Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>Hello again, folks, and welcome to the dog days of summer. It's time for our latest "Ides of..." survey, our bimonthly attempt to unravel yet another woodworking mystery, or debunk another myth.

Though it is not particularly turning related, one topic that has been widely debated in recent years is the issue of hand tools vs. power tools. Most woodworkers (but not all) would rather prepare and dimension stock with power equipment, saving their manual labor and hand tool skills for the final stages of a project -- the joinery, final surfacing and detailing. How do you decide which tool to use for a given job? What are the tradeoffs? What are the optimal efficiencies? Is there a formula, or can you develop a process for deciding on the fly?

As usual, in a week or so we will harvest your replies, strip them to their bare essentials and send them off to Woodworker West magazine for our next "News & Views" column, to appear in their September-October 2007 issue.

Thanks again for your participation!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Russ Fairfield

>I can't answer your survey. I am one of those people who thinks a 3-HP router is a hand tool.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use the quickest and easiest method to get the desired result.

When the table saw is being used as a finishing station, a hand saw is quicker and easier for a simple rough cut to length. But most of the time I use power tools for most of the work and then do the finishing touches by hand.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#4

the obvious one, power, than hand

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

RonZ

>Well, my math teacher in college laid down an important fundamental idea. While it doesn't apply to everything, it is certainly apropos for the woodworking industry, espiaclly if you try and make a living out of it like myself: Don't do any more work than you have to. I would add that it must not impinge on the quality of a product.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Wilford Bickel

>Usually the job dictates the tool. If a horse has kicked and broken a single board off in the barn then it is easier to use a hand saw to cut one board then transport the board to the miter saw in the shop and back to the barn. If I have to rebuild half the barn - then I will transport power tools to the barn! Right now I am working on a new cane handle that has to be custom fitted to my hand - that gets hand rasps and hand sanding to make sure it fits properly. The shaft will be turned on the lathe so that makes it about half and half on that job. Like I said above - in my case the job I am doing will dictate what tools are needed. I like my power tools but sometimes it is quicker on small jobs to use hand tools and I can do more exact sizing using hand tools.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Jorge Castaneda

>Back on the early sixties, my woodworking mentor said: "if the wood is bigger than the saw, the saw goes to the wood, if the saw is bigger than the wood, the wood goes to the saw".

To that I must add, some of my work is in islands further out than this island, where there is no power and thus a lot of the work is done by hand even if there is a generator, have you tried carting around your stationary shop tools in and out of boats, and up the hill?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

David Breth

>There are a few things that play into it for me.

1) I don't like using power saws. I use them, but I will never feel comfortable with them because they go through digits as easily as wood. So, if I feel I can make decent time using hand tools versus power, I'll choose hand just for my own comfort level.

3) When I make toys for my kids, I try not to use power tools (except lathe & drill). I make it a point to use my great-grandfather's saw for at least one cut. I figure it might look nicer that way.....well, really, I just like the idea of reaching across the generations to involve him in the project. Just my own littel tradition I guess, but for those items I think my kids will have forever - toyboxes, particular toys, I like to add that difficult-to-describe element.

3) I am a hobbyist. Very important distinction that influences my decisions versus others. My time isn't typically used in the shop in a business sense.

David B.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#9

Roger in MO

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Roger in MO

>Very seldom will I reach for a hand tool if the task can be accomplished with available power tools. Just basically lazy I guess. Roger

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Andi Wolfe

>For efficiency: power tools

For pleasure: hand tools (there's just nothing quite like the sound of a curl of wood coming off a well-tuned handplane or a well-honed chisel)

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Brodie Brickey

>Overall, as a turner I prefer power to hand tool. That being said, I'll put an out of round blank on the lathe instead of cutting it on the bandsaw. I power sand when possible and then move to hand sanding.

Dimensioning lumber should only be done with power tools. Carving and other fine work like marquetry or inlay should be done by hand. If wood pieces are really small, then a hand tool may be safer than the power tool. Shaping can be done by either. Part of the problem is do you have everything tool wise? I don't so hand tools may come more into play until I can afford the power versions.

One hand tool I still use a lot of before and after the power version is the broom. :) Pesky sawdust!

Regards,

Brodie

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#12

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Ron in Drums PA

>That's why I love lathe work, you get the best of both worlds.

You get to use a hand tool (gouge) while using a power tool (lathe) all at the same time.

How can you ask for more?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Stephen Mushinski

>If power is available why not use it! When even liked to do most of the sanding with a drum sander before assembly. Then again I drive V8 cars and trucks so I guess I am very un-green in this day and age.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Ed in Sptbg.

>I think you should learn to use both. I really enjoy turning, but I still find time for flat work, too. Thru the years, I've been able to judge just how serious someone is about woodworking by whether he/she took the time to learn how to properly tune and use a handplane. I can't imagine how to do really good work without them.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY*** *LINK*

#15

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY***

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Ellis,

Neat idea for a thread.

I tend to use power tools most of the time and then hand tools for final fitting and joint making. I dimension lumber with a planer and joiner and use the table saw to cut the pieces to size. For profiles on edges, etc, I also us a router.

Handtool uses include things like fitting joints (M&T, dowel, etc) and for trimming things for that final fit. I use a #4 for smoothing panels, but invariably the last thing to touch the surface before finish is a ROS. I like the uniform look it provides.

Like others have said, however, there is something very satisfying about using hand tools. To me, it is like turning in that using hand tools makes me feel somehow more connected to the wood and the project.

Thanks,

Mike

Running a mixed shop in Apex, NC