have a nice sweeping profile from the nose. A higher shoulder will often be the cause of catches.

I also suggest that you crank up the speed on your lathe. You'll get a lot smoother cutting. When teaching a beginners bowl class we usually turn a 7 or 8 inch bowl. I have the students set a speed of about 1200 RPM. More advanced students would be about 1600 RPM.

Wally

Re: Bowl Gouge

#22

THANK YOU

Julie

>THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU

thanks for all the fantastic help

and advise.

Will let you know how it goes

Re: Bowl Gouge

#23

location

Julie

>Charleston SC

Re: Bowl Gouge

#24

Re: Wally, Thanks for posting...

Allen Neighbors

>I think I've finally got it into my thick skull. I though you were supposed to grind the bevel at a different angle... I can see how having a 'shorter' bevel would let me ride the bevel around the curve, now. Just hand grind another bevel, making the main bevel shorter!!! Thanks again, I've probably had this explained already more than once, but this time, it clicked! :)