Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

When is Thin Too Thin?...

Posts

When is Thin Too Thin?...

#1

When is Thin Too Thin?...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'm turning pieces for piercing, and they must be thin walled. 1/16th inch. Over the years I've turned hundreds of thin walled HF's. On a few of them I've screwed up. Okay, I just did it again. A nice piece of curly maple. 4 inches dia. and about 7 inches deep. The wood is dry. I shaped the outside except for near the bottom, roughed it out inside, about 3/8 to 1/2 inch walls. I sanded the outside, sanding the upper 2/3rds. It's a small opening, about 3/4 inch. I'm doing fine, getting it nice and thin down almost to the heavy wood near the bottom, measuring frequently with my calipers. Measured it once more....says zero thickness. Yep, I can see tiny holes through the wood.

I've done this often enough over the years that I don't go bananas....just a few choice cuss words, a couple of heavy sighs, take it off the chuck, a longing glance at the pretty wood, and into the trash bin....Oh well.

Wally

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#2

Gee Wally!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I thought you would have used up all of your mistakes by now. If you still have some left after all the time you have been turning, I must have more mistakes left than I can shake a stick at. I was hoping I was making a dent in them. I make them quite often, so I thought there might not be that many left.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#3

Been there, done that, too many times.

john lucas

>

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#4

Dick Hines

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

Dick Hines

>When is thin to thin? I would say when the tip of your hollowing tool can be seen sticking throught the side of your HF.

Wally every body who does hollow forms has done that. If they say not their eyes are brown.

Sorry to hear of your latest disaster.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#5

Ric Taylor

I Know it Doesn't Help, But it's Only Wood...

Ric Taylor

>

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#6

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

Juergen

>If you are going to pierce the piece anyway, put a few holes in it after you complete the external shaping. J Paul Fennnell suggested this technique during one of his demos.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#7

Barb Siddiqui

Good golly

Barb Siddiqui

>and I thought I was eventually going to be smarter than that! If you're still doing it, Wally, I'll have to relax and take my lumps when that happens again. Drat. -BarbS

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#8

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

john lucas

>I had forgotten that Binh Pho also suggested putting a tiny hole in the area to be pierced so you could measure the thickness.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#9

Re: Good golly

eliot d

>Wally,

I know you are a rather advanced wood turner, so I guess it happens to even experienced turners. I find, when using a laser rig, that I don't usually go through the wall. I say,'usually' because, if the laser dot happens to shift( to the right) without your noticing it, you've had it.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#10

Re: Good golly

eliot d

>What I mean is --- shift to the right in relation to the tool tip.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#11

Am I the only one?

Carole Valentine

>Who has this weird idea in my head that lasers are sort of an easy out - that you should learn to hollow thin and consistently by hand before you allow yourself that luxury?

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#12

Re: Am I the only one? No

Don in Central Illinois

>I agree. I'm holding off on a boring 'system' until I can get better at freehand. It's just like photography, you should start out with a manual everything camera so you know what does what and why. Then when you go to a more automatic system, you're still in control.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#13

Re: Am I the only one?

Stuart Johnson

>Carol, Are you using other advanced items like a bowl gauge, 4 jaw chuck, electric rather spring pole power? I understand what you mean but I don't really agree with the need to perfect a simpler (not easier) process first.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#14

Re: Am I the only one?

john lucas

>I have to agree with Stuart. Although I think thin vessels like Wally is doing are better done by hand the lazar and boring bar makes it so easy that I can start a brand new turner on hollowing and they can have success which of course makes it more fun. Now this is on a vessel with walls that are more like 1/4 to 1/2".

I learned to hollow with the armbrace and using the captured bar system is so much more relaxing and with the lazer you can hollow to moderately thin really quickly. Then I have to just measure and cut and measure and cut which is I guess what Wally does.

I have a moderatly poorly made lazar mount for my bar and it's very easy for it to move a few millimeters out of whack. When your trying to turn a vessel down to 2mm thick for piercing that's inviting disaster which is why I ended up with a vase last time instead of a hollow vessel.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#15

Re: Am I the only one?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole,

There is craftsmanship of certainty and craftsmanship of risk. For some wierd reason the risk factor is what makes hollowing fun and challenging for me. As Clay Foster says...there is a reason they call it a boring bar.

Jen :)

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#16

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

George Van

>I had a similar situation a few days ago Wally on a walnut piece only I got mine a little thinner than the one you just described! ;-))))

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#17

Re: Am I the only one?

eliot d

>I have some conflicting issues about your point. I started hollowing with the Stewart arm brace and several large(3/4") Stewart tools. I moved on to various laser rigs because I figured I could handle larger work that way and control the thickness better. I then spent three days with David Ellsworth at one of his workshops, where the emphasis was, certainly, on doing it "by hand" with long straight tools sometimes made in the shop. I am now of the opinion that it's best to start the hollowing of a vessel by hand in the Ellsworth fashion to get through a small opening and around the shoulder, and measure often with his simple wire method. But once the shoulder thickness is established and the shoulder is more or less completed, I have no problem with shifting to a laser rig to get the rest done. I turned a fairly large (13 x 2 1/2") flat ("river stone") hollow form through a small opening using this kind of algorithm and got it done. I had earlier brought this turning, when only partly hollowed, to the Ellsworth class hoping to do it there. But even David said that it would be in the "too hard" category for a three day workshop and that my shoulder would ache for a week! Yet using my modified ElboTtool at home got me through it nicely with no shoulder problems. (The piece is at the Sansar Gallrey in Bethesda, Md priced at $1600.)

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#18

Re: Am I the only one?

Allen Neighbors

>No, you're not the only one. But that doesn't mean I do. :)

I enjoy using the laser, and I also enjoy doing some hollowing by feel.

I can't do really thin... with either ... consistantly. :) Maybe someday.... sigh...

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#19

Steven Antonucci

That's funny!

steve antonucci

>I never met Clay, but I'd sure like to. He seems like an interesting guy, and with that line, a great sense of humor!

Steve

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#20

Steven Antonucci

If you know how to hand hollow...

steve antonucci

>then all of the claims of torque and such are meaningless. If you are getting those forces by hand, you are simply doing it wrong.

I laughingly refer to captured laser systems as "cheater bars". Since the wood doesn't know how it's being cut, in the end, neither will the viewer of the finished work. We had a few days of discussion about how much "help" a turner can ask for before it's no longer his/her work, but something else.

If we have a computer controlled CNC cutterhead spinning a ball mill inside the vessel, it's no longer man made, right? For me, once you start getting to how the wood is cut and introducing "automation", you start to get away from the craft. Lasers measuring is just smart, but not accurate enough for "really thin" work.

90% of hollowing is to get down to the last 10%, but it's the time spent with the wood spinning, learning what's inside, and whether or not the last 10% needs any special attention that makes it fun for me.

Thankfully, you'll always be able to know when something is hand hollowed (for now). If the hole in the top is less than an inch, it was probably not done with a captured system.

Let the pigeons loose...

Steve

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#21

Re: Am I the only one? (Long)

Tim GC

>Since picking up a lower spinal injury some years back, I have difficulty bending (actually bending is easy ... it's the getting back up again that is a trifle more difficult). I am OK with pens and shallow bowls etc, but vases and deep forms wide or narrow necked I have a problem with. After a few bends and twists to view progress I am FUBAR'd for the rest of the day or maybe longer. I am looking into investing in a captive boring system or maybe manufacturing one (See www.Laymar-Crafts.co.uk) A Laser strikes me as a ruddy good addition. I will still try and get a hollow form finished in the 'Traditional' way ... but don't hold your breath.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#22

Modification?

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Eliot: I use the elbo tool and really like it. What modification did you make to it?

Thanks

Tom

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#23

Re: Am I the only one?

Ed in Sptbg.

>Jennifer, sounds like you,ve read David Pye's books...others should also. Then, they would know what you're saying.

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#24

Re: Am I the only one?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I don't own a laser light for hollowing. I did use one once and I think that it's a good thing. I may get one some day. I've been using my Stewart tool for a long time and it isn't perfect. When you're turning thin walls your utmost attention is required. Especially through a small opening. I wouldn't trust a laser to be accurate enough for 1/16th inch walls. Very frequent use of good calipers is a must.

I have a pair of calipers that do a very good job. They were made in Australia back in the 80's. Unforunately, the company that made them has been out of business for some time. I think that the patent has probably run out, so somebody could do turners a favor and manufacture some.

Wally

Re: When is Thin Too Thin?...

#25

Yup : )

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>