Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Posts

Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#1

Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>It seems that every few months sombody brings up the subject of copying others' work. With a few exceptions, most of it is rediculous in my opinion.

Some time ago I posted a photo of a piece on WoW. It had lots of pyrography. Somebody accused me of copying Molly's work. Absolutely NOT! First, the form was one that I had used for years, long before Molly turned her first bowl. The texturing and the the theme was not like anything Molly had done. In fact Molly herself stated that mine was original and not a copy. But the charge had still been made. Look at the pic and see for yourself.

There have been some posts on WoW more recently by Joey Richardson. Some absolutely wonderful platters with piercing, color, and using butterflys as a theme. The charge of copying Binh Pho's work was made by a well known turner. Rediculous! The form was a platter which is not a form that Binh uses. Who knows who was the first to use piercing on turnings. It wasn't Binh. Butterflies? One of Mother Natures creatures which anyone should feel free to use. Again, the charge of copying was made.

In my opinion this whole subject of copying and plagarism has been way overblown.

Did Ellsworth really copyright a form, or is that just a stupid rumor?

Wally


img

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#2

I wish I could copy your work.

Troy German

>And the work of many others who post here. I'll keep trying.

Getting better,

Troy

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#3

Wally, I agree with you ...

Ed Moore

>wholeheartedly. I find some of the comments to be so politically correct that they are offensive. The piece you showed is distinctly NOT Molly and for someone to suggest that it IS simply shows their incompetence.

Chris Stott wrote a nice book on boxes, showing fifty styles. Are all the shapes his? No. In some cases he attributes the style to someone and in some cases he overlooks what I think is an obvious identification. Should the rest of the turning world stop making boxes because of this book? I think NOT!

I posted a picture of a Big Leaf Maple box recently and the style was obviously influenced by Richard Raffan. Richard uses Australian woods and probably never made a BLM box. And the shape is different from what I think he would have chosen. I think he should be pleased that his work influenced what I did and I hope that he doesn't feel threatened by this meager talent.

Incidentally, I really like the piece you showed. In particular, I like the falling leaf.

Ed

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#4

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I have very few creative juices in my body so most of my work has always been using other peoples ideas. I consider myself a craftsman and not much of an artist. So I would would be thrilled and honored if someone stole an idea from me. That would be the best compliment I could get.

My grandpa always told me if I had nothing good to say about someone, then say nothing.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#5

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

russ Fairfield

>I agree with you that these conversations are rediculous. They serve no useful purpose and do nothing other than scare the new woodturners and make them afraid to post a picture of something they made.

Nobody here will ever have to face the problem because none of us will ever turn anything in our lifetime that will have enough value to cover one days worth of legal and court fees in a copyright action. Comparing our turned wood with Chihuli is equally rediculous. His art sells for 100's of thousands of dollars, and that is worth suing somebody over. It is the rare piece of wood that will rise to anywhere near that kind of money.

When somebody asks, I tell them to turn what they want, and forget about it. It really is much ado about nothing.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#6

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Ron McKinley

>Considering that 80 billion humans preceded us on this earth and that woodturning has been around 4,000 or more years I doubt that any of us can create a really "original" turning, including Ellsworth!.......Ron

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#7

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

don lewonczyk

>Russ, not meaning to be a wise guy but you have plagiarized Wally on rediculous,spelling bee lesson today, ridiculous! I looked it up in the dictionary thats how I know. I don't see how anyone can copy someones stuff down to the last dot,burn line, pierced hole, etc. When you bought your lathe, band saw,woodburner and chain saw were there any instructions on which way you could only use it? I couldn't copy Wallys burnings but I do things with my burner that would come close to looking like it was something he might have done but why on earth would I want to do that? I buy patterns and I draw some, other people buy the exact patterns but I've yet to see any two identical pieces come out of the same pattern and thats with me doing them let alone two differient people. This topic has been amusing but not very educational and im glad im not hung up on it. Don L

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#8

Steven Antonucci

I think there are several camps here

steve antonucci

>There are those that feel that anything can be copyrighted and all work must be unique to have value or significance.

There are those that feel that somethings (my hand is up) can be copyrighted (Firmanger seaflowers, Keith's turned roses, Art Liestman "puzzle illusions"), but techniques and shapes can not (burning, bowls, color, hollowforms)

Finally, there are those that do not respect the work of others at all, and willfully copy it for there own profit. We've all seen them, and we don't think real hard about this category.

The first two seems to be where the battlelines are formed...

Steve

BTW- I wouldn't label that form a "Molly" either, but I could see someone looking at her process for surface decoration and seeing a correlation. Seems like a clear middle of the road position for most of us, huh?

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#9

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Yes, and when I want to be really emphatic I might say Reeediculous!!

Wally

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#10

Re: I think there are several camps here

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>BS....The only correlation is that they're both burned and they're both black...Molly uses a basketweave pattern. Mine is done with a round ball pen.

Wally

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#11

I wouldn't worry too much Wally...

jay in tx

>some folks will cry [wolf] at the drop of a 'hat'. Is Stetson the only company that makes hats from felt? Were James and George Lock the only men to ever make a bowler hat out of hard felt? Am I using the hat references way to ineffectually? Joey's work is real pretty, she should be proud. Just like hat styles, sizes, and materials; peoples opinions will vary and other people will snigger at their unabashed narrow mindedness as they color their opinions based on their perceptions colored and steeped in their own self-righteous indignation... Hey I'll stop rambling now, hope you enjoyed creating your "Molly Look-a-like" as much as many of us enjoyed looking at it. (Wink, Wink, nudge and giggle)

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#12

Steven Antonucci

I forgot, you like to argue with me

steve antonucci

>So if you burned cave paintings of mastodons instead of horses, you'd feel like that was original work? Or would you say that it was influenced?

I'm not suggesting that your work is a copy, but you made a lot of pieces before Molly started turning. How many were burned with a round tip in any pattern? If the answer is none, then I think influenced by the technique is fair to say.

Influence is not a dirty word, and it doesn't mean that you copied. I have been influenced by many, but I produce original work with all of the techniques I use.

Look at yourself in the mirror. You've been turning for 60 years, and in all of that time, you don't think you've ever been influenced by someone? Molly may not have invented the technique, but she's certainly known for it.

Calling BS right back at you...

Steve

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#13

THOSE PEOPLE NEED TO GET A LIFE

robert davis

>

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#14

Step back Steve

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Steve I don't like your tone.....

Take care,

Jim

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#15

Reeediculous!! and totally assinine

Ruth Niles

>That's how I feel about anyone saying Wally copied Molly.

That's how I feel about the whole "plagiarism" nonsense.

That's how I feel about the egotistical people who think they were the FIRST and ONLY person to burn a design, carve a leaf, color a bowl or any other artistic process.

My neighbor's 2 1/2 yr. old grandson colored a bowl with magic markers that was headed for the burn barrel, (looked a lot like Steve's bowl) maybe I should post a picture and call it an "Original Braidon" and no other 2 1/2 yr. old can use the same colors on a cherry salad bowl. Get REAL.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#16

JL

Re: In the words of Tom Lehrer...

JL

>Plagiarize,

Let no one else's work evade your eyes,

Remember why the good Lord made your eyes,

So don't shade your eyes,

But plagiarize, plagiarize, plagiarize...

Only be sure always to call it please, "research".

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#17

Steven Antonucci

That's your right, but not my problem, Jim.

steve antonucci

>You don't have a dog in the fight. Why put one?

Steve

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#18

Boy, That Is The Truth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have never read such a crock! In fact I am going to quit reading this whole thread.

Wally, Ed, Russ, Ruth thank you!

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#19

Re: No, Steve, it is your problem.

russ Fairfield

>Your argumentatitive attitude is preventing reasonable conversation, and your desire to start a fight is getting everyone pissed off. It might not be your goal, but that is what has happened, and PO'd people will look for a more friendly place to talk about woodturning.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#20

I'm Outa' Here.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Steve, WC is NOT your personal playground.

Wally

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#21

Wally, my people will be in touch with your people

Molly Winton

>

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#22

Re:Steve's argumentative attitude...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. was the reason he was booted out of the WOW site, and now we have to be confronted with it here??? Back off Steve, and get a life!

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#23

Tired of this trhead go to WOW

Stuart Johnson

>for the art vs. craft thread. Personally, I think they both are a load of pretentious crap.

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#24

Very Well Put Wally.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Copying, Plagarism Again?.....

#25

Lets Move Along

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Steve,

Short of putting on my WC Moderators Hat I am asking that we all just stop here, end this and move along.

Steve you seem to have made this your point of argument and that is fine, but your confrontational attitude is wearing thin and not in line with constructive thought.

I will leave it at that,

Take care,

Jim