>I assume you are buffing wood. The red stick is tripoli it gives a nice shine. The white stick is called white diamond, but contains no diamond. It gives a higher gloss than the red stick. Yes do use separate wheels and a third wheel for wax. The normal order is red, white wax. If I want a softer sheen I skip the white. If you buff too long you can actually cut through your finish.The green is chromium oxide. It is great for honing tools. It can be used on a strop or you can make a wheel out of MDF and load the edge with the Green compound. For honing tools make sure the wheel is rotating away from the tool edge.
>Steve: I agree with the other posters. I got some buffing wheels and supplies at a jewelry supply outlet, and got a stick of red stuff I thought to be equivalent to Tripoli. Thanks to a recent post, I learned that the red stick was actually a fine rouge for polishing metal, and I changed over to Tripoli as soon as I could get it. The Tripoli can remove sanding scratches from some wood sanded to 220 grit; on some woods you need to sand to finer grits. The system as designed works great, and I find that the sticks are consumed inversely proportional to the grit--the Tripoli goes first and the wax bar lasts quite a while.
I use the hard beeswax bars. You have to give the spinning wheel the slightest touch to load it. Too much and it just gums up the wood. Ideally you would also use different types of wheels for each product.
>Some folks call Tripoli 'red' but it is really reddish brown which is actually more brown than red. Tripoli and White Diamond both are more coarse than the Red Rouge. The Red compound is Jeweler's Rouge, sometimes used as a first abrasive for polishing metals. Even it is reddish brown, but it's more red than brown. Confusing? :)
I also use separate wheels. One each for Tripoli and White Diamond, and separate wheels for Carnauba Wax and Beeswax, and I have a soft flannel wheel that is just for re-shining a previously buffed piece, when I'm getting ready for shows. After using it a while, it probably has a little of everything on it. :)