Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

"Finding your Voice"....

Posts

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#26

I know my voice, its Alto

Ron in Drums PA

>This reminds me of a very old story.

There was this college dorm at a music school and the students there would practice their instruments day and night.

There was this one student who would only play a b-flat on his cello. Day and night, night and day he would play this one single note over and over again.

After a while this began to get on the nerves of the other students, "What does he think he is doing?" "This single note is driving me nuts!" "He will never become a pro if he continues this way." "What is he crazy or something"

A group of students decided to have a talk with the b-flat cello guy. "Hey, why are you always playing the same note, it's driving us nuts!" they demanded to know.

B-flat cello guy stops playing for a moment, looks up and says, "While all of you are searching for the perfect note, I've found it." He then continues to play his perfect note.

----

Stop worrying about these catch phases.

If you see a technique or a finished piece that touches a chord inside of you, try it, explore it, even build on it.

Sometimes trying to "Finding Your Voice" gets in the way. Besides most of the time it finds you while you are busy talking to the wood.

Enjoy!

___

PS, Chet Akins is an awesome guitarist!

I'll bet he found his voice not because he was looking for it, but because he throughly enjoys what he was doing.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#27

Tell us what you really think, Barbara!! LOL

Ruth Niles

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#28

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

ET

>Other craft media, like glass, pottery, quilting, weaving, etc. have been around for a long time, Hundreds of years. There are shapes, patterns and surface designs that were developed and modified so long ago that they are considered to be "classic". Originator unknown. Today people who work in these media can reproduce these classic designs without offending or plagiarising any known maker. Or the craft/artist can strike out on their own and develop something "new". A good example that immediatley springs to mind is Dale Chihully (glass).

Woodturning is so new that the "classic" shapes or designs have been made by craft/atists who are still alive and making their own classic pieces. Therefore, we feel the pressure to make something new and different. Even though Rude Osolnick is deceased, we don't feel right about reproducing his classic candle holder shapes and offering them as our own classic reproductions. ET

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#29

Well said, Brian.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#30

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

Carole Valentine

>Speaking of nothing new...I was watching one of the extras on the Jimmy Clews video where he takes you to a museum of artifacts from an ancient Roman fort. Among them were a small turned wooden box and a sewing kit very similar to the ones John made. Both were, I believe, over 2000 years old.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#31

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

Don O.

>Another interesting topic for discussion Keith. I found my voice recently-yelling at a piece to stop catching my tools and tearing out the grain !! ;-))

I think others have expressed it better than I ever could. I like Ruth's take on the subject very much. Honest and to the point. I wish I had more time to search for the signature style to call my own. I have yet to even try some of the "standard" projects that I want to work on. I'm lucky that I don't have to make my living at turning since I would be broke, but it allows me to turn what makes me happy. If I'm fortunate enough that someone likes my work enough to give me money and take it home, that's a bonus. My brain does not work like most truly creative artist's. I am more of a literal, linear thinker. I am a technician, not an innovator. I have no problem with that. My wife is a more figurative and divergent thinker. Somehow we manage to get along anyway.

I have been exposed to and inspired by many wonderful artists/craftspeople, yourself included. I can only hope their work has stuck with me to stimulate the creative juices someday so that I can create something special and unique. I'm still struggling with good form and fair curves. I marvel at those who have the creativity and motivation to have found their "voice" or "style" or whatever they want to call it.

I can turn a bowl. Will it ever be confused with a Bill Neddow masterpiece? Hardly. I can turn a hollow form. Will it ever be confused with the perfection of Ellsworth? Not a chance. Plagiarism? Not here. Emmulation? Absolutely! Signature? Doubtful. Happy? You bet!!! Works for me.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#32

Oh darn are those romans copying me again.

john lucas

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#33

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

Fog Tanner

>I went to the Dead Sea Scrolls exhibt a few years ago, in one of the cases were some items from the period and area where the scrolls were written. All of the items were objects used for daily activity, some were pottery vessels and there were several turned wooden bowls. The wood is dark from 2000 years of age, almost black, but the shapes are ones that you will find at almost any club's show and tell.

Going back another 2000-3000 years, you will find the same shapes in Egypt and Babylon. But, what I find interesting are those objects which they have pieced back together, as they are always found shattered. When glued up, a number of them are just plain ugly and most probably the reason they were shattered. Of course another use for some of those were "offerings" where they were shattered. I find it humerous that there are some that are "looking for their own voice", that they are using that "voice" which was considered ugly 4000 years ago. There is a reason no one has used that "voice" for the last 4000 years and why it was shattered in the first place. But, that goes along with some of those that have "found their voice", which can also be found in shapes from 4000-5000 years ago. Which just shows that the ancient Egyptians and Babylonians had no problem copying our "voices". Should have known when they said that their inspiration came from watching some princess walking down the Nile, that it was really a piece from an instant gallery......

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#34

Re: "Finding your Voice".... *LINK*

Edgar Davidson

>For those of you who haven't seen the short video - Binh Pho�s tribute to Frank Sudol - you should have a look. A large part of Frank's message in the video deals with this subject, and the underling questions or issues. I like the way Frank has verbalized his philosophy on life, art, copying, and yes...finding your own voice...link below.

Best regards,

Ed D.


Tribute

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#35

No, I Better Not :-)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#36

Not to be confused with...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>and totally unrelated to deer berries and rabbit berries (droppings).

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#37

Steve Kubien

Mostly my voice says...

Steve Kubien

>..."What the bleep were you thinking?!?!?! That was really bleepin' dumb.

Lately my 'voice' has been saying, you made another wide-bottomed bowl, now fix it!

Steve Kubien

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#38

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

RonZ

>The Jimmey Clewes video also showed a box with a spinning top as a cover. I knew someone who will go nameless that said he invented it even though he got it from Bonnie Klein. Bonnie showed that the elsworth grind existed about 100 years ago. Etc., etc.

With that said, one of the things I do for a living is make Torah rollers known in Hebrew as 'aitz chaim', the tree of life. While this has been made for a few thousand years with various styles and shapes, I doubt I'm doing anything new. One of my newest commissions is to make the Torah rollers out of purple heart. So unless they dig one of those up, that might be original.....

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#39

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

john lucas

>We seem to be talking about 2 different things. Finding your own voice or style is totally different than copying and that is different than plagerism. Finding your own voice is simply something that some of us want to do to set ourselves apart from the rest. This isn't an ego thing necessarily and certainly not required to sell your work. It's simply a desire to add your own personal touch to what you do.

Copying in my mind at least is simply that. Copying something to learn how it's done, to work with the forms and see why they work and to learn the techniques required to make that piece and to learn new skills. Nothing at all wrong with that and that is the way we learn.

Plagerism is purposely trying to immulate someone elses style in order to sell your own work. This doesn't mean turning a bowl or vessel that looks like the Romans or greeks made, this is purposely copying a very specific style to try and make a profit off of someone elses hardwork.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#40

Personally, I think it's "finding your rut"

Craig Daymon

>I enjoy turning most when I am trying new things, seeing new shapes and angles to approach. Some well known turners seem to stick with that one recognizeable shape/style with only slight variations. Maybe because those forms sell better, but that only reminds me of rock bands that tour for years playing the same old tunes because those are the tunes the fans want to hear. I do have to say (and there is nothing wrong with this) that I have met more turners that are driven by what they can sell lots of more than what new form they can create.

I like the artists that can't sit still and wants to try new things. Mike Kehs comes to mind, as he's a member of our local group. He is known internationally for his inside-out works, but in the last year alone he has explored variations on Bin's thin wall designs, some wonderful turned mirrors with carved cave-scapes and a variety of terrific hollowforms...an area he proclaimed a lack of skill only about 6 months ago.

Another name to watch for is Derek Weidman (boy, I hope I spelled that right). He has been working on multi-axis turnings that he enhances with an incredible ability to carve. He is taking classes with Mark Sfirri and recently did a collaborative piece with Jacques Vesery. He's also VERY young for a turner (still a college student...in other words, he hasn't retired yet). This guy has real talent!

Side note: Dom, you missed a great demo at Dave's.

Anyway, I'm more impressed when a turner can show me something new.

-Craig

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#41

Re: What are "wheat berries"?

Allen Neighbors

>Barbara, you rock, Girl!!!!

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#42

Re: Mostly my voice says...

Arch

>For me this perennial subject's "second, third, fourth ---->infinite verses, same as the first". They always end up saying "shut up and turn". The more talented can turn and talk. I can barely turn and chew gum!

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#43

Re: Yea Bill !!! :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#44

Thanks Allen :-)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#45

It is two different things, John, but

Ruth Niles

>it seems the woodturners who are using that term are the professionals or more famous turners who are actually saying "do your own thing and stop copying mine."

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#46

Re: It is two different things, John, but

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If a turner is good to copy Binh Pho or J. Paul Fennell or Jacques Vesary they're good enough to have their own style to do whatever they want to do.

Wally

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#47

Keith Tompkins

Re: Personally, I think it's "finding your rut"

keith tompkins

>Craig, I met Derek at the "Mother Goose" gallery in Portland. He showed me a few of his multi-axis pieces, and asked me to critique them. I was quite impressed with the three pieces I examined...although he's only 26, and fairly new to turning, he's not at all intimidated by any of it. He knows what he wants to produce, then goes ahead and does it. He's someone to watch!

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#48

Keith Tompkins

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

keith tompkins

>HI Dinyar, I've thought the same thing...many turnings sure resemble pottery pieces I've seen.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#49

Keith Tompkins

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

keith tompkins

>Hey Ed, There may be nothing new under the sun, but I'd bet Moses would have loved to get his hands on a GPS unit.

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

#50

Keith Tompkins

Re: "Finding your Voice"....

keith tompkins

>Dave, I share similar memories of my visit to David's a few years back. I enjoyed the talks around the dinner table, the critiques, and his outlook on our craft. It soon becomes apparent why he's a giant in the turning field.