Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Question about power sanding

Posts

Question about power sanding

#1

Question about power sanding

Steven Kubien

>How many of us use a drill to power our sanding disks versus using an inertia sander? I just made a crude inertia sander and it seems to do as good a job, just as quickly and is LOADS easier to handle (lighter, easier to manipulate etc). I've only tackled one small (6" diameter) bowl with it but it looks like a good move to me.

What's everybody else doing? Pros and cons of one method over another?

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Question about power sanding

#2

Re: Question about power sanding

Fog Tanner

>I use both. I use the angle drill (Harbor Freight on sale) for the courser grits and then the Vic Woods inertia sander for the finer grits. It also depends on the pieces. I am doing some now that are strictly limited to using the angle drill for course removal and then hand sanding for the finer grits. There are also some which are done only by hand, too thin for either of the other two. And any shaping is done by hand, it is too easy to remove too much with the power sanding.

All my wet sanding (either minteral spirits or water) is done by hand, don't want to make a bigger mess along with getting the pads messed up.

Re: Question about power sanding

#3

Steven Antonucci

I have a cheap RA air tool.

steve antonucci

>I use it to power-sand on and off the lathe, and I also use an inertia sander... and sand by hand when I'm bored...

I can't commit to anything, man...

Steve

Re: Question about power sanding

#4

Re: Question about power sanding

Stuart Johnson

>I use a Grex ROS and let it work as an inertia sander when the compressor kicks on.

Re: Question about power sanding

#5

Re: Question about power sanding

Charles Yawn

>Steven, I have and use both. The Milwaukee angled drill get the most use and is used for rough sanding. I like the drill because I can control the speed and direction easier. The Sorby sander gets used in tighter or deeper jobs. Use the 2 inch pads on both. The smaller pads don't seem to last long enough. Charles

Re: Question about power sanding

#6

Re: Question about power sanding

robo hippy

>I do 95% power sanding. Never tried an inertial sander. Did hand sanding until I found out about the power sanders. Biggest advantage over the inertial sanders is that you can sand when the lathe is turned off. This is good for problem spots. Also, I turn green wood to final thickness, let them dry and warp, and then sand and finish. I couldn't sand them with an inertial sander. I also like to sand with the lathe running very slow. Partly because of the warped bowls, and partly (especially with the coarser grits) because I can see what is being done as I do it, not having to turn the lathe off and on. I have heard that with the inertial sanders that it is a bit more difficult to sand out the very center of the bowl because the fpm (feet per minute) speed is so slow.

robo hippy

Re: Question about power sanding

#7

Re: Ric, the Dollar and Pound...

Tim GC

>I use a small purpose build motor from Kirjes, shaped like a miniature grinder but with a 3/8 chuck at each end. A 1mt flexi shaft works off one end. I have it mounted overhead so can just reach up switch it on and reach any part of a turning I need to.

Re: Question about power sanding

#8

Re: Question about power sanding

Fog Tanner

>I turn out of round bowls, both green and on eccentric chucks. I use the inertia sander on these with no problems. Normally I have the speed down when sanding, and the low rpms let the iniertia sander follow the surface.

I have not had the problem in the center of the bowl, but I can see where it would be if you were in a hurry. A lot of years sanding on model race planes taught patience when it came to sanding. A good paint job took around 20 hrs, of which 30hrs was all hand sanding - you couldn't use power sanders for that detail or finish.

Re: Question about power sanding

#9

Re: Ric, the Dollar and Pound...

Tim GC

>I'm blowed if I know where the title above came from ... it's supposed to be about sanding ...

Obviously too tired to type, off to bed, in the UK!!

Re: Question about power sanding

#10

Re: Question about power sanding

Allen Neighbors

>Steve, I have a Sioux angle drill that I use on large bowls, inside and out, until I get down to the finer grits, then I use my roller-blade sanders. I prefer the Sioux on the outside of all large pieces... inside too, if I can get it in there.

I have a couple of rollerblade sanders that I've cut down to 2" and one that's 1 1/2" dia. All the rest are 3" dia.

My little boxes and smaller items are sanded by hand, lathe slow.

I've enclosed an old pic (I now have about 15, for all grits and more) of my rollerblade sanders. The foam pad is from cheap flip-flop shower shoes. I use contact cement to stick the pad to the wheel, and the velcro to the pad.

I use Vince's paper.

Hope this helps.


img

Re: Question about power sanding

#11

Thanks everyone

Steven Kubien

>I really appreciate the responses. I have no intention of giving up my drill but I will definately be making a few more of the inertia sanders. FWIW, it seemed really easy to use and pretty effective for the centre of the bowl.

Thanks again,

Steve Kubien

Re: Question about power sanding

#12

Re: Thanks everyone

Barry Irby

>Steve, I made Inertial sanders out of ordinary sanding mandrels with round shafts. I turned a handle and drilled a hole through it at an appropriate angle. I counter bored the hole to accept an bearing that the mandrel fit through. Used a cap nut (like a little Panama hat) to retain the mandrel in the assembly. Not sure the bearings were necessary. If you drill a clean smooth hole in hardwood the mandrel might spin well enough. A little oil or wax would help.

Re: Question about power sanding

#13

Re: Question about power sanding

eliot d

>I believe that inertia sanding will usually leave fewer sanding scratches. But for problem areas, one must sand by hand or with a power sander with the lathe off. I use both a Milwaukee close quarter drill and the cheap knockoff from HF. (So far, I see nothing wrong with the $29.99 HF.)

Re: Question about power sanding

#14

Re: Question about power sanding

Rick Allen

>When I first started power sanding with a Souix drill I always held the drill upright (sanding pad higher than the power cord). With the coarse grits this would often "catch" and try to spin the drill out of my hand.

I now use the drill upside down, especially for the coarse grits. With the drill pointing down (the sanding pad lower than the power cord) I no longer have sanding "catches".

Re: Question about power sanding

#15

Re: Question about power sanding

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I use a close quarters angle drill (Milwaukee). While much is by hand, I do most of my bowl power sanding with the lathe turned OFF and rotated back and forth by hand. I think this allows me to control things better. This method would not work with an friction-driven sanding disk.

JKJ

Re: Question about power sanding

#16

Re: Question about power sanding--a another tip

eliot d

>After each grit I blow both the sanding pad and the drill with high pressure (about 90psi) air. This procedure cleans my Astodot pads perfectly and I believe it prolongs the life of my drills. And , while I'm at it, I blow the dust off the work piece.

Re: Question about power sanding

#17

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Question about power sanding

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I use both a power sander and a friction drive.

It depends on the wood, the speed and the design. I find that a power sander is downright dangerous with high lathe speed or bowls etc. with spaces or voids. If the sander catches it either drags everything into the turning or throws it out at me!

I would use the friction sander more often if there was a safer method of holding it, the English designs tend to get my hands too close to the work. I have tried making a new handle but it became unwieldy!

Regards, Peter.

Re: Question about power sanding

#18

Re: Question about power sanding

Steven Kubien

>Peter, I think I may take what you've said and try to make a longer handle (15-20"), set the sanding pad at an angle to the long axis of the handle and use the tool rest way out to offer some support. I'll put a small handle on the long handle like the Munro hollower. as I think and see things in my mind, it makes sense to me. Thanks for sparking the brain juices.

Steve Kubien

Re: Question about power sanding

#19

Allen Neighbors sanders

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Allen, did you not post a treatise on making your sanders some time in the past?

Re: Question about power sanding

#20

Re: Allen Neighbors sanders

Allen Neighbors

>I believe I did, Carol, but I don't know how to find it. I guess just search the archives for Homemade Sanders, or Rollerblade Wheels... I know those words would be in it.

I have to leave right now, but I'll try to search for it later tonight. If I find it, I'll post a link.

Re: Question about power sanding

#21

earlier thread

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Steven,

I just noticied this old thread on the same subject:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=25217

There is some comprehensive information in the message "Earlier Review of Passive Sanders" by Lyn J. Mangiameli --

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=25255

JKJ

Re: Question about power sanding

#22

Re: earlier thread

Steven Kubien

>In the past I have found that if Lyn wrote it, it's worth reading. Thanks a lot!

Steve

Re: Question about power sanding

#23

Re: Here's the link... *LINK*

Allen Neighbors

>Some things have changed. I use contact cement now instead of epoxy... the epoxy was too brittle for me. And I use Vince's blue disks, because they hold up better than the other's. I have one 3" sander for each of 10 grits, beginning at 80, plus I have some smaller ones. These are really efficient, but will generate way too much heat if you're not careful.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=106755

Re: Question about power sanding

#24

Re: Allen Neighbors sanders

Carol Reed - in Nebraska

>Thanks, Allan.

Any reason you used all-thread rod as opposed to unthreaded rod? And where do you find the wheels? Thrift shops? I don't do flip-flops, either. Suitable substitute?

Thanks. I much prefer making tools than to just outright buy them. Usually I wind up with something that works much better (and lasts longer)!

Re: Question about power sanding

#25

Goop!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I bought replacement Velcro from The Sanding Glove at the 2006 Dessert Roundup. They also sold me Household Goop to glue it on with. They said it is the best glue they have found for Velcro. I am sold on the stuff. I've been using it for a couple of years now with no problems. Heat doesn't seem loosen it and it holds well. There are several versions of Goop make sure you use the Household version. The Sanding Glove carries it and so does my local Home Depot. I'm just a happy customer. I have no other connection to any of the above.