Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

First hollowform - needs critique

Posts

First hollowform - needs critique

#1

First hollowform - needs critique

Pat Taylor

>I haven't posted here in a long while, but I'd like to get some straight-up honest comments on this cherry hollowform. It's my first, so I'm looking for brutal honesty so I know what to work on.

Cherry, 7" x 3", form inspired by southwestern pottery, finish is watco danish oil with beall buffing.

Thanks for looking.

pat


img

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#2

Well... since you asked....

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>I would not change a thing!! I think you nailed it. The form look wonderful to my eye. And the photo is really good too.

Excellent job,

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#3

Yes, Ditto what Dave says....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Pat this is a lovely form. I love it. Since we can't see or feel the inside we'll assume that it looks and feels as lovely as the outside. The beauty of on line critiques :)

Keep it up. This one is a winner for sure!

Jen

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#4

I could not agree.....

TDaniel

>more. You nailed it. It's a beauty!

TD

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#5

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Carole Valentine

>Very nice, Pat. I can't believe this is your first HF - you are a natural. The lip of the opening looks to be very thin. Is the wall thickness the same throughout? Shoulder areas of these forms can be difficult.

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#6

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Pat Taylor

>The wall thickness is not as uniform as I'd like. It thickens a bit near the bottom. About 1/8 at the top to 1/4 at the base. The shoulder does get thin... rookie mistake, I guess! Thanks for the kind words.

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#7

Andy DiPietro

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Andy DiPietro

>Pat

Congratulations on doing a great job on your first hollow form. Be careful, you could catch the hollow form bug. What is the diameter of the opening? It looks larger then most forms but I think it is the correct proportion. I think the bottom should be thicker then the sides. A 1/4" thickness is fine for the bottom. It will not crack since the bottom diameter is small relative to the rest of the form.

Did you use the Monster tool rig to hollow this piece?

Andy DiPietro

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#8

Super! I always ask myself ...

Ed Moore

>when critiquing, "Do the parts fit?". And the answer here is a resounding "Yes!" The opening is just right for the shape. I wouldn't want it larger or smaller.

The second question I ask is "Do the curves transition from one to the other nicely?". A mathematician would say that I am looking at inflection points. [grin] And, are there any extra curves that detract from the quality?

You have passed the second test with flying colors. Smooth work!

Ed

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#9

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Pat Taylor

>Thanks! The opening diameter is about 1.5 - 2" (it's at home so I can't measure). It is perhaps larger than some other hollowform openings, but in addition to making hollowing easier on my first try, I did intentionally size the opening with a piece of pottery in mind, and I like the proportions I settled on.

I did use the Monster system II, and now that I know how to use it the second piece should go more smoothly. ;) I can't say enough good things about the monster tools.

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#10

yup...

GaryG in MD

>That's a real beauty Pat. I want to hold it -- please bring it to S&T next month. Very well done! ...Gary

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#11

Re: yup...

Pat Taylor

>Thanks Gary. I'll bring it to the September meeting. :)

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#12

I have always felt that...

david

>if you have a discerning eye, you can get the exterior form down pretty well according to most standards. The difference between a pro and a relative newbie's pieces is usually the uniform thickness of the walls and the time it takes to finish the piece. A newbie will work longer and harder at sanding away the tool marks or torn grain that a pro will not leave because of superior technique, etc.

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#13

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Pat,

I do these forms a lot (trying to not do them so much now), but like everyone said, this one is great. Opening is a good size, you could go smaller as many do, but don't go much larger. Though you did not do it here, be very careful not to create a flatspont when you transition from the shoulder to the neck.

You should be proud of this one. The wall thickness thing comes with experience, and the only people you will impress are other turners.

Mark

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#14

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Barry Turner

>Nice wood........nice shape. Very nice! So nice, in fact, that it makes me want to touch it and see if it feels as good as it looks! I'm betting it does.

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#15

Thanks everyone!

Pat Taylor

>

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

#16

Re: First hollowform - needs critique

Mike Nelson

>Very nice turning Pat, I wouldn't worry too much about the thickness as long as the graduation from opening to base is uniform and smooth. If the inside of a wide mouth piece is smooth then you have accomplished your goal.