Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Beware of what you ask for

Posts

Beware of what you ask for

#1

Beware of what you ask for

Russ Fairfield

>During all of the discussion of TD, the AAW, and this forum, I have read more than just a few complaints about the old-timers here on WC. These complaints have ranged from their work getting preferential treatment when pictures are posted, to the fact that nobody ever contrdicts their advice.

This message is directed at those who have complained.

It is that very mix of old-timers, experienced woodturners, intermediate, and beginners who have made Wood Central the useful and popular forum that it is. It has made it the best place on the Internet for a beginner and intermediate woodturner to get a reliable answer to their questions. That there is often more than one answer, and sometimes conflicting answers, only proves that woodturning is not an exact science and that there always more than one way to get almost anything done.

Telling the old-timers on this site to shut up and go away is asking for the destruction of the very thing you appreciate about Wood Central. Should all of the old-timers take your advice and leave, there will only be beginners talking to beginners, and there will be nobody to give experienced advice and guidance. Is that what you really want Wood Central to become?

Many of the experienced woodturners have already left because of this same attitude you have expressed in your recent threads. I am sure TD will think twice before he answers another question about anything; and I am sure that I am not the only one who is wondering why I am still here.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#2

Re: Well stated, you old curmudgeon!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#3

Steven Antonucci

Exactly

steve antonucci

>I'll take the good TD with the bad TD any day over no TD...

Steven

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#4

Re: Beware of what you ask for

Barry Irby

>Many companies have a policy of laying off the old timers (higher paid) and hiring newbies with in come cases college degrees or other training that appeared to make them qualified. The companies thought they were lowering employee expense by hiring new lower paid workers who were less risk on the health care, got less vacation and other benefits, etc. What has come back to haunt them is that they fired the knowledge base that got them where they are.

So, I would appreciate it is all you old timers would stick around and answer my questions. I will sort out the contradictory answers and then do what I wanted to do to start with, but at least I will know where I went wrong.

So, anyone who has ever helped me, Thank You.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#5

Re: It is often the injection of......

Jamie Donaldson

>...personalities and personal conflicts that taint the atmosphere of any gathering of homo sapiens, and WC is no different. If we could just leave the cults of personality out of the discussions we would all be better able to openly communicate in a civilized manner, and without competition.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#6

Re: Exactly

Don in Central Illinois

>I whole heartedly agree.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#7

Re: Beware of what you ask for

Bill Crommett

>Is this a continuation of the old thread, or is this another "Bitch " ?

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#8

Re: Be positive- it's a new day.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... and a new thread.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Beware of what you ask for

keith tompkins

>Russ, I've tried to stay out of this mess, but you bring up a point that cannot be stressed enough. It is unfortunate, but there are many, many skilled turners who no longer post at this site.

When I served as moderator of this site, I stressed that all opinions concerning woodturning were welcome here. I believed that this forum could be a place for the meaningful exchange of ideas, and an excellent place for sharing openly. Sadly, my optimism was short-lived.

As a professional woodworker and turner with a strong design background, I believed I had something of value to contribute to this site. Yet, each time I posted a thread on design principles or a similar topic, I came to regret it due to the negativity that followed. One contributor even went so far as to ask that I be permanently banned from this site simply because of the artistic content of my posts!

Want my opinion on which lathe to buy? What grind to use? Grinder speed? Sure, no problem! However,if you're looking for meaningful advice, honest critique, or help with design problems you'll have to sign up for one of my classes. I can no longer comfortably share my opinions here.

The many good friends I've made here have made it worthwhile to still hang around.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#10

I'll have to side with Russ and Keith

david

>and jump in here too. Also, for the record, all my interactions with TD have been positive ones.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#11

Re: And I have received posts.....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. taking me to task(and worse!) because I called Russ a curmudgeon! I have met Russ, and have high admiration for him and his wealth of knowledge. His brain has deleted more info than I will ever be able to learn, and I always use curmudgeon as a term of respect. Few will ever gain the skills and wisdom of age to achieve this title in my eyes, and if Russ is offended he certainly can tell me so himself without the intervention of others.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#12

I've seen forums like that.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I monitored a number of forums before settling on my current set. There was one fairly active forum had very few experienced turners and it evolved into a chatty forum about woodturning. It seemed to meet the members needs, but it had only a small fraction of the information content that WoodCentral does.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#13

Re: And I have received posts.....

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I bet they were from the younger set raised on "Political Correctness". Whatever happened to honest discourse?

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#14

Re: Beware of what you ask for

jeff myroup

>I find it very sad that a few bad apples have ruined it for the rest of us. I don't post alot, because I don't know alot. I have learned everything I know about turning from the internet and books. Mostly the net, not only the forums but individual websites that demonstrate various techniques. The post you made some time ago about finial design has helped my progress greatly. I hope some day I can give back. I guess all I am saying is that it is a sad day when the veterans stop posting because of all the BS. Although I have never met any of you, I have always found you, and the rest of the veterans of this site, honest and willing to help. Thank you.

Jeff

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#15

You Have Got To Be Kidding!!!!!!!!!!.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Bring called a curmudgeon aftr reaching a certain age is a complement.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#17

I had to laugh at that, Jamie,

Dinyar Chavda

>as I consider myself an acolyte to Russ in many areas, including that of being a curmudgeon. In fact, my private e-mails to him are often signed as "YOCIT", (ye olde curmudgeon-in-training). You will notice the "e" at the end of "olde"---I had to reach a certain level of proficiency before Russ informed me that I had earned the right to spell "old" that way!

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#18

Re:The "e" is required when ...

Jamie Donaldson

>....preceeded by a "ye!" ;-)))

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#19

Sometimes I need a cheerleader, sometimes a critic

Joe Pack

>Keith, I haven't yet posted my work here asking for critiques, but, when I eventually do, it will be because I want honest, constructive feedback to help me improve. If you, or any other experienced "old f***" tell me an angle could be improved or a foot is out of balance, I will appreciate it and thank you for your help.

On the other hand, if I post my work here and say, "Wow, look at what I made! I'm so proud!!!" I would hope the people who know what they are talking about would either say something nice (or at least neutral) or say nothing at all.

Either way, although I am finally old enough to be an old f*** my self, I am still naieve enough to believe that most folks are decent enough not to "flame" me for my efforts. I am naieve by choice, preferring to think the best of people as long as I can. For the record, if I ever ask a question about a technique or ask for an experienced opinion, I would be upset only if you didn't answer. As long as the answer is constructive and meant to help me improve, I can handle and appreciate it. I think the vast majority of people here do just that.

Thanks in advance.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#21

Re: You Have Got To Be Kidding!!!!!!!!!!.

Jerry Whitaker

><

I hope so Barbara. About 2 years before I retired, my boss referred to me as the Old Grizzled Curmudgeon. Not sure I like the "OLD" part.

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#22

Re: Jerry. Just had to post this... :)

Allen Neighbors

>Main Entry: cur�mud�geon

Pronunciation: (")k&r-'m&-j&n

Function: noun

Etymology: origin unknown

1 archaic : MISER

2 : a crusty, ill-tempered, and usually old man

- cur�mud�geon�li�ness /-lE-n&s/ noun

- cur�mud�geon�ly /-lE/ adjective

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Sometimes I need a cheerleader, sometimes a cr

keith tompkins

>Joe , we are in agreement except one tiny thing.....I'M NOT OLD!!!!! he he. I'd be glad to help you any time!

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#24

Re: Jamie, I wear the title proudly

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: Beware of what you ask for

#25

Re: Russ- I suspected as much! You're a ...

Jamie Donaldson

>... fine specimen of the genre, but not yet in a class with Andy Rooney from CBS!