>Just a general question for the folks going to symposia- do you contribute to the Instant Gallery? If so, why? Exposure? Sales? Just for fun?
Conversely, why not? Fear? Loss?
Let's hear it...
Steven
P.S. I'm going to my first "event" (unless we count Five Barns...) and I will probably bring one piece- which is a set of three vessels. My intent is to see if there is any reaction to my work (positive or negative).
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Terry Fox
>Steve,
If you are talking about Totally Turning this weekend, it will be my first, also. I've been wrestling with the Instant Gallery question, too. I've decided that I'll take some pieces in hopes of getting some objective opinions of my work relative to others. To my friends and family, I'm the best turner there ever was! I don't know about trying to sell them - I have no idea of how to price them. I guess I'll wait and see.
Terry
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler *LINK*
Mike Brazeau
>For Totally Turning, I have one piece I am bringing that I completed late last year and posted here. It was a bit different and I am intersted to see if I get any feedback, positive or negative from those that see the actual piece. First time to a symposium. Take regularly to our guild show & tell
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Fog Tanner
>If I have something at the time I take a few pieces. I look at the instant galleries at a symposium no different than the ones we have every month at our club meeting. This past weekend I took an interesting offcenter bowl because Ruth Niles wanted to see it. She didn't make it, but I got to show it to some friends who had wanted to see it. I actually took two pieces, the other was a gift for a friend's wife but I kept it in the gallery until Sunday.
A couple of years ago, I took a set of segmented suction fit lid boxes that I had made. They wound up being picked by one of the lead turners for critiquing during the Saturday night banquet, so that was a positive experience.
Most of the time it is a fun thing, not looking for sales. If I have something interesting I take it, it is always fun to hear the comments. And it is another way of seeing how your work compares against other works. "Something is only as good as what you compare it against" (R.R). If you feel that other pieces are better, it gives you a goal. If yours are better, it gives you incentive to do better because they will now have a goal. As long as people don't look at it as some sort of elitist ranking, then it is a positive experience for everyone. And if someone is looking at it as an elitist type ranking, they are always under pressure to produce a high level of work, the journey ceases to be exciting - the pieces less spontaneous and more predictable and they fall back into the rankings of mere commoners. It all levels out in the end.
Overall it is an enjoyable experince, and worth the time and effort to take a few peices. I am already working on some pieces for next year and I just got back from the symposium we had this past weekend.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Allen Neighbors
>I didn't take any this time, because it was my first symposium, and I didn't know exactly how things worked. But I will next time. It's fun to stand close and hear some of the comments.
I was surprised by the instant gallery at SWAT. There was one area that was roped off so you couldn't touch the pieces, but in the rest of the gallery, touching was almost encouraged.
There were some extremely well done pieces displayed throughout,of such quality that inspired all of us to learn more, practice more, and expand our horizons. There were also pieces that were of outstanding form, but the finish was poor, showing sanding marks and even some toolmarks. And some of these were by "professional" turners, that I have heard about for years.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>It was my first symposium this past weekend at the NC Woodturning Symposium. I took three pieces and placed them in the gallery. There was only one other person who had boxes in the gallery. It was interesting to stand in the area and hear the comments about them. In general I was very pleased. But the highlight of the event for me was when Dick Sing gave me a critique and then followed it up with pointers on how to do some of the things he talked about while looking at my boxes. He was very approachable and very helpful. To my knowledge there was no formal critique session at this symposium.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
keith tompkins
>Hi Steve, First, I would certainly bring any pieces you have....many turners leave their pieces home, only to regret not having them in the IG.
In most symposiums, including Totally Turning, there just isn't time to do a formal critique on every piece. Usually two or three of the invited demonstrators are asked to perform the critique; they go through the IG in advance selecting those pieces they feel merit attention. They usually follow AAW guidelines, and the comments are positive and informative. Sometimes suggestions are made concerning ways a piece can be improved...David Ellsworth and Michael Hosaluk are among the very best in that regard.
It can be discouraging if someone's work isn't selected for the critique....it's not easy to watch someone walk past your work without a comment. Unfortunately, there just isn't time to review every piece, and pieces selected for critique will depend on who's performing the critique that day. It is perfectly acceptable to approach them later and ask for a private critique....most will be glad to do so. There are also many skilled turners on hand to bounce questions off as well.
The purpose of the critique is to function as a learning tool, but it is certainly an honor to have a piece selected. In Louisville, only 30 out of 1300 pieces were selected....it was even worse in Portland, where there were 1500 pieces, I believe. A critique at the national level gives exposure to one's work that would be difficult to achieve otherwise.
One of my favorite things to do at any symposium is to walk through the IG, selecting my favorites....then, see how my selections fared in the critique...I may be a bit biased here, but I feel the IG at Totally Turning compares favorably with any other symposium I've attended, including the national events.
Bring examples of your work....you'll be glad you did.! I look forward to meeting you there.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Ric Taylor
>Absolutely. If I'm there, my pieces are in the instant gallery. For me, the instant gallery is the best part of any symposium.
There is nothing to be afraid of. Nobody is going to point and laugh.
After awhile, the focus of your local club becomes pretty narrow, you hear the same comments over and over. At a symposium, you are exposed to fresh ideas and perspectives. It's a great way to receive praise as well as constructive criticism, and broaden the way you view your own work.
Some of my best friendships in woodturning were started with a conversation about my pieces or his/her pieces in the instant gallery.
Get the most out of your symposium experience, put your pieces on the table. You won't regret it.
Ric
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>Sure,
I bring a few pens and place them in the IG. I also put a price on them, unless I don't want to sell them then I just list them as Not For Sale. But, I like to sell my work....LOL.
Exposure of your work is always good to help get feedback, feedback can make you better.
take care,
Jim
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>I would like to encourage you to take a piece or two for display in the Instant Gallery. Do it without expectations, but rather as a means of saying "This is what I do well.". Good things can happen.
At OVWG two years ago I was amazed when Jamie Donaldson bought one of my boxes in the IG. I took two and sold three.
At the Yankee Symposium in June I took a nice zebrawood platter, a red mallee double natural-edged bowl (a la Jimmy Clewes), a cherry goblet, and a couple of sea urchin ornaments. I was dumbfounded when Michael Hosaluk and Jimmy Clewes got to Table #3 during their critique and Michael made a beeline for the zebrawood platter. He had clearly done his homework beforehand because he knew just what he wanted to say. His kind words about the design and execution made the Symposium for me. And, before the critique began I saw someone looking at my work and he clearly wanted to take the last card I had there. I knew there were more in the box under the table so I told him to take it and proceeded to get out more cards. As it turned out he wanted the info because he wanted whoever made those things to do a club demo. So, good things can happen when you least expect it. I knew how good the zebrawood platter was, but I really didn't expect anyone else to notice it. Someone else came up and said he liked the goblet best of all. The unsolicited comments can be very rewarding and extremely helpful.
At one Symposium I attended, the critiquers clearly selected the work of their local hosts to discuss. I felt that some other good work was overlooked, but the hard work of these hosts was rewarded nicely. In the end, it probably didn't matter, but I realized that one should evaluate the critique and take it for what it is worth.
Ed
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>I took my VERY first bowl to the Florida Symposium this January. It was selected for critique by John Jordan (if I remember correctly). I was congratulated on it's shape. It had a round bottom, instead of the square corner that is found so often in early turning attempts. His few words to an almost beginning turner were worth the whole price and effort of attending.
Bill in WNC mountains
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>.. Instant Galleries as fertile hunting grounds for pieces I liked for my collection. Used to be able to find some real bargains until nearly everyone caught on to that action!!! ;-)))
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Mostly I do. Exposure, yes. Sales, yes. The big symposia are good exposure. Donating to the Auctions of AAW - your Best Pieces, not just something that you would give away, is tremendous exposure.
Mark
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>I usually bring something to the IG. I'll be there this weekend at TT2007. Looking forward to meeting all you WC folks. I mostly bring things for fun as I am not that serious of a turner, just a hobbyist.
See ya there !
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
keith zimmerman, Normal, IL
>Steve, my first "symposium" was the End-o-Badger fest that became IndyFest. At that first get-together, I did not take anything for the IG. I regretted it immediately. Ever since, I have taken a few pieces. I like the exposure and any discussions that might arise about my work or someone else's often leads to a new learning opportunity.
keithz
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Galler
david
>Portland was my first AAW symposium, and it was not my first stop on a multi-stop trip, so size and space was a problem. I wavered, but finally decided to submit a small bowl NFS in the IG. The small size and the single piece relegated my work in the back of a grouping of other single pieces by other turners. My piece looked lost and I made a mental note to myself: Next time, submit either a larger piece or multiple pieces. Since my work is influenced by the strong forms of Bill Luce's pieces, the highlight of the symposium for me was getting up the nerve to ask Bill for a critique, which he graciously did with honesty and frankness. I think my work since Portland has improved as a result. Without my IG piece, this kind of interaction would not have been possible.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>....To my knowledge there was no formal critique session at this symposium.
At the SWAT symposium in Texas last weekend, there was an entire 1 1/2 hr. session by David Marks, Cindy Drozda and J. Paul Fennell critiquing pieces from the Instant Gallery.
Re: Poll: Do you bring your work to Instant Gallery?
>Jerry, that is correct. At lunch on Saturday, Mr. Sing and I were chatting and he said he wanted to see my work. After lunch he and I went to the Instant Gallery and he took the time to look at each of my boxes and give me suggestions on how I might improve my work. I appreciate his suggestions and kindness very much.