Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

How would you cut this log?

Posts

How would you cut this log?

#1

Ellis Walentine

How would you cut this log?

Ellis Walentine

>Here is a pretty nice looking cherry log I just scored. It's about 30" in diameter and 8' long, with a three-way crotch at the top and burls all the way up. I'm concerned that it may be hollow though. I won't know until I do some poking around with a coring bit or a chainsaw.

My dilemma is this: I don't know whether to cut it up for lumber or for turning blanks. If the log is sound, I'm leaning toward making lumber out of it. My sawmill guy only has a 24" portable band mill, so he'd have to square it before he could cut lumber from it, and that would negate any nice natural-edged slabs that I might get out of it.

There's also a value aspect to this decision. How much would 150bf of cherry burl lumber be worth versus several dozen premium cherry burl turning blanks?

Tough decision, eh? I posted this on the main board and I thought I ought to post it here, too, to get the turner's perspective on how you would hack it up for blanks. If it's hollow and there is only a shell a few inches thick of solid wood, would you cut it into platter blanks? If not, would you make giant salad bowl blanks? Tall blanks centered on the burl features for tall pots?

Dithering in Doylestown,

Ellis



Re: How would you cut this log?

#2

Auction Time!!!!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I'm thinkin' let someone else with a deeper wallet decide how to use the wood. You have a enough things to worry about.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#3

Re: How would you cut this log?

Jerry from Lapel In.

>Send it to IndyFest ,we will take care of it and maybe send you a little piece back.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: How would you cut this log?

Mike Stafford

>I have no advice on how to cut up the log but a little piece large enough for a box turner I know would be looked upon as a charitable act...8)

Also, it looks like poison ivy in the crotch in the second picture. If I were you I would be careful with the poison ivy....

Re: How would you cut this log?

#5

Re: How would you cut this log?

Brent at Robust

>Ellis, because there is no real bowl shape sticking out, I'd suggest starting out cutting thick 4-6" slabs that could be bandsawed into burl-rich, round blanks. You could also cut some thinner slabs for lumber at the same time, kind of making it up as you go depending on the grain.

Good luck with it, looks like fun. Brent

Re: How would you cut this log?

#6

Andy DiPietro

Re: How would you cut this log?

Andy DiPietro

>Hi Ellis,

It is a tough problem. One option is to do both. If you like the Nakashima style crotch tables. You could slab out one or two table 2" thick tops and cut up the rest for turning blanks. The enclosed pictures are crotch walnut table tops from a Nakashima tour a went on.

You will probably need a 3 foot wide mill to do it.

Andy D.


img

Re: How would you cut this log?

#7

Andy DiPietro

Pic2 

Andy DiPietro

>


img

Re: How would you cut this log?

#8

Table slabs of 3"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ellis,

I have a guy on your side of the crik who can do 48" on his traveling Woodmizer. Good sawyer, very nice guy. I'll PM if you like.

I'd to 3" to dry under weight and then have options for resawing and bookmatching when the time comes. I think you'll have more gnarl that burl, and the interlocking grain will explode with grafics when flat-sawn.

mm

Re: How would you cut this log?

#9

Re: With that crotch at the top......

Jamie Donaldson

>...I would bet the void goes quite some distance down onto the trunk. I would crosscut just below the crotch to find out if the trunk is hollow, and probably rip thru the pith to find out more about the worth as flat planks or turning stock.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#10

That rot bothers me.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>My experience with cherry has been that the rot runs a long way inside the tree, both above and below the source of the rot.

You might get some decent 8' boards from the one side and, if you're lucky, some 4' boards from the other side. The rest would be turning stock.

I'd recommend making blanks for the types of items you like to turn. Personally, I'm not into big bowls and platters, so I'd cut most of it for medium bowls and smaller.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#11

Ellis Walentine

I don't get poison ivy

Ellis Walentine

>My wife does though, so I have to sleep on the couch after encountering it. :-)

Re: How would you cut this log?

#12

Re: How would you cut this log?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Ellis, if you plan on being there when the log is cut that is the best time to decide. I have often cut both from the same log. If there is rot, it will soon become apparent. Around here a cherry log of that size would probably have shake. How long has it bee down?

Re: How would you cut this log?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Yeah, I sorta was thinking about that

Ellis Walentine

>I lopped the three-way crotch off this afternoon and there are definitely some good slabs in there, even with the one hollow stem.

The hollow goes all the way to the base of the tree and is about 6" - 8" in diameter, but the wood all around it is solid as a rock. There should be some five-foot slabs and some dandy quartersawn (or flatsawn boards) and probably a bunch of turning blanks left over. Maybe I'll auction them here on WC to try to bring in some income for the treasury.

Thanks for the feedback. Thanks to all of you for the good feedback, as I don't have time to respond to everyone individually.

I'll keep you posted on progress.

Ellis

Re: How would you cut this log?

#14

Re: I don't get poison ivy

Carole Valentine

>Neither did I until about a year ago. Have ignored it my entire life until then. You can bet I don't ignore it any more. You can become sensitized to it, Ellis, so best to take care when removing it.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#15

Ellis Walentine

Exactly what I did, Jamie (see post above)

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: How would you cut this log?

#16

Steven Antonucci

2.3M pen blanks (save sawdust for animal bedding)

steve antonucci

>

Re: How would you cut this log?

#17

Ellis, I would not bother with sawing for lumber

Keith Newton

>I can tell you that any board will likely have the grain running more through the thickness than down the length. When this is the case, it will end up being so twisted and warped, that it will be worthless for anything other than small turnings or firewood.

If you notice, where you have a root-buttress on the near end of your photo, there is a ridge which spirals up to the right. If you knock some of the bark off with a hammer, and look closely, you will be able to actually see the cells, and they are likely even more slanted than those ridges.

If you want to see what the lumber will look like when it starts drying and splitting, send me an email, and I will take some shots of some that looked better than that before sawing. In fact, I will send you some real cheap. Ha,

On the other-hand, there will be some fine figure for turning vessels. Although, even then, most people are not astute enough to appreciate that as much as the maker of such things as the makers. Good luck K

Re: How would you cut this log?

#18

Yikes, is the treasury low?

JKJ in East TN

>>Maybe I'll auction them here on WC to try to

>bring in some income for the treasury.

Thanks for the reminder to donate again (for those of us who haven't signed up for the recurring donation). It's easy to get busy and forget.

JKJ

Re: How would you cut this log?

#19

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: I don't get poison ivy

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Neither did I until about a month ago. I've been aroundit, off and on, for all my 62 years, and never had a problem with it. Then, about a month ago, I accidently got into a patch of it with my weed wacker, and evidently got some of the sap/oil on my legs.

Everything from the top of my socks to the hem of my shorts was inflamed. It's just now going away. Lots of Benydril lotion, etc. has been used!

Jim D.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#20

ebd

Re: How would you cut this log?

ebd

>I would take my chain saw and rip right up the pith. Once that is done you can see what you've got and make better decisions. You have to cut the pith out anyway. Why not get a peek inside?

Re: How would you cut this log?

#21

Ellis Walentine

Fall fund-raising *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>Hi folks,

Apropos of JKJ's post, I see an opportunity to toot a horn that I have not tooted for a while because I absolutely hate to ask for donations. Call it pride, call it stubborness, whatever. But, as many of our longstanding visitors know, this site relies on you as well as our advertisers. Our ad revenues alone fall way short of paying all the bills plus a living wage for me and my part time secretary and our part time sales guy, much less anything for our loyal corps of volunteers without whom this site would absolutely not exist, at least in its present form. We all rely on outside revenue to buy us the time it takes to keep WoodCentral afloat and alive.

So, in case you're so inclined, any and all donations, recurring donations through PayPal, hat or t-shirt purchases, benefit auction item donations or donations in kind are appreciated more than you know.

Looking forward to a great woodworking season coming up,

Ellis

PS It may interest you to know that there were 2,898 turning messages posted in August alone, and the total number of turning messages read in August was 477,966. That's an average of 165 "reads" per post. Total messages read on all boards was 1,315,391. And August is a slow month; January figures are about 40% higher in any given year. That's a lot of traffic and I think it says something about the quality of the people who make up this community. I'm proud to have you all be part of it.


Support WoodCentral!

Re: How would you cut this log?

#22

Ellis Walentine

I don't know, Barb

Ellis Walentine

>... how long it has been down, that is, but there is some end checking, so I suspect it has been a while. I cut the three-way crotch off yesterday and was pleasantly surprised to find that the center rot is only about 6" in diameter and runs more or less straight down the tree. There is a lot of solid wood on all sides of it.

I am trying to get in touch with a guy who has a 42" band mill. I want to split the log adjacent to the rot first to see what the flat-sawn figure is like. From there, it should be easier to figure out what to do with the rest. No matter what, there's going to be a lot of turning wood when it's over. I'll let y'all know, since I don't have much time to turn these days. Too much going on.

Thanks for the advice.

Ellis

Re: How would you cut this log?

#23

You haven't lived until you have

Don Henthorn

>squatted over the top of a kerosene lamp in the middle of the night trying to relieve the itch of poison ivy all over your crotch and private parts. Such was life on the farm back in the 1920's. I can still feel that heat.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#24

split that there log

JKJ in East TN

>>I want to split the log adjacent to the rot first

>to see what the flat-sawn figure is like.

A discussion a few years ago on a sawmilling forum discussed a simple common "old time" method of splitting a very large log. Several people wrote that they occasionally use this technique today to split logs too large to fit on their mills.

It involved chainsawing a pocket into the side of the log (near one end, if I rememember correctly), filling with gunpowder, then setting it off with a fuse. This is supposed to work well but is reported to be a little noisy so earplugs might be advisable.

One gentleman had this further advice: "...you can never use too much fuse..."

JKJ