Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Skew DVD

Posts

Skew DVD

#1

Roger in MO

Skew DVD

Roger in MO

>Which DVD would be a good choice for learning to use the skew? I've turned quite a bit but when it comes to the skew I mostly "catch"

Looking at "The Skew Chisel" by Alan Lacer or "The Taming of the Skew" by Mike Darlow. Or is there something better than one of these?

I'll appreciate recommendations.

Thanks, Roger

Re: Skew DVD

#2

Re: Skew DVD

Fog Tanner

>The something better is a lot of practice. I learned to use the skew from Richard Raffan's "Turning Wood" and "Turning Wood Projects". I also had a handson class with him after I had been turning for about two months.

After watching his video's I knew he was high on the skew for spindle work. As a result I would practice for several hours each night for those two months before the hands on. I would get a catch, go in watch the video or read the section on catchs in his book and go try it again. If I could have perfected the spiral run backs I got I would have been happy, but no two were alike so I finally gave them up (after more practice).

By the time the hands on came, I could use a skew and not be embarresed. I couldn't use a gouge very well and found that everyone else in the class (more experienced than myself) couldn't use the skew. I'm still working on demystifying the spindle gouge.....

Since then, one of the other things I found that will help you a lot is a friction drive. I make light pulls and use a friction drive for those. It is all skew exercise and can be fast and loose. If you get a catch, the wood will stop and you can see why. Tighten up the tail stock and go at it again. Takes all the fear of the spiral run back away (which can be quite exciting at the higher speeds). A dead center, which can be found at some of the machine supply houses for around $10 will work for larger exercises.

Basicly, there is no one video/dvd that will replace the practice and attention to detail you get from several thousand little pieces. The movement that becomes automatic with all those passes, to the point of where you really don't think about it. Its whatever you learn with and become comfortable. I learned from Hisskewness, and have followed that style - works for me so I just keep trying to refine more and more.

Good luck in your quest, it is indeed a most interesting and rewarding journey.

Fog

Re: Skew DVD

#3

Re: Skew DVD

Don in Central Illinois

>I agree with Fog. I have, as a Christmas gift, Alan Lacer's "Son of Skew". They all make it look so easy. Practice, practice, practice.

Re: Skew DVD

#4

Re: Skew DVD

eliot d

>Fog, Please let me get something straight:are you reading a book that has you practice getting scroll backs?! Perhaps as a way of learning? Weird, I think. I try to avoid them! But I'm open to new methods.What book is it?

Re: Skew DVD

#5

Re: Skew DVD

Fog Tanner

>When I first started, like a lot of other people, I would be cutting along and then wind up with a spiral. After reading the sections of getting a catch for the nth time it started to make sense as to what I was doing wrong. It was also something I could never duplicate successfully. I did have one piece where I was able to leave the spiral groove in, but have not been able to duplicate it. In a discussion with Hisownself, even he cannot duplicate a spiral run back. He said if he could he would make some new pieces with a different design direction. So I think the perfection of the spiral groove will be left to some young turner that has the time to embrace its design possibilites and to develop the method and requiste tool control.

Like you, I do try to avoid them these days. But for some reason then only happen these days when I am doing a club demo or a rotation at the club retreat. Of course those little events are always to show what can happen when you do it wrong and keep people awake. One of the things I liked about Raffan was when even he got a catch, he was quick to admit it. The catchs he was demoing he announced beforehand - the others were just a catch like the rest of us - usually followed by a remark of somelike "well that was interesting, must be more careful" - then followed by the reason for the catch.

Re: Skew DVD

#6

I Vote For Alan Lacer

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I have a few DVD's on skew work, the one that helped me the MOST was the first of ALan Lacer's...

Take care,

Jim

7 Skew owner

Re: Skew DVD

#7

Re: Skew DVD

Ed Heuslein

>Many are good skew turners. Many are good teachers. There are few who are both adept at skew work and teaching. Alan Lacer is supurb at both. His DVD's are second to none when it comes to teaching the skew. My own personal input - as long as you're learning something new, learn it both right handed and left handed. You'll be glad you did.

Re: Skew DVD

#8

Re: Skew DVD

HarryB in Kukpsville

>There is also a third DVD on the skew. It is by Alan Batty. He goes through the basic cuts in detail and also adds some insight into the spindle gouge and parting tool. (A parting tool can be used as a small skew.)

He demonstrates making a cabriole leg and goes over sharpening. Unlike Alan Lacer, he does not use the skew for every possible cut. Instead he uses the most appropriate tool.

Both the Lacer and the Batty DVD's are good. You can't go wrong with either.

Re: Skew DVD

#9

Re: Skew DVD

eliot d

>Thanks for the long response. but you didn't quite answer my question: do you actually try to get spirals? At any rate, you seem to understand the mechanism well. Can you say what it is that you do wrong when you get one?

Re: Skew DVD

#10

Re: Skew DVD

Gordon Seto

>I would vote for both Alan Batty and Alan Lacer.

I have not seen the DVD by Mike Darlow. I would pass. I have tried to watch his other DVDs. With at least 6 or 7 tries, I couldn't stay awake and finish the whole thing. His monotone voice and unnecessary details put me to sleep. If your advanced math is a little rusty; then you may want to take some math refreshing course first. IMO, they are information overload.

If you just want some lessons and go to your shop to practice, then either Alan is good enough.

Gordon

Re: Skew DVD

#11

books

JKJ in East TN

>I started terrified of the skew and now it is my favorite tool for much spindle turning. I learned by following Darlow's and Raffan's turning books. They include good instruction and suggest practice methods. I agree that practice/practice/practice is vital. With time, the catches become fewer and eventually quite rare.

I personally prefer books over videos unless the video is used along with the book. The problem I have with videos in general compared to books is due to time constraints video productions must skip over a tremendous amount of valuable information that is usually in the books. Also, I can learn only so much from watching someone else turn wood. I prefer to have the methods described and then develop the techniques while turning the wood myself.

However some people have told me they cannot learn from books, in which case the video has to be better than nothing.

BTW, more than any other tool I find the skew must be razor sharp to get good results. I sharpen on the Tormek than hone repeatedly with a very fine diamond paddle "stone" while working.

JKJ

Re: Skew DVD

#12

Re: Skew DVD

Fog Tanner

>I guess the short answer is no, I do not try to get them. The ones I have encountered are when I was careless or wasn't paying attention and let the cutting portion of the blade go past the fifty percent line. And you are right, I encountered enough in my first two months that I had ample quantity of samples to survey what was causing me problems. Had I been using a friction drive it would have taken much less time, although it would not have been as exciting.

In planing cuts (going right to left) I use the blade with the long point down and leading. This puts the blade more parallel to the axis and less tearout on some woods. I cut on that portion just behind the point (or to the right looking down) of the tool, trying to stay in the first half of the width. If I get careless and let the blade roll clockwise where the cutting portion is in the other side of the halfway mark, the heel or short point can dig in and feed backwards.

If I am cutting to the right, where I generally have the blade closer to the perindicular of the axis (15 degress off verticale with my grind), the cutting edge is still at around 45 degrees to the on comming wood. I still follow the same rule in where the cutting portion of the edge is. Too far and the other side of the blade can dig in produce a spiral run back or and interesting catch. I generally roll beads with the short point, flipping to the long point about half way around. I have to be careful following the curve on tops of boxes more than just rolling beads for all these reasons.

I do use a slightly curved edge, which for me lessens the chance of a catch or spiral runback. I can use one with the straight edge, but prefer the curved - one of those whatever works for you deals.

Fog

If I start encountering those, it is usually a sign for me to do something else for a while.

Re: Skew DVD

#13

Re: books

Fog Tanner

>I have to agree on both the books and the Tormek. My vocation requires reading a lot of technical manuals, so reading is second nature and there is so much more detail than on the videos. And with the book, you can set it on the bed, hand turn the lathe, and follow what the edge is doing in the wood compared to the pictures. Roll the tool as shown in the book and see what is going on at 1 rpm. I have only read Raffan's books and so far they have been enough.

Like you I use the Tormek to keep and edge on my skews, along with honing the edge. I have a stack of Home Depot credit applications that I use for checking the edge. If the edge slices through the paper, its sharp. If it tares the paper, needs sharpening or honing.

Re: Skew DVD

#14

Try these FREE short videos by Ken Grunke. *LINK*

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>For free quick learning, I don't think you can beat these 4 short videos that Ken Grunke made about 2 yrs. ago. Watch them several times and keep an eye on his hands and placement of the skew and you can go to your lathe and mimic his moves to get the feel for what he is trying to teach. They won't make you a pro right away, but you will get better in the time it takes for a DVD to arrive at your door step.


Woodturner's Resource

Re: Skew DVD

#15

Re: Skew DVD

RonZ

>IMHO

While Mike Darlow is good, he p[uts me to sleep by being over technical.LAcer is good. To quote what R.Raffan told me 'keep practising, you have no choice but to become better.'

Contrary to popular belief, everyone gets catches, the idea is to keep them at a minimum.