Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

Posts

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#1

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

JKJ in East TN

>John L.,

While watching your inside-out demo in Knoxville, it occurred to me that it should be possible to use 3D modeling software to simulate and test inside-out designs before mounting the wood in the lathe. (I did 3D modeling/animation work for years before retiring this past year.)

Between feeding the horses and pickling okra tonight I made a simple test based loosely on your demo, with the results in two included images. (Actually my wife is pickling the okra at the moment while I'm goofing off here at the computer.)

The first rendered image shows the initial block of wood in blue. The yellow lines indicate the crossection of the inside shape to be cut away (along with the centerline), equivalent to the paper patterns you showed us.

The second rendered image shows the four quadrents reassembled, the yellow 2D outside shape to be cut, and the result.

The images here don't really do the method justice since the 3D model can actually be interactively rotated, zoomed, and disassembled for examination.

This modeling method not only makes it easy to visualize exactly how much wood will remain in critical areas (I almost "cut" through on my first attempt!), but clearly shows the how the inside void will appear on the surface along with any distortion introduced by the outside shape. For example, it is surprising how large the heart-shaped holes appear compared to the holes on the reassembled block. (But I see now, the void is larger towards the center so the deeper you cut, the larger the surface shape.) It should be possible to interactively "tweak" the inside shape to give the exact final shape desired.

The model also makes it easy to see exactly how the "floor" and "ceiling" will appear.

When I actually get around to trying an inside-out piece with real wood, I suspect this 3D modeling method could save a lot of frustration and a few trees.

Good clean fun! Thanks again for the demo.

JKJ

IMAGE #1:


img

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#2

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation, image #2

JKJ in East TN

>IMAGE #2:


img

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#3

Are you sure about the corners?

david

>I generally am pretty good at visualization--my day job depends on it ;-). I like the second set of solid modeling images, but I can't see how the first set would come out like you have shown. I may be missing something here, and apologize if I am.

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#4

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

john lucas

>John That's exactly what I would like someone to do is produce some software that lets you do exactly what you just did. I guess it already exists if your good enough to use it. It looks like it also shows the distortion of the design that occurs when you alter the outside shape too much. That's really cool.

Now that you've finished the Okra and I've finished my roof maybe we can work on some turning.

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#5

Re: Are you sure about the corners?

john lucas

>David in inside out turning you turn the first shape out of 4 parts like in John's first drawing and then you split these apart, rotate each part 180 degrees and reassemble. That gives you the shape of the first image in the second photo. Then you turn the outside shape which gives you the second image.

Or as Burl Ives sang in a very,very very old song about making rabbit skin gloves, you turn the inside, skin side outside, turn the outside skin side inside. Is that confusing enough. How many of you young folk remember Burl Ives. I'm still looking for the Big Rock Candy Mountain.

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#6

John, it's yonder, past the lemonade brook! :-)

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#7

Froggie went a courtin

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#8

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

Ralph Watts

>John makes this simulation look easy. It's not. It requires a high skill and experience level to do this kind of software work and some fairly expensive software. John is a master. However, there are several (<$1,000) packages that you can use but it takes serious dedecation for a sustained period to reproduce John's work. I think I'm going to try turning this thing....

regards, Ralph

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#9

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

JKJ in East TN

>>...a high skill and experience level

I've been doing this so long I forget sometimes how much effort it takes to learn! I spent over 2000 hours learning and increasing my efficiency before I felt I could charge for my services without feeling guilty.

But it's great fun and quite useful - off the job I've used it for things like farm fence design, remodeling visualization, shop planning, and volunteer video work. I think the software I use is over $4000 now (I got free software and updates in exchange for providing internet tech support so I'm not quite sure of the current price), but as Ralph points out there are much less expensive and even free packages available. My son showed me a book on Blender this weekend, a free (open source) 3D package.

JKJ

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#10

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation Image #3

JKJ in East TN

>A couple of more images I should have made last night -

On the top row this image better shows the actual 2D cutting shape crosssection, the volume which was removed, the resulting 3D shape after the first turning, and two views of the same shape with the four pieces turned "inside out" just before the second turning.

Note that the 2D shape must be extended all the way to the include the outside corners of the initial block. That portion towards the very outside is what mostly affects the the ceiling and floor of the cavity - in this case I continued the shape sharply downward causing a large sharp point dropping from the ceiling and a deep fissure in the floor. Turning the lines up instead at the outer edges would create a quite differnt look.

The bottom row has some additional views after the first turning as well as the piece after the final "outside" turning (the piece is lined up with the blocks above).

John K Jordan

IMAGE #3:


img

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#11

John Lucas - InsideOut simulation Image #4

JKJ in East TN

>This image shows shows one finished segment (they are all identical) from several angles. Note how THIN the wood would be in one point - this model suggests perhaps changing the outer shape a bit to leave more wood and perhaps reduce the chance of disaster.

One important thing to note about simulations of this sort - it is easy to design something that would be impossible to turn! As John Lucas pointed out in his demo, even this "simple" heart shape can be difficult to turn successfully due to the undercutting, perhaps requiring special tools. And even if it is cut successfully, it may be impossible to sand. A more practical design might requre less undercutting and perhaps rounding off or flattening the upper point. Using wood less prone to tearout also seems important. (Hmm, I've got some nice pieces of cocobolo waiting for a project...)

John K Jordan

IMAGE #4:


img

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#12

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

JKJ in East TN

>>...maybe we can work on some turning.

John,

Good idea! I'm thinking of trying a wand with an inside out handle. :)

Actually, if you are interested in the 3D technique, it might be fun to create models and a good set of images illustrating the entire process. Perhaps you could print these or project them as slides to use along with your inside-out turning demo.

Also, if you have an interesting design you want to play with, I'd be glad to try to model it for you, perhaps with some varitations.

John

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#13

Re: Are you sure about the corners?

JKJ in East TN

>>... I can't see how the first set would come out like

>you have shown. I may be missing something here...

david,

You are probably missing a more correct image from me. I messed up the first one and didn't include the entire crossectional shape - the shape in Image #3 extends the shape all the way to the corners of the block. I hope that's more clear.

JKJ

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#14

FormZ demo free download *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>John (and John), I've been playing around with FormZ for years, and figured out how to create an inside/out ornament after a few hours of experimentation. Of course with the demo, you can't save anything but it's otherwise fully functional and you can simply take a screenshot. It's another one of those programs that if you have to ask how much, you can't afford it. I did ask a while back, and it was around $1400 at the

The process of creating an ornament isn't too awful complicated, if there are step-by-step instructions. But there isn't, unless I or someone makes them. I would, if there was some interest from a couple people or more. You can get the demo program at http://www.formz.com/ and you can create any lathed form just by clicking out a profile with the mouse.

In a big nutshell, to make an inside/out ornament, you create a long square block, arrange it with a corner exactly on center. That corner will end up being on the outside. Form a profile into the other corner, which will be the inside shape. Lathe that profile and subtract it from the block. Re-arrange the block to put the second corner at center. Form the outside profile, lathe it, and subtract it from the block. Duplicate the block to create 3 more objects, and you have an ornament.

Anyway, here's a sampling of what I've done:


Pixelwood Ornaments

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#15

Itsy Bitsy Spider

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#16

Thanks for the info. Great stuff!!

david

>

Re: John Lucas - InsideOut simulation

#17

Re: FormZ demo free download

JKJ in East TN

>Ken,

FormZ seems pretty good. I bought a copy primarily so I could read and convert files provided by architect firms where it was widely used. It has some great terrain tools and the snap system beats (or at least used to beat) anything but SketchUp.

Many architects are now moving to SketchUp since it is quite cheap. It is aimed primarily at architectural work, but it is getting more powerful each release. I think you can get a free functional version from Google. Mesh models from both programs import nicely into the software I use (Discreet/Autodesk 3DS MAX).

The method you used for the inside-out modeling appears to be similar to what I used. It wasn't difficult, but as my piano teacher was fond of saying, "everything's easy once you know how." (I always considered that true for most everything EXCEPT piano playing!) BTW, after you learn the functions and methods of work specific to any 3D software, I think the real skill in 3D modeling/animation is reflected in how efficiently you can create something you've never tried before.

JKJ