Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Posts

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#26

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Fog Tanner

>It is a good thing that the ancient Egytians and Babalonians didn't copyright all their forms, designs and embellisment techniques - all those claiming ownership would be out of business along with the rest of us. The same can be said of the Greeks and a number of other civilizations that preceeded us. And there is no telling what the Chinese still have buried in some of their massive tombs. And you can't leave out the Hopi and Navajo, that made forms too.

Even the ugly stuff has been made, if you look at the ancient sites where they made offerings in pottery and then smashed them at the site, when pieced back together you will find that ugly bowl that we all made starting out. The only way to know if it is good looking or not is to make something ugly for comparison.

In 1000 years when all the great gurus of today are long forgotten, these same ignorant arguements of owenership will be going on - the only change will be the name of the gurus in the future as Raffan, Ellsworth, Key, Stockdale, and everyone else will have become a myth and long forgotten. Of course my favorite is guru is urug spelled backwards, like Serutan - you had to be there.........

Time to go out and copy some more Egyptian forms......

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#27

Re: Yea Fog!!! :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#28

Steven Antonucci

Does anyone bother to read my words

steve antonucci

>or just assume that I'm picking a fight?

I think I can say with a great deal of certainty that my original comments were not confrontive nor a personal attack. I merely stated that I understood how someone could construe Wally's piece as derivative. I never said it was derivative. I never said he copied Molly's work. Actually, if you bother to read the words, I defend his work as "not a Molly". But I stand by my original words, which is I could see how people might think it's derivative even if I didn't.

The argument actually started when Wally took offense to the fact that I saw some influence. He began the confrontation, calling my opinion BS, and defending his ground. I'm a big boy, so I ask a very simple question, and I haven't heard his answer. Next thing I know, there's the lynch mob at my door asking me to come to a necktie party.

I guess that they'll have to wait, 'cause I'm busy planning my next fight. What can I say, I have no life and this kind of stuff gives me great joy (sarcasm, for those of you that think you know me...)

An as for WOW, I left on my own accord because I refused to let someone censor my right to my opinion. I have plenty to do in my life, and I've met lots of people through WoodCentral who will vouch for me personally. Sure I've got lots of opinions, and probably even more faults, but the main reason that this is a good place to hang out is that Woodcentral has always allowed friends to have a forum for open discussion about anything.

If we lose that, I'm gone.

Steve

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#29

BTW- I wouldn't label that form a "Molly"

Ron in Drums PA

>Those are Steve's words

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#30

Re: You left WOW because .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... your membership was terminated, blocking your access, regardless of how you wish to spin the facts.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#31

Very nice piece...

Peter Teubel

>I really like the overlapping leaves. What are it's dimensions? I can never guess from pics...

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#32

Steven Antonucci

Actually, you think you know, but you don't

steve antonucci

>I left WOW because it wasn't the right environment. My membership was not terminated, and I actually contacted Herm recently when I got three renewal e-mails asking to take me off the list.

You were there, but missed a whole bunch of stuff that went on behind the scenes between me and Herm, where it shall remain because it's nobody's business but mine.

So feel free to bring it up whenever you want to put me on the cross, but you don't know what happened.

Steve

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#33

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

eliot d

>Having read all these posts, I still think there is something to be said for not simply copying someone's signature pieces without some kind of attribution. Being influenced by a style or technique is an entirely different matter. That is why we look at others work. Again, to choose my favorite examples, I for one , would not do an Art Liestman's puzzle piece.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#34

Re:Steve's argumentative attitude...

Stephen Mushinski

>ROFL - I remember that!

Steve, taking a swing at Wally will get you something for sure. A whole lot of enemy's!! What some of our more experienced turners deserve is respect. If you do not agree with something they say so be it. It is not a place for you to start an argument.

Not sure I like what happened with Terry D a few months ago. Now, we do not see him posting. I always search out what Russ, Wally and a few others have to say about everything and anything as I know I will learn something from it.

From reading what happened on WOW and other posts here I cannot say the same of what you have to say.

BTW: Wally I believe that worms were the first to make holes in wood then a nice Polish man from Canada started using a dental drill to do the same thing. My understanding is it was the late Frank Sudol.

You talked about Joey! Well Binh learned from Frank, Frank learned to colour from Giles Gilson and Giles learned from someone else. So does that not mean Joey coping someone else?????? I love what Joey has done and she should recognized for it not compared.

Most of it is nonsense. Just get back to enjoying the sound and smell of spinning wood people!!!!

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#35

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Sean Troy

>LMAO because I would never have to worry about someone copying my work. I don't even like copying my own work.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#36

Right on Troy...

Ron McKinley

>I've only turned a few pieces that I really like so I don't have to worry about someone copying mine!

This whole thing got started at AAW Symposiums a few years ago and I thought it was silly at the time. Some wise person once said, "There is nothing new under the sun!" .......Ron

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#37

Re:Steve's argumentative attitude...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Thanks Steve. You're right about the worms. Many years ago when Frank Sudol first started demoing J. Paul Fennel and I attended his demo at whatever symposium it was. Frank credited Paul with inspiring him to start piercing. I don't know where Paul learned it. I remember being at a symposium, probably Provo, back in the 80's when a woman had a very thin walled bowl with very lacey looking piercing in the instant gallery. I can still remember it, so you can see that I was impressed.

I just finished a thin walled piece today and am working on a design for piercing it. Hey, I've been doing this stuff for a long time and I'm still having fun.

Wally