>is a phrase we hear frequently as turners, and judging by some recent comments on WC, is pretty annoying to many of us.
I think the phrase is interchangeable with "developing your own style", and it is something artists in many fields strive to achieve.
As an example, I studied guitar for several years, so I'm aware that most players strive to develop a recognizeable style of their own. In many cases, it's easy to recognize a guitarist after listening to just a few notes being played....BB King, Eric Clapton, Mark Knoffler, Chet Atkins, (to name a few) each have a distinct style. Thousands of players have emulated their playing styles.
In flat woodworking the name Sam Maloof is another good example of someone with a distinct style, whose work has influenced many. He found his voice long ago.
I think aspiring turners are faced with a similar situation...in order to gain name recognition, acceptance in good galleries, etc., we need to develop a recognizeable style as well. After all, there is a lot of competition out there. Works by Bin Pho or Jacques Vesery are good examples of this....their pieces are instantly recognizeable to nearly all turners, and are highly sought after by collectors.
How many turners are trying to "find their voice", and how many think the term is just so much esoteric nonsense...? I'm Curious, since I spend quite a bit of time on the subject in my demos and classes.
I think that a large part of it is driven by pressure from the galleries. From their viewpoint (which is quite reasonable), it is a lot easier to sell a 2nd Binh Pho that is recognizably a Binh Pho, than one that is totally different.
Secondly, I think it is a matter of personality. There are some who get bored doing the same thing, or variations on a theme, while others see that as a step towards perfection, and enjoy the exploration of nuances.
I find that the impulses that drove me in my professional life (AADD) have as strong an influence on how I approach turning.
Finally, it should be noted that in several cases where the work is recognizably that of a turner, if you expand the field to include other media, it may no longer be so unique. In such cases, has the person "found his/her voice", or just copied someone else from another field before others in the turning world became aware of it, perhaps, unconsciously so?
I attended a class at Dave Ellsworth's place a few years ago. I got some good info, but I wished I had taken it a few years before. Many of the things he was teaching I had already learned. This is not to say it was not worth it, but I was already pretty set in my ways by then.
The best part of the whole weekend was the breaks for lunch and dinner. To be able to pick the brain of a pioneer in the field of woodturning was awesome. I learned so much about the intangibles from Dave, marketing, finding your voice... or style, was a part of every food break. But the thing I remember the most was his wonderful collection of works from other artists in his home. There were pieces from almost everyone I had ever admired in the field of woodturning.
I began to play a little game with myself. I tried to look at the piece and decide who had made it before I turned it over to see the name. I found I was correct on about 99% of the pieces. So I do feel that there is a style to all the greats working in turned wood. At least the ones I have admired for so many years.
I guess for me, it is ok to try to find that voice. We have several people that post here that have done just that.
To me, it is not a inside joke. It's what I strive for. But you know... that is just my humble opinion. :)
Best wishes,
Dave
PS.. The best piece I saw at Dave's was the thin plate turned by Del Stubbs that had to be signed with a needle because it was too thin to be signed with a pen. It would have bled through. :)
>Hi Keith, As I seem to be the culprit that started this thread,I will say,I have no problem with doing as they say"findin...................vo... Many of us work toward that goal.Whether that is what we will really want if we actually get there is another thing to discuss sometime.I think what I find offensive is just the phrase itself.Somehow I find it pretentious(we dont get to use big words like that up here in cold north very often)when someone tells us that we should strive to reach that goal.Sort of like we dont have enough brain cells to figure it out without help.Personally,I make whatever I feel like making,and if there is a bit of someone elses design lodged in the back of my mind because I saw and liked a piece,I dont feel that I have to search the archives to be sure I didnt use "someone elses inspiration".If we put a picture of something that someone else has made in our shop and look at it while we are turning,with the intent of copying,then we had better take up another pastime.Lets see where this leads?Ruth, any ideas?
>term that divides turners into two groups. There was a lot of discussion a couple of years ago about copying. There are a fair number of people who do demonstrations and produce books and DVD's for most of their income. Most of these folks realize that turners are going to learn from them and they expect others to make pieces like the pieces that they teach/demonstrate. The fine line is somewhere between producing a few similar pieces for a local market and trying to place similar pieces in the national market and in well-known galleries.
I think that the rub for some is the sense that some who use the term are trying to have it both ways. They want the income from teaching the skills and style, but they expect others not to try similar pieces.
The book by Chris Stott, "Turned Boxes, 50 Designs" presents an interesting logical situation. In the book he makes a strong case against copying. Of course many of the designs are copies of the work of others, some of whom receive credit in the book and some seem to be overlooked. But the question I have is "Does Chris now think that he owns those designs and others must keep hands off?". He includes detailed drawings with dimensions, so I see the book as encouraging turners to make copies of these boxes. Of course these boxes are going to be sold.
I would recommend against the over-use of the phrase "finding one's voice" and use terms that say what you really mean. Somehow "finding your own style" is a much nicer phrase and it lacks the smarminess that the first one seems to have associated with it.
>Finding your voice implies that 1. you have something to say 2. It is worth saying 3. Others will recognize what you are saying 4. Your pieces state that particular message.
It's all very stifling having only one thing to say.
Maybe we should just strive to produce things that are aesthetically stimulating in some way (not always the same way) and have some aspect to them which is relatively unique. Note that I said "relatively" because otherwise, nobody could produce anything.
>I guess I come from the same musical background as Keith, Chet Atkins was my hero and to this day can tell that he's the one playing just by hearing a few notes. In Photography it is the same thing. You see a ton of good photos out their but it is fairly easy to recognize a certain artist by his style. Ansel Adams, Eliot Porter and Robert Glen Ketchum come to mind. I was in an art gallery in Nashville and saw an incredible photo from Alaska. I thought man that looks like a Robert Glen Ketchum style shot. Sure enough it was.
Woodturning is no different. You can (and I obviously do) turn just about anything you want and that's perfectly fine. Most turners out there making a living are doing just that. However if you want to differentiate yourself from all the other turners then you have to develop a style that is your own. Someone coined the phrase "find your own voice" (possibly Frank Sudol). Unfortunately it came along about the same time that everyone was talking about copying other peoples work so to many people the frase came to mean don't copy my work. I don't think that is how the phrase was intended. I think it means just what it says, find your own voice.
Many people copy the famous artists. That's how we learn and I think David Ellsworth spoke about that very thing in an article not to long ago. I have two friends who studied under Binh Pho. Both made pieces that were easily confused with Binh's. Now several years later you can see their work and can easily see the influence of Binh Pho but (here it comes) they have found their own voice and you can see that they have injected their personality in the pieces and made them their own.
This is a great hobby and great artform. As a practitioner you can feel free to go at it any way you want. If all you want to do is collect tools (damn that's getting close to home) then that's fine. If you want to make the same bowls over and over, that's fine. Do what makes you happy. Personally I love to see it all.
>I mostly have trouble lowering my voice! I never lost it of course, and often it can be heard lampooning the pretensions of those guilty of windbaggery.
I make what I want to make when I get the time to make it. Often I am making something someone else is paying me to make, and they are not interested in my voice except to hear it on the phone telling them their stuff is ready.
Count me as one of those turners that think the phrase is nonsense. Having been through the corporate school of "buzz words", I'm sick of hearing them. "Cross functional temas", "Pushing the Paradyne", "Levering low hanging fruit",....BAH!
Your work is what you put into it. As you progress in skill level you start to put more and more of your own touches on your work. For some this comes easier than others. No amount of staring at the wood, trying to "feel the art inside" is going to accomplish what skill, practice, and immagination can.
>There's nothing new under the sun. Intentionally or unintentionally, all of us are just combining forms and features that have been done before. The differences are in the good or bad executions of those combinations. John Lucas is right. "This is a great hobby and art form....Do what makes you happy."
>I would like to start by stating that "finding your own voice" has nothing to do with plagiarism (to me). Plagiarism is the act of intentionally copying someone else's work for your own "profit".
There is nothing wrong with copying someone else's work for your own personal collection or skills development. "Plagairism" happens cross mediums (turners copy potters, nature, etc.), but in each and every piece of wood lies enough difference to make any object unique.
"Finding a voice" is as others have pointed out, a funny way of saying developing your own style. I'm like Bill Grumbine- I make what I want, when I want, with whatever I've got. You'd be hard pressed to walk into a gallery and "recognize" one of my pieces as "an Antonucci". Finding a voice just means creating a style that becomes associated with one's larger body of work.
Whatever we decide to call it, I do think that there is value in "branding" one's work if your motive is to market and sell pieces. For the collector, it's a bit of status to have someone look at a piece, and know it's "an Antonucci" without having to touch it. (I did the same thing at David Ellsworth's place when I took the class- 99% right...)
I'm still "working on a bucket of ripe tomatoes" (doesn't sound as highbrow as "finding my own voice", right?)...
>As to the actual phrase, I agree with Mac, it's just offensive to (most) of our intelligence. It actually makes me feel a little inferior or less talented or annoyed.
Ed made an excellent point about copying (which is what this thread is all about, right?) "They want the income from teaching the skills and style, but they expect others not to try similar pieces." I've always maintained anyone who feels possessive about their "original" design should NOT teach or demonstrate it. (example only here folks) Andi Wolf should demo burning and painting cats on a plate, J. Paul Fennell should demo turning a thin salad bowl and piercing geese. They are now demoing, teaching their technique and the audience, if they don't like cats and geese, will do something different.
Dominic said, "Your work is what you put into it. As you progress in skill level you start to put more and more of your own touches on your work. For some this comes easier than others. No amount of staring at the wood, trying to "feel the art inside" is going to accomplish what skill, practice, and immagination can." Hear! Hear!
I don't think you're being fair to us peons saying you can recognize famous works, heck that's easy, you see it all the time with their names, watch their videos, take their classes. I'm more thrilled with being able to recognize one of Carole's HF, a Jim Shaver pen, Bill Neddow's bowls, a John Lucas mirror, etc. Only a few become "famous" because "fame" is their goal.
I've seen a lot of copies, none are so perfect that you'd think they were done by the artist themselves. It's just obvious who they took a lesson from or attended a demo. And where did the famous get their idea from in the first place? another demonstrator ? a potter? a glass artist? an antique? a book? The only "original" thing we as human beings do is put existing things together in a different way.
I think I can speak from experience because my coffee scoops are my original design. I got the idea while in an old feed store, seed scoops used 100 yrs. ago (various sizes for various size seeds) and loved them but how to make them useful? I have a plastic measuring cup (they used to put them in cans of coffee) and started making 1/8 cup scoops. There are a lot of turners making them now and selling them and not saying "this is a Ruth Niles design" and I say to them "I'm thrilled you liked my idea. Got for it!" And if they make more money than I do or become "famous" making coffee scoops, I'm proud of them.
Can you tell this is a burr in my britches?
I have to get out in the shop now, my wood wants to tell me to find my own voice.
>After 25 years of turning I don't think I want a voice, I have too much fun just making a little bit and selling it. My one gallery is enough for me. I did the art & craft shows for a number of years. My biggest obligation and sales was the 4 Renaissance Festivals I had going for a number of years. There is more to life now than Woodturning which I do maybe ten hours a week. Got to save time for Wife,travel,grandkids,golf,computer drawing,woodcarving and just living a life of luxury now that I'm retired.GT
>Being a 'newby', I have to 'copy' others work. I don't yet have the ability to work on design, when I am still working on the ability to avoid catches. Once I have the techniques down, then I can think about being 'artistic'.
>All of this "Finding your voice" "letting the wood speak to you" etc. is a simplistic way of expressing more complicated thoughts. If you read through different postings you will soon see that the avoidance of using correct terms and phrases is rapidly disappearing. To use one that really grates on me is DNA. Until recently almost anyone with a Jr. High education knew that is stood for Deoxyribonucleic acid. Now all of a sudden people who apparently don't want to type the extra letters of denatured alcohol had decided to use DNA.
Don't even get me started on "veggies" and "wheat berries".
>I've enjoyed reading the comments on this thread.
Some folks have eluded that there is nothing really new. I hope that is not true because I optimistically believe in innovation and creativity. It's something I strive for. Now whether I am successful at it is another matter. :-)
I believe that if you are a good crafts-person you can be successful even though you are "running with the pack". But I think chances for recognition and perhaps a higher level of "success" are bettered for those who dare to be different. Perhaps the likes of Betty Scarpino would serve as one example.
>For someone that wants to break into the collectible art market, I think it is important to develop a distinctive style.
For the hobbyist, amateur, and/or craft show person, it doesn't matter one bit. As others have said, bombarding this person with nonsense like "finding your own voice" and "don't copy what I just showed you how to do" is more than irritating. It is very counter-productive.
The creative person always adds their own touch to whatever they do.
>I don't think I have found my own voice. I am still perfecting my skills. I am at the point in my skill development where I look at something Chris Stott has in his book and ask myself how did he do that. Then I go to the shop and see if I can turn anything similar. Usually it is somewhat similar but will never be a duplicate of his work as it is unlikely I will ever have his skill. Most of the time I find that there is some feature or curve that I don't know how to replicate. So I change the design to accommodate my level of skill while trying to make it as pleasing to my eye and my wife's eye (she is my best critic). Usually if I am able to please her most everyone else is pleased.
Fortunately I have discovered some other critics which have helped me advance both my skill and design sense. Some folks here and at other sites have made astute observations and suggestions to help me improve my work. So anything I turn now is not my own voice either because I took some one's idea, modified it because of my skills, and also because of my wife's suggestions, and also as a result of suggestions I have received here and elsewhere for which I am thankful. Does all of that equal me having my own voice?
Some things that I now turn that originally were based on another person's work are now only vaguely reminiscent of that person's work. For instance, when I first turned a mosque box it was very much like one of Richard Raffan's mosque boxes. In fact a more experienced turner told me that boxes like that are referred to as "Raffanettes". Well, I was pleased that someone would think that I could turn something that resembled anything that Richard Raffan could turn. Over time I have modified my version of the mosque box and it does not look like Richard Raffan's, or Chris Stott's mosque boxes any more. It is my design? I doubt that anyone would agree with that. It is my adaptation of a master turner's work that accommodates my skill level and design sense and I like the way it looks. So does my wife...
I don't hear the wood talking to me because with all the advice I receive I don't think the wood can get a word in edgewise....:))))
>Some natural food idiot sometime in the past decided that they would call grains of wheat, "wheat berries". I use it as an example of ultimate ignorance.