Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Doing it backwards

Posts

Doing it backwards

#1

Doing it backwards

Russ Fairfield

>I just read the Log of the Wednesday Chat Room discussion. I read the whole thing as a general confirmation of "the wood talks to me" school of woodturning.

The preferred way of working for most woodturners is to put the wood in the lathe and then figure out what to do with it. In other words, they let the wood "talk" to them. This is the way all of the famous woodturners have instructed us for years, and as a result, this is the way most of us do it.

I have always done the opposite. That is partly because I have never had wood talk to me other than in anger, and partly because of the way I approach turning something from a piece of wood.

I always have a vision for a piece, sometimes even a sketch, and THEN I look for a piece of wood that best fits what I want to do. Every piece that goes on the lathe was selected for a desired outcome before the tool touches it. Sometimes my wood selection is proven to be wrong, and then I have a choice of finding another piece of wood or changing my mind about to do with this one. If I don't have the right wood for what I want to make, I wait until I do.

I am beginning to think that I am the only woodturner who does it this way.

Re: Doing it backwards

#2

Re: Doing it backwards

Bill Crommett

>Russ : As long as you don't get too lonesome out there, just hang in there and do your thing ! There will always be room for diversity.

Re: Doing it backwards

#3

That's two of us, Russ.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Doing it backwards

#4

Re: Doing it backwards

john lucas

>Russ I do both. Most of the time I will have an idea of what I want to make and will look for the wood. Other times I will have a piece of wood laying around and one day I'll simply see something in that piece.

Most of the time when I just put a piece on the lathe and just start turning the finished product is mediocre. Yea it's nice and well finished and has a good shape and it sells but it's not particularly outstanding. Sometimes the wood can make it go that extra step but I rarely get really nice wood so I have to make do with what I can afford or find.

The best pieces usually come about because I will be making something and I'll see another possibility in that form. Then I work on that and will see more improvements or changes. Usually after several generations I figure out what it is I'm trying to do and turn out a really nice piece. If I had the time this would probably be the beginning of a series but since I work too much I will often let the series die.

Re: Doing it backwards

#5

Re: Doing it backwards

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've never heard a piece of wood say a thing to me except when it screeches that It's getting too thin. I always have a prettty fair stash of wood in my shop. I often stack and unstack blanks looking for just the right piece of wood for a piece that I have in mind. I often spend time orienting a blank to get the best out of it but the wood is quite silent during the process.

I guess that I know what people are saying when they say the wood speaks to them....I guess that I'm just not artsy enough to hear it.

Wally

Re: Doing it backwards

#6

I share the communication problems ...

Ed Moore

>that have been expressed here. Wood doesn't talk to me and I am relieved to learn that it doesn't talk to some others. My silent comment to those who say that the wood speaks them is "Then you should have listened." Then I silently ask about their rose garden, because it's my opinion that what they say grows roses - real well.

Or, as was mentioned in a thread a while back - Oompah!

Ed

Re: Doing it backwards

#7

Russ, you can't hear it?

TDaniel

>My wood says "I don't want to be a bowl, I want to be a hollow form". You have to put your ear down closer to the lathe. I guess my being a short little Irishman helps, I'm closer to the wood. Try starting a turning at about 4 a.m. when it is really quiet and see if that helps. You might also try new batteries in your earpiece. I know there is something that will work for you. By the way, all wood isn't English so you need to learn as many foreign languages as possible. Don't give up, you'll get it.

TD

Re: Doing it backwards

#8

Sometimes it does

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>but when the the voices in my head start yelling at it, it usually shuts up. Trust me, you DON'T want them mad at you! :>)

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Doing it backwards

#9

Re: Doing it backwards

Carole Valentine

>Only time I have had wood talk to me is when it says "You dumbass!" right before the inside gets bigger than the outside. I am slowly learning the language. :)

Sometimes I will pick a piece of wood for a specific project, sometimes I will think of a chunk that has been sitting in my shop and all of a sudden I will know what to do with it. Whether I believe that chunk of wood sent me ESP messages telling me that it's heart's desire was to become a certain piece depends on how many glasses of wine I happen to have had.

Re: Doing it backwards

#10

That's the trick-3 or 4 glasses of Port and even

john lucas

>the porch is talking to me. 5 glasses and my Dog and I have lengthy conversations about the difference between art and craft. :)

Re: Doing it backwards

#11

Re: Doing it backwards

eaglesc

>All the scraps I work with say:

" Make something with me or its' into the burn pile!Oh NOOOOOOOOOOOOO !"

Re: Doing it backwards

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Doing it backwards

Mike Stafford

>I participated in the chat the other night and if I gave the indication that wood talks to me I am sorry. I do not have the ability to fully evaluate a piece of wood I am chucking up for a box until I have rounded it up. Then, the wood does provide me with information but I have to be able to read that information. Sometimes the box I had planned will not work out with the grain patterns I see after rounding it up.

I round up lots of pieces of wood and have them standing on their spigots on shelves in my shop. I look at them, study them and decide how best to display what they have to offer. They are probably turning away from me and saying something like, "Don't choose me I am happy right where I am. I don't want to be gouged, skewed, parted, sanded, bludgeoned, cursed and slathered."

Never heard 'em say that but it wouldn't surprise me to learn that they do.....Maybe in the hands of some of the masters they say,"Do me, do me."

Re: Doing it backwards

#13

Steven Antonucci

Happened to me one time...

steve antonucci

>The wood said to me " I want to be a bowl."

I said, "Shut up or I'll cut you, man!"

The wood cowered, "I don't want any trouble..."

From there, all of the other wood in my shop learned to just keep it's opinions to itself...

Steven

Re: Doing it backwards

#14

Re: Doing it backwards

Bill Neddow

>I think the reality of wood turning lies somewhere between the two extremes. I have never had a piece of wood speak to me. But I do not approach it like Mike Darlow, either. He was in Ottawa here a few months ago and gave a two day advanced course. He said that to him, wood was just a piece of cellulose. All his work is precisely drawn out before he starts and the wood has to conform exactly to the drawings. Now, if I was trying to make a living doing spindle turning, especially the large columns he is noted for, I probably would have the same approach. I understand where he is coming from. If you are making four 16 foot columns for the front of a building, they had better be the same. If you are producing hundreds of spindles for stair rails, the hundredth and the first had better be the same. So, there is a need for this approach.

But, as a bowl turner, I cannot work like that. I would lose too much beautiful figure in the wood. Before I put a piece of wood on the lathe, I study the chunk of wood and I have an idea of what shape I am going to aim for. But as soon as it is round, I will stop the lathe and reassess my concept. Often, I will change it, because I will have discovered some beautiful curl, or a hidden bit of burl that would have been lost if I had continued. But, again, I will have a firm concept of where I am going before I proceed. I do not proceed "on spec" as I have found that I will end up with an egg cup, not a salad bowl, if I do that. The idea is to save and display the best the wood has to offer. This pays off at the galleries in increased sales because people are looking for beautiful wood.

like Wally, I have quite a stack of green wood, and drying bowls (about 3,000). So, if I get a bright idea, I can usually find an appropriate blank to modify. I leave the blanks a little thicker than most turners specifically so I can do this. Sometimes, I cannot find a likely candidate. So I sketch the idea and make some notes in a little notebook I have specifically for this. First time I find a block of wood that I can rough, incorporating this idea, i will do it. That means some ideas have to wait a year or two for the wood to dry -- but that is part of being a wood turner. I find that this is not a bad thing, as my idea will probably have matured and improved by the time I actually finish the bowl.

As an aside, Mike said that at one point he tried making bowls. He saw a glass bowl he liked with sort of a slumped rim and a little rise on the inside. He made drawings of it, and produce a whole bunch exactly the same. They simply would not sell -- so he went back to something that did -- spindles.

My reaction (which I did not voice at the time) was that he might as well have send a mould of the bowl to China, and have the Chinese cast dozens of the bowls out of sawdust and paint grain on them. If you want bowls the same, go to Costco and get the glass ones there for about $15. In fact, they had some absolutely beautiful ones there last week about 18 inches in diameter, for $40. I have no intentions of trying to compete against this.

My clientele (and I think, most people) are not looking for that, thank goodness. They are looking for a beautiful and unique bowl. They want pretty graining. And, most important to me, they appreciate and are willing to pay for a high-end craftsmanship. By that, I mean a bowl turned with clean, elegant lines and finished to a high standard. They want it to be special. They do not want to see two or three exactly the same sitting together for sale.

This does not rule out doing series of bowls. In my case, each of these bowls may follow a common theme, but each is also unique. I develop the idea more in every bowl I do. Sometimes I hit dead ends. Sometimes everything turns out right, and I am amazed at what I have done. That is what keep it exciting for me.

Re: Doing it backwards

#15

Re: Doing it backwards

Ed Karch

>I do it like Russ, usually with a general sketch and if there is detail another sketch for detail. I may make adjustments as it progresses and it may arrive at the abondon ship point if the plan doesn't come together.

Re: Doing it backwards

#16

Re: Doing it backwards

gary s clarke

>Russ, the only inanimate object that speaks to me is the coffee pot in the morning which seems to say "coffee, you need coffee". Do the design and then pick the wood for your segmented object.

Re: Doing it backwards

#17

Re: Doing it backwards

Art Liestman

>I wasn't able to chat on Wednesday, but I'm surprised, Russ, that you say "The preferred way of working for most woodturners is to put the wood in the lathe and then figure out what to do with it. .... This is the way all of the famous woodturners have instructed us for years". I've listened to a lot of famous woodturners and I don't remember any of them saying to decide what to do with the wood once you have it mounted on the lathe. Can you tell me who (specifically) says to do that?

I have hosted dozens of "famous woodturners" (even you!) and have supplied materials for them to demonstrate with. In all cases, they've made specific requests for raw materials to make what they intend to make. I can't imagine that any of them (making either artistic or functional work) would head to their own shops, pick up a chunk of wood, mount it, and then decide what to make. It makes much more sense that they would head to the shop knowing that they wanted to make, for example, a honeydipper, select appropriate wood for that, rough cut it to the right size and shape, mount it, and make it.

As for myself, I know what I want to make in advance, I find a piece of wood that seems likely to yield a good result, and then I make what I wanted to make. Of course, there may be slight surprises that arise once the interior is exposed that make it difficult to do exactly what I intended. At that point, I'll either make a slight modification to accomodate the surprise (a bark inclusion, for example) provided that I can do that and still end up with an acceptable result or will pick another piece of wood to make what I intended to make. I just came in from making a prototype of a new piece from a cylinder of wood that was abandoned last week when the surprises weren't compatible with my goal. I didn't like abandoning it at the time, but it was nice to have a pre-rounded cylinder today.

Back to my question, Russ. Who told you to let the wood speak to you?

Re: Doing it backwards

#18

JL

Re: Doing it backwards

JL

>As I turn mostly spindles for furniture, I always sketch or make a pattern first. You have to have the lengths right or the stretchers will never be in the right places. Diameters are another problem.

Re: Doing it backwards

#19

Me, Either..........

Barry Turner

>I've never had wood that talked to me, either. I've had a few pieces that I have talked to though...........:-)

Re: Doing it backwards

#20

Re: Doing it backwards

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>While I have heard people say that they have heard people say they let the wood speak to them, I have always though that anyone the would actually say that thinks that they are sounding Artistic, and not like some crass Craftsman. B.S.

Mark

Re: Doing it backwards

#21

So it was YOU!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>...that started all of this!

..and hear I thought it was Elvis :)

Re: Doing it backwards

#22

Re: Doing it backwards

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Perhaps a good lathering of soap on that potty mouthed wood might take care of some of that verbal abuse you're getting from it Carole? That couldn't have been a piece I sent to you!

; )

Re: Doing it backwards

#23

Mike Stafford

Re: Doing it backwards

Mike Stafford

>Mark, with all the species of wood you use in your wonderful segmented work thank goodness the wood isn't speaking to you. It would sound like the Tower of Babel.

Re: Doing it backwards

#24

Re: Doing it backwards

Russ Fairfield

>Art is correct. This is the topic that separates the real artist from the BS Artist. Letting the wood "talk to me" is a concept that sounds good to the uninitiated, but has little basis in reality.

As for naming one, I can't. This is an example of the mythical "They" who gets blamed for everything.

Re: Doing it backwards

#25

Re: Doing it backwards/Mark Kauder

Mac

>Hi Mark, We have another artsy f..... phrase to deal with now,it's "finding your voice". Now isn't that " special?"What do you think about that one,Russ?