Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

Posts

Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#1

Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

Craig Daymon

>I was hollowing some small turnings recently and trying to use a 1/4" detail gouge. It seemed to flex a bit too much when more than 1" or 1.5" off the rest. A 3/8" was too big. I think a 5/16" (which is pretty much dead on 8mm) would be perfect. I have an 8mm bowl gouge to base this on, but not a detail gouge.

I know we have a great crowd of small turners here, what do you think? What tool sizes do you use for...approximately 2.5" to 3" hollow form turnings?

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#2

Steven Antonucci

I made some tools out of O1 and allen keys

steve antonucci

>I have a straight shank cutter and a bunch of bent tools. I often hollow very small turnings through 1/4" holes with them. The 1/8" O1 steel is OK (some vibrations) at 1" over the rest, but when your entry hole is only 1/4", no one can tell.

Steven

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#3

Ric Taylor

Small Turners would be Less Than 5 Feet ..... :)

Ric Taylor

>

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#4

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?) *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Craig,

Have you looked at the detail and shallow detail gouge from Doug Thompson? With better steel, you can grind your shallow detail gouge to a steeper angle and allow you clearance. On his shallow detail gouge, the flute is very shallow, there is still a lot of steel underneath the edge, you can extend much further beyond the toolrest without chattering.

Gordon


Thompson Tools

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#5

Roger in MO

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

Roger in MO

>I ground a hardened concrete nail, one that looks like an oversize horse shoe nail. Sharpened the head and drove it into a dowel. I can reach about 2".

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#6

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

Carole Valentine

>I use either the mini Keltons or custom tools made from Allen wrenches. For the outside, I still use my 3/8" bowl gouge, but my gouge has very long wings and a steep grind.

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#7

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

john lucas

>Craig for hollowing you really don't necessarily need a gouge. A solid rod with the tip groung sort of like a bowl gouge and then flattened on top will hollow quite well. I have made them in 1/4" and 5/16. With 1/4" I can easily hollow christmas ornaments up to 1 1/2 to 1 3/4. With the 5/16 I can hollow up to about 3", probably more if I take light cuts.

I use drill rod to make them and then harden the tip but if you don't mind sharpening often you can use just about any steel. A really good way is to silver solder a HSS cutter onto cold roll steel.

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#8

Supported Hollowing Tool

Mike Brazeau

>Craig - I thought I had posted this last year here but can't find it if I did. I made this Supported Hollowing Tool specifically for doing the globes of ornaments, but it will work well on anything small. It is 1/4" cold rolled steel square stock silver soldered and a piece of 3/16" HSS metal lathe bit silver soldered to it. Forgive the quality of the picture. I just layed it on the scanner. The gap at the end is 1 3/4" and the overall length is 6". I use a 5/8" hole on ornaments and there is lots of clearance. It takes a lot of the stress out of holding the tool while hollowing.


img

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#9

Re: Supported Hollowing Tool

john lucas

>I love it Mike. I'm going to have to make one of those and see how I like it.

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#10

Thanks for all the feedback and more info (long)

Craig Daymon

>I have contacted Doug about 5/16" tools. He's going to call his steel supplier and look into the possibility.

I do put a long bevel on most of my spindle tools, especially the shallow detail gouges. I know with end grain you are suppose to hollow from center out, but I was getting a real clean cut with that long bevel on a 1/4" tool, making shallow cuts from the edge working in. It just got a bit chattery doing this at about 1.5" off the rest. Probably, I think, what would work best for me would be a long bevel going in as long as the cut is moving away from center and then shift to a short bevel working from center toward the transition point. The short bevel one I could probably make from drill blank, but the long bevel I would rather have a shallow detail gouge.

I like Mike's supported tool and for most projects of this size, it would be great. Might even be best for what I am doing, but I also need a relatively thin bottom on this.

Current project description:

I did my first thin stemmed goblet recently. About 5" tall with a 3/16" stem. Then I did the first attempt at the project idea, an egg-shaped hollow form at the top of the spindle and a bowl shaped base with a heavy rim. I'm also considering a hollowed bird head covering the entry hole on the hollow form. I plan to call it, "Leaving the Nest". The first attempt is about 9" tall with a 1-3/4" hollow form and 3/16" stem. The proportions are wrong. The egg needs to be more elongated, the entry hole needs to be smaller (vibration mishap) and the nest is far too small. (Somewhat inspired by Vesery's nest on the back of the recent Fine Woodworking.)

Making a spindle steady would certainly help with the hollowing.

But cutting this thing at the end of a spindle is, I think, also why I can do it better cutting inward rather than scraping toward the outside.

I don't know if this changes any suggestion.

I'll post a pic if I succeed.

-Craig

Re: Turning small hollows, 5/16" detail ideal (?)

#11

I also use the mini-keltons...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>they work wonderfully when hollowing small vessels and forms.

keith