Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Posts

Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#1

Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Jim Reasoner

>I was looking at the link on the post about the soft jaws and noticed that the Nova G3 chuck is about $80 less than the talon. They appear to be similar in most details and was wondering if the talon is that much better in quality or anything else. I don't have a 3 jaw chuck and am trying to determine which one is my best bet.

I think both these chucks would handle what I generally turn but I learned long ago- cheaper is not always the best choice.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#2

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Ed in Sptbg.

>Jim, I would personally call it a toss-up. I have both chucks and like them both. As a plus for the Nova, most of the Oneway jaws will fit it.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#3

Bill Blasic

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Bill Blasic

>I do not own a oneway chuck but I would not bad mouth it as I'm sure it is a good chuck. I chose the Nova chucks and I have three of the G3's and they are a very well made chuck. I chose the Nova's because all the jaws fit all the chucks with one exception. That means you can interchange all the jaws (with one exception) between the Super Nova, Super Nova II, G3, Midi and Titan. The one exception being the power jaws for the Titan (three hole)only fit the Titan. I hole heartedly endorse the Nova's as I'm sure owners of Oneways and Vicmarcs do theirs.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#4

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Gordon Seto

>I have Nova chucks because all their jaws (except 1) are interchangeable across the whole Nova chuck line, small to jumbo, old and new. That would save a lot of money.

I like their long nose jaws and pin jaws. They allow me clearance around the head stock to work on the back side of the turning.

I also like the faceplate ring. I can flip my work back and forth without having to remove the faceplate ring immediately like using a regular faceplate. Even the ring is still attached; I can still use my tail stock for support.

Talon has a lot of loyal users; I don't think you can go wrong with Oneway. But if you want to add their bigger chuck - Strongholdl; none of the Talon jaws would fit. That would cost a lot of money.

Gordon

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#5

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Dick Coers

>I've only ever owned Oneway chucks. It started when Nova came up with the "rightie loosey, leftie tightie" chuck key that really seemed an annoyance. I didn't like the way the end of the key flopped around either. The thing that really sold my though was the number of rings inside the chuck jaw for grabbing the stock. The Oneway has 5 sharp rings and the Nova had one that was not as sharp. Seemed that the grip would be alot better. That was in the learning days and grip was a big deal for me. Glad to say that the catches are alot fewer these days, but I'm still a Oneway fan.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Mike Stafford

>I have used Nova chucks since I bought the original Nova on closeout, tommy bars and spanner operated. I then bought the original Supernova and subsequently have been adding Supernova II's to my arsenal every chance I get. I have at least one of every jaw set. I have been using the Nova spigot jaws which have multiple sharp serrations internally and an extended jaw length to hold my box spigots. I like the extra clearance the extended jaw provides to access the area near where the jaws clamp on. I have not had a blank come loose from those jaws.

I have had an opportunity to use Oneway Stronghold and Talon chucks and the Vicmarc chucks and they are all good chucks. I guess it is a matter of personal preference and what you get used to....

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#7

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Gordon Seto

>As long as you have all one brand; I won't get more confused. I will have to turn the chuck key other way for recess and tennon anyway.

It is how well the matching of the shoulder that gives strength to the holding power. With Dovetail jaw, you can leave the recess as is on the bottom. With serrated jaw, you always have to take the chuck marks off.

BTW, you can also get the "smooth jaw" as an option on Oneway chucks. Nova also has couple spigot jaws that has sharp teeth. Along with their step jaws, they are my least favorite.

Oneway family has a bigger Cole jaw. To me, I am not a fan of Cole jaws; too many screws to adjust for size and won't work for natural edge. I either use a jam chuck or vacuum for reverse turning.

I don't see a clear winner or loser from any of the major brands. I think Oneway, Vicmarc, Axminster and Nova all make good chucks. You have to choose what is the best for you. Nova gives me more bang for my $$.

Gordon

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Mike Stafford

>Gordon, you are so correct about removing the jaw marks. They are worse when using the serrated spigot jaws but since I turn off that part of my box anyway I am not concerned about the damage that is done there.

For bowls where the tenon was going to be an integral part of the design I would not recommend the spigot jaws unless you were going to reverse turn the bottom and reshape the spigot/foot.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#9

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

David

>I had pretty much made up my mind to buy the talon (for a Jet mini) but a vendor at one of the wood shows was offering the Nova G3 at a substantial discount. I talked to some of the turning club members who were turning at the show and pretty much got a "six of one, half dozen of the other" response so I bought the Nova. Have had no problems with it. The keyed chuck is easy to use and I've had no slippage with the jaws that wasn't caused by my stupidity (ie a horrendous catch.) Bottom line, I'd let price guide your choice. Don't think you'll go wrong either way.

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#10

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Rick Allen

>I find the Oneway jaws have a better design for holding work securely over a wide range of tenon sizes.

The Nova line of chucks doesn't have an instert which will fit the bigger Oneway lathes. So if there is some hope in your future to get a Oneway lathe then the Nova Chucks can't be adapted to fit. You could use a spindle adapter but that just adds an additional tolerance to the runout.

The chuck spindle adapter for the Oneway chucks have set screws available to lock the chuck on the lathe spindle which can be engaged to prevent an unintended dismount of the chuck. Most folks don't worry about this. I have seen a chuck dismount from a Jet Mini. That caused a LOT of excitement and a trip the emergency room for the gouge the chuck took out of the hand (don't try to catch a spinning flying chuck).

Recap:

Oneway has more secure jaws

Oneway has a broader range of inserts available

Oneway can be locked on the headstock spindle with set screws

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Mike Stafford

>Rick, all of my Nova inserts have a provision for a set screw to lock the chuck to the spindle. Maybe some of the older inserts did not, huh?

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#12

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Gordon Seto

>Adding more chucks is more likely than upgrading to Oneway lathe for most people.

There are plenty of good lathes such as Stubby, Robust, Powermatic, Vicmarc that use 1�" X 8 spindle. I think I can live with one of those.

As to the set screws, it is mostly lathe specific. The Jet mini lathe spindle do not have a flat area for the set screw. If you use the set screw, you may mess up the thread of the lathe spindle.

The Nova insert "L" comes with set screw, is for the Nova DVR lathe that has this feature.

Gordon

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

#13

Re: Nova G3 vs. oneway talon chuch

Fog Tanner

>While I don't have the Talon, I have two Strongholds and most of the jawsets for them. I also have three Vicmarcs, one of the 5 1/2" and two 3 1/2". The chucks I use most are the Vics. I like their feel and operation much better than the Strongholds. I also like the hex key much better than the key on the Stronghold/Talon. It is a standard hex that can replaced if lost by a trip to the local machine supply.

Having had pieces (boxes) come out of the Oneway straight jaws, I did buy dovetail jaws for my Strongholds and this cured that problem - the Vics all came with dovetail jaws. Nowdays for making boxes I use the Shark jaws on my 3 1/2" Vic. Each has their own experince and a lot has to do with how much you push the machine and chuck. I am waiting on the VM150 now for the larger bowls (22"-23") I do. One cannot have enough chucks, you really need to have several to keep from changing jawsets - only problem is they keep coming out with new jaws....

I did look at the Nova you are talking about for my mini. It seemed like a nice chuck, but I got a good deal on a Vicmarc VM90, which is the lever operated 3 1/2" chuck and went that way. I have used the Nova a number of times at the club woodturning retreat and they worked OK and one of the reasons I thought about getting one. It is well worth looking at all of them and comparing them before starting off, if I had I would have five Vics now instead of the three and two Strongholds.