Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

making small tools

Posts

making small tools

#1

making small tools

eliot d

>I've made some 3/8 " hollowing tools from O-1 drill rod. Now I would like to make some 1/4 " tools, but I keep thinking that they will vibrate too much -- even for fairly small forms. Is there a readily available material that would vibrate less? Do you recommend any commercial hollowing tools in the 1/4 diameter size?

Re: making small tools

#2

Re: making small tools

john lucas

>Eliot I recommend the 1/4" tools for small things. I also made a set of 5/16". You are correct that the 1/4" tools vibrate but I can cut up to 2" if I take light cuts. I usually use them for short vessels and go to the 5/16" for the deeper ones. I also have a 3/8" set but I use the 5/16" the most for hollowing christmas ornaments.

If you order your drill rod from Travis or Enco just order one of each 1/4, 5/15 and 3/8. The shipping doesn't cost anymore The 3/8" is really good for making hook tools and hollowing tools for vessels up to about 4" or so.

Re: making small tools

#3

Re: making small tools

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I hollow Christmas ornaments with tools made from 5/32" and 3/16" hex wrenches (Allen wrenches). It all depends on how deep you need to go.

Re: making small tools

#4

commercial tools

JohnKJordan in East TN

>eliot d,

Sorby markets a set of three mini hollowing tools with shaft diameters much less than 1/4", about 0.2". I don't notice significant vibration. Of course, when used for small things the length of unsupported tool shaft is short.

JKJ

Re: making small tools

#5

Re: making small tools

Keith Newton

>You probably already know this, but I will post it anyway.

If you are trying to work through the smallest hole possible, you should be able to get better stiffness by grinding off the sides of the rod, making them elliptical. The height as it passes through the opening is where the stiffness is gained, and since you are passing through the hole at an angle, the appearant opening is an ellipse that becomes thinner the more you increase the angle from the axis of rotation.

Re: making small tools

#6

Re: Between old screwdrivers and.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....Allen wrenches I have found I can make most of the minitools I have ever needed.

Re: making small tools

#7

Re: making small tools

john lucas

>Keith I'm not an engineer and don't even play one on TV but wouldn't a round shaft have more metal and be less likely to vibrate. An oval shaft still has to fit through the same round hole.

Re: making small tools

#8

Cement nails...

Jerry Hall

>have worked for years as raw material to make hardened hollowing tools for one of our NorCal mentors, and he is going to demo the making of them at our February meeting. His miniature hollow forms are a delight.

Anybody with any experience doing this? Are there any web sites for the making of tools of materials mentioned in this thread?

Re: making small tools

#9

Re: making small tools

Barry Irby

>John, I am not an Engineer either but I did attend a fine Engineering University. (Man, that was tough three weeks). I think Keith is correct. An oval would be stiffer. That is if you hold it so the taller axis is the vertical axis/ that is, the tool is taller than wide. Think about a rectangular stick like a ruler. Pretty stiff one way and flexible the other. Same concept.

Also, his other point is that if you pass a round shaft through a round hole and it is an exact fit, you have no freedom of movement in any direction, but is the shaft were an oval that nearly touched the top and bottom of the round hole, you would have more freedom left to right. As a photographer, you are aware that if you look at a circle from any angle other than straight on, it appears to be an ellipse. In effect as you turn the tool left to right the opening into the HF becomes an ellipse. Get down on Eye level and look at one and you will see it clearly. Almost the same effect as knocking the corners off a square rod to put it into a round hole. In this case you are knocking off the "fat cheeks" but saving the height.

Both of these effects would be pretty slight on the scale of a 1/4" shaft, but if you are going for that last little bit it might be something to think about.

Re: making small tools

#10

Re: making small tools

eliot d

>I haven't thought about grinding the tool shaft to an oval shape. If you start with a certain diameter and grind off portions of the sides, I can't see that it can get any stiffer ( because the vertical dimension is the same.) But it will certainly give more side-to-side "elbow" room when moving through the opening. I like the idea. Thanks.

Re: making small tools

#11

Re: Between old screwdrivers and.....

eliot d

>When you use a screwdriver shaft, do you grind and sharpen the end , or do you just use the shaft to hold a metal lathe bit in the end -- the way you would with drill rod? If the answer is to sharpen the end, are there certain heat treatments that are necessary? I like your idea of using screwdriver shafts because I figure I can find just about any diameter lying around the shop.

Re: making small tools

#12

Re: For most of my screwdriver.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...tools I shape the cutting/scraping tip and then harden only the tip with a MAPP torch and water quench. They will hold an edge longer than the unhardened tips. And every shop has a collection of old screwdrivers lying around somewhere! The round shaft of about 3/16"~1/4" works best, and longer shafts give deeper working ability but more chatter hanging off the toolrest.

Re: making small tools

#13

me too , jamie

robert davis

>

Re: making small tools

#14

Re: making small tools

john lucas

>Barry I did think about the sideways movement but the roundness still bothers me. Using your ruler analogy. Lets say the ruler is 1/4" by 1". If you take a 1" round dowel would it not be as stiff or stiffer than the ruler. If we are talking the square area then then the ruler would definitely be stronger in that plane.

I'm just trying to wrap my wee little brain around this concept.

Re: making small tools

#15

Re: For most of my screwdriver.....

john lucas

>2 of my favorite tools are screwdrivers. Like jamie I grind the shape and then harden them. They work fine without hardening but hold an edge better after hardening. Mine are little scrapers that i use when I need to really fine tune a box lid. One is ground so I can do the inside and one is done for the outside.

l They are also handy for cleaning up foot details on the bottom of a bowl.

Re: making small tools

#16

You are right John.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The required hole opening is the same for the rod and the oval, and the rod will be stiffer.

Re: making small tools

#17

Re: You are right John.

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>The required hole opening is the same for the rod and the oval...

Considering an ellipse with the major (long) axis vertical, this seems correct only if the rod is always pointed exactly down the axis of the hole and not angled to the side. If swung left or right, the oval shape would provide more clearance with the swing angle depending on the axial geometry of the opening and the minor axis of the ellipse.

Re: making small tools

#18

Re: making small tools

Barry Irby

>John, We are talking about what to do with a "Limited" amount of material. We limit the amount for different reasons. In some cases we want to limit the weight. A solid steel square that was say 8" by 8" would be stronger than a steel I beam that was 8" tall and 8" wide, but it would be many times heavier. So to limit the weight of the buildings and bridges and use the steel more effectively, we use the I Beam.

Think of the oval tool he mentioned as an oval skew. If you laid it done flat on the tool rest so that it were a 1/4" tall and an inch wide with it hanging over two inches and got a massive catch, it might break. If you stand it up so that it is an 1" TALL and got the same catch, something else is going to give. It would break the rest or the banjo.

So if we are limited by a tiny hole and we have to pass a tiny shaft through the hole and want to move the shaft left to right, the oval make sense. Lets say the small round shaft was four "units" wide and four "units" tall and you had an oval one that was 3 units by five units. They would have very nearly the same amount of steel but the taller one would be a little stronger as long as you keep the long axis vertical.

OTOH, If you took a steel rod that was five units each way and ground it down to the point it was three by five, it would not be as strong and the round one. (All of this is assuming the steel is identical and equally heat treated. No cheating substituting some super steel for one and not the other.)

So, I think you can pass a 3X5 oval through a six unit hole and have more wiggle room that if you passed a 5 unit round tool through the same hole. To get the wiggle room with a round tool you would have to drop back to a a 3 unit round tool and that clearly would not be as strong as a 3X5 tool. Clear as mud? Let's all sing,"I can see clearly now...."

Unless you can buy oval bars, it is too much trouble to grind them your self for this very slight improvement. Thus we have the curved and angled tools.

Re: making small tools

#19

Re: making small tools

Keith Newton

>Thanks Barry, I liked you analogy. Several of the tools which I have made are as you describe, where I started with rectangular stock, then rounded off the corners.

It helps more than I would have thought. I believe a 25% incerease in height may produce ~ 100% more stiffness.

Re: making small tools

#20

Re: You are right John.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>True. Significant for angles greater than 20* or so with a straight bar. A swan neck bar changes the picture entirely, either negating the effect or exacerbating it.

Personally, I'd never try hollowing through a hole that close to the diameter of the bar.

Re: making small tools

#21

Steven Antonucci

I don't think that they're stronger

steve antonucci

>but I see the point... which is that the force being applied to the cutting end is "shear" at the toolrest. Torque is proportional to distance, so hanging it out longer will increase the force through the cross section, but most of the force is "down", not left to right.

The perfect illustration of this principal is a parting tool. An oval isn't stronger, but it doesn't matter in the short "diameter" since there is no meaningful force in that plane.

Steve

Re: making small tools

#22

Re: For most of my screwdriver.....

eliot d

>Is this the deal where you heat to get a straw color and then quench? Isn't there a follow up procedure to "temper" the steel, also? Does it matter if you quench in water or oil? I remember some posts about all this; but , frankly, I have forgotten the details. Which would be better -- allen head wrenches or screw drivers shafts?

Re: making small tools

#23

Re: making small tools *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>I recommend M-2 pre-hardened cutter bits from Wholesale Tools. Example: 1/4" x 6" round @ $2.10 (part # 2227-0020) and 1/8" x 4" @ $.90. These are polished smooth, ready to shape and sharpen. Can be cut with your grinder and bent with a torch without changing the hardness. Thirty bucks will get you enough steel for many tools. Make scratch awls for Christmas for all your woodworking friends.

The knowledge of how to temper and harden A or W or O steel is not needed. That has already been done, because heat treating HSS is not practical with an industrial kiln.

Bill in WNC mountains


Wholesale Tools

Re: making small tools

#24

Re:Eliot- I use both for different .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....purposes- the Allen wrenches for hollowing under the shoulders. Heat the tool tips to red hot and quench- there is no need to temper the shafts because they weren't hardened. This is strictly a low tech tool making process.

Re: making small tools

#25

Re: I can understand both sides...

Allen Neighbors

>because I hollow through a 5/8" hole with a 1/2" tool shank.

But I really can't believe that if I ground down the sides of my tool shank (to make it oval) that it would make it stronger. It would give me more room to swing the tool, but I think that's all the benefit.